SHC stays appointment of board chairmen
The educational boards in Sindh, awaiting appointments of full-time chairmen for several years, are likely to continue functioning under the interim heads as the Sindh High Court has stayed the recent appointments of eight chairmen for the boards.
The Hyderabad circuit bench on Tuesday put the respondents, including the Sindh government through the chief secretary, Sindh Universities and Boards Department and the Search Committee besides the eight chairmen, on notice for March 26.
"Until the said date, the subject summary shall not proceed to the adversity of the petitioners," reads the order.
The petitioners Abdul Jabbar Abbassi and Sikandar Ali Mirjat were candidates in the recruitment process. The former is an associate professor teaching English language, based in Hyderabad, and the latter is the chairman of the Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education, Larkana.
A summary was moved with those eight names, besides one of Brig Syed Waseem Akhtar, to the Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah on February 3. But Akhtar's name in the shortlisted candidates stirred a reaction in the province because of his domicile of another province, prompting him to withdraw his candidature.
"This is another instance which demonstrates that the recruitment process is a sham and based on nepotism and reeks of mala fides," the petitioners contended.
The CM, on March 1, endorsed the eight names as recommended by the search committee for the appointment.
The two petitioners hinged their case upon the contention that the search committee, which conducted the recruitment, acted out of its purview because its domain is confined to the appointments of the public sector universities' vice chancellors.
Another argument, pleaded by BISE Larkana's chairman Mirjat, cited that none of the eight chairmen had prior experience of working in the educational boards of Sindh.
He alleged that all the board employees with relevant work experience were ignored in the appointment process in violation of the court order. He recalled that the secretary boards and universities had given a verbal assurance in the SHC on December 13, 2024, stating, "In the cases where candidates with equal qualifications are available, preference would be given to those with experience working within the department."
The petitioner pointed out that the same statement was made a part of the judge's order but the government respondents ended up allegedly flouting that order.
There are seven educational and one technical boards in the province. The eight names recommended for the posts of the chairmen include Dr Asif Ali Memon, Ghulam Hussain Soho, Mansoor Rajput, Muhammad Misbah Tunio, Musharraf Ali Rajput, Dr Rafiq Ahmed Chandio, Khalid Hussain Mahar and Dr Zahid Ali Channar. They secured 56 to 59.4 scores in the recruitment process.
The positions of chairman for the BISEs of Hyderabad, Sukkur, Larkana, Mirpurkhas and Nawabshah, as well as the secondary and higher secondary education boards of Karachi and the Sindh Board of Technical Education, were advertised in December, 2023. The petitioners prayed the court to declare the said appointments and the February 20 summary and its March 1 endorsement by the CM as unlawful.
They also pleaded the court to restrain the notification of the appointments and to bar the selected candidates from acting in pursuance of the summary.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Alvi allowed to withdraw up to Rs1m
A constitutional bench of the Sindh High Court (SHC) has permitted former president Dr Arif Alvi to withdraw up to Rs1 million from his frozen bank accounts. A two-member bench of the SHC, headed by Justice KK Agha, heard a petition challenging the freezing of the former president's bank accounts. During the hearing, an investigation officer from Islamabad and National Cyber Crime Agency Director Waqar Ahmed appeared before court. Ahmed requested the court to grant additional time to submit the response.
Express Tribune
4 days ago
- Express Tribune
K-P is abandoning children
The writer is a Lecturer in English at the Higher Education Department, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Email him at namdar057@ Listen to article Let's call it what it is: K-P is abandoning its children. Not metaphorically, not in the way people toss around, 'Oh, the system is broken.' No. The system isn't broken; it's functioning exactly as it's allowed to, with chilling indifference to the rights of the most vulnerable. A recent report by the provincial Education Department pulls no punches. Legions of children enrolled in over 10,000 public schools across K-P arrive each day at buildings as bare as unfinished construction sites. No boundary walls. No electricity. No washrooms. Not even drinking water. Over 5,000 schools in K-P operate without a single watt of electricity. In more than 2,000 schools, safe drinking water is a rarity. Thousands more lack washrooms or a protective wall around them. In Peshawar — the provincial capital itself — 21 schools are in the dark, 15 can't offer clean water, 17 lack even a toilet and eight stand exposed, wall-less, to the city's sprawl. Peshawar, not some remote hillside village! Think about that for a second. We send our children off to elite schools in cars, armed with water bottles, packed lunches and backpacks stuffed with textbooks. Meanwhile, countless children in this country walk into schools that don't even have a toilet. Is this the dignity we promise every child under the Constitution? Yet, millions don't even get this indignity because they never enter a school at all. Thirty-seven per cent of children in K-P are out of school altogether. That's millions of futures we're snuffing out before they even begin. Nearly eight out of every 10 children in Lower and Upper Kohistan never even make it into a classroom. In Peshawar alone, over half a million are out of school — of those, 319,000 are girls. It's not a gender gap anymore; it's a gulf. And if you thought the ones lucky enough to