Clinical director supports law change calls after two-month-old dies
Photo:
Supplied
Warning: This story has details of the death of an infant.
A Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) clinical director is supporting calls for a law change mandating medication be checked by two people before it's dispensed following the death of a two-month old baby after she was allegedly given medication at an adult dosage by a pharmacy.
A member of the national executive of the Pharmaceutical Society agreed a change is needed, but said pharmacists need to be better resourced, adding the New Zealand pharmacy workforce "is in crisis".
RNZ revealed Bellamere Arwyn Duncan died at Starship Hospital
on 19 July. The two-month-old was allegedly given an adult dosage of phosphate by a Manawatū pharmacy. A coroner's preliminary opinion is she died from phosphate toxicity.
The revelations have prompted the Ministry of Health and Health New Zealand to "urgently" undertake a joint review into the incident with Medsafe visiting the pharmacy to ensure they are safe to continue operating. The Pharmacy Council, which is also investigating, said it's "clear that an awful error has occurred".
Bellamere's parents are calling for a law change that would make it mandatory for medication to be checked by two people before it is dispensed.
Do you know more? Email
sam.sherwood@rnz.co.nz
University of Otago's Dr Jason Wister, a Senior Medical Officer neonatologist and Dunedin Hospital's Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU) clinical director, told RNZ he was in favour of the suggested law change.
"I would be very supportive of that. That is the policy that we have in the NICU. I think that's fairly standard practice within NICUs, that all medications require two people to check them before dispensing.
"It seems like that would be a safe, low-risk, high-reward situation that would take very little time and effort to mandate."
Dr Wister said phosphate was "well known" as a potential for toxicity, especially in infants with "significant morbidity and mortality associated with it".
Bellamere Duncan's parents were allegedly given an adult dosage of phosphate by the pharmacy.
Photo:
Supplied
The medication was prescribed for preterm infants for their bone health and bone growth, he said, and a safe dose for a baby would depend on its weight.
The label on the medication Bellamere was given directed her parents to dissolve one 500mg tablet of phosphate twice daily in a glass of water.
Her parents gave her three bottles in 24 hours as had been recommended, totalling 1500mg.
Dr Wister said the total amount she received would have resulted in a "massive overdose".
"With regards to the effect of the phosphate toxicity, it would most likely be due to causing hypocalcemia (low calcium).
"Phosphorus and calcium are in balance. As phosphorus increases, calcium decreases. An abrupt increase in phosphorus levels could have led to severe hypocalcemia which can cause seizures, muscle stiffening, cardiac arrhythmia, and laryngospasms."
Lanny Wong a pharmacist, director of Mangawhai Pharmacy and a member of the national executive of the Pharmaceutical Society told Checkpoint Bellamere's death was "devastating" and she supported a "full, transparent investigation so the lesson can be learned from this tragedy".
Wong said dispensing medicine like phosphate was "not a routine process" for a community pharmacy.
"It is considered quite a complex process, require precise calculations, specialist knowledge and full attention."
She said phosphate was given in a dispersible tablet.
"It does require the pharmacist to have full attention to do the calculation, and sometimes to cross check the dose against the weight of the baby and with the prescriber before the dispensing go out."
Wong said she was "fortunate" she had multiple pharmacists in her pharmacy, and had her prescriptions checked by another pharmacist if she was doing a "complex dispensing".
Asked if there needed to be changes mandating a second check, she said there did, but said pharmacists needed better support.
"I think it needs to change, but to change it, we need to be well resourced. We need to be well funded, and we need to be supported. That's what we need. But at the moment, we're simply not supported - let's just be frank, New Zealand pharmacy workforce is in crisis."
Wong said New Zealand had 7.95 pharmacists for every 10,000 people compared to 9.3 in Australia, 9.1 in the United Kingdom and 9.6 in the USA.
"So we are absolutely stretched. So our number do matter. There's a lower density of pharmacist means there's more pressure on people, longer working hours, reduced rate, and all the vital safety check has been compressed at the moment.
