
Prosecutor reflects on ‘long road' to justice for baby Victoria
Samantha Yelland, senior Crown prosecutor for CPS London, told the PA news agency: 'I feel that justice has been done.
'It's been a long road, it's been a lot of work, but, you know, no work is too much when anyone's died, but particularly a young child who wasn't able to stick up for herself or fight for herself.'
Last year, a jury failed to reach verdicts on whether the defendants were responsible to Victoria's death but did convict them of concealing her birth, child cruelty and perverting the course of justice by hiding her body in a shed.
Ms Yelland sought a retrial on charges of manslaughter and causing or allowing Victoria's death in the public interest, even though it meant a second six-month trial.
Explaining the decision, she said: 'A baby died in circumstances which she absolutely didn't need to and could have been avoided.
'That is why it's serious and it needs to be prosecuted. Obviously none of us expected it to take this long.'
Dealing with a case involving the death of a baby is 'always upsetting' even for an experienced team, she said.
Ms Yelland said: 'I consider it a privilege to prosecute baby cases. It is very upsetting, it could be harrowing, but usually the people charged with their killing is someone who is supposed to look after them.
'Some of the evidence in is not very nice, but we're just looking at the whole picture and wanting to get justice for the person who has died.'
Images of Victoria's body found rotting amid rubbish in a Lidl bag in a shed near Brighton have stuck in her mind throughout the case.
She said: 'I've seen what baby Victoria looks like inside of that bag. I've seen the post-mortem photos.
'We didn't subject the jury to that because that is not a nice thing to see. But the baby is in that bag, which we know she was carried around in when she died, but also when she was alive. It is probably what stays with me the most. And what was on top, the rubbish, the Coke can and the sandwich wrapper.
'And the two police officers finding it. You can see how moved they are when they realise that they found it. Obviously, that had been a manhunt been going on for a couple of days by that stage.'
On the defendants' actions after four other children were taken into care, Ms Yelland said: 'We never said that they didn't love their children, but when it comes to decision making, it's the prosecution view that they think of themselves above the children.
'And that's why they got themselves into the predicament they did. And that's why Victoria died, and that's why they continued to keep her there in that bag for however long it was after she died and not go to the police and not explain the situation.
'And that's why I charged perverting the course of justice rather than preventing the lawful for burial, which is another offence I could have considered.
'For me, it was more than that because they kept it for such a long time that the state that she was in was such that we couldn't be sure if there had been an injury – not that we're saying there was for a minute – but we wouldn't have been able to tell because at the amount of time that she'd been in there.
'I do accept that there were experts that said that everyone grieves differently and everyone deals with things differently, but I think the whole theme of this case is that they think about themselves more than they think about their children and other people.'
Ms Yelland said the case had presented multiple challenges for the prosecution before baby Victoria was found dead on March 1 2023.
Discussions had already started about charging Gordon and Marten even in the absence of a body.
The CPS pressed ahead with charges despite a post-mortem examination failing to ascertain exactly how Victoria died.
With no pathological cause of death, the jury was asked to look at other evidence that Victoria died from hypothermia or smothering, as the defendants claimed.
Ms Yelland said: 'We decided that although there were two distinct ways in which she may have died, our main case is that she died of hypothermia.
'The defendants raised that she was smothered and in response to that, we say, while we don't accept that, even if that were to be the case, the circumstances in which she was smothered are such it still amounts to grossly negligence manslaughter.
'It's our case that hypothermia would have been heavily involved in any smothering anyway, because she's been subjected to very cold conditions with the items that she was wearing and would not have been as healthy.'
In a change from the original trial, an expert replicated cold and damp conditions in the tent where Victoria died and examined her inadequate clothes pointing to hypothermia being the likely cause.
Other challenges involved piecing together and assessing sightings of the defendants from across England in the seven weeks they were on the run with baby Victoria.
Mr Yelland said that the prosecution was able to narrow the timeline in the second trial although the prosecution still asserted Victoria survived for longer than the defendants had said.
Towards the end of the retrial, Gordon, who by then was representing himself, provided the prosecution with the chance to lift the lid on his 1989 rape conviction in the United States after he gave a misleading impression of his childhood.
