MoD urged to reveal details of nuclear incident at Faslane
Figures show that a Category A event occurred at HMNB Clyde between 1 January and 22 April.
The Ministry of Defence (MoD) defines Category A as the most serious; however, it has claimed the incident was categorised as of "low safety significance" and did not pose a risk to the public or result in any radiological impact to the environment.
HMNB Clyde is based on the banks of Gare Loch at Faslane in Argyll and Bute.
It is the Royal Navy's headquarters in Scotland and is home to Britain's nuclear submarines, which includes the Vanguard vessels armed with Trident missiles.
Nuclear Site Event Reports (NSERs) detail incidents at nuclear facilities and are classified based on their safety significance and impact.
Responding to a written question earlier this year by SNP MP Dave Doogan, Maria Eagle, minister for defence procurement and industry, confirmed dozens of incidents at Faslane and nearby RNAD Coulport - the storage and loading facility for the Trident programme.
Nuclear site events (22 April 2024 to 22 April 2025):
• Coulport: 13 Category C and 34 Category D
• Faslane: 1 Category A, 5 Category B, 29 Category C, and 71 Category D
Ms Eagle stated she could not provide specific details of the Category A or B incidents "as disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the capability, effectiveness or security of any relevant forces".
She assured Mr Doogan that "none of the events caused harm to the health of any member of staff or to any member of the public and none have resulted in any radiological impact to the environment".
However, in the past week, concerns have been reignited over the environmental and public health impact of the UK's nuclear weapons programme.
It comes following an investigation by The Guardian and The Ferret, which uncovered radioactive water from RNAD Coulport had leaked into Loch Long due to faulty old pipes back in 2019.
The secrecy battle went on for six years.
The Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) reported the discharges were "of no regulatory concern", while the MoD said there had been "no unsafe releases of radioactive material" into the environment.
In response to the "catalogue of failures", the SNP's deputy leader is calling for an "urgent explanation" from the UK government as to what actually happened at Faslane.
MSP Keith Brown said: "Nuclear weapons are an ever-present danger and this new information is deeply worrying.
"With repeated reports of serious incidents at Faslane and now confirmed radioactive contamination in Loch Long, it's clear these weapons are not only poorly maintained but are a direct threat to our environment, our communities, and our safety.
"Worse still, the Labour government is refusing to provide any details about the Category A incident."
The MoD said it was unable to disclose the details of the incidents reported for "national security reasons", however all were said to be categorised as of "low safety significance".
A spokesperson for the MoD said: "We place the upmost importance on handling radioactive substances safely and securely.
"Nuclear Site Event Reports demonstrate our robust safety culture and commitment to learn from experience.
"The incidents posed no risk to the public and did not result in any radiological impact to the environment. It is factually incorrect to suggest otherwise.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
43 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
10 pictures from Glasgow's VJ Day 80th anniversary service
The poignant service was attended by senior military personnel from the Royal Navy, Army and RAF and reserve units, and representatives from faith groups and organisations across the city. (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) Lord Provost Jacqueline McLaren, who also attended the event, said: 'When Japan announced its surrender to the allied forces, the time was met with relief and celebration that after six long years the Second World War was finally over. 'People sometimes forget that after VE Day in May there was service personnel still actively engaged in combat, and today we remember them and their sacrifices, just as we did a few weeks ago. (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) 'This is a time to reflect on their selflessness, the courage displayed, and the resilience of those brave people who put their lives on the line, on the ground, in the air, and on the oceans, to keep us safe and to build a better world for our children.' A parade remembering the Glasgow heroes who fought in the 'forgotten war' will be held in Knightswood on Saturday. (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) (Image: Colin Mearns) Bailie Anne McTaggart will represent the Lord Provost and lay a wreath at the Veterans' Memorial Monument. She will also present a commemorative Glasgow 850 plate to the Knightswood veterans' organisation as acknowledgement and appreciation, from the city, of the organisation's work and support to city events and causes over the years.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
