
Steve Borthwick's selection call could cost Marcus Smith a Lions place
The players will have the same desire but those from England, Scotland and Wales will have an additional motive for wanting the battle to continue to the final whistle of the final game. This is a British and Irish Lions year and, whether you can prove it or not, their natural suspicion is that an all-conquering Ireland side is likely to edge all the marginal decisions when it comes to getting on the plane to Australia in June.
Over the years, I have had the chance to discuss the way that selections work with various Lions managers and coaches and each tour is different. However, there are some points which all of them mentioned as being difficult to deal with and one of those is how you weigh what you see during the tournament and your thoughts about players pre-tournament.
How do you balance the maxim 'Form is temporary, class is permanent' against what is accepted as common wisdom that you must pick players on form? Do you favour an outsider's decent performances in a successful side over a previously favoured player who might have been unable to play because of injury? Does a good display in a poorly performing team show a player's talent or does it just mean that he stands out against a lower benchmark?
Has Borthwick compromised Marcus Smith's Lions prospects?
If we go to a few specifics, we need look no further than the looming selection conundrum around the fly-half position. If you wanted a less in-depth look at this issue, you could simplify it to: ' Steve Borthwick costs Marcus Smith a Lions place' – a harsh but technically true viewpoint when you consider the following.
Before the tournament started, based on past performances and the form shown in the most recent Autumn international series, most people would have had Smith as one of the three fly-half choices, with an outside possibility of him starting over Finn Russell. There was no consensus over Sam Prendergast, Jack Crowley and Fin Smith, who most thought would scrap it out for the third No 10 slot.
If it turns out that Ireland win a slam and England take second place, there is a good chance that Marcus Smith – now England's full-back – might lose out altogether, with both Prendergast and Fin Smith being taken Down Under.
Fan forums chatter is very much instant reaction to the last thing seen and the fact that Marcus Smith was England's most creative force last year will be forgotten. The fact that he was considered the more versatile player and thus was moved to cover the absence of George Furbank will also be forgotten.
A top-two finish might tempt Andy Farrell to overlook the fact Fin Smith and Prendergast are still quite young and their experience is limited. There is no real doubt that both have talent, but we have yet to see whether this is capable of being sustained over time.
Farrell and his selection panel must carefully consider whether it would be the right decision to take two 22-year-olds in such a pivotal tactical position. Neither player will have more than 11 caps and Farrell has to be sure he can cover a situation where Russell is ruled out of a Test for whatever reason.
We will have no way of knowing if this turns out to be the case, but it would be ironic if Farrell were to prefer Marcus Smith over either his England namesake or Prendergast because he wants a player who can cover both 10 and 15 from the bench.
The one other common comment about selection dilemmas concerned injuries. Sometimes it is better to miss losing games, but that depends on you having the reputation in the first place.
Sione Tuipulotu is probably safe, but Furbank is going to have to do outstanding work for his club, Northampton, to get over the line and that presupposes that Farrell is willing to take into account post-tournament form in his decisions.
So, let us hope that the fourth round of this year's competition continues to excite and is better officiated than the third. Although there have been no egregiously poor performances, I think the standard in the tournament thus far has not been much better than average.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
11 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Rangers vs Viktoria Plzen LIVE SCORE: ‘Leaked' team spot on as Souttar CAPTAINS team with Tavernier, Raskin dropped
The Gers have made MAJOR after the manager's comments at the weekend EUR ON Rangers vs Viktoria Plzen LIVE SCORE: 'Leaked' team spot on as Souttar CAPTAINS team with Tavernier, Raskin dropped Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) NOT long not until kick off at Ibrox - as Russell Martin makes a massive gamble by dumping captain James Tavernier and talisman Nico Raskin from the Gers side to take on Viktoria Plzen The new Ibrox gaffer has negotiated past a tricky looking Panathinaikos clash but was furious with his players after Saturday's draw with Motherwell. Sign up for the Rangers newsletter Sign up And he's taken advantage of an immediate chance to shuffle the pack for tonight's Champions League qualifier against Viktoria Plzen. Oliver Antman plays after being registered in time to play a part tonight as rumours circulating online that the Gers boss could make FOUR changes to his starting line-up, including DROPPING James Tavernier, were proved correct Fellow new arrival Mikey Moore misses out due to ongoing registration and international clearance issues relating to his age. The prize for the winner a play-off clash with Red Bull Salzburg or Club Brugge. Rangers are taking on Viktoria Plzen TONIGHT, Tuesday, August 5 It's the first leg of the sides' Champions League third qualifying round clash The big game will be played at Ibrox Stadium in Glasgow Rangers vs Viktoria Plzen kicks-off at 7.45pm UK time High-profile French referee Clement Turpin is in charge with Jerome Brisard on VAR Rangers vs Viktoria Plzen will be shown live on BBC Scotland Coverage will begin at 7.30pm The match can be streamed free via the BBC iPlayer and the BBC Sport Scotland website There will be live radio coverage on Sportsound on BBC Radio Scotland


Daily Mirror
11 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Man Utd to have major say in Liverpool's £150m Alexander Isak transfer chase