When he refuted the convictions, the prosecution moved swiftly to produce an embossed certificate from a Florida court to prove it.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Scottish Labour MP launches bid for 'untouchable' prison bosses to lose immunity from prosecution
The campaign comes after an inquiry into two deaths at a Scottish jail found a 'catalogue of failures' in the prison system. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A Scottish Labour MP has put forward plans to strip 'untouchable' prison bosses of being shielded from prosecution over suicides in a Scottish young offenders institute. Blair McDougall, the MP for East Renfrewshire, has tabled a ten minute rule bill in the House of Commons, calling for Crown immunity in UK prison estates to be abolished. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad An inquiry into two deaths at Polmont young offenders institute found they could have been avoided Crown immunity, which has been previously removed from the NHS and police, essentially halts any criminal consequences for the prison service due to failings. Under the current law, the Crown, including the Scottish Prison Service (SPS), cannot be held criminally responsible for deaths in custody. Both the Scottish Government and the SPS have backed calls to remove the Crown immunity but it would require action at Westminster to do so. Mr McDougall's constituents, Linda and Stuart Allan, lost their daughter Katie, 21, when she died in Polmont Young Offenders Institution in 2018. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A fatal accident inquiry (FAI) last year found that Katie's death and that of 16-year-old William Brown could have been prevented but for a 'catalogue of failures' in the prison system. Speaking in the House of Commons, the MP said: 'The problem with prison deaths is UK-wide but these losses are a particular problem in Scotland. 'The loss of young people in prisons is felt especially.' Katie Allan, 21, and William Lindsay, 16, who died within months of each other in 2018 at Polmont Young Offenders' Institute | Contributed Mr McDougall pointed to research showing 'our prison death rates are akin to those in Azerbaijan' and findings that 'Scotland's suicide rate was more than two and a half times higher than the average and about double that of England and Wales'. The Labour MP highlighted so-called 'ligatures" - anything that could be used to tie something in a way that poses a risk of strangulation or hanging. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad READ MORE: Suicide prevention strategy launched in wake of Polmont YOI deaths He said: 'Years after both deaths, nobody in the prison service had thought to remove the doorstops or to replace them with safer, sloping alternatives. Bunk beds had not been removed. 'Nothing for me signifies that institutional lack of care - the failings that someone somewhere should have been held legally responsible for.' Scottish Labour MP Blair McDougall | Jane Barlow/TSPL Mr McDougall said that 'eventually, the authorities said there was enough evidence to charge the prison service with breaches of the health and safety act'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He added: 'But there was no prosecution…because of Crown immunity. 'The Health and Safety at Work Act places duties on state-run prisons but Crown immunity means they cannot be prosecuted for breaching those duties. If they'd died in a privately-run prison, there would have been prosecutions.' The MP warned that the Scottish Prison Service is 'untouchable because of Crown immunity'. He added: 'An untouchable service remains unaccountable. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Without legal consequences, prisons across the country appear incapable of learning lessons or making changes. Every day with immunity risks more avoidable deaths. 'If those running our prisons won't act, and they haven't, they should lose their protection from legal consequence.' Mr McDougall's bill will now move forward through the Westminster legislative system. A Scottish Prison Service spokesperson said: "We recognise the profound responsibility we hold in caring for people during some of the most vulnerable periods of their lives. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "When someone dies in prison custody we know families, and the wider public, rightly expect us to do everything possible to prevent further tragedies.


