Gerry Adams' victory in libel case against BBC 'bound to have a chilling effect', says legal expert
Gerry Adams winning his libel case against the BBC is "bound to have a chilling effect" on both the journalism and legal sectors, a legal commentator has said.
Joshua Rosenburg, a legal commentator who worked at the BBC for more than 20 years, said Mr Adams' success will "make people think twice about defending cases... It will make people think twice about investigative journalism".
"Even if they thought that they were in the right, but they simply couldn't afford to go to court."
He added: "It will make people ever more careful to ensure that they don't say something that they can't defend and justify in court."
On Thursday, the former leader of Sinn Féin was awarded €100,000 (£84,000) in damages after winning his libel action against the BBC over allegations made in a Spotlight programme and online article.
It claimed that he sanctioned the killing of British agent Denis Donaldson; he denies any involvement.
Speaking outside the court in Dublin, Mr Adams said the case could have been settled "a long time ago".
However, Mr Rosenburg said settling a libel case "means making an apology, which is very embarrassing".
"The BBC said that it supplied extensive evidence to the court of the careful editorial process, and it was accepted and conceded by Gerry Adams' legal team that the broadcast and publication were in the highest public interest.
"They clearly felt they had no option but to defend their journalism."
Despite losing the case, BBC journalist Jennifer O'Leary said: "I had nothing to hide, only sources to protect, and I want to thank them for trusting me".
BBC director Adam Smyth said the organisation was disappointed with the verdict.
He said: As our legal team made clear, if the BBC's case cannot be won under existing Irish defamation law, it's hard to see how anyone's could. And they warned that today's decision could hinder freedom of expression."
Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Brit teen jailed in Dubai over holiday fling begs for mercy
The teen has pinned his hopes of release on a pardon from Dubai's leader 'PLEASE FREE ME' 'PLEASE FREE ME' Brit teen jailed in Dubai over holiday fling begs for mercy A BRITISH teenager jailed in Dubai over a holiday fling has begged for mercy. Marcus Fakana, 19, has submitted a plea for clemency to the country's ruler. 2 Brit teen Marcus Fakana, 19, jailed in Dubai over a holiday romance, has begged the country's ruler for clemency Credit: PA 2 The Brit teen is being held at the harsh Al Awir prison Credit: AFP He was sentenced to a year in prison for having consensual sex with a 17-year-old British girl. Both Marcus and his young lover had met while on holiday with their families. Marcus, who was 18 at the time, has been held for months in the harsh Al Awir prison. He has now pinned his hopes on a pardon from Dubai's leader, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum. READ MORE UK NEWS CASHING IN 9m pensioners will get Winter Fuel Payment after U-turn - will YOU get the cash? Radha Stirling, founder of Detained in Dubai, which is supporting the teen's family, said: 'This has been the most traumatic and life-altering experience imaginable for Marcus. 'He is barely an adult himself and never intended to break any law. 'What happened was legal in the UK and consensual. 'But now he is facing permanent damage to his mental health and future prospects.' Prison conditions are reportedly taking a toll on Marcus, who is said to have only limited contact with his family. His parents, from Tottenham, North London, have made repeated appeals to Foreign Secretary David Lammy MP. I jetted off on ultimate lads' weekend…only to be arrested, tortured at 'Dubai Alcatraz' & threatened with death by firing squad They have also asked the British Embassy in Dubai to help secure his release. Ms Stirling added: 'Marcus has shown remorse and fully respects the laws of the UAE. 'He only hopes the government will show compassion and allow him to return home to rebuild his life. 'We implore Sheikh Mohammed to hear his pleas.'