Newcastle United striker Alexander Isak continues to face an uncertain future and the Sweden international's next move could hinge on Manchester United's business The future of Liverpool target Alexander Isak could yet be impacted with old rivals Manchester United. While United aren't in for Isak themselves, their transfer battle with Newcastle over Benjamin Sesko could have a knock-on effect on the Swede. Liverpool's initial approach for Isak was knocked back by Newcastle, who want close to £150million for their leading man. They have bid roughly half that for Slovenia international Sesko - £69.5m plus up to £8m in add-ons - but dont have a clear run at the RB Leipzig star. According to The Telegraph, Liverpool have no plans to make a renewed bid for Isak as things stand. However, the same publication indicates things might change if the Magpies sign a new striker. Manchester United have a chance to throw a spanner in the works, then. If they are able to beat Eddie Howe's side to Sesko then, in all likelihood, Isak will be going nowhere. The latest developments come as United and Newcastle both brace for a decision from Sesko - with a deadline potentially coming as soon as Tuesday night. The striker is ready to trade the Bundesliga for the Premier League, but both clubs will feel they have a case. It has been a frustrating summer so far for Newcastle. Anthony Elanga their only senior outfield signing, joining in a £55m move from Nottingham Forest, while goalkeeper Aaron Ramsdale has joined from Southampton. They have missed out on other targets, though, with French striker Hugo Ekitike opting for Liverpool and Joao Pedro choosing Chelsea. It's not just forwards who have looked elsewhere, either, with centre-back Dean Huijsen moving to Real Madrid and goalkeeper James Trafford deciding to rejoin Manchester City. One man who could yet move to St James' Park is Yoane Wissa. Eddie Howe's side have so far failed to meet Brentford's asking price for the Congolese international, who has now returned to training in West London, but there is still time left in the window. "We're looking for the best players that we can get," Newcastle manager Howe said over the weekend. "Whatever our target position is, we're looking for the best so I see all situations open and available to us. I feel that's the only way that we're going to get to where we want to go, which is to maximise, and it's quality over quantity. "It always has been. That's always been the way that we try to work and the way that we try to recruit, and I think we've done it pretty well to this point. "It's been a challenging summer, because we've missed out on various targets for loads of different reasons, but we're still very competitive, and we're still in there trying to bring very good players to the club - and that won't change til the window shuts."


Daily Mirror
11 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Ferrari told to snub Oliver Bearman for 'super' F1 rookie to replace Lewis Hamilton
Lewis Hamilton raised doubts over his own Formula 1 future at the Hungarian Grand Prix when he responded to his qualifying nightmare by saying Ferrari 'should change driver' Bernie Ecclestone thinks Ferrari should look towards two Formula 1 rookies when identifying a potential replacement for Lewis Hamilton. But the 94-year-old former F1 supremo did not mention the name of Oliver Bearman who is the one actually being prepared by Ferrari as Hamilton's eventual successor. Hamilton's future is firmly in the spotlight right now as a result of his comments at the Hungarian Grand Prix. After qualifying 12th in Budapest, the seven-time F1 champion declared himself "useless" and said his team "probably need to change driver". His mood was not much better a day later when he failed to make any progress in the race and finished where he started, one lap down on the leaders. But Hamilton did at least tell reporters that he would be back after the summer break and that he still loves racing. Ferrari team principal Frederic Vasseur has also jumped to the defence of his driver and it is understood that the team is not even beginning to entertain the idea of replacing Hamilton, either during this season or before the end of his contract which currently runs until the end of 2026. If they were to make a change, they would in theory turn to one of their reserve drivers, Zhou Guanyu and Antonio Giovinazzi, both of whom are former F1 racers with Sauber, or British academy graduate Bearman who is currently plying his trade with customer team Haas and who is seen as Hamilton's eventual successor. But Bernie Ecclestone believes there are a couple of other rookies on the grid who should also be considered. "If I could steal him, I would take Isack Hadjar from Racing Bulls," the former F1 supremo told Mail Sport. "He has done super well in his first year and is a great guy. I also rate our friend from Brazil [Sauber driver Gabriel Bortoleto ]. He is talented. Both of them are sensible, too." While it is unlikely that Hamilton will give up on his dream of winning an eighth F1 title just yet, Ecclestone believes it is time for the 40-year-old to move on. He said: "Lewis is very talented, was and probably still is. But, like a lot of leading sports personalities when they reach the top, there is only one way to go, and it is not a good direction. It is only down. Sky Sports launches discounted Formula 1 package This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more £43 £35 Sky Get Sky Sports here Product Description "They get tired. Lewis is tired. He has been doing what he is doing forever. He needs a rest from it for good, a total reset to do something completely different. He may not think it, but he will soon get used to doing other stuff away from motor racing in retirement. I think he should have done it a while ago. The guy is not a cheat. But he would be cheating himself if he goes on. He should stop now. "If I were looking after him I would negotiate with Ferrari immediately and say, 'If you have someone to replace Lewis, he will step aside. He is not fighting for a World championship and is at a stage of his life when it would not be worth him spending two years laid up in bed with a broken back or anything else nasty. He does not need to take the risk any longer. He has won seven world titles and that is quite enough."