The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Sunday school teacher jailed for sexually abusing nine children protected by church leader, Victorian cult inquiry hears
A Sunday school teacher who was jailed for sexually abusing nine children was protected by the leader of his fundamentalist church, after parents reported the abuse to him instead of police, a Victorian parliamentary inquiry has heard. Catherine and Ryan Carey, former members of the Geelong Revival Centre (GRC), gave evidence at the first hearing of the parliamentary inquiry into the practices of cults and organised fringe groups on Wednesday. The inquiry was established in April, after allegations of coercive practices at the GRC, as detailed in LiSTNR's investigative podcast series Secrets We Keep: Pray Harder. The church has not publicly commented on the allegations contained in the podcast. Led by the legislative assembly's legal and social issues committee, it is not examining specific religious groups or their beliefs but the methods they use to attract and retain members – and whether those practices amount to coercion that should be criminalised. Ryan told the inquiry the man had a valid working with children check at the time of the offending and described the government's screening process as a 'Band-Aid on an amputee.' Sign up: AU Breaking News email 'He was convicted last year of molesting nine kids in the Geelong community and the parents that found out reported it to the cult leader – and this was in the judgment – instead of going police,' he said. 'There was a two-and-a-half day lag where this guy was able to destroy evidence – I think was 12 terabytes of child pornography – because the parents didn't do the right thing and go report this [to] police.' Catherine said during this time a child was also left in the care of the man. She said GRC's leader only contacted police after learning the man had already turned himself in. Ryan said the abuse went unreported because the GRC acted like a 'state within a state' and believed its authority was 'higher than the law of the land.' He said when sexual abuse occurred within families, it was also 'covered up' by the GRC and victims 'blamed' by their offenders. 'The girls were always seen as the flirts and the ones that were leading the men astray, like it was never the male's fault, which is, it's just horrible,' Ryan said. He told the inquiry the environment within the GRC was 'unsafe for kids', saying it was common for young people to be left alone with elders. Elders, meanwhile, were regularly instructed to physically punish children – especially those with single mothers. 'If you were in Sunday school or child minding, you could hit kids,' Ryan said. 'It was absolutely disastrous. I speak to adults now that are still traumatised.' Families were also instructed to discipline their children harshly. Ryan told the inquiry he was told to 'crush my kids' will by the time there are three to make them compliant' while Catherine said comparisons were made to 'breaking in a horse'. The couple have since left the GRC and founded the group Stop Religious Coercion Australia. They maintain the centre is a cult, as it uses 'friends, family and fear' to control its members and isolate those who leave. Ryan said his father was 'second in charge of the cult' in Geelong and, from the moment he was born, he 'answered to the cult and the cult leader', living in a 'constant state of fear' that the 'world was going to end'. Catherine, meanwhile, joined at age 19, during a period when she had experienced trauma and felt isolated and vulnerable, or 'ripe to be sucked into a cult', as she put it. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The GRC has been active since the late 1950s and has a network of more than 20 assemblies across Australia and overseas. At its peak, the couple said the GRC had more than 650 members, though the number has since fallen to about 200. Each working member was expected to donate at least 10% of their salary to the GRC, described as a 'free will offering'. 'It's not really free will. It's 10% or your risking hell,' Ryan said. He said some members were discouraged from seeking medical treatment, for everything from broken bones to cancer, as it was believed illness could be healed by prayer. 'I had a close friend that he was so indoctrinated he believed that God would heal him in his cancer and he passed away,' Ryan said. The couple also allege some who have left GRC have gone on to commit suicide or died of a result of alcohol and drug abuse. 'I know of suicides in even teenage years, where kids stuck in that situation have suicided,' Ryan said. 'It feels like a hopeless situation.' Catherine added: 'Not to mention ones who … because of addiction and things like that died as a result of that, from their trauma.' In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14. In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@ or jo@ In the US, you can call or text the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline on 988, chat on or text HOME to 741741 to connect with a crisis counselor. Other international helplines can be found at


The Guardian
7 hours ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: Ozzy Osbourne dies, childcare centre worker accused, starvation horror in Gaza