be enrolled were at least getting a decent education, think again. Because unable to fund enough textbooks, the province now prints half and asks schools to source the rest from promotees, turning scarcity into strategy. The hand-me-down model might sound thrifty, but in practice, it's a debacle. Most old books either fall apart, go missing or are defaced with scribbles, tears and tea stains. And let's be honest: a lot of students just don't return them. So expecting this to work as a long-term plan isn't just lazy or absurd; it's negligent! What all this adds up to is a blatant violation of Article 25-A of the Constitution which guarantees every child the right to free and compulsory education. It also tramples all over the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Free Compulsory Primary and Secondary Education Act, 2017. Laws on paper, like fire alarms in buildings no one checks. Turning this around requires the provincial government to act decisively across several fronts. First, it needs to stop pretending its job is done at enrolment. Children need functioning schools, not just roll numbers. Fixing basic infrastructure — electricity, toilets, clean water, boundary walls — isn't some high-minded reform; it's the minimum standard of decency. Second, launch a real plan - not just window dressing - to bring out-of-school children (OOSC) into the system. This must include targeted efforts in high-need areas like Kohistan — even Peshawar — and the tribal districts, especially for girls left behind in droves. Third, stop slashing textbook budgets and start facing reality. If the government wants students to reuse books, it must put in place a real system to collect and track them. Or better yet, fund a full print run, because this isn't where we should be paisa-pinching. This isn't a resource issue; it's a priority issue. And so far, our priorities are glaringly apparent in every broken classroom, every empty desk and every torn-up textbook. K-P is failing its children. And if this doesn't set off alarms, maybe we've failed too. Because at the very least, K-P's children deserve better. That shouldn't be a radical thing to say.
1729685382-0%2FUntitled-design-(57)1729685382-0.png&w=3840&q=100)
Express Tribune
31-05-2025
- Express Tribune
Weekly delusion
Listen to article Feeling oppressed and nauseous while heading to work? Read the morning paper and you'll find yourself in a mixed state of agony and amusement. As baffling as it sounds, you'll come across news updates that will not only leave you questioning your sanity but will also have you asking yourself: "Do these people really know what they're talking about?" Let me give you an example. The apex court will be hosting a symposium on judicial reforms where focus will be on encouraging the use of technology to modernise our judicial system and make it more efficient as a result. Now, on the face of it, sounds like the need of the moment. I, sitting on my chrome horse, can engage in this revolutionary discussion all I want while sipping on my expensive cold coffee. But you do realise that for modern technology to be utilised efficiently, you need tech literate court staff? Not only tech literate, you need court staff that knows basic English, and knows how to use a computer (which of-course utilises the English language). Also, court staff should be tech literate enough to navigate their way through daily tech troubles to ensure regular tasks don't require calling the IT guy all the time. Not only this, you also require uninterrupted access to high-speed internet which of course, in our country, is a myth. At the slightest of convenience, the not-so-smart officials sitting in telecommunication offices will shut the internet down in the name of 'national security'. Good luck running the system with no internet. 'Sir, system down hai' is a haunting sentence we've all heard. Loadshedding is another story. Don't even get me started on that. Sir(s), you cannot engage in judicial reforms and talks about digitising the judiciary until you hire court staff and clerks who have knowledge of everything I've mentioned above. And all of us recognise the fact that no sane degree holder will work as court staff unless a) you pay them well and b) you don't keep blaming them for actions of the higher-ups (reported fact). In other funny news, over 3,800 vehicles owned by senior bureaucrats and police officials were seen violating traffic laws in Lahore with impunity. Will these people ever be held accountable? Never. They own us. Laws don't apply to them; laws only apply to the slaves who pay taxes. Democratic republic? Not by a country mile. I am sure this is the case all over the country, not just Lahore. A child is a reflection of their parents. Next time you see citizens violating traffic laws, don't be surprised, instead, call up your MPA and give him a schooling (assuming the looking-busy-doing-nothing official answers). A spokesperson for a forum in Karachi which focuses on young parliamentarians stated that it is for the youth, and specifically the youth parliamentarians, to play their role in "modernising legislation" and "assisting the marginalised communities". Are these the same marginalised communities you want to help which persistently get labelled as traitors and terrorists each time they voice their political dissent? Also, respected spokesperson/to whom it may concern, what youth are you referring to? The wise and smart youth have already left the country and the rest are in the process of leaving. Brain drain is real and the sooner we accept the sooner we'll be able to retain skilled labour. About time we accepted the fact that the youth have lost hope in the system. The wise have left, the naïve have stayed. The system has failed us and continues to fail us, every day. We all know how this works but because it has always been about the money and about power, we all continue to be willfully blind to this. By the way, I did my job (that I get paid to do), where is my promotion? Where's my fancy title? Do I get to throw a party too?