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
New Maddie evidence found in prime suspect's lair - from toys to 80GB hard drive
Christian Brueckner was revealed to be the chief suspect in the case of Madeleine McCann's disappearance with German police examining evidence from his property An explosive new Madeleine McCann documentary has revealed new bombshell evidence that may prove that Christian Brueckner is the prime suspect in the case. The new film hones in on circumstantial evidence found in his lair that points directly to why German national Brueckner is the prime suspect in the case that has gripped the world since Madeleine vanished in 2007. Clues have been few and far between since little Madeleine disappeared during a family holiday to the Algarve some 18 years ago. The investigation uncovers the disturbing finds at Brueckner's abandoned factory as well as his sickening obsession with young children. 'Madeleine McCann: Inside the Secret Evidence' digs into circumstantial evidence, including images of children's swimming costume and toddler toys that were found at his property. The Sun's documentary also claims police found a mask, guns as well as sickening child kidnap stories written by Brueckner. "A very small girl enters the room," he said. "She's definitely not older than five. Blonde, long hair tied in pigtails bounces cheekily back and forth as she comes towards me. I feel like I'm in paradise right now." In one harrowing tale reportedly penned by Brueckner described using chemical ether on a mum and toddler outside a preschool. The documentary also revealed the existence of an 80gb hard drive that could have played a key role in persuading investigators to go after Brueckner. The hard drive also put Brueckner at the heart of the search location in Arades Dam, in Portugal. The documentary also revealed Brueckner also wanted to "capture something small and use it for days." He also threatened it would not matter if "evidence is destroyed afterwards" before adding: "I'll make a lot of Police files show the biggest leap forward in the understanding of the case since German police announced in 2020 that Brueckner was the chief suspect in the Madeleine McCann case. The documentary also revealed how Brueckner refused to answer police questions and fail to give an alibi. Brueckner has not been formally charged over Madeleine's disappearance or her murder. It also featured an interview with Irish holiday rep Hazel Behan, 41, who Brueckner was cleared of having raped in 2005 during a trial in Germany last year. The documentary uncovered details that outlines investigators' fears that Brueckner could end up taking what he knows with him to the grave without any closure being given. The most recent search for any clues related to the search for Madeleine McCann lasted three days in Praia da Luz, last week. It happened close to where Brueckner is known to have had camped. German investigators were aided by Portuguese police and were seen using diggers and radar to search into the ground. Despite this "noting of consequence" was discovered.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Fury as BA calls Falkland Islands capital by its ARGENTINIAN name in ‘ludicrous and insulting' blunder
Falklands war veterans slammed the error, which BA promised to investigate FALKLANDS FURY Fury as BA calls Falkland Islands capital by its ARGENTINIAN name in 'ludicrous and insulting' blunder BRITISH Airways has been branded disgraceful for using the Argentinian name for the capital of the Falklands Islands on in-flight entertainment screens. The UK's flag carrier airline refers to Port Stanley as Puerto Argentino. Advertisement 3 Port Stanley is the Falkland Islands' only city Credit: Rex 3 255 British military personnel died in the 74-day conflict in 1982 Credit: Getty The British title is relegated to a set of brackets underneath. Ed West, of The Spectator magazine, spotted the blunder and said: 'Curious wording for a British Airways in-flight map.' Last night, BA promised to investigate as the error was described as 'ludicrous' and 'insulting' by Falklands war veterans. Argentina still claims sovereignty but its invading forces lost the 74-day conflict in 1982. Advertisement British forces scrambled halfway around the world to put down General Leopoldo Galtieri's troops after they took Port Stanley in a surprise raid. This Saturday is the 43rd anniversary of Britain's victory. Former head of the Royal Navy, Admiral Lord West, who won the Distinguished Service Cross during the war, said the name error was 'disrespectful' to islanders. He told The Sun: 'It's disgraceful. Advertisement 'The Falklands are a British overseas territory and 99.9 per cent of islanders want to stay British. 'We have said very clearly there will be no discussions about sovereignty. The New British Airways First Class Seat 'For the flag carrier airline to give Port Stanley another name is unforgivable.' Lord West, whose HMS Ardent was sunk by Argentine forces, added: 'I don't know why they would do it. Advertisement 'Everyone on the Falkland Islands calls it Port Stanley. 'They should change it back as soon as possible. 'This is insulting to the population of Port Stanley.' In all, 255 British personnel lost their lives defending the islands. Advertisement In 2017 Argentina's senate voted to rename Port Stanley as Puerto Argentino and celebrate Sovereignty Day there if it is ever recaptured. The in-flight map shows only the names of world capitals and not countries' names. It means BA does not reference the Falklands by its Argentinian name Islas Malvinas. British Airways' parent company, International Airlines Group, is based in Spain. Advertisement A BA spokeswoman said: 'We are grateful this has been brought to our attention. 'We'll be reviewing it with the third party supplier that provides the in-flight map service.'
