Edmonton's decision to pass on Broberg/Holloway looking so much better just now
Article content
The Edmonton Oilers Broberg/Holloway fiasco hadn't been top of mind in Oil Country, but then came a viral tweet from the St. Louis Blues this past week, that franchise gloating about its offer sheet success with the two former Oilers.
Article content
https://t.co/0PyfNa8ZTu pic.twitter.com/mWRfeHYpo3
— St. Louis Blues (@StLouisBlues) May 13, 2025
Article content
The Blues' post on X-twitter got me thinking again about the matter, as did Edmonton's second round victory over Vegas, with both Jake Walman and John Klingberg combining to give the Oilers excellent minutes as the second pair defensive unit.
Article content
The money used to pay Walman and Klingberg this year is arguably the same money that the Oilers could have used to match the Broberg and Holloway offer sheets, at least if the Oilers had been in an aggressive and risk-taking mood last August when new GM Stan Bowman had to make that call.
Article content
Make no mistake, Edmonton's failure to sign Broberg and Holloway were and always will be a major screw-up by the Oilers. At the same time, Klingberg and Walman represent an excellent use of that cap space.
Article content
Overall, it could well be that the Oilers are a better team now than they would be if they had matched the offer sheets, and I'm not just saying that because Dylan Holloway missed the 2025 playoffs due to yet another injury in his injury-riddled career, thought that can't be set aside.
Article content
Article content
To assess Bowman's decision at the time, let's look at the facts he faced.
Article content
1. Due to neglect, slow-promotion, and the over-cooking of Broberg, the young player had soured on the Oilers organization by the fall of 2023.
Article content
When the Oilers sent him to Bakersfield of the AHL that fall, Broberg requested a trade. Broberg played well in Bako and it could be that if GM Ken Holland had pounced then and tried to sign up Broberg to a new deal, showing great interest in the player at a down moment, he could have got him signed. Oilers.
Article content
2. St. Louis had made a move to trade for Broberg and Dylan Holloway during the 2024 season, but Holland refused to make such a deal. That said, he evidently knew of St. Louis' interest in the players. Did he ever pass that on to Jeff Jackson, who took over from Holland as GM on July 1, 2025?
Article content
3. Jackson went on a free agent splurge that July, bringing in Viktor Arvidsson and Jeff Skinner and bringing back team free agents like Adam Henrique, Connor Brown and Mattias Janmark. There was wide approval of these moves, including from me, but the assumption was that Jackson also was close to reasonable deals with Holloway and Broberg, both Restricted Free Agents. Broberg had been a Top 4 d-man in the Stanley Cup Final, with Holloway a second line winger in that series. Surely the Oilers would not risk losing such fine young players to offer sheets, right?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
37 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Triumph reunites to lay it on the line at Stanley Cup final in Edmonton
EDMONTON – Canadian rock legends Triumph will reunite for a three-song set ahead of Game 2 of the Stanley Cup Final on Friday. The Mississauga power trio — Rik Emmett, Gil Moore and Mike Levine — rose to fame in the late '70s and '80s with hits like 'Lay It on the Line.' The song gained a new wave of attention after being used heavily in Rogers' playoff television promos during its hockey broadcasts. It will be Triumph's first public performance since 2008. The band last played a private set in 2019 at Mississauga's Metalworks Studios during the filming of their documentary, 'Triumph: Rock & Roll Machine.' Levine will not take part in Friday's reunion show, but Emmett and Moore will be joined by three other musicians for the set. They'll perform outside Rogers Place as part of the Rogers Festival at the Final, which also features The Glorious Sons. The appearance is part of Triumph's 50th anniversary celebrations, which include a tribute album out Friday featuring Slash, Sebastian Bach and more. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 5, 2025.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
From 2015: Connor McDavid becomes Edmonton Oilers' first overall pick in 2015 NHL draft
In 2015, the Edmonton Oilers selected Connor McDavid first overall in the 2015 NHL Draft.
