Maharashtra Govt slaps ₹10 Lakh fine on Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital over denial of emergency care
Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital has been fined ₹10 lakh by a government-appointed committee for violating key provisions under the Maharashtra State Public Charitable Trust Scheme. The committee, led by joint charity commissioner Rajni Kshirsagar, found the hospital guilty after probing the death of Tanisha Bhise — a pregnant woman who allegedly died after being denied admission due to her family's inability to pay a ₹10 lakh advance.
The case brought to light serious lapses in the enforcement of guidelines meant to protect patients in emergencies. As per a government resolution dated April 4, the hospital's refusal to provide immediate care breached Clause III of the charitable hospital norms, which mandate that no advance payment should be demanded in emergency cases and life-saving treatment must be provided without delay.
Further, investigations revealed that the hospital violated its obligations under Section 41AA of the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950, which requires charitable hospitals with annual expenses exceeding ₹5 lakh to earmark 2% of their billing towards an Indigent Patients' Fund (IPF). This fund is meant to ensure free or subsidised care for the economically weaker sections.
The inquiry committee's report, submitted to the Chief Minister's Office on Saturday, noted that Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital not only failed to meet these legal responsibilities but also contributed to a tragic and avoidable loss of life, exposing serious flaws in the system meant to safeguard underprivileged patients.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
13 hours ago
- Time of India
Telangana CM Revanth Reddy instructs officials to prepare action plan to expedite works in medical colleges
Hyderabad: Telangana Chief Minister Revanth Reddy instructed the officials on Monday to prepare an action plan immediately to ensure the functioning of 34 medical colleges with all necessary facilities. According to a release from the Chief Minister's Office (CMO), CM Reddy also ordered the officials to constitute an Official Committee to develop infrastructure in all medical colleges. The Committee should visit each college and submit a report on the development of amenities, the requirement of funds, expediting the completion of all works in the colleges, assistance from the government, etc. CM Reddy held a review meeting with the officials of the Health Department at the ICCC on Monday. He discussed several issues raised by the National Medical Council (NMC) regarding the medical colleges in the state. The Chief Minister directed the officials to prepare a comprehensive report on all the issues related to recruitment in government medical colleges, promotions of teaching staff, increased beds in hospitals affiliated to medical colleges, the requirement of medical equipment in the colleges, and filling of the vacancies. The Chief Minister said that the state government will release necessary funds immediately and that officials should immediately bring to the government's attention the release of funds and permissions from the Union Ministry of Health . The state government will address all these issues by approaching the Union Minister for Health and Family Welfare, JP Nadda, and the concerned officials in the ministry, the CM said. In view of the high demand for nursing staff in Japan, Chief Minister Reddy instructed the officials to include Japanese language as an optional subject in the Nursing Colleges. The Japanese Government has already extended its support to provide arrangements for teaching the Japanese language to nursing students in the state, the Chief Minister said. CM Reddy also suggested that officials study the issue of using an App to closely monitor the patients who come to the hospitals, doctors' services to the patients, and hospital opening times. Considering the importance of medical services and medical education, the Chief Minister instructed the state Chief Secretary K Ramakrishna Rao to conduct a review of these two wings in the third week of every month. State Health Minister Damodar Rajanarsimha, Chief Secretary Ramakrishna Rao, Chief Minister's Principal Secretary V. Seshadri, Chief Minister's Secretary Manik Raj, Health Secretary Christina Z Chongthu, Director of Health Dr. Narendra Kumar and others were present during the meeting.
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Odisha CM Majhi asks health dept to take urgent steps to control spread of diarrhoea
Bhubaneswar: Amidst an outbreak of diarrhoea in some areas of Jajpur and Keonjhar districts, Odisha Chief Minister Mohan Charan Majhi on Sunday directed the health department to take urgent measures to prevent its spread to neighbouring districts. According to a statement from the Chief Minister's Office (CMO), all health facilities in the affected districts have been placed on high alert. "Neighbouring districts have also been advised to remain vigilant. Disinfection of drinking water sources has begun in Jajpur, alongside a temporary ban on street food sales and intensified food safety inspections," the statement added. Adequate supplies of medicines have been ensured and medical teams have been deployed to contain the outbreak, the CMO said. Health Minister Mukesh Mahaling is monitoring the situation through regular meetings with medical officers and administrative officials. A team from the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) has also arrived in Odisha to assist the state government in controlling the outbreak. So far, seven people have died due to the outbreak in Jajpur district , which was first reported on June 9, Additional District Medical Officer (ADMO) Prakash Chandra Bal said. Out of 1,750 people diagnosed with diarrhoea in the district, 1,500 of them have recovered and about 250 are under treatment, officials said. "The situation is yet to be brought under control. When no new patients are admitted to hospitals, we will be able to control it," Director of Public Health Nilakantha Mishra said. Adding to the worries, 11 diarrhoea patients also tested positive to cholera, Chief District Medical Officer (CDMO) Bijay Mishra said. A 14-member central team visited the district on Sunday to assess the ground situation. The team visited some hospitals where diarrhoea patients have been admitted