Are filmmakers being silenced by Arbitrary Censorship?
In a democratic nation where freedom of speech and artistic expression are considered fundamental rights, a string of recent incidents involving the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) has stirred fresh debate around censorship and creative liberty in Indian cinema.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The two most prominent cases—Janaki V/S State of Kerala and Sitaare Zameen Par—highlight a concerning trend: creators are being forced to make politically and religiously motivated changes, often with little or no formal communication, just to get their films cleared for release.
A Name That Sparked Controversy
The Malayalam courtroom drama Janaki V/S State of Kerala starring
and Union Minister
was denied censor clearance at the last minute despite being scheduled for release on June 27.
The issue? The protagonist's name—Janaki. According to the CBFC, the name, which is another widely accepted form of Goddess Sita, was deemed inappropriate for a female character portrayed as a victim of assault.
This sudden decision, lacking any formal written notice or show-cause, drew immediate criticism. FEFKA (Film Employees Federation of Kerala) general secretary B Unnikrishnan during his conversation with The Times Of India asked .
'Many Hindu names are derived from deities—will they all face censorship?' Unnikrishnan, noting that his own telefilm with a character named Janaki had previously passed CBFC approval.
This isn't the first time such censorship over character names has occurred. Director M B Padmakumar faced similar pushback over a character named Janaki in his film Token Number. In that case, the CBFC had suggested replacing the name with 'Jayanti' or 'Krishnan'—names that lacked the supposed divine association and only when the name was changed to Jayanti was the film approved for screening.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
CBFC's Micro-Management of Creative Choices
If Janaki V/S State of Kerala presents a case of religious sensitivity gone awry, the CBFC's treatment of Sitaare Zameen Par, starring
and
, showcases an even broader issue—political influence creeping into creative decisions.
Bollywood Hungama in its report stated that after being unhappy with the cuts suggested by CBFC's Examining Committee the film was eventually reviewed by the Revising Committee, headed by Vaman Kendre. Their suggestions involved the following changes
Replace "Businesswoman" with the gender-neutral "Businessperson."
Replace 'Michael Jackson' with the generic term 'Lovebirds.'
Remove a visual element tied to the word 'Kamal' (interpreted as a reference to the lotus, the BJP party symbol).
Most notably, include a quote by Prime Minister Narendra Modi after the opening disclaimer
These demands raise an uncomfortable question: since when did CBFC's role extend to prescribing political messages in fictional narratives? Adding a quote from a sitting prime minister turns it into an ideological imposition.
Despite these interventions, Sitaare Zameen Par was eventually granted a U/A 13+ certificate, and the film released on June 20. But at what cost to artistic autonomy?
Are Certain Narratives Being Silenced?
With growing examples of this kind of interference, one must ask: will upcoming films that delve into sensitive mythological or historical subjects also face similar scrutiny?
A case in point is Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana, starring
as Lord Ram and Sai Pallavi as Goddess Sita.
The story of Ramayana is inherently complex and filled with emotionally intense sequences—Sita's abduction by Ravana, her Agnipariksha (trial by fire), and her eventual abandonment by Ram despite being pregnant with Luv and Kush. These episodes are not only central to the plot but also deeply embedded in Indian cultural memory.
Will the CBFC now raise objections to how Sita's trials are depicted? Will they argue that showing her as a victim undermines her divinity? If using a name like Janaki is already contentious, what of a film that retells her entire journey, including the injustices she faced?
This isn't just hypothetical—it's a very real concern in today's political and social climate, where identity, religion, and ideology intersect more than ever before.
