SBI seeks review of SC ruling denying secured creditors priority over attached assets
State Bank of India
has filed a petition seeking review of the Supreme Court's May 15 judgement that held that secured creditors will not have priority of interest over movable and immovable properties attached by the Maharashtra government under the provisions of the Maharashtra Protection of Interest of Depositors (in Financial Establishments) Act, 1999.
SBI
said the decision needs to be reviewed as it creates a bad precedent, thereby undermining the certainty and sanctity of secured lending; violated established doctrines of repugnancy and exclusive legislative competence; eroded the priority rights of secured creditors, thus impacting India's credit system and
NPA resolution framework
.
'Section 238 IBC (
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
) gives it overriding effect over any other law. In case the moratorium is disturbed, and the assets are alienated, it would seriously jeopardise and frustrate the effective implementation of a Central Act viz. IBC,' the SBI said.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Buy Lifetime Office 365
ps.sbs
Download
Undo
The impugned judgment misapplied Article 246 by allowing a state law (MPID Act) to override or dilute Parliamentary laws—SARFAESI Act (2002) and RDB Act (1993), the review petition filed by counsel Sanjay Kapur stated.
'...enforcing a security interest is one of the prime objectives behind the enactment of the
SARFAESI Act
by the Parliament and it does not overlap with the objective of the MPID Act. However, if the attachment proceedings against the Secured Asset under MPID Act is allowed to be continued, it would directly disrupt the functioning/operation of the Parliamentary enactments viz. SARFAESI Act, IBC, etc, and would result in apparent repugnancy, in which case the parliamentary enactments would prevail,' the PSU bank said.
Live Events
While upholding the Maharashtra government's decision to attach the properties in the Rs 5,600-crore
National Spot Exchange scam
, which had affected over 13,000 investors in 2013, the
SC
had in May held that the state depositors law will override the provisions of Central
financial recovery statutes
, including the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act and IBC.
The top court said that "no priority of interest can be claimed by the secured creditors against the properties attached under the MPID Act, and that the provisions of MPID Act would override any claim for priority of interest by the secured creditors in respect of the properties which have been attached under the MPID Act."
It further held that properties of the judgment debtors and garnishees attached under the 1999 Act would be available for execution of decrees passed by a committee set up by the apex court despite a moratorium provision under Section 14 of IBC.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Aquarius Daily Health Horoscope Today, July 17, 2025: Let your heart guide your healing
Forgiveness is not about forgetting—it is about freeing yourself from the past. Today offers a chance to let go of old hurt and create space for peace. You are not weak for forgiving; you are brave for choosing peace over pride. Let your heart lead. Whether it's forgiving someone else or yourself, release the burden. Lightness follows when you stop carrying pain that's no longer helping you grow. Aquarius Health Horoscope Today Your body may hold emotional stress today. Headaches, fatigue or stiffness could be signs to slow down. Gentle yoga or breathing exercises can help. Avoid skipping meals, and focus on warm, nourishing food. Keep your water intake up and stay away from stimulants. Balance is key—your body heals better when your emotions are lighter. Aquarius Wellness Horoscope Today Your wellness improves when you allow emotional flow. Cry if you need to, talk if you feel heavy. Don't pretend everything is okay—honour your feelings with honesty. Spend time with someone who listens, or simply write what you feel. Today is not about fixing everything but making space for healing. Choose peace over pressure. Aquarius Love Horoscope Today In relationships, healing is possible today if you allow it. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Đây có thể là thời điểm tốt nhất để giao dịch vàng trong 5 năm qua IC Markets Tìm hiểu thêm Undo If you're in a relationship, an open-hearted conversation can bring you closer. If you're single, reflect on what kind of love you truly deserve. Don't carry past pain into future connections. Love begins with self-kindness. Allow your heart to soften. Aquarius Career Horoscope Today In work, you may feel emotionally distracted. Don't ignore tasks, but also don't force too much. Focus on work that brings meaning or creativity. Avoid overthinking how others see you. Do your part sincerely and trust that consistency pays off. Forgive past mistakes at work too—you're allowed to grow. Aquarius Money Horoscope Today Today offers a calm energy for money matters. You may have a realisation that changes how you spend or save. Let go of guilt tied to past financial choices. Start fresh. A new opportunity or advice may come your way—listen with an open mind. Even a small step toward financial healing is worth celebrating. Aquarius Affirmation Today: I release the past and choose peace today. Discover everything about astrology at Times of India , including daily horoscopes for Aries , Taurus , Gemini , Cancer , Leo , Virgo , Libra , Scorpio , Sagittarius , Capricorn , Aquarius , and Pisces . Read your detailed Horoscope Today and Horoscope Tomorrow here.
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Who fired Maurene Comey and Why? See ex-FBI Director daughter's high profile cases and what happened on day of departure
Maurene Comey, a senior federal prosecutor in the Southern District of New York and daughter of former FBI Director James Comey , has been dismissed from her position. Her removal comes after years of high-profile prosecutions, including cases involving Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell , and Sean 'Diddy' Combs. Maurene Comey Fired On Wednesday, Maurene Comey was officially fired from the US Attorney's Office in Manhattan. The Justice Department did not publicly announce the reason for her termination. Multiple individuals familiar with the situation said she received no explanation. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Select a Course Category Healthcare Project Management Data Science others Public Policy Management Leadership Degree Data Analytics Others Operations Management Digital Marketing healthcare Design Thinking MBA PGDM Technology Cybersecurity Product Management CXO Finance MCA Data Science Artificial Intelligence Skills you'll gain: Financial Analysis in Healthcare Financial Management & Investing Strategic Management in Healthcare Process Design & Analysis Duration: 12 Weeks Indian School of Business Certificate Program in Healthcare Management Starts on Jun 13, 2024 Get Details Comey had served in the office for nearly 10 years. Her most recent title was senior trial counsel. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like An engineer reveals: 1 simple trick to get all TV channels Techno Mag Learn More Undo Also Read: ESPYS 2025: Start date, time, nominees, host, musical performers, presenters and how to watch on TV and stream live online Maurene Comey High Profile Cases Maurene Comey was part of the prosecutorial team that filed sex trafficking charges against Jeffrey Epstein in 2019. Epstein was accused of running a child sex trafficking network. He died by suicide in jail while awaiting trial. Live Events Comey also helped prosecute Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's associate, who was later convicted and sentenced to 20 years in prison. Maxwell is currently appealing her conviction. Comey also played a lead role in the prosecution of Sean 'Diddy' Combs. The case did not result in a conviction on the most serious charges. Her work on the case had drawn media attention due to Combs' high profile. Trump Administration's Influence Comey's firing comes amid political tensions involving her father, James Comey. He led the FBI during the early investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election. He has faced criticism from President Donald Trump and is reportedly under investigation. A person close to the matter stated that having the Comey name was seen as 'untenable' by the current administration. Right-Wing Pressure Campaigns Targeted Comey In recent months, right-wing figures like Laura Loomer publicly called for Maurene Comey's removal. In May, Loomer demanded Attorney General Pam Bondi fire her. These calls intensified after the DOJ declined to release further files on the Epstein case . Also Read: Stranger Things 5 Trailer: Release date, time, episode schedule, official synopsis, returning and new cast members What Happened on Day of Departure? On the day of her departure, dozens of her fellow prosecutors at the Southern District of New York gathered to escort her out of the building. The show of support followed a year marked by resignations and internal conflict at the office. Earlier this year, several prosecutors resigned in protest when the DOJ ordered the SDNY to halt a corruption investigation involving New York City Mayor Eric Adams. Who fired Maurene Comey? It is unclear whether the order to fire Comey came from interim US Attorney Jay Clayton or directly from the Department of Justice. The office has not issued a statement. FAQs Why was Maurene Comey fired from the Manhattan US Attorney's Office? No official reason has been provided. A source said her family name and political history may have made her position difficult under the current administration. What high-profile cases did Maurene Comey work on? Maurene Comey prosecuted Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and Sean 'Diddy' Combs. She held the title of senior trial counsel at the time of her firing.
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Balasore bandh over student death disrupts traffic on NH-16
Balasore: Hundreds of trucks and private vehicles were stranded on the Kolkata-Chennai national highway at Balasore since the early hours of Wednesday with BJD calling an eight-hour bandh in protest against the death of a 20-year-old college student. The shutdown, observed from 6am to 2pm, led to the closure of markets, offices and educational institutes as locals united in demanding justice for the student, who had set herself ablaze on her college campus on July 12 over alleged inaction against sexual harassment by a faculty member, and succumbed to her injuries on Monday night. Demonstrations were held throughout the district with protesters blocking key junctions, including Station Square and Fakir Mohan Golai Chowk in Balasore town, burning tyres and disrupting vehicular movement. Traffic on NH-16 came to a standstill near Uttereswar in Soro as BJD workers, led by Soro MLA Madhab Dhada, blocked the route. The traffic bottleneck persisted till around 3pm. "I was going from Paradip to Kolkata. Traffic has been stopped due to a strike call by BJD. Many trucks have been stranded here since 6am. We don't know when the vehicles will be allowed to move," Shaikh Faruq, a stranded truck driver, said earlier. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo "We are protesting against the govt's inaction. The girl sought help multiple times but her pleas were ignored. Her death will not go in vain," said Dhada, while addressing media persons during the protest. Shops, govt and private offices, schools and colleges remained closed across the district. Only emergency services such as ambulances and hospitals were allowed to operate. The bandh impacted Balasore town and major blocks, including Soro, Simulia, Khaira, Nilagiri, Remuna, Basta, Baliapal, Jaleswar and Bhograi. Train services were also severely affected. Several trains, including passenger services passing through Balasore railway station, were delayed or halted as agitators protested on the tracks in Balasore and Soro. BJD members blamed the college administration, local police and the state govt for gross negligence, alleging that her repeated appeals for help were ignored, forcing her to resort to self-immolation. "The bandh is not just a protest; it is a collective cry for justice. A young life was lost due to the apathy of those in power. We demand an impartial inquiry and strict action against all those responsible, including the college principal. We also demand the resignation of higher education minister Suryabanshi Suraj and CM Mohan Charan Majhi," said Sabita Sahoo, chairperson of Balasore Municipality. She said the bandh also serves as a warning to the govt to take immediate steps to prevent such tragedies in the future. BJP's Balasore Sadar MLA Manas Dutta said, "While the state govt has already initiated swift action over the incident, the bandh serves no real purpose. BJD called the bandh merely to stay in the limelight. The bandh had zero impact and was rejected by the people." DIG (eastern range) Satyajit Naik said that around 15 platoons of police forces were deployed at sensitive locations to maintain law and order. He said the bandh was largely peaceful, with no major violence reported.
