JD Vance says UK and US have 'disagreements' over Gaza during Kent visit
JD Vance said the US and UK have 'disagreements' over their responses to the crisis in Gaza but share the same 'common' goal to end the war as he met David Lammy to discuss the conflicts in Ukraine and the Middle East.
The US vice president begun his UK holiday with a visit to the foreign secretary's country retreat at Chevening in Kent.
Appearing alongside the foreign secretary on Friday, the vice president confirmed Washington had 'no plans' to recognise Palestine, which Britain has pledged to do unless Israel agrees to a ceasefire.
Vance, who has previously accused the UK of retreating from democratic values, struck a more positive chord as he spoke of his 'love' for the country during his trip to the Grade I-listed stately home.
The two men went carp fishing in a pond near the 17th-century house, and are understood to have caught some fish.
He heaped praise on his 'good friend' the foreign secretary, and said Britain and the US should work together to 'bring greater peace' to the world as the two countries 'have a lot in common'.
The two men went carp fishing in a pond near a 17th-century house in Chevening, Kent. / Credit: PA
However, he made clear that there were differences of opinion between the two administrations on how to address the war and humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
Asked by reporters at the top of a bilateral meeting with Lammy what he thought of the UK's plans to recognise Palestine, Vance said: 'Obviously, the United Kingdom is going to make its decision.
'We have no plans to recognise a Palestinian state. I don't know what it would mean to really recognise a Palestinian state given the lack of functional government there.'
He said both sides wanted to 'solve that problem' of the crisis in Gaza, but 'may have some disagreements about how exactly to accomplish that goal, and we'll talk about that today'.
Sitting alongside the US vice-president at the start of a bilateral meeting at Chevening House, the foreign secretary said: 'Of course we will be discussing the developing situation in Gaza, which is a great concern, and of course the ongoing war in Ukraine, and the desire to see that come to an end.'
Vance visited Chevening while on holiday in the Cotswolds with his family who join him to go fishing with Lammy. / Credit: PA
Despite coming from differing political backgrounds, Vance and Lammy are said to have developed a personal rapport, bonding over their difficult childhoods and Christian faith.
Vance visited Chevening while on holiday in the Cotswolds with his family, who joined him and the Foreign Secretary to go carp fishing at the countryside estate on Friday.
'Unfortunately, the one strain on the special relationship is that all of my kids caught fish, but the foreign secretary did not,' the vice-president said.
'It is great to be here, my wife and I love this section, this area of the UK and we were actually here a couple of years ago, so we love this country.
'Just on a personal note, I have to say that I really have become a good friend, and David has become a good friend of mine, and so it's great to spend some time here with him… you've been a very, very gracious host to me and the whole family.'
Friday's meeting comes at a time of persistent global uncertainty, with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu suggesting an expansion of his country's campaign in Gaza and Russian President Vladimir Putin reportedly preparing to meet US President Donald Trump in the coming days..
Vance said the US government's two goals are 'very simple', saying: 'Number one, it's we want to make it so that Hamas cannot attack innocent Israeli civilians ever again, and we think that has to come through the eradication of Hamas.
'Second, the president has been very moved by these terrible images of the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, so we want to make sure that we solve that problem.
'I think all of us can work on how to solve that problem. Obviously, it's not an easy problem to solve, or it would have already been dealt with, but we share, I think, that focus and that goal. We may have some disagreements about how exactly to accomplish that goal, and we'll talk about that today.'
Asked about the criticism he has previously directed at the UK over issues like freedom of speech, he claimed his concerns related more widely to 'the entire collective West'.
In February, Vance claimed that a 'backslide away from conscience rights has placed the basic liberties of religious Britons' under threat, and attacked the use of laws to enforce buffer zones around abortion clinics.
'I think the entire collective West, the transatlantic relationship, our Nato allies, certainly the United States under the Biden administration, got a little too comfortable with censoring rather than engaging with a diverse array of opinions,' the vice president said.
'I just don't want other countries to follow us down what I think is a very dark path under the Biden administration.'
Lammy said 'commonalities and differences' in political debate were part of the 'joy of living in a democracy like ours'.
