A for effort: First year of cellphone bans in Canadian schools gets mostly positive marks

CBC

a day ago

Sixteen-year-old Roha Akram was skeptical when teachers in Calgary announced a cellphone ban during the first assembly of the school year.
"I was like, 'No one's going to follow this,"' the Grade 11 student recalled of the change in September.
"It's just the nature of teenagers. We don't like rules."
Teachers didn't want to see phones on desks or in pockets, Akram added. "They wanted it in the backpack, in the locker, in the car."
She said the ban has been good for some students, who just need a reminder to focus in class, particularly when teachers are speaking. But others have struggled.
One teacher took a phone away from a boy who was really attached to his device, she said. "He started acting crazy. He went around asking everyone, 'Can I use your phone? Can I use your phone? I need to go on Instagram.'
"I saw phones are kind of becoming an addiction."
Last fall, most provinces introduced policies to limit cellphone use in schools, similar to jurisdictions in other countries.
Now, as the school year wraps up, education ministries across Canada say the impact of banning cellphones has been positive overall.
They say it has taught students not to develop unhealthy attachments to their phones and to focus on lessons in the classroom.
Before the ban, Manitoba Education Minister Tracy Schmidt said a school librarian complained to her that students were too quiet sitting around the stacks of books.
"The students would come in groups, sit down at a table together, pull out their cellphones and they would all sit there. You could hear a pin drop," said Schmidt.
The cellphone ban has returned the chatter and socialization among students, she said.
"They still come with their groups of friends, but now they're sitting, they're talking, they're laughing. They might pick up a board game. (The librarian) was really, really grateful to the province for taking this step."
Ontario 's education ministry said parents and teachers found the ban created a better learning environment.
"As we close out the first full year of implementation, we will continue gathering input to understand how the policy has worked in practice, where it has been effective, and where further support may be needed," said spokesperson Emma Testani.
In Nova Scotia, school staff were surprised by how smoothly it was to implement the new directive, said education spokesperson Alex Burke.
"While not all students like leaving their devices out of the classroom, there is a general acceptance of the benefit of limiting cellphone use and appreciation of the opportunity to ignore their phones," said Burke.
WATCH | Teachers say students are more focused:
Ontario teachers see benefits from classroom cellphone ban
6 months ago
Duration 2:18
Four months into Ontario's ban on cellphones in classrooms, many teachers say students have accepted the change and are more focused, but it's too early to say if there's been an impact on performance.
The Edmonton Public School Board, Alberta 's largest school division, said it didn't notice any significant issues.
"Schools had the flexibility to determine how best to implement the ban, whether it meant introducing new practices or adjusting current ones," said spokesperson Kim Smith.
A year of the ban doesn't mean students aren't still using phones in class, admitted Akram. Some have just become more sneaky.
One fellow student used a textbook to hide his phone while teachers were talking, she said.
"He just watches YouTube Shorts the whole class."
Akram said she also occasionally uses her phone during work time in class — her AirPods in her ears, under her hijab — so she can listen to music.
When teachers do confiscate phones, they're typically returned at the end of class or the school day, she added.
Akram said she can see why the ban might be necessary for Generation Z and students with unhealthy attachments to their phones.
She said she thinks teachers will be stricter with the ban next year.