logo
GP shortages continue to disadvantage people in remote WA despite government efforts

GP shortages continue to disadvantage people in remote WA despite government efforts

A new report has revealed WA's North West faces the greatest challenge with doctor shortages of anywhere in the state, while local governments in other remote areas are campaigning for the federal government to cover the costs to retain GP services.
For the third consecutive year, the Pilbara had the highest proportional movement of GPs out of the region, losing 23.4 per cent of its workforce, according to Rural Health West's report.
Further north in the Kimberley region, there has been an 8.1 per cent drop in GPs, and had the lowest number of doctors move into the area.
Aboriginal Health Service GP Fiona Cleary in Roebourne, 1,500 kilometres north of Perth, said they had to close a pop-up medical clinic in nearby Karratha for several weeks due to a lack of staff.
"Not having access to GPs then puts a second pressure onto the hospital, so then they get all the patients coming in with GP stuff, not emergency stuff," Dr Cleary said.
She said access to childcare and the cost of living in the Pilbara contributed to the high turnover rate.
The median cost of a rental in Karratha is $1,183 a week, according to a May CoreLogic report.
While Dr Cleary's rent is partially subsidised through her organisation, she said it would "definitely deter" her from staying in the region if she had to pay the full price in Karratha.
City of Karratha Mayor Daniel Scott said affordable housing continued to be the biggest barrier to attracting health professionals, with nearby towns like Wickham "desperate" for GPs.
He said the shire was creating a new housing policy for GPs and allied health services, after a fund supporting GPs recently expired.
Dr Cleary's colleague, Aaron Donald, said the high turnover disadvantaged the community's wellbeing.
"It can break down care because you don't have the flow of knowing the history, knowing what's been tried before," Dr Donald said.
"If you're only here for a year or two, that's a fairly limited amount of time to try to build a relationship where patients trust you".
The Kimberley's regional hub of Broome has seen a clinic close, with no prospect of it reopening.
The Broome Doctors Practice was vacated last week after closing its doors suddenly in February, leaving patients in the lurch.
At the time, Spectrum Health chief executive Philip Coelho was optimistic the clinic would reopen later this year in a newly built surgery.
But Mr Coelho confirmed the practice will not be relaunched, citing difficulties in getting doctors to regional areas.
"We have removed everything and handed the practice back to the landlord," he said.
"The simple reason is because we don't have doctors, or a supervisor, who will go up there."
In Western Australia's south, the proportion of GPs leaving the region was lower than in the Pilbara at 13.5 per cent.
Six local governments have an alliance to draw attention to the amount they are having to pay to attract GPs to the remote areas and want the federal government to cover the costs.
The local governments of Gnowangerup, Jerramungup, Kojonup, Narembeen, Lake Grace, and Ravensthorpe collectively contribute about $1.5 million annually towards GP services.
That is not including housing, vehicles, and buildings for the surgeries.
The Shire of Narembeen has fewer than 1,000 people, and in the 2023–24 financial year spent $305,000 or 16 per cent of the income from its rates to recruit GPs.
Over the same period, the Shire of Lake Grace, with a population of about 1,200 people, paid $250,000 amounting to 7.3 per cent of the rates income.
Shire president Len Armstrong said the money should be coming from the federal government.
"It takes money away from our core business of providing infrastructure and community structures for our communities," he said.
Rural Doctors Association of Western Australia president Clark Wasiun said financial incentives were not the only factor in recruiting GPs.
"It's not about throwing money at the doctors," Dr Wasiun said.
"If there's better infrastructure in some of these towns, and the most obvious one that comes to mind is childcare services, that will not just encourage them but enable them to go to those more remote towns."
Livingston Medical provides GPs to local governments in the alliance.
Michael Livingston said they had a "rural generalist hub" model which included working with doctors who were training and ensuring those taking up the roles had proper support.
"We reckon we save the state about $14-20 million a year in preventable retrievals, that is when people don't have to be flown out because there's a doctor there who can see to the patient," Dr Livingston said.
Mr Armstrong said going through Livingston Medical had reduced the pressure on the Shire of Lake Grace to source its own doctors.
"We've only been working under this model for going on two years, we're fairly comfortable with it, we're just not comfortable that we've got to pay a cash component," he said.
"We've most probably tried half a dozen different models and methods of getting doctors into our area, even at one stage here in Lake Grace we were flying in and flying out doctors from Albany."
The proposal from the six local governments for federal funding was listed for discussion at the recent Australian Local Government Association National General Assembly.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler said the government was considering the findings of the Working Better for Medicare Review, which examined existing policies to attract and distribute the health workforce, including for regional, rural and remote areas.
The Rural Clinical School of WA began in 2002 and works with medical students who are in their penultimate and last year of studies.
The students undertake training at one of 15 regional sites across the state, and project officer Juliet Bateman said the program was oversubscribed by about 50 per cent.
Ms Bateman said the program was limited to the availability of places that met the necessary criteria, including being able to offer appropriate supervision.
Dr Wasiun said spending time in a regional area while training could be a game changer.
"If there's that exposure to rural places for junior doctors, then you've got a much better chance of that doctor staying in that rural area or moving on to another rural area rather than going back to the city," he said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dad barred from interfering with son's cancer treatment speaks out
Dad barred from interfering with son's cancer treatment speaks out