"And on top of that, pharmacies are acting like a shock absorber as well for the rest of the primary health system. You know, for people that can't see GP, they're actually going to go see their pharmacist. And, you know, and the government wanting us to do more vaccinations and our jobs is becoming more complex, but we haven't received the funding or the support to help us do this."
Bellamere was flown to Starship Hospital after she suddenly stopped breathing.
Photo:
RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly
On Monday, a police spokesperson confirmed to RNZ police were undertaking inquiries on behalf of the coroner. If police detected any criminality then it would be up to the coroner to decide if they paused their inquiry while police carried out further investigations.
Health Minister Simeon Brown told RNZ on Monday he raised the incident with the Director-General of Health as soon as he was made aware.
"She assured me that there would be an investigation undertaken by both the Ministry of Health and Health New Zealand. That investigation is underway.
"I am advised that this incident has led to Medsafe undertaking an urgent assessment of the pharmacy. A further investigation is being undertaken by the Pharmacy Council, and the death is also the subject of a Coroner's inquest."
Health agencies would provide information to the coroner as needed to support the inquest.
"It is important that the reviews are undertaken, and that the circumstances that led to this incident are understood. I expect that these investigations may propose recommendations, and that these will be reviewed once reports are complete."
Labour health spokeswoman Ayesha Verrall said in a statement to RNZ she was "horrified" to hear of Bellamere's death.
"I will follow the outcome of the review closely to see if there are opportunities to stop this from happening again."
A Health and Disability Commissioner (HDC) spokesperson said the Pharmacy Council had notified HDC of the incident as was required under the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act.
"HDC has referred this complaint back to the Pharmacy Council to manage as we consider they are best placed to address the issues raised."
The Pharmacy Council said they were unable to comment further when asked by RNZ on Monday whether they supported calls for a law change.
"Our enquiry and investigation processes are currently underway and, until these are complete, we cannot provide any further details. At the end of the process, we will make any recommended changes to ensure as best as possible an event like this does not happen again."
Pharmac's director equity and engagement, Dr Nicola Ngawati told RNZ medicine doses for children were generally worked out based on the child's weight.
"And so many formulations for children are oral liquids to allow for accurate dosing. These oral liquids may also be more suitable for certain adults, for example, people who are unable to swallow tablets.
"Whether or not a medicine is manufactured in an oral liquid formulation is a commercial decision for pharmaceutical companies."
Pharmac was always happy to consider funding medicines in an oral liquid form, one of our factors for consideration is suitability," Dr Ngawati said.
Pharmac says medicine doses for children are generally worked out based on the child's weight.
Photo:
While in hospital Bellamere's mum, Tempest Puklowski gave Bellamere her drops for Vitamin D. Nurses also administered her phosphate.
When they left hospital they were given some Vitamin D in a little bottle, and a prescription for iron and Vitamin D.
The following day Bellamere's father, Tristan Duncan went to a Manawatū pharmacy with the prescriptions. He was given the iron, but said the pharmacy refused to give the Vitamin D as the staff thought the dosage was "too high for her age and her weight".
The staff said they would call the neonatal unit and follow-up.
A few days later Puklowski received a call from the unit to organise a home care visit. During the call she was asked if she had any concerns, and Puklowski asked if they had been contacted about the Vitamin D. They had not, and said they would follow up and rewrite the prescription along with a prescription for phosphate.
A day after the phone call, on 2 July, Duncan went to the pharmacy to collect the medication and came home with just the phosphate. Unbeknown to the parents they had allegedly been given an adult dosage of phosphate.
The label on the medication directed them to dissolve one 500mg tablet of phosphate twice daily in a glass of water.
That evening they gave Bellamere her first dose of the medicine in her formula water. They would give her three bottles in 24 hours as was recommended.
The couple noticed in that period that her eating was off, and thought she was "extra gassy," Puklowski said.
"She was still feeding fine. She just wasn't maybe going through a whole bottle compared to what she was," she recalled.
Then, the day after she got her first dosage Bellamere suddenly stopped breathing.
Bellamere was taken to hospital and rushed to the emergency department. Once she was stabilised she was taken to the neonatal unit where she stayed overnight before she was flown to Starship Hospital.
The couple had taken a bottle of the medicine with them to Starship Hospital. She gave it to the staff who saw that they had been given an adult dose. The staff then requested the original prescription which confirmed the script had been written with the correct dosage, but somehow the pharmacy had given the wrong dosage Puklowski said.
"I keep thinking about how much she ended up having and it just makes me feel sick."
Tragically, Bellamere died at Starship Hospital on 19 July.
The couple are adamant they want changes to the system for giving out medication.
"It's the sort of thing that can't really be overlooked," Puklowski said.
"There needs to be something better in effect, rather than just relying on one person to make sure you're getting the right prescription, having at least a few eyes."
The owner of the Manawatū pharmacy that dispensed the medication said in a statement to RNZ the baby's death was "a tragedy".
"Our sympathy is with the family and whānau. This is a very difficult time.
"We are looking into what has happened to try to understand how this took place. There will also be external reviews which we will work with."
RNZ asked the owner how the medication was given at the wrong dosage, whether they disputed the allegations, when the pharmacy became aware the wrong dosage had been given, and what confidence people could have about other medication received from the pharmacy.
The owner said the pharmacy was "devastated about what has happened and are investigating to find out how this occurred".
"It is not appropriate to comment further at this stage."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
17 minutes ago
- RNZ News
'It takes a toll on people' - long-term mental health support needed for flood victims
The Tasman region has been hit by two flood emergencies and repeated orange heavy rain warnings in recent weeks. Photo: Supplied/ Jodie Reed People in the Tasman region will need long-term mental health support after devastating winter floods, a mental health advocate says. Locals have endured two flood emergencies and repeated orange heavy rain warnings in recent weeks. The Rural Support Trust said many already flood-affected residents were feeling tired and very anxious as more heavy rain fell on the region. Mental Health Foundation chief executive Shaun Robinson said when disaster struck, people were usually in a more practical mode, adrenaline pumping, and doing what they needed to do to respond. It was the aftermath that could leave some people feeling depressed, hopeless or isolated - a natural human response to a very difficult situation, he said. "It's then when you have to look at the aftermath and the fact that things are not going to go back to the way they were, that can be really difficult and that's when it can really start to affect people's mental health and well-being," Robinson said. "People need to really create a new sense of what living in that place is going to be about." He described what was happening in Tasman as an "ongoing natural disaster" rather than separate floods. Community connections made a big difference. "What we've seen and what farmers and rural people have told us from the Cyclone Gabrielle experience was that it was communities continuing to work together that made the difference to them continuing to have hope and a sense of not being alone in this and therefore boosting their resilience and mental well-being," he said. The government also needed to look at what support it provided, not only offering counselling, Robinson said. "Whatever communities do and whatever government does to respond to a situation like Tasman, really needs to be boosting those community networks, those community responses to this ongoing crisis," he said. "It is the months and even years after these major events that we need to encourage that sense of community resilience and actually put some work into creating and sustaining that community resilience. "That is certainly what the government is responsible for resourcing as part of its response to natural disasters." It was important that communities felt supported and did not feel like the country had forgotten them, he said. Robinson hoped people would feel comfortable to reach out and ask for support if they needed it. Rural Support Trust Nelson Tasman chair Richard Kempthorne said people were getting tired after heavy rain has battered the region multiple times within the space of weeks. "It certainly takes a toll on people. Many of these people who've lived in the area for years and they've lived on their properties for years and they've had flooding before," Kempthorne said. "But very few people have had a flood to this extent." Many people in the Motueka and Wai-iti valleys relied on their business in the area for income so flooding also threatened their livelihoods, he said. "During the flood event, it will just be step back and let it happen. Once it drops, what's the damage left and then what can we do? "What we encourage and what people I think are actually quite good at is to chopping it down into - what do I need to do first and what are the steps I need to take? Not trying to do it all at once and just bite one chunk off at a time." Kempthorne said people should reach out for help as there was support available. That included Taskforce Green which was going onto farms to clear debris, Big Bake in Wakefield which was preparing food for rural communities, Federated Farmers, and the Rural Support Trust which offered counselling support. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