Morning everyone. A mother in Victoria has claimed her daughter was assaulted at a childcare centre by a worker who subsequently kept their job, our exclusive story reveals. Elsewhere, Larissa Waters has distanced herself from the Australian Greens expulsion stoush, Israel is facing intensifying international condemnation for its killing of starving Palestinian civilians in Gaza and in the US Republicans are fanning the Epstein firestorm by calling his convicted associate Ghislaine Maxwell to testify to Congress. Plus: legendary rocker Ozzy Osbourne has died aged 76. 'Fighting for fair' | It was an emotionally charged first day of parliament yesterday as Ali France, slayer of Peter Dutton and new Labor MP for Dickson, delivered a very personal first speech detailing her 'epic journey' to Canberra. Exclusive | A mother has claimed that her two-year-old daughter was sexually assaulted by a worker at a Victorian childcare centre but there was no witness or CCTV of the alleged incidents, so the educator is still working there and has not been charged. 70 is the new 50 | Australian employers must change their views on workers aged over 50 and stop seeing them as 'old' if the country is going to become more productive for longer, our economics editor argues today. 'I wasn't involved' | Greens leader Larissa Waters says she has not read documentation outlining why the party's co-founder Drew Hutton was expelled because she has been busy preparing for parliament. Battery blow | After a fire on board a Virgin flight from Sydney to Hobart was caused by a lithium battery in a power bank, Catie McLeod finds out whether it's safe to carry the devices on to planes. 'Morally unjustifiable' | Israel has bombed warehousing and staff accommodation in Gaza belonging to the World Health Organization amid intensifying international horror at its continuing attacks on starving civilians. Israel's policy is 'unacceptable and morally unjustifiable', the Catholic Latin patriarch of Jerusalem said after visiting a church in the territory. We have a visual story on how food drops became death traps for Palestinians in Gaza. Maxwell subpoena | US Congress will subpoena Ghislaine Maxwell, the imprisoned sex trafficker who was a close associate of Jeffrey Epstein, to testify amid a political firestorm over the Trump administration's decision not to release its remaining Epstein files. It came after justice department officials said they would meet Maxwell to see if she 'has information about anyone who has committed crimes against victims'. Here's why the case continues to drive a wedge between some prominent Maga supporters and Trump. Follow developments live in Washington where the Trump administration also announced it will quit the United Nations' culture and education agency Unesco. Black day | Ozzy Osbourne, the frontman of heavy metal pioneers Black Sabbath and one of rock's most notorious hellraisers, has died aged 76. Dubbed the 'prince of darkness', he had suffered ill-health for many years and appeared frail at a farewell concert two weeks ago. Energy breakthrough | The world is on the brink of a breakthrough in the climate fight and fossil fuels are running out of road, the UN chief said overnight, saying 90% of renewable power projects are now cheaper than fossil fuel alternatives. Child labour | Russian authorities have involved children in the design and testing of drones for the country's war in Ukraine through competitions that begin with video games and end up with the most talented students headhunted by defence companies, an investigation has found. What's behind the cancelling of Stephen Colbert? CBS has described the cancellation of the Stephen Colbert show as 'purely financial'. But, as the Guardian's Washington DC bureau chief David Smith tells Reged Ahmad, others are not so sure. Meanwhile Colbert has declared the 'gloves are off' in his war of words with Donald Trump. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ An Indigenous mother who gave birth to a stillborn baby in the 39th week of her pregnancy says that her concerns were dismissed by staff at hospital in regional New South Wales. She had been to see doctors eight times in the same week with concerns. 'I just wanted to be heard and I wasn't,' she tells Sarah Collard. For this week's taste test Nicholas Jordan and friends try 22 olives ranging from Sicilian and green to kalamata and black. Of the winner, one reviewer wrote that 'I want to draw a still life painting of these' – while of the worst, Nicholas writes if he hadn't been conducting an olive test he might not have known they were olives. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Rugby union | A hybrid First Nations & Pasifika XV players pushed the Lions all the way in last night's historic match in Melbourne with the tourists only making sure of their 24-19 victory in the last quarter. The First Nations performance inspired their players to issue a challenge to play the Wallabies. Tennis | Carlos Alcaraz has become the latest in a series of leading men's players to withdraw from the Canadian Open as the world No 2 joined Jannik Sinner, Novak Djokovic and Jack Draper on the sidelines. Football | England and Italy are contesting the first semi-final of the Women's Euros in Geneva. Follow the action live. Some high-profile private lenders face crippling losses from the collapse of Jon Adgemis' Sydney pub empire, the Australian claims. There could be trouble at the millionaire factory, the Fin Review reports, as Macquarie Bank faces its first investor 'strike' over disquiet at high executive pay and bonuses. The Newcastle Herald has the big news though – the results of a competition to find the best pies in Australia. Education | David Pocock will hold a press conference in Canberra at 9.30am calling for stronger university reforms. Brisbane | The opening of a hearing for commission of inquiry into the child safety in Queensland will be held. Environment | An ICJ ruling on a Vanuatu climate case is due in at 11pm. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword