Brett Sutton made it through a pandemic. Now he's fighting a new war
This week, his idea won in-principle support from the Australian Academy of Science and the Academy of Health and Medical Science, as well as from the Australian Science Media Centre (Nine, owner of this masthead, is a paying member of the centre).
'In an increasingly fragmented information environment, bringing the right voices together in a co-ordinated way has never been more important,' said Professor Louise Baur, president of the Australian Academy of Health and Medical Sciences.
Australian Academy of Science president Professor Chennupati Jagadish said he was concerned evidence-based information was being 'drowned out by disinformation, and reliable and independent sources of knowledge are increasingly rare'.
Globally, Australians retain an extremely high trust in scientists – ranked fifth in a survey of 68 countries published in Nature Human Behaviour earlier this year. And misinformation has always been a part of society; much of it, like astrology, is tolerated as harmless.
The problem we now face seems instead to be driven by a global collapse in trust in institutions, combined with a media and social media environment that empowers people to choose the version of the truth they want to watch, said Associate Professor Will Grant from the Australian National Centre for the Public Awareness of Science.
'It's a pull away from competing over what is true to instead saying we can have our own truths, our own world,' he said.
Some 61 per cent of Australians worry about political meddling in science, per Edelman research released this year. Nearly half of people globally distrust government to care for their health.
Trust in media to accurately report health information fell by 16 per cent in Australia since 2019; 35 per cent of people now say they can be as knowledgeable as a doctor if they have done their own research.
In 2019, Australians' trust in government fell to its lowest level since 1969, according to a tracking survey run by the Australian National University.
Society has three institutions for finding out the truth: science, journalism and the courts, said Grant. 'All those are under attack.
'We are decaying our central institutions. We are losing our central social ability to adjudicate truth.'
Sutton's coalition was welcome, said Dr Susannah Eliott, CEO of the Australian Science Media Centre, but faced a tricky task, as people might actually find a coalition of science institutions less trustworthy than individual scientists.
A similar effort in the US, the Coalition for Trust in Health and Science, floundered because it tried to simply compete directly with misinformation, rather than engaging people in genuine dialogue, said Tina Purnat, a misinformation researcher at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
'It can feel pretty paternalistic if you are on the receiving end,' she said. 'I think the positioning of any coalitions as 'defenders of science' and using combative language can massively backfire in any effort to de-escalate polarised discussions.'
Sutton is not yet clear on what shape his coalition will take or how it will be funded, but he wants it to be separate from government. 'Government can be the reason why people lack trust in where information comes from,' he said.
AI: a growing misinformation threat
Even as Sutton works to pull together his coalition, Australian researchers are tracking a new and growing misinformation threat: artificial intelligence-enabled bots.
Automated accounts have long plagued social media. But they have generally been fairly easy to spot. Not any more.
Bot developers have linked Twitter and Facebook accounts to AI models like ChatGPT, giving the bots the ability to post like humans – and even respond or retweet. 'The bot is pretty much mimicking human behaviour,' said Dr Muhammad Javed.
His team at Melbourne's Centre for Health Analytics has tracked these bots as they made a major impact on social media discussions of vaccination. In preliminary data presented to the Communicable Diseases & Immunisation Conference earlier this month, they found nearly a quarter of social media content around the new RSV vaccine was generated by bots – most of it around safety concerns.
Loading
Social media companies have made efforts to limit anti-vaccination content – but the bots were getting around this by behaving as though they were real humans posting adverse effects they had received from a jab, Javed said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
5 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Australia needs to cough up its ‘regulatory hairballs', declares PC boss
Productivity Commission boss Danielle Wood is calling on all levels of government to launch a war on red tape and bureaucracy, describing an avalanche of laws over recent years as 'regulatory hairballs' that have held back living standards. Before the federal government's three-day economic roundtable, which Treasurer Jim Chalmers says will tackle red tape in areas from housing to mining approvals, Wood will use a speech on Monday to argue that politicians have sought to over-regulate the country at the expense of economic growth and opportunities for all Australians. Wood is one of the key attendees at the roundtable that will include business, community and union leaders who will canvass issues ranging from the shape of the tax system to the rise of AI to the lack of competition across parts of the economy. In an address to the National Press Club, Wood will say that economic growth has fallen down the list of priorities. Governments at all levels have instead focused on other policy goals. This had contributed to 'regulatory creep' where governments feel they have to respond to any issue with new laws or red tape, as voters looked to a 'Canberra fix' that ultimately led to decisions that slowed growth. Loading She will argue all governments should follow the lead of the administration of former American president John F. Kennedy, which put up signs in the US Commerce Department asking: 'What have you done for growth today?' 'Perhaps it's time to distribute that sign to government agencies and ministerial offices all around our country,' she will say. 'Regulatory hairballs have found their way into almost every corner of our economy. Growth has simply fallen down the list of priorities in policymaking.'