9 News

time15 hours ago

  • 9 News

Dad barred from interfering with son's cancer treatment speaks out

Your web browser is no longer supported. To improve your experience update it here A WA father barred from interfering with his teenage son's cancer treatment says he now supports the boy receiving chemotherapy . The family claims they wanted time to consider their options, but the boy was taken away before they could. His son is fighting a rare blood cancer, which was only recently diagnosed, but this father says he feels like the teenager was kidnapped after doctors said he needed chemotherapy. A WA father barred from interfering with his teenage son's cancer treatment says he now supports him receiving chemotherapy. (9News) "They said, 'We're taking the boy to Perth, we're flying him right now to hospital', and we felt very pressurised," the father claimed in an interview with 9News. "I said, 'we need 24 hours just to review our options, there's a few key people to speak to'." The father claimed they did not get that time and police eventually arrived at their home. "The boy went back in the house because the house was surrounded, and it seemed that they were absolutely going to kidnap him," the father claimed. "Every time there's a a shape move behind us or a red and blue light, we're all filled with terror." The father (left) was handcuffed and his teenager taken to Perth Children's Hospital for treatment for acute myleoid leukemia. (9News) The father was handcuffed and his teenager taken to Perth Children's Hospital for treatment for acute myleoid leukemia. The Family Court was told it was an emergency and without it, the boy could die within weeks. But on the weekend, his father cut his chemotherapy line. "I asked for them to pause until we could then look at alternatives," the father claimed. He said he had now changed his mind and "we fully support the hospital". "We're happy to go along with them. Honestly I just need the time to do my own research. A WA father barred from interfering with his teenage son's cancer treatment says he now supports him receiving chemotherapy. (9News) "I do believe that each of us should be able to choose our own healthcare, that should be a human right." The boy's chemo continues here at Perth Children's Hospital where it's expected he'll have to attend for at least the next four to six weeks. "He's a real talent and he's an amazing boy," the father said. "If anyone's going to beat it, he will." Western Australia Perth courts cancer health CONTACT US Auto news: Why Australians are still driving around without insurance.

High cost of living affects specialty cheese sales but sheep dairy industry still hopeful
High cost of living affects specialty cheese sales but sheep dairy industry still hopeful

ABC News

timea day ago

  • ABC News

High cost of living affects specialty cheese sales but sheep dairy industry still hopeful

Did you know sheep's milk is considered to have more nutrients than cow's milk? The sheep dairy industry in Australia is small, particularly when compared to regions like the Mediterranean where sheep's milk and cheese are an integral part of people's diets. But that is not stopping Australian producers and dietitians from wanting to raise awareness about the alternative milk's health benefits and unique taste. Eat Sustainably nutritionist Amelia Harray said sheep's milk had a higher percentage of protein than milk produced by cows or goats. "With that comes a higher amount of calcium, phosphorus, manganese, zinc, and all these other really essential nutrients that our bodies need to stay well each day," Dr Harray said. Dr Harray, who is also a researcher with the University of Western Australia's medical school, said despite the health benefits of sheep's milk, it would likely not be a viable option for people with a dairy allergy. "Many people who have a cow's milk protein allergy will also react to milk from other mammals, including sheep and goats," she said. Cambray Cheese, located about 240 kilometres south of Perth, is Western Australia's only commercial sheep milk and cheese producer. Owner Tom Wilde said he was "spreading the word" as much as possible about the benefits of sheep dairy products. "When we do the farmers' market in Margaret River every weekend, people have a try [of our products] and we can tell them about how it's a lot better for your gut and easier to digest," he said. "Traditionally, people are looking for goat's milk and cheese. A lot of people don't even know that there's sheep's milk or sheep's cheeses around, so it's just about educating people." Mr Wilde said Cambray Cheese sold its first batch of sheep's milk in 2024 for $12 a litre, about three times the price of a litre of cow's milk. "We were worried that people wouldn't be able to afford the price that it needed to be because it's expensive milk, but there were no issues. People absolutely loved it," he said. "The milk is very sweet compared to cow's milk, and it's really nice and thick. It's lovely milk. Meredith Dairy, a family farm located 120 kilometres west of Melbourne, is Australia's largest sheep and goat milk and cheese producer. Director Julie Cameron said sheep and goat dairy products were generally more expensive due to the extensive labour requirements. "We can get a litre of milk a day from a sheep, we can get 3 litres from a goat, but if you're a cow dairy farmer, you can get between 15 and 40 litres a day," she said. Due to improvements in animal production and automation, Ms Cameron said she had only raised her prices once in the past three decades. She said the demand for specialty cheeses had fallen recently as a result of the current "economic crisis". Despite this, Ms Cameron said she remained hopeful the situation would turn around. "We talk to the dairy buyers in the supermarkets and they say sales are slow for specialty cheeses, which is sad, but maybe people don't have that spare money for discretionary purchases of luxury items like mould-ripened cheeses or blue cheeses or imported cheeses," she said. "But I have faith that the economy will pick up, and I'm sure the sales of these specialty cheeses will pick up again." Mr Wilde said he would like to see more farmers give sheep milk production a go. "It's probably one of the biggest industries of start-ups and failures in Australia," he said. "There are not many sheep dairies still running in Australia because it's very labour-intensive. "[But] if you love sheep, then it's worth it. "We would actually love to be able to buy sheep's milk from other farmers. If that was an option, then we could focus on the cheese side of things."