and held a meeting with the district administration. Mahaling also visited various hospitals in Jajpur district and Anandpur hospital in Keonjhar district during the day and interacted with patients and doctors. "It is a matter of concern for us that cholera has been detected in Jajpur. A team from SCB Medical College and Hospital in Cuttack has been deployed in the district. We are trying to bring the situation under control," he told reporters. Rural Water Supply and Sanitation (RWSS) teams are disinfecting drinking water sources in the district, while food inspectors and disease surveillance teams are also working to bring the situation under control, officials said. ASHA and Anganwadi workers, and health workers have been supplied with halogen tablets and ORS packets for distribution among the people, they said. People have been advised to take precautionary measures, avoid having outside foods, and adhere to hygienic practices, they said. Diarrhoea cases have also been detected in parts of the Cuttack district, Astaranga area in Puri district and Bhuban NAC in Dhenkanal district, officials said. Over 50 people were diagnosed with diarrhoea in Gholapur village in Cuttack, and 20 people were affected in Puri's Astaranga. Similarly, over 30 persons in Bhaban NAC have been affected with diarrhoea, they said. In light of rising cases of diarrhoea, the Housing and Urban Development (H&UD) Department has directed all Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) and district-level officials to initiate immediate preventive and response measures. Department principal secretary Usha Padhee has called for enhanced vigilance and real-time monitoring to ensure the sanitisation and safety of all water sources, with particular attention to vulnerable urban pockets. Meanwhile, BJD president and Leader of Opposition Naveen Patnaik accused the state government of taking the cholera outbreak lightly. He said cholera has taken a serious turn in the districts of Jajpur, Kendrapara, Bhadrak, Puri, Cuttack, and Keonjhar, and the outbreak appears to be spreading to other districts as well. Taking to X, Patnaik wrote, "The state government's light-handed approach to the cholera outbreak in Odisha is shocking and disturbing to everyone." "Cholera has endangered people's lives. What had not been witnessed for many years is now disrupting life in various districts," he wrote. Claiming that 14 people have lost their lives due to the outbreak, Patnaik extended his condolences to the bereaved families. He urged the state government to remain alert and take strong, immediate measures to curb the spread of the disease and protect public health.
Hindustan Times
6 days ago
- Hindustan Times
Doctors should not refuse treatment under IPF scheme
PUNE: Towards effective implementation of the Indigent Patients Fund (IPF) scheme and putting an end to discrimination against needy patients, the state government has directed the Maharashtra Medical Council (MMC) to instruct doctors in charitable hospitals not to deny treatment or examination to patients from economically weaker sections, officials said. A government resolution (GR) was issued on Tuesday granting permission to establish a Special Inspection Team under the charity commissioner, medical education and drugs department; and Charitable Hospital Helpdesk for implementation of the IPF scheme. The team will include the charity commissioner, Maharashtra or a nominated member; principal secretary, medical education and drugs department or a nominated member; and head of the Charitable Hospital Helpdesk or a nominated member. Furthermore, the GR states that all charitable hospitals must implement various health schemes of the central and state governments. The departments must prepare and submit to the law and judiciary department a list of hospitals that have received land or concessions from local municipal corporations or central/state government/district collector's office. The decision was taken during a meeting headed by chief minister Devendra Fadnavis on April 23, 2025, to review the functioning of the Charitable Hospital Helpdesk, officials said. For effective implementation of the IPF scheme, the charity commissioner's office must ensure that charitable hospitals display the status of vacant beds, government health schemes, and other related information. This updated information must also be available online and on a dashboard. Besides, disciplinary action should be taken under the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950 and directions issued by the Bombay High Court (HC) against charitable hospitals that avoid implementing the scheme or do not use the online system developed for the scheme. Rameshwar Naik, head of the Special Help Cell, Maharashtra, said that the decision has been taken by the chief minister with the aim that no needy patient should be deprived of treatment for financial reasons. 'An inspection committee will be constituted to conduct an audit of charitable hospitals. The government has also approved 186 posts of charitable health workers that will be filled through outsourcing. These posts will be filled on priority and will assist eligible patients to avail the treatment,' he said. Meanwhile, the government said that to determine the economic status of patients, beneficiary patients must submit any of the following documents namely income certificate from tehsildar, ration card/BPL card or PAN card (if available). The revenue and forests department must instruct tehsildars to verify and issue income certificates after thorough checks. All charitable hospitals should operate only one IPF account. If multiple IPF accounts exist, the funds should be consolidated into one. A centralised system should be created for monitoring these funds through the charity commissioner's office. The facility There are 58 charitable hospitals in Pune, 74 in Mumbai, and 430 across the rest of the state. The IPF scheme was framed by the Bombay HC and rolled out in September 2006; all charitable hospitals in the state have to allocate two per cent of their gross billing to help indigent patients. All charitable hospitals have the mandate to earmark and reserve 10% of their beds for indigent patients to be treated for free, and 10% of beds for economically weaker sections. This aid has to be in the form of free treatment to those with an annual income below ₹1.8 lakh, and at 50% discounted billing for patients with an annual income below ₹3.60 lakh.