STV News is now on WhatsApp
Get all the latest news from around the country
Follow STV News
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Anthony Albanese says Benjamin Netanyahu is ‘in denial' about crisis in Gaza
Benjamin Netanyahu is 'in denial' over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, Anthony Albanese claimed after a phone call with the Israeli leader, saying frustration with Israel's military campaign in the besieged territory was part of Australia's decision to recognise a Palestinian state. The prime minister's escalating public criticism of Israel comes as the French president, Emmanuel Macron, overnight welcomed Australia's commitment to recognise Palestinian statehood at the UN General Assembly in September. 'I spoke with prime minister Netanyahu. He, again, reiterated to me what he has said publicly as well – which is to be in denial about the consequences that are occurring for innocent people,' Albanese told ABC TV. Albanese yesterday said Australia's pledge to recognise a Palestinian state was 'predicated' on conditions agreed to by the Palestinian Authority, which included no role for terror group Hamas in a future government. The prime minister said the international community could block Hamas from standing in future elections in Palestine, but refused to say whether Australia would revoke its plans to recognise if such conditions were not met. 'You can [stop Hamas from standing in elections] if you have the Arab states in the Middle East all speaking as one, as well as the Palestinian Authority, as well as the international community. Yes, you can,' he told Nine. In a press conference, Albanese went on to say that violence in the region, including Israel's planned military occupation of Gaza City, 'just cannot continue into the future without an end point.' 'The international community is coming up with an end point, which is, how do we resolve this? How do we get a permanent security position?' he said. Macron, who declared in July that France would recognise Palestinian statehood at the General Assembly, said Australia was 'joining the momentum' of a global push toward resolving the crisis in Gaza. 'This reflects our commitment to the two-State solution and to the need to collectively rebuild a political pathway, without which there can be no peace and security for all,' he wrote. There are a raft of unanswered questions including how the Palestinian state will be formed, how it would be demilitarised, and where Australia would establish an embassy. Albanese and foreign minister Penny Wong shrugged off repeated questions in media interviews on Monday and Tuesday about how Australia would respond if the Palestinian Authority's commitments were not met, or if they would reverse their recognition pledge. 'What we will also do is work with the international community to hold the Palestinian Authority to its commitments,' Wong told the ABC's 7.30 program on Monday night. The Coalition opposition is critical of the Labor government's decision, claiming it rewards Hamas, and that the government has failed to answer outstanding questions. The opposition leader, Sussan Ley, said on Tuesday the government hasn't clarified its position on how those conditions will be met. '[Albanese] actually refuses to say what will happen if the conditions that he sets out for recognition are not met,' she told 2GB radio. 'Those conditions are unlikely in many views to be met. One of them is that there can't be a role for the terrorists in any future Palestinian state, but Hamas is there, they're on the ground, they're in control.' Former Liberal prime minister, Scott Morrison, claimed Jewish-Australians would feel a 'sense of betrayal' at the government's shift. 'It will prove a hollow gesture, like for all those who have taken this step before it. None should take any comfort in it. Meanwhile the suffering will regrettably continue in Gaza and the hostages will remain in captivity,' Morrison wrote on his website. Israel's government has been deeply critical of Anthony Albanese's decision, and also said Labor is rewarding Hamas. In a statement on X, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sharren Haskel, said the move was about domestic politics, not peace. '50 of our hostages remain in Hamas's dungeons of torture, being starved to death - being forced to dig their own graves, yet the Australian government has decided now is the right time to reward the monsters of October 7 with recognition of a Palestinian state,' she wrote. 'This decision by Australia won't change anything in Israel or Gaza, but let's be quite clear, this is all about domestic politics, not peace.'
Glasgow Times
3 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Starmer set to speak to Trump alongside European leaders ahead of Putin meeting
The Prime Minister warned on Monday that peace 'must be built with Ukraine, not imposed upon it', amid concerns of Kyiv's exclusion from talks between Mr Trump and his Russian counterpart. The two leaders are set to meet this Friday to discuss the future of the Kremlin's invasion, without the presence of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, Mr Trump has confirmed. Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky (Leon Neal/PA) The US president has also signalled he thinks Ukraine might need to cede territory in order to end the conflict, stating there is likely to be 'some land-swapping going on'. Speaking during a lengthy press conference, Mr Trump pledged to 'try to get back' some of Ukraine's 'oceanfront property' from Russia. He said: 'We're going to change the lines, the battle lines. Russia has occupied a big portion of Ukraine. They've occupied some very prime territory. We're going to try and get some of that territory back for Ukraine. 'They have taken largely – in real estate we call it oceanfront property. That's always the most valuable property.' Mr Trump said he would speak to the Ukrainian president following the summit and suggested he could meet Mr Putin at a later date. The call on Wednesday, organised by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, will include Mr Zelensky. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky (Suzanne Plunkett/PA) In a joint statement earlier this week, the leaders of Britain, France, Italy, Germany, Poland, Finland and the European Commission said: 'Ukraine has the freedom of choice over its own destiny. 'Meaningful negotiations can only take place in the context of a ceasefire or reduction of hostilities. 'The path to peace in Ukraine cannot be decided without Ukraine. 'We remain committed to the principle that international borders must not be changed by force.' The Prime Minister and Canada's Mark Carney had also agreed Ukraine's future 'must be one of freedom, sovereignty and self-determination' during a phone call on Monday. Another week has ended without any attempt by Russia to agree to the numerous demands of the world and stop the killings. In just the past 24 hours on the front, there have been 137 combat engagements, and this is the case every day. The Russian army is not reducing its pressure.… — Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський (@ZelenskyyUa) August 11, 2025 A Downing Street spokesperson said: 'They discussed their unwavering support for Ukraine and ongoing work to stop the killing, and end Russia's war of aggression. 'Both leaders underscored that Ukraine's future must be one of freedom, sovereignty and self-determination. 'They welcomed continued international efforts, led by President Trump, to bring peace and agreed that this must be built with Ukraine, not imposed upon it. 'Both leaders agreed they would continue to work closely with President Trump and President Zelensky over the coming days. They agreed to stay in touch.' No 10 had earlier backed Mr Trump's interventions over the war but warned that Mr Putin cannot be trusted 'as far as you can throw him'. Asked whether Sir Keir believes the Russian president could be trusted in negotiations, the Prime Minister's official spokesman said the UK supported both Kyiv and the US president's push for peace, but not Moscow. 'Never trust President Putin as far as you could throw him, but we obviously will support Ukraine,' he said. 'We will obviously support President Trump and European nations as we enter these negotiations. 'But it is exactly why we've been leading this work on the coalition of the willing, because any ceasefire, as I say, cannot just be an opportunity for President Putin to go away, re-arm, restrengthen, and then go again. 'So we're not going to leave it to trust. We're going to ensure that we're prepared such that we achieve a ceasefire.' US President Donald Trump is set to stage talks with Mr Putin (Jane Barlow/PA) The US president has suggested that any peace deal was likely to involve 'some swapping of territories', with reports suggesting this could involve Ukraine giving up its Donetsk region. But Mr Zelensky has already rejected any proposal that would compromise Ukraine's territorial integrity, something that is forbidden by Ukraine's constitution. He said Mr Putin wanted to 'exchange a pause in the war, in the killing, for the legalisation of the occupation of our land – he wants to get territorial spoils for the second time'. Mr Zelensky added: 'We will not allow this second attempt to partition Ukraine. 'Knowing Russia, where there is a second, there will be a third.'