Lack of aged care beds, home support in keeping the elderly in hospital in WA
Lack of aged care beds, home support in keeping the elderly in hospital in WA

ABC News

timea day ago

  • ABC News

Lack of aged care beds, home support in keeping the elderly in hospital in WA

Each day around 200 hospital beds in Western Australia are taken up by people who do not need to be there, according to state budget estimates released last month. It is the result of a lack of aged care vacancies and at-home support for older people, particularly in regional areas. The issue has added pressure to the state's already stretched health system, which experienced its worst month on record for regional ambulance ramping in May. Patients are being admitted to hospital for genuine health issues, but to be released into an at-home care model, they may have to wait an extra 10 days in hospital, while those waiting for a residential aged care place face an additional 16-day wait on average. WA's Shadow Health Minister Libby Mettam said not enough was being done to address the issue, and patients should not be staying in hospital longer than medically required. "It also has an impact on the rest of the hospital system, and it all comes as an unnecessary cost to taxpayers." An average hospital bed costs $2,370 per day compared with an aged care placement of about $350 a day. A 2022–23 report from the state's auditor general, Management of Long Stay Patients in Public Hospitals, highlighted concerns for the patients themselves, the impact on the health system, and a lack of data in relation to the ongoing issue. WA Minister for Seniors and Aged Care Simone McGurk said aged care was a federal government responsibility, and there were not enough beds available across the country. At the end of March, federal Department of Health, Disability and Ageing figures showed there were 87,597 people nationally waiting for home care packages. The state government has committed to a $100 million low-interest loan scheme to help aged care providers deliver up to 500 additional concessional aged care beds. The scheme is expected to be rolled out next financial year. Ms McGurk said the state government's Time to Think program also provided 42 beds at different aged care facilities in Perth for those leaving hospital, but it only operated in Perth. Ms Mettam said the scarcity of residential aged care options in regional areas was of great concern. In Northam, about 95 kilometres north-east of Perth, aged care providers estimate there is an undersupply of nearly 200 residential aged care beds, predicted to reach 350 beds by 2032, including 160 retirement accommodation places. The town has two aged care facilities with a total of 80 beds, built in the 1970s and 80s and privately run by Juniper Aged Care. The Shire of Northam said it was aware of 50 aged care clients who had relocated to Perth because their needs could no longer be met by the existing facilities, which were in vital need of upgrades or expansion. Northam is home to more than 12,000 people, and the town's services also cater to the wider Wheatbelt region, according to Shire President Chris Antonio. "The ageing population, particularly our farmers, want to stay close to where they are from," he said. "It is close enough that they can still go back to the farm or the town that they grew up in without having to move to the city. "They don't want to live in the city and, by not having aged care beds, we aren't making that possible for them." Cr Antonio said the local government was asking for state and federal government support. Cr Antonio said the shire estimated private providers would need an investment in excess of $10 million to provide the level of aged care the region needed. He said Killara Adult Day Care and Respite Centre, which provided temporary care to aged care clients living at home, had taken on four clients in the past month from Northam Regional Hospital to reduce the strain on the health system. Juniper Aged Care chief executive Russell Bricknell said without additional Commonwealth funding for home care packages, those in need would "pass away before they get any support". "If I'm an older person and I'm having to make decisions because I'm getting frailer, the absolute preference is to maintain my independence in my home, close to my community, close to my family, and getting the supports in the home," he said. In a statement, federal Aged Care Minister Stuart McRae said the government was investing almost $1 billion through the Aged Care Capital Assistance Program to help providers and aged care facilities develop residential aged care homes across Australia, especially within rural and regional areas.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store