'Poker Face' season 2 is now streaming on Peacock — and it might be my favorite show of 2025 so far
Two years ago, "Poker Face" introduced us to my favorite modern TV detective, Charlie Cale (Natasha Lyonne).
Rian Johnson's mystery series was an old-school, "Columbo"-adjacent mystery every bit as appealing as his Netflix murder-mystery franchise, "Knives Out."
As of today (May 8), our favorite BS-detector is back in action on Peacock. The first three episodes of "Poker Face" season 2 are now available to stream, and follow our drifting detective as she tackles a fresh set of unorthodox cases across America. You may like
I was a big fan of the first season and just had the chance to watch the first 10 episodes of season 2. I'm pleased to report I've come away a very happy viewer indeed.
I'll try to keep things as spoiler-free as possible, but if you want to go in without knowing anything, just know that if you loved season 1, you're going to want to make time for "Poker Face" season 2. Otherwise, you can find my full reaction below. 'Poker Face' season 2 is more of the same — and that's no bad thing Poker Face Season 2 | Official Trailer | Peacock Original - YouTube Watch On
"Poker Face" was a real win right out of the gate: a great blend of an affable lead, fun plots, and plenty of laughs. It's easy to see why it was such a hit with viewers the first time around.
If you're one of the many people who fell for this new blast of cozy crime-solving back in 2023, you'll be pleased to know that the show's not really changed — and that's not a criticism.
Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
"Poker Face" season 2 doesn't stray from the show's established formula. It's still following Cale across America, still boasts an impressive roster of guest stars (each doing solid work), and still delivers whipsmart writing and intriguing, oddball mysteries, all of which are as entertaining as ever.
So what's different? Well, season 2 is just a little more audacious than before. Cale's journey here sees her wandering into even wilder situations this time around.
(Image credit: Peacock)
Those situations involve, say, a vindictive tween desperate to be the top dog or a plot involving identical sisters (all played by an enigmatic Cynthia Erivo).
These mysteries might be more out there, but they're no less satisfying to watch unfurl; each chapter is distinct in tone and feel, and has its own highlights. One moment, we're paying homage to classic heist movies in a big-box retail store; the next, we're dealing with a celebrity alligator at a police awards show gone awry.
It's a smart evolution, in my eyes. We're not deviating from the formula that made "Poker Face" a critical darling in the first place, but just building on what made it a hit in the first place. Verdict: Put 'Poker Face' season 2 at the top of your watchlist
(Image credit: Peacock)
"Poker Face" season 2 is a second, bigger batch of compelling (if contrived!) mysteries, Charlie's as magnetic as ever, and the stellar guest cast's full of impressive turns — if you love mystery stories, crime comedy, and Natasha Lyonne, you'll be well-served here.
Season 2 proves that Johnson's mystery-of-the-week series has serious staying power. I blitzed through all 10 available episodes and would happily have streamed dozens more.
Season 2 cements the "Poker Face" formula as a certified winner, and I look forward to both the series finale and — hopefully — to many more seasons to come.
"Poker Face" season 2 episodes 1-3 premiere on Peacock on Thursday, May 8, with new episodes airing weekly thereafter through to July 10. In the U.K., "Poker Face" season 2 will air on Sky and streaming service NOW. More from Tom's Guide
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Tom's Guide
32 minutes ago
- Tom's Guide
Netflix's new Travis Scott documentary made me never want to attend a concert again
Live music is one of my greatest passions in life. Even as I write this article, I'm furiously refreshing my phone trying to score tickets for an upcoming concert, and my weekend plans? Seeing Sam Fender's huge homecoming show at my favorite soccer team's stadium. Yet after streaming Netflix's new documentary that chronicles the tragic events that unfolded at 2021's Astroworld festival during rapper Travis Scott's headline set, I suddenly feel a little hesitant to wade deep into a crowd of thousands of people again. It's a deeply chilling watch. The doc is called 'Trainwreck: The Astroworld Tragedy,' and it explores the crowd crush that occurred during the Houston-based event attended by over 100,000 people. It resulted in the tragic deaths of 10 people, with 25 more hospitalized and injury numbers in the hundreds. It's certainly not the most entertaining watch, even if the presentation is as slick as you'd expect from a Netflix original, but it's a feature-length doc that has impacted me, and if you're also a dedicated gig-goer, then I think you need to stream this right now. Like many documentaries of this ilk, 'Trainwreck: The Astroworld Tragedy' begins with the 'happy period' as we see numerous Travis Scott fans give talking-head interviews expressing their excitement and anticipation for the upcoming concert at NRG Park in Houston, Texas. Anybody who knows what went down at Astroworld in 2021 will know what's coming next: a deadly crowd crush would lead to multiple fatalities, and I appreciate that the documentary filmmakers (who also made Netflix's excellent "Trainwreck: Woodstock '99") don't attempt to overdramatise the events. The tone is respectful throughout. I can't claim that 'Trainwreck' offers much in the way of entertainment, but it spotlights a tragedy that deserves to be remembered, and that the live music industry must learn from. The transition from people having fun at a gig to fighting for their lives is shockingly sudden, which likely mirrors the experience of attendees. The audio recordings of desperate 911 calls during the event are particularly stomach-turning and will deeply unnerve you. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. So while I can't claim that 'Trainwreck' offers much in the way of entertainment, it does spotlight a tragedy that deserves to be remembered, and that the live music industry must learn from. Because what happened at Astroworld can never be allowed to repeat itself. If you're a live music fan or just want to understand how the events of Astroworld unfolded, then I strongly recommend 'Trainwreck.' It's also a pretty trim watch, at around 80 minutes long, which is another strength; the doc presents the situation without unneeded bloat. In recent years, whenever I've attended a live music event (which, as noted, is extremely often), I typically find myself reflecting on Astroworld at some point, and this documentary gave me further insight into a tragedy that really did hit home with me in several ways. 'Trainwreck: The Astroworld Tragedy' is a well-produced and very harrowing documentary, showcasing how what should have been a memorable evening for all in attendance descended into a situation where 10 people never got to return home. It's also the next chapter in what Netflix is calling the "Trainwreck anthology." The first part was the Woodstock '99 limited series, released in 2022, and there are six more documentaries on the way that will "examine some of the most disastrous events ever to blow up in mainstream media." If you're looking for something to raise your spirits after watching 'Trainwreck: The Astroworld Tragedy,' be sure to check out our guide to everything new on Netflix in June 2025, which includes some more light-hearted TV shows and movies alongside more docs. Watch "Trainwreck: The Astroworld Tragedy" on Netflix now
Tom's Guide
32 minutes ago
- Tom's Guide
Netflix just added an 'underrated' crime thriller show that's already crashed the top 10 — and there are 6 seasons to binge-watch now
Thriller fans are being well-served by Netflix this month. Along with NBC's "Blindspot," the streaming service recently welcomed family crime thriller "Animal Kingdom" to the platform — and it looks to be a hit with streamers. For the uninitiated, "Animal Kingdom" is a gritty drama that originally ran for six seasons between 2016 and 2022, airing on TNT in the U.S. It's based on the 2010 Australian movie of the same name, and throws us in with a chaotic, dysfunctional family who operate a criminal enterprise out of Southern California. "Animal Kingdom" was one of the many new things added to Netflix at the start of the month, and it's been a mainstay in the Netflix Top 10 ever since. Over a week after it arrived, it's still sitting at the #7 spot, not far behind Netflix Originals like "The Survivors," "Ginny & Georgia" and "Sirens." Trying to decide whether to stream "Animal Kingdom" on Netflix? You can find a little more info about the show and hear what viewers have to say about the streamer's new arrival. TNT's "Animal Kingdom" is a crime drama based on the 2010 Australian movie of the same name. The show revolves around the Cody family. We follow young Joshua "J" Cody ("Peaky Blinders" star Finn Cole), who moves in with his estranged relatives after his mother dies of an overdose The Codys, as it turns out, run a criminal enterprise out of Oceanside, California, with J's tough grandmother Janine "Smurf" Cody (Ellen Barkin) at the helm. The dysfunctional Cody dynasty funds its lifestyle through (among other things) heists, and J's quickly sucked into this dangerous criminal world of shifting loyalties and secrets. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. In addition to Cole and Barkin, "Animal Kingdom" also stars Scott Speedman, Shawn Hatosy, Ben Robson, Jake Weary, Molly Gordon and Carolina Guerra, among others. "Animal Kingdom" comes reasonably well-recommended. While the series doesn't have a complete critics' rating on the review aggregate site, Rotten Tomatoes, the first two seasons hold ratings of 76% and 80%, respectively, with the site's consensus on the first season reading: "Bolstered by Ellen Barkin's acting prowess, 'Animal Kingdom' is a darkly intriguing, although occasionally predictable, twisted family drama." Fellow viewers, however, rate it significantly higher; the show has an average Popcornmeter rating of 87% and has drawn some very high praise for the acting, the (occasionally predictable) twists and more. Comparisons to "Sons of Anarchy" seem common, too. The show's subreddit is being taken over by newcomers who've stumbled onto "Animal Kingdom" now that it's on Netflix, talking it up, while original fans have been discussing rewatching the show from the start, or hoping that the drama finally gets the reception they believe it's always deserved. Looking through reactions in both places, I've seen the word "underrated" thrown around plenty of times, so I'm not too surprised to see "Animal Kingdom" has continued to be a top Netflix watch in the days since its arrival on the platform. I only just started streaming the show myself (it passed me by the first time around), so I wouldn't want to give my own "Animal Kingdom" verdict just yet. However, from the position of being an "Animal Kingdom" newcomer, I can say that I'm intrigued by what I've seen so far, and I'm keen to see what trouble lies ahead for J, Smurf and the rest of the Cody family across these six seasons. If you're between Netflix binges and you're looking to sink your teeth into a gritty family thriller, one that boasts a cast of very questionable characters, then it certainly feels like "Animal Kingdom" will fit the bill just fine. And with dozens of episodes available to watch right now, it should keep you busy for some time. Not sold on streaming "Animal Kingdom?" We can still help you find your next must-watch show. If you're looking for more streaming suggestions, check out our definitive round-up of the best Netflix shows for tons more top recommendations.