What you need to know about Wednesday's nurses strike
Nurses held an 8-hour strike last December. A new strike is planned for 24 hours on Wednesday. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Nurses are going on strike on Wednesday. About 36,000 nurses, midwives and health care assistants will be off the job from 9am Wednesday to 9am Thursday. Last-ditch negotiations on Monday failed to reach an agreement . There will be pickets and marches throughout the country. Nurses are concerned about staffing levels and safety . The latest pay offer was also dismissed as a "massive backward step" . Health NZ is offering a 3 percent pay rise over 27 months, plus two lump sum payments of $325. NZNO's counter-offer seeks a 5 percent pay rise over two years, along with $2000 flat rate increases for senior positions. The union also seeks to restore a Tikanga Māori allowance. "The average salary for both senior and registered nurses, including overtime, PDRP allowance, and penal rates, is $125,662, Health NZ said . "Members also need a wage offer that enables them to meet the rising cost of living without them and their whānau going backwards financially for the important mahi they do," said Paul Goulter, chief executive of the New Zealand Nurses Organisation. "We believe the offer we have made to the union is a fair one given our current financial constraints," Health NZ said. In a statement, Health New Zealand said "we are disappointed that the New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO) is taking strike action when there is a fair offer on the table." "We are concerned about the impact strike action will have on patients who are waiting for planned care." Goulter said the latest offer from Health New Zealand ignores worries about safe staffing . "Patients are at risk because of short staffing. Nurses, midwives and health care assistants are stretched too thin and can't give patients the care they need. This is heartbreaking for our exhausted members who became health care workers because they want to help people." A safe staffing agreement was dropped from negotiations with Health New Zealand. Figures obtained by NZNO from Health New Zealand show surgical hospital wards were short-staffed more than half of all day shifts last year. Health New Zealand said in their statement it also seeks to keep nurses and patients safe. "While we are aware of NZNO's commentary in recent weeks we would like to reassure New Zealanders that Health NZ is completely committed to safe staffing. "For us safe staffing in a busy hospital environment includes the skills mix of the staff, the way care is provided, strong clinical judgement, flexibility and thoughtful decision making from our experienced leaders on the frontline. We take responsibility for operational and patient safety decisions seriously as we are accountable for the safety of patients who access our services." Paul Goulter, chief executive of the New Zealand Nurses Organisation. Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon Goulter said the key issue was making sure there was enough staff to "ensure patient safety", which was "foremost in the minds of our members" during negotiations. "While, obviously, there's a wage element, we're trying to do our best to ensure we get staffing that's appropriate to meet what patients need and we seem to have come up short on that," he told RNZ recently. Negotiations began last October, but the union said bargaining had stalled over "big ticket items" centred on public safety. Nurses also walked off the job in strike in December for eight hours. "We are striking because patient safety is at risk every day due to chronic understaffing and under-resourcing," Wellington nurse Hilary Gardner said. "We simply don't have enough nurses to provide the level of care our patients need and deserve. It's not safe, and it's not fair - for patients, their whānau, or the staff trying to care for them. We've raised concerns time and time again, but nothing changes - so now we're taking action to stand up for safer care." Acute and emergency services will still be provided, including maternity care, intensive care, ambulance services and emergency departments. Patients already in hospital will still receive ongoing care. "... The public can be reassured that we have an agreement with NZNO for life preserving services support throughout the strike and our hospitals and emergency departments will remain open," Health NZ Chief Executive Dr Dale Bramley said. "To maintain patient safety, most clinics will be closed. However, if you have a hospital appointment, please come to your appointment unless we have contacted you directly to reschedule." However, most appointments for the strike days will be rescheduled. "It is estimated that 4300 planned procedures and specialist appointments would have to be postponed should the 24-hour strike action on 30 and 31 July go ahead," Dr Bramley said. Aged residential care, St John Ambulance, GPs and hospice services are not affected by the strike and will carry on as normal. Anyone unsure about whether they need emergency department care should contact their GP or call Healthline 0800 611 116 for free advice. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone The union does not rule out further action if their concerns aren't met, Goulter said. "Our members have indicated this strike is just the beginning and they are in it for the long haul." "Our members don't take this action lightly. They are striking because they are exasperated with being short-staffed and their patients being put at risk because Te Whatu Ora refuses to resource safe staffing levels and instead staffs to an arbitrary budget set by the government. "The public know that when there aren't enough nurses, patients wait longer to get the care they need. Critical observations and treatments may be delayed, errors are more likely and health outcomes worsen. A lack of nurses has reduced numbers of elective surgeries for years and contributed to longer waiting times and the current backlog. "Any member of the public who has been to a hospital recently knows the reality for patients and the nurses, midwives, health care assistants and kaimahi hauora who care for them." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
More support needed for rural Māori looking after whānau with dementia, researchers say
Dr Makarena Dudley. Photo: University of Auckland / Supplied Too many rural Māori whānau are caring for loved ones with dementia - or mate wareware - without support, diagnosis or the information they need, according to two leading brain researchers. Sir Richard Faull, director of the Centre for Brain Research at the University of Auckland, and deputy director, Māori, Dr Makarena Dudley, say Māori and Pacific people are affected by dementia more than any other group. They spoke to Nine to Noon about travelling around the country visiting marae sharing information and hearing stories. So far they've held hui at marae in the Far North and Whanganui, and more are planned. Dudley said the goal is to reach out to all Māori communities, particularly those in remote areas, to share information about the condition and gather the kōrero of caregivers. "Some of these caregivers are desperate for support, they're caring for sometimes loved ones who are exhibiting very challenging behaviours. Looking after somebody who has mate wareware particularly in the more severe stages of the condition can be extremely challenging and often even amongst Māori families that responsibility is often left to one person." Providing support for caregivers is one of the major parts of this program, Dudley said, many are isolated in rural areas and don't know where to turn to for help. "There was an international study done actually across a number of nations that caregivers often die more than the person they are tending to." Aotearoa is in the midst of conducting a nationwide prevalence study, which has another year to go, but once it's finished there will be accurate data about the extent of dementia among Māori, she said. The goal of travelling around to marae is to reach out to all Māori communities to give them information about dementia and listen to their experiences with the condition, she said. "Then we can take that information back with us and decide okay so here are the issues, here are the problems, how are we going to address this, how are we going to help to fix this and so we've visited around about 25 marae so far. .. we've spoken to hundreds of kaumātua, we've listened to their stories, some of them quite heartbreaking. "One of the main themes that's come across from all these visits is that there is a profound lack of information available to the Māori community and more so for those who are living more remotely not only is there a lack of information but there are virtually no services available to them." The Centre for Brain Research is currently funding a program to support caregivers in Ahipara, Dudley said so far its been a success and it's service that doesn't require a lot of funding. Dudley has also helped develop an app to help Māori affected by dementia. The app provides all the basic information a whānau might want to know about dementia, she said. The app provides all the basic information a whānau might want to know about dementia. Photo: supplied Faull said the ethos of the Centre for Brain Research is not only to do research but communicate that research to people and then listen to them. Faull said it's a privilege to go out to marae to listen to people and put that ethos into action. "We are actually seeing an absence of services in so many ways, this is for Māori and non-Māori, but especially for Māori so that's why it's important for us to go out and tell them about the risk factors." If you address the risk factors you can reduce the prevalence of Alzheimer's by about 60 percent, he said, so communicating that to people on the ground is vitally important. Sir Richard Faull. Photo: University of Auckland / CBR Dudley said when developing a model for treating dementia that resonates with Māori they need to use the information from both knowledge bases, western science and mātauranga. "They need to know information from both worlds." "Because there is a lot of information out there now but Māori don't really buy into it, it doesn't resonate with them because its not in their speak, it's not familiar to them the language that is used the way it is introduced to them." The Centre for Brain Research is currently working to produce a model that works for Māori, she said, once that happens she believes progress will be made in reducing incidents of dementia. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