In the words of the late Satyajit Ray, 'Cinema's job is not to provide answers, but to ask the right questions.' It's time the CBFC remembered that.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
23 minutes ago
- Indian Express
When PM Modi went to Cyprus: A Mediterranean push, a buffer against Turkey
Written by Shairee Malhotra On June 15, Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrived in the island nation of Cyprus on a two-day visit, marking the third by an Indian PM after Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 2002, as a key stopover on his way to the G7 summit in Canada. This marked Modi's first foreign tour since Operation Sindoor against the backdrop of escalating tensions in the Middle East and volatile global developments. As evident in Modi's visit in February to the port city of Marseille in France, which also recently hosted the inaugural edition of Raisina MED — an extension of New Delhi's flagship Raisina Dialogue — India is keenly watching and investing in its outreach to the Mediterranean. With its strategic location in the Eastern Mediterranean at the crossroads of Europe, North Africa and the Middle East, Cyprus is positioning itself as a key partner and important node towards realising the India-Middle East-Europe-Economic Corridor (IMEC) linking India to Europe. This convergent outlook on connectivity underpins the two countries' interest in expanding ties. Modi's visit focused on boosting avenues for India-Cyprus bilateral collaboration across a range of sectors from trade and investment to innovation, security and connectivity, and mobility and tourism. Referring to Cyprus as the 'gateway into Europe' for Indian companies, President Nikos Christodoulides and Modi addressed economic stakeholders at the India-Cyprus CEO Forum in Limassol, pitching greater business linkages in the areas of civil aviation, shipbuilding, startups, infrastructure and innovation. Bilateral trade in 2023-2024 was valued at $136.96 million, and a newly launched trilateral India-Greece-Cyprus (IGC) Business and Investment Council is likely to accelerate this. Already, Cyprus, with a population of only 1.3 million, is among the top 10 sources of Foreign Direct Investment into India due to its friendly taxation regime and the routing of various European investments via Cyprus. Freshly signed MoUs between NSE International Exchange Gift City and Cyprus Stock Exchange will bolster financial ties. Moreover, Cyprus may become the second European country after France to adopt India's UPI for cross-border transactions. In tandem with recent custom, Modi also interacted with the 11,000-strong Indian diaspora in Cyprus, with plans for direct air connectivity and enhanced people-to-people ties on the radar. As the India-EU entente strengthens across multiple sectors from technology and trade to security and defence, this outreach to Cyprus forms part of a robust and expanded Indian footprint in Europe, moving beyond traditional power centres and tapping new geopolitically significant geographies. In recent years, New Delhi has deepened its engagement with the Central and Eastern Europe region, the Nordics, the Baltics and now increasingly the Mediterranean. Meanwhile, Cyprus's upcoming six-month Presidency of the Council of the EU in 2026 is an opportunity to shape narratives at the EU level and progress towards concluding the India-EU Free Trade Agreement, already touted as a priority by the Cypriot government. The visit was strategically timed on the heels of rising Indian tensions with Turkey that provided overt political and military support in the form of drones, cargo planes and a warship to Pakistan during clashes following the terrorist attack in Pahalgam. Since then, India has attempted to galvanise countries to unify against terrorism and consolidate global support following Operation Sindoor and its targeting of Pakistan's terrorist infrastructure. Both India and Cyprus have historically reinforced each other's positions in their respective regional disputes on Kashmir and Turkish-occupied Northern Cyprus. Considered amongst India's most 'time-trusted and dependable friends', Cyprus has supported a permanent seat for India on the United Nations Security Council, and its entry into the Nuclear Suppliers Group. To counter a belligerent Turkey-Pakistan-Azerbaijan axis, India has systematically deepened relations with Greece, Cyprus and Armenia, which have their own troubled histories with this alignment. Against this backdrop, Modi's visit to the Green Line, the demilitarised buffer zone between Cyprus and the Turkish-occupied Northern Cyprus, was a symbolic act of solidarity with the former. The India-Cyprus joint declaration devoted a substantial section towards counter-terrorism efforts, including dismantling of terrorist infrastructure and safe havens, coupled with strong Cypriot condemnation of the Pahalgam terrorist attack. The two countries are aiming to expand defence ties, building upon a previous MoU signed in 2022 and a Bilateral Defence Cooperation Programme (BDCP) in 2025, through greater defence industrial cooperation, new dialogues on maritime security and cybersecurity, and cooperation on crises responses and emerging technologies. Renewable energy is another area of convergence, given Cypriot efforts in gas exploration in the resource-laden Eastern Mediterranean and India's quest to diversify energy imports. As New Delhi and Nicosia upgrade their partnership and deliberate on the formation of a five-year roadmap for the future, harnessing economic and geopolitical synergies will pave the way for a promising, fresh era in Indo-Cypriot relations. The writer is Deputy Director and Europe Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Canada Admits: Kanishka Worst Terror Attack in Our History