Elle
an hour ago
- Elle
Finished 'Dept. Q'? Netflix's New Murder Mystery 'The Survivors' Should Be Your Next Watch
For those looking to fill the Dept. Q-shaped whodunnit hole in their life, Netflix has come up trumps, once again, with yet another murder mystery: The Survivors. The Survivors, which launched on the platform on June 6, stars Charlie Vickers as Kieran Elliott and Bridgerton's newest darling Yerin Ha as Mia Chang, a young couple who are haunted by ghosts of their past when they return to their childhood hometown to be with Kieran's ailing father and emotionally distant mother, per Netflix. FIND OUT MORE ON ELLE COLLECTIVE The limited six-episode series, which is based on the bestselling Jane Harper novel of the same name, boasts all of the elements of a winning murder mystery with a brooding, simmering tension throughout and a moody, murderous setting, not dissimilar from its Dept. Q predecessor. Needless to say, it's the murder mystery we all ought to be bookmarking and binging. This is everything you need to know about The Survivors. Set in the fittingly sleepy seaside town Evelyn Bay in Tasmania, The Survivors tells the story of Kieran (Vickers) and Mia (Ha) as they return to their emotionally fraught hometown. 'Kieran Elliott's life changed forever when two people drowned and a young girl went missing in his hometown of Evelyn Bay,' per Netflix. 'Fifteen years later, returning with his young family, the guilt that still haunts him resurfaces. When the body of a young woman is found on the beach, the town is once again rocked by tragedy and the investigation of her death threatens to reveal long-held secrets, the truth about the missing girl, and a killer among them.' 'It's a family melodrama disguised as a murder mystery,' the series' showrunner Tony Ayres said of the series. 'Because the things that are really at its heart are things like a son wanting his mother's love and the mother who just cannot afford to give it because her whole world might fall apart.' Alongside Elliott and Ha, The Survivors also stars Robyn Malcolm, Damien Garvey and Apple Cider Vinegar's Thom Green and Julian Weeks. The full cast is below: The series was filmed throughout the Australian state of Tasmania, and is set in the fictional town of Evelyn Bay, where the book takes place. However, as Ayres stressed in an interview with Netflix, 'Evelyn Bay doesn't actually exist. Jane [Harper] made it up out of a number of different places.' The Survivors was filmed in an area of Tasmania called Eaglehawk Neck, which Ayres noted has 'such a gothic landscape. It's cliffs and sea caves and this pounding ocean. It really is so spectacular.' Netflix has not yet greenlit another season, but given the precedent set by previous the streaming service with its other limited series that it's ended up commissioning second seasons of, including Nobody Wants This and Squid Game, there's still plenty of time for a second outing of The Survivors. The Survivors is available to stream on Netflix now. ELLE Collective is a new community of fashion, beauty and culture lovers. For access to exclusive content, events, inspiring advice from our Editors and industry experts, as well the opportunity to meet designers, thought-leaders and stylists, become a member today HERE. Naomi May is a freelance writer and editor with an emphasis on popular culture, lifestyle and politics. After graduating with a First Class Honours from City University's prestigious Journalism course, Naomi joined the Evening Standard as its Fashion and Beauty Writer, working across both the newspaper and website. She is now the Acting News Editor at ELLE UK and has written features for the likes of The Guardian, Vogue, Vice and Refinery29, among many others.