Edmonton Journal
an hour ago
- Edmonton Journal
Panthers hockey world reacts to Edmonton Oilers beating Florida in Game 1
Article content How is Florida Panthers hockey country taking Edmonton's 4-3 OT win over their favourite team? What are they blaming the loss on? The mainstream media, social media and podcasts were full of theories. Here are some of the highlights, with some neutral commentary included as well: Article content Florida fan Jacob Winans @JacobWinans8 Nico Sturm in for Nosek next game. My goodness what a costly mistake. I miss Kevin Stenlund Florida fan kyle @Kylepuck16 We didn't lose the game because of the penalty in overtime so stop blaming Nosed Florida fan Adam @AGBRSports I've got nothing good or positive to say. Florida fan Erik 😺🏆🐀 @erik_on_hockey The good news is, this is among the worst Florida has looked this postseason, so I expect a big response from them. It ain't over yet Florida Panthers Insider George Richards @GeorgeRichards The Florida Panthers had never lost a playoff game under Paul Maurice when leading after the first or second. Until tonight. Leon Draisaitl scores the first and final goal as the Oilers take Game 1 of the Cup Final in OT. Article content Article content Panthers fan Jacob Winans @JacobWinans8 The overtime mistakes and dead legs were bad. But it never has to get there if the Panthers play with an ounce of urgency in the third. To come out at only get two shots on goal the entire third period was completely unacceptable Bill Horosz of the On the ProwlL Florida Panthers Den podcast Panthers were taken off guard by the Oilers being physical last night. That won't happen again. With that they also need to establish a consistent forecheck. It was almost nowhere to be found in Game 1. Florida fan Dylan @miamiguydylan The Oilers beat Bob on the glove side for all 4 goals tonight. Just something worth noting Florida fan mathias @MathiasMejia_ panthers had an off night and still were able to take a fiery edmonton team to OT. they'll be ok Panthers goallie Sergei Bobrovsky There were lots of good things. We put it behind us and get ready for the next game. The next game is a big game. Article content ESPN's ᴀʀᴅᴀ Öᴄᴀʟ @Arda Leon Draisaitl in the Stanley Cup Final: 2024: 0 goals in 7 games on 16 shots on goal 2025: 2 goals in 1 game on 4 shots on goal Florida fan @VinMasiDylan @miamiguydylan Panthers played a fantastic second period and then something just changed. Played terrible the rest of the game. Florida fan Jacob Winans @JacobWinans8 (Fourth line players) Nosek, Greer, Gadjo needs to be a package. If they're not all in the game, none can be in the game. That line was god awful tonight Florida fan Dylan @miamiguydylan Stupid penalty by Nosek leads to that. Going to cry Panthers fan Adam @AGBRSports Like there was no need for that Nosek penalty. Time running out in the period He had time and space. Just play it up the ice, clear the zone. Don't throw it into the stratosphere. Brilliance from Draisaitl and McDavid. Wow. Probably a pretty good sign for the Oilers in the big picture of this series that they were able to comeback and win in a game that was largely dictated by the Florida forecheck. Article content Bill Horosz of the On the ProwlL Florida Panthers Den podcast Players seemed very calm and matter of fact during postgame interviews. A little too calm for my taste. Paul Maurice was heaping praise on Nosek for what he did in Game 3 vs. Toronto and said we wouldn't be here (Finals) if it wasn't for him. Panthers fan TONY-O @MojoFilter64 Seth Jones with the overplay on the side boards near the blue line on RNH caused this play (the winning OT goal) to happen ….. should have forced him inside toward Marchand but he didn't. Panthers fan Koby Doran @Lyteskin_Prince Reinhart, Barkov, Ekblad all being ghost in the most important games lol. Might as well play Bennett line and Marchand line 60 minutes. Panthers fan Robbie @GVGC1970 Panthers were the better the team. Never easy on the pp when they've got McDavid and Drisital. Panthers in six. 👊 Cat 'N' Rats podcaster Kirby Lupul— 😼 🏆 😼 @KJ_Lups Draisaitl performance along with depth scoring / Dman scoring. Really felt FLA needed Game One in this series. A split in Edmonton is essential. First pairing (Ekblad and Forsling) really bothers me vs EDM in playoff matchup- speed and power of Edmonton eats them up Article content Panthers fan Dr. Debunker@doctordebunker Tkachuk @TKACHUKycheese_ lost this game for us. Watch this guy on the ice. Slow as molasses. Hes clearly hurt. Not the same player. Give someone else a shot and sit this one out big guy…Get Tkachuck off the ice . Guy is clearly playing hurt and it shows. Not skating. Put someone else in who gives us a chance Florida fan Jacob Winans @JacobWinans8 Boy there's nothing I love more than a Matthew Tkachuk Great Clips commercial after he just spent the evening doing absolutely nothing of value in Game 1 of the Final Panthers fan ZeroTrust Capo @The_CyberDon You can't make a terrible mistake like that. Nobody was even pressing you Nosek!!! Panthers fan M33 @Moore33Gaming What a stupid way to lose a game. Bill Horosz of the On the ProwlL Florida Panthers Den podcast Don't sit on a lead. When you get a couple of goals past Skinner, dial up the pressure even more. Panthers failed to do that. With that Panthers need to have a net front presence to screen Skinner and deflect shots/handle rebounds. Article content Panthers fan zubic @zubic_eth What an absolute fumble after being up 2 goals 😭 Panthers fan John Ricard @johnricard Could the media gush any more for Edmonton and Mcdavid? It was gross. Florida fan Big Hits 🇺🇸🎸🏒⛳ @young5skiers Head up… It took a penalty call late in overtime to give the Oilers a chance to win the game. If I'm Florida, I'm feeling pretty confident 😎 Florida fan *WADDLEVILLE* @WADDLEVILL61682 They cheated y'all. It's all good though. Only win they'll have 4 dubs till B2B Florida Panthers championships! @SazonBailando Woke up feeling like I got stabbed last night. That OT Oilers goal killed me. ESPN's John Buccigross @Buccigross 14 of the previous 18 Game 1 OT winners have gone on to win the Stanley Cup Final. Florida fan FL PanthersMuse @flpanthersmuse Bobby last night: — .913 SV% — 42 saves — 4 GA — 11 high-danger saves Kept us in it🙏🏻 Florida fan Adam – 🙀🏆 @FlaPnthrsPunk Bob deserved better. Must win in Game 2. 😾 Florida Panthers player Sam Bennett It was a one-goal game, a tight game. It could've went either way. They had a good push in the third. Article content Latest National Stories