/ Jun 23, 2025, 03:24PM IST At the 40th anniversary of the Air India Flight 182 bombing, Canada's Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree delivered a powerful speech, calling it the "single worst act of terrorism and mass murder in Canadian history." Speaking from Ireland alongside Indian leaders, Anandasangaree described the tragedy as an "act of pure hatred and evil", reaffirming Canada's commitment to fighting terrorism. The minister honored the 329 victims—most of them Canadian citizens—and urged the global community to stay united against hate, extremism, and intolerance. His strong words come at a time when India has also urged Canada to act decisively against extremist threats, especially Khalistani groups. Watch this emotional and politically significant moment that may reshape Indo-Canadian counterterror efforts.#kanishkabombing #airindia #airindiakanishka #garyanandasangaree #canadapublicsafety #terrorism #indiaremembers #329lives #fightterror #canadaindia #massmurder #kanishkabombing #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews
Time of India
31 minutes ago
- Time of India
$80 per barrel: 4 ways Strait of Hormuz closure will impact India, and what the Govt can do about it
The war against Iran continues to escalate, with the United States getting directly involved in a bombing campaign against the country's nuclear facilities. President Trump further escalated his rhetoric on June 22 with him claiming that he's aiming for a full-scale regime change in Iran, which had led to fears about a long-drawn out conflict, something vice-President JD Vance ended up directly addressing in an interviews with NBC News's Meet the Press. There is no credible evidence of Iran developing nuclear weapons, but even without such an arsenal, Iran's regime has powerful economic leverage at its disposal, namely its control over the Strait of Hormuz. Should the regime blockade this vital trade route, mass economic disruption is sure to follow, with India being no exception. Here are 4 ways a blockade might disrupt the Indian economy, and what the Govt can do about it. 1. India imports 40% of its oil from the Middle East 40% of India's oil supply is imported from Middle-Eastern countries such as Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Iraq and the United Arab Emirates. All the trades routes for these countries pass trough the Strait of Hormuz, so a blockade will disrupt the oil supply from all these regions. What India can do: Diversify its supply focus to alternative countries such as Russia, and Qatar. 2. Oil prices may rise to $80 per barrel 🚨 🇺🇸 🇮🇷: BREAKING: IRANIAN PARLIAMENT HAS VOTED TO CLOSE STRAIT OF HORMUZ.- 20% of the Worlds oil supply travels through this area. - Expect major oil price spike, major supply shortages, and inflation reverberating throughout the US and oval economy. The Strait of Hormuz blockade's supply disruptions are likely to raise global oil prices beyond the current benchmark of $77. Prices can go up to $80 per barrel, or even $90, per analysts like Goldman Sachs, should the situation continue to escalate. What India can do: Provide oil and petroleum subsidies to cushion the impact of short-term fluctuations and prevent the costs from being passed down to the consumer. 3. Increased diplomatic dependence on Russia and Qatar While alternative suppliers such as Russia and Qatar provide a large proportion of India's oil already, the Strait of Hormuz blockade will risk increasing India's dependence on them. India's trade relations with Russia have already come under scrutiny thanks to the war in Ukraine, so it may be prudent to diversify the alternatives at the country's disposal. What India can do: Lean further into suppliers from the United States, West Africa and Latin America, even if those suppliers end up more expensive. 4. Supply chain disruptions and delays We have been closely monitoring the evolving geopolitical situation in the Middle East since the past two weeks. Under the leadership of PM @narendramodi Ji, we have diversified our supplies in the past few years and a large volume of our supplies do not come through the Strait… Even if adequate trade deals remain in place, a major blockade will still have cascading effects and lead to broader disruptions in the crude oil supply chain. An escalating war against Iran may lead to hard-to-anticipate delays in oil shipments, not to mention the disruptions that inevitably arise when India reworks its suppliers. What India can do: Tap into its strategic petroleum reserves to offset short-term supply disruptions and ensures the country never suffers from an extended petroleum shortage. Escalating tensions in the Middle East are bound to disrupt crude oil supply chains for not just India, but many regions across the world. However, as Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri has said, India is already diversifying its suppliers and reducing its dependence on the contested trade route. With the right steps towards preparedness, India can weather the imminent disruptions and maintain its geopolitical strength.