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Anthony Albanese accuses Israel's Prime Minister of being 'in denial' about situation in Gaza, as doubts are raised about the faith he is placing in 89-year-old Palestinian Authority leader
Anthony Albanese has accused Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of being 'in denial' about the humanitarian catastrophe unfolding in Gaza, as serious doubts are raised about the Prime Minister's faith in the leader of the Palestinian Authority. Albanese revealed on Monday that Australia would recognise Palestinian statehood at the United Nations next month, following similar commitments made by other Western allies including the UK, France and Canada. The long-awaited announcement triggered a flurry of furious criticism from Israel and Jewish groups, who accused the Labor government of playing into Hamas 's hands by 'effectively 'rewarding terrorism'. But Albanese hit back on Tuesday morning, accusing the Israeli government of presiding over a 'completely unacceptable' situation whereby Gazans are dying of starvation. Albanese said that when he spoke to Netanyahu last Thursday, the Israeli Prime Minister made the same argument that he had made a year ago. 'That if we just had more military action in Gaza, somehow that will produce a different outcome,' Albanese told the ABC. 'What it's producing is more and more innocent lives being lost. More and more violence. More and more destitution that we're seeing play out with the starvation that has occurred in Gaza.' Albanese accused Netanyahu of being 'in denial about the consequences that are occurring for innocent people'. But doubts have been raised about the faith Albanese is placing in the 89-year-old Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas. Albanese claimed on Monday he had ensured commitments from Abbas that terrorist group Hamas will play no future role in the Palestinian state, free elections will be held and that he will demilitarise. Abbas, who has not faced election since 2005 in the notoriously corrupt West Bank, has also promised to end 'pay to slay' rewards for terrorists and their families. However, Jewish groups have pointed out that he has a notorious track record of breaking promises. 'He has a record of repeatedly breaking commitments he has made in the past, including numerous unkept promises to hold Palestinian elections,' said Executive Council of Australian Jewry president Daniel Aghion KC. 'Secondly, neither he nor the PA have the power to deliver on those commitments. They do not have the capacity to secure the release of the hostages, disarm Hamas and remove it from control over parts of Gaza.' Colin Rubinstein, Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council executive director, said that Abbas and the Palestinian Authority was 'irredeemably corrupt, and so hated by its own people that, as polls repeatedly show, any election would result in a Hamas victory'. 'The Palestinian Authority has rejected every opportunity to achieve a two-state peace for the last 25 years,' Mr Rubenstein told The Australian. 'It incites its population to hatred of Israel through every available medium, including education, and glorifies and financially incentivises terrorism.' Israeli President Isaac Herzog accused Albanese of handing Hamas 'a reward for terror, a prize for the enemies of freedom, liberty, and democracy'. Meanwhile, Israel's ambassador to Australia Amir Maimon also unleashed on the decision, claiming 'peace is built by ending terror, not rewarding it'. 'By recognising a Palestinian state now, Australia elevates the position of Hamas, a group it acknowledges as a terrorist organisation, while weakening the cause of those working to end violence and achieve genuine, lasting peace,' he said. More than two million Palestinians face severe food insecurity, based on United Nations projections. At least 90,000 protesters marched across the Sydney Harbour Bridge earlier in August to call on the government to sanction Israel. The crisis in Gaza began when Hamas attacked Israel on October 7, 2023, killing 1200 people and taking about 250 more hostage. Israel's military response has since killed more than 61,000 people, according to Gaza's health authorities. Israel has denied the population is suffering or dying from starvation, even though it has throttled the flow of aid to Gaza for months, international human rights groups have said.