Perth Now
5 hours ago
- Perth Now
Agency chief's solution to economy woes
Decision makers must adopt a 'growth mindset' to fix the productivity problem plaguing the economy, according to Australia's productivity tsar. Labor's highly anticipated Economic Reform Roundtable will kick off on Tuesday, bringing together 'a range of people with a range of views', as described by Anthony Albanese. The point of getting unions, business leaders, and policy experts in the same room as politicians is building consensus on how to boost productivity, or how efficiently an economy produces goods and services. Productivity Commission (PC) chair Danielle Wood will use a major speech on Monday to call on fellow roundtable attendees to be bold as they 'thrash out potential reforms to kickstart Australia's flagging productivity growth', warning that failure could bust the 'generational bargain' of handing over a better country to the future. 'I'm thrilled by the new appetite for economic reform that the roundtable has created over the past two months,' Ms Wood will tell the National Press Club, according to a copy of her speech seen by NewsWire. 'Ultimately the government will be judged on its actions and the outcomes they achieve. 'But it has taken an important step by recognising and pursuing economic growth, and the productivity that drives it, as a prime goal of policy. 'This 'growth mindset' – an elevation of growth and the benefits it brings – has been missing from Australian policy for far too long.' Productivity Commission chair Danielle Wood is calling for a 'growth mindset'. Aaron Francis / The Australian Credit: News Corp Australia Faced with challenges posed by geopolitical turmoil, climate change and an ageing population, she will point out that young Australians do not believe they will have 'better lives than their parents'. 'The expectation that life will get better for each successive generation is Australia's generational bargain,' Ms Wood said. 'For many generations we have fulfilled its promise. Until, perhaps, this one. 'Overwhelmingly, young people today believe they won't live better lives than their parents did. 'As chair of the Productivity Commission, I'm worried too.' She will note that the PC has already given the Albanese government some options. Her agency released five reports over the past month zooming in on key areas, ranging from increasing economic agility and workforce training to harnessing artificial intelligence and the net zero transition. On economic dynamism, the PC proposed reforming Australia's corporate tax system to encourage business investment, which has declined since the Global Financial Crisis. It would cut the corporate tax rate for most businesses to 20 per cent and introduce a 5 per cent cashflow tax on all businesses, with a view to creating friendlier conditions for investors. The result, according to Ms Wood, 'would increase investment by $7.4bn and GDP by $14.6bn'. 'Big enough to get out of bed for, I would think,' she will say. Sky News Political Editor Andrew Clennell has commented on the Albanese government's upcoming economic roundtable. 'We know in terms of tax reform, GST and capital gains tax and negative gearing have already been ruled out by the PM,' Mr Clennell said. 'But there does seem to be consideration of a road user charge.' On AI, the PC warned against a new overarching regulatory framework for AI and instead update existing regulations to address risks like fraud and discrimination. 'This would translate to an additional $116bn in economic activity – equivalent to boosting incomes for each Australian by $4300 a year over that period,' Ms Wood will say. 'A growth mindset means that we must not regulate our way out of this opportunity.' Less regulation was an overarching theme in all the PC's reports. Using those the reports as guides, Ms Wood will put forward three 'lessons about what a growth mindset looks like'. 'Regulate with growth in mind,' she will say, calling for 'leadership from the top when the policy sausage is being made'. The Albanese government's Economic Reform Roundtable will kick off on Tuesday. Martin Ollman / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia In a nod to AI, she will say, 'Real growth comes from new ideas and technology,' arguing that productivity growth comes from new ideas, products, processes, and ways of managing people. While physical inputs have limits, human ingenuity does not, Ms Wood will say. Therefore, a growth mindset should focus on fostering innovation and enabling Australia to benefit from its own inventions and those of others. Her final lesson is that productivity 'is a game of inches'. 'There is simply no single policy reform that can bring productivity growth back to its long-term average of 1.6 per cent,' Ms Wood will say. 'To shift the dial, governments will have to make a lot of pro-productivity decisions.' Though, acknowledging the mammoth task, she will say she is 'optimistic that there is a package here that can make a difference to Australia's prosperity'. 'Governments must embed the importance of growth in every decision they make,' Ms Wood will say. 'This means engaging with trade-offs, better program delivery and design, and the 'boring but important work' of reducing administrative burden. 'We must ensure that governments pursue a growth agenda, for the benefit of businesses and workers today and, more importantly, for the generations to come. 'And that's worth a few days locked in a room.'
The Age
5 hours ago
- The Age
Australia needs to cough up its ‘regulatory hairballs', declares PC boss
Productivity Commission boss Danielle Wood is calling on all levels of government to launch a war on red tape and bureaucracy, describing an avalanche of laws over recent years as 'regulatory hairballs' that have held back living standards. Before the federal government's three-day economic roundtable, which Treasurer Jim Chalmers says will tackle red tape in areas from housing to mining approvals, Wood will use a speech on Monday to argue that politicians have sought to over-regulate the country at the expense of economic growth and opportunities for all Australians. Wood is one of the key attendees at the roundtable that will include business, community and union leaders who will canvass issues ranging from the shape of the tax system to the rise of AI to the lack of competition across parts of the economy. In an address to the National Press Club, Wood will say that economic growth has fallen down the list of priorities. Governments at all levels have instead focused on other policy goals. This had contributed to 'regulatory creep' where governments feel they have to respond to any issue with new laws or red tape, as voters looked to a 'Canberra fix' that ultimately led to decisions that slowed growth. Loading She will argue all governments should follow the lead of the administration of former American president John F. Kennedy, which put up signs in the US Commerce Department asking: 'What have you done for growth today?' 'Perhaps it's time to distribute that sign to government agencies and ministerial offices all around our country,' she will say. 'Regulatory hairballs have found their way into almost every corner of our economy. Growth has simply fallen down the list of priorities in policymaking.'