VJ day in Scotland marked by pipes at dawn and two-minute silence
Events have been held around Scotland to commemorate the 80th anniversary of VJ Day.A lone piper played at Edinburgh Castle at dawn ahead of a national two-minute silence for those who served in the Far East and Pacific during the Aberdeen, the Gordon Highlanders Association Drums and pipes performed on the city's Castlegate, while in Renfrewshire veterans held a victory Day, or Victory over Japan Day, is commemorated on 15 August each year and marks the date in 1945 when Japan surrendered to Allied forces, bringing World War Two to an end after nearly six years. A service of remembrance also took place at Cavell Gardens in Inverness, where the solemn silence was observed at King Charles III and Queen Camilla joined World War Two veterans, aged between 96 and 105, for a remembrance service at the National Memorial Arboretum in Staffordshire. In an address to the nation later, the King will say the service and sacrifice of those who fought and died in the Asia-Pacific theatre will never be forgotten. The event in Aberdeen was held at the Gordon Highlanders monument. The statue honours the last armoured regiment fighting at the end of the gathered for the event in the city's Castlegate, including representatives from the Burma Star Association and the Royal British American visitors, who were in the city on a cruise holiday, were also in Lively, 78, from Arkansas, told BBC Scotland News: "My father fought in Europe and was put on orders to go to Japan before the war concluded. "I'm glad they are still remembering those men and women who died for us."We can't forget what happened. If you forget history, you re-do history."Fellow veteran, Ernie Palmer, 77, from Georgia, added: "This is so needed. We are forgetting too much and forgetting the price that was paid."As time goes by and veterans die off, it is getting forgotten and isn't being remembered enough, so this is very appropriate."The brutality of the enemy in those days was horrendous. It had to be stopped. It stopped at great cost. So many men from this area paid that cost." Jim Smith, 72, from Aberdeen, was present in memory of his father, Victor, who served in the Gordon told BBC Scotland News: "I wanted to be here to remember my father and his colleagues who suffered. "He was interned by the Japanese for three-and-a-half years."He spoke very little about what happened. He didn't reflect. The only thing I ever heard from him was, 'I was one of the lucky ones'. "He said that the poor devils who didn't come home, they are the ones everyone should think about. He was just thankful he came home." Elsewhere, veterans from the Erskine Home in Bishopton, in Renfrewshire, were joined by family and supporters on a victory group crossed the Erskine Bridge in tribute to those who served at the end of the World War Seymour, 90, who served alongside the Gurkas in Malaya (now Malaysia), laid a wreath at the VJ Memorial Stone at the from Sunderland but now living in Scotland, he was just ten years old when the war ended but remembers street about the walk he said: "It was my way of honouring those who didn't come home."It was an emotional day but also uplifting to see so many people coming together."
Leader Live
3 hours ago
- Leader Live
Category A nuclear incident reported at Faslane naval base this year, MoD confirms
Category A incidents are where there is judged to have been 'actual or high potential for radioactive release to the environment'. The MoD said it is unable to release further detail about the event for security reasons, but stressed it posed 'no risk to the public and did not result in any radiological impact to the environment'. Defence Secretary John Healey described it as being of 'low safety significance'. Officially known as HMNB Clyde, Faslane in Argyll and Bute is home to the Royal Navy's flotilla of nuclear submarines. Figures made public through a response to a written parliamentary question in May show the incident was one of 28 'nuclear site events' recorded at the facility between January 1 and April 22, 2025. Of the other 27 incidents, two were graded category B, seven as category C, 13 as category D and 5 as 'below scale'. Last year there were 119 incidents recorded at the base. In her written answer, UK defence procurement minister Maria Eagle said nuclear site event reports were raised to 'foster a robust safety culture that learns from experience, whether that is of equipment failures, human error, procedural failings, documentation shortcomings or near-misses'. A Ministry of Defence spokesperson said: 'We place the upmost importance on handling radioactive substances safely and securely. 'Nuclear site event reports demonstrate our robust safety culture and commitment to learn from experience. 'The incidents posed no risk to the public and did not result in any radiological impact to the environment. It is factually incorrect to suggest otherwise. 'Our Government backs our nuclear deterrent as the ultimate guarantor of our national security.'
