Tenants scarred by flat of horrors
Zoe Eckhoff, 19, and two of her close friends signed a year-long fixed-term lease for a Queen St property, which was set to be their first flat.
However, the tenants soured on the property after inspecting it in late January and discovering vegetation choking gutters, black mould and grease in vents and windows, curtains covered with black mould, rubbish strewn throughout the property, borer dust throughout wooden fittings, peeling lead paint in soffits and broken gutters.
"It was horrendous, to be honest, there was just random furniture everywhere.
"There was pots and pans outside the door, and so much borer as well.
"All of the utensils in the drawers were wet, the whole bench was wet — there was mould everywhere, and wallpaper peeling, and all the stuff you don't want to see as a tenant."
She said the experience was "traumatising" and "terrifying".
In February, the tenants advised the landlord, Man-Oock Holdings, they would be withholding rent and taking her to the Tenancy Tribunal.
The tribunal's first ruling found the landlord "turned a blind eye" to many of her responsibilities under the Residential Tenancies Act, but it was also "not open for one party [the tenants] to unilaterally decide to stop paying rent".
No suppression was available to the landlord because she was only partly successful, the tribunal ruled.
It was only after mediation that Miss Eckhoff and her fellow tenants were able to end the tenancy.
A second tribunal ruling followed, saying "as a result of the agreement all costs will lie where they fall, and the previous order of the tribunal cannot be enforced".
Miss Eckhoff felt the system was stacked against her.
"I think that landlords need to be held way more accountable for the kind of stuff that they get up to.
"It just feels like I was set up for failure."
The emotional toll had been "wrenching".
Last week, Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment tenancy compliance and investigations team conducted visits to 53 Dunedin properties.
The majority had some maintenance issues and three properties had "multiple breaches" of the healthy homes legislation.
Miss Eckhoff said she was pleased to hear about MBIE's initiative, calling it a start.
"I was very happy to hear that, to be honest — thank God someone is doing something about this.
"I hate to say cross-examine your landlord, because it feels like something that shouldn't be our duty, but honestly, it's not a bad idea.
"I wish that I had, because I probably would have found a lot more and it would have been very helpful."
The Otago Daily Times reported in 2019 there had been 21 Tenancy Tribunal cases involving Man-Oock Holdings since 2017.
Man-Oock Holdings did not wish to comment.
matthew.littlewood@odt.co.nz
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
4 days ago
- RNZ News
Landlord finds squalid home, tenant Jessica Michelle Duffy ordered to pay $4822
By Catherine Hutton, Open Justice reporter in Wellington of Photo: 123rf A landlord's final inspection of a house revealed some surprises, including baseball bats and chains under the beds and couches, modifications to the garage and a flatmate still living there with his dog. The landlord, whose name is suppressed, provided the Tenancy Tribunal with photographs of the house to show tenant Jessica Michelle Duffy made no attempt to clean it before she left in February. The landlord described the state of the house as squalid, which the tribunal accepted. "Cupboards were still full, dishes were piled in the sink and bench, the bathroom still had personal items, furniture was still in all the rooms and the woodshed was piled with a tremendous amount of rubbish. "Baseball bats and chairs were found under the beds and couches. The wood burner was loaded with the remnants of burnt aluminium cans and glass bottles. "The bathroom required an immediate application of Exit Mould and personal items removed with gloves, before being considered hygienic enough for occupancy and professional cleaners." During an inspection on 28 January, the landlord also discovered a missing downpipe and a broken window in one of the rooms. Despite being asked in writing to make repairs before mid-February, Duffy made no effort to do so, the decision said. In another room, four large rectangles had been cut into the carpet, destroying it. The carpet also had suspected paint stains that couldn't be removed. As well as the damaged carpets, there was a strong smell of cigarettes, ash and dog throughout all the rooms. As a result, the landlord decided to replace the carpet and sought a contribution from the tenant. The garage had been heavily carpeted, and the walls and windows boarded up and lined with underlay and black material. While the flatmate removed the wall lining, an extensive quantity of boards, material, carpet, underlay, rubbish and personal effects remained in the garage. The garage door was also broken and had to be replaced, because it had been levered open. The recently released decision also noted that, because the keys weren't returned, the locks had to be replaced and the lawn needed to be mowed. In its decision, the tribunal accepted the landlord's claim that the clean-up required two skip bins, and "many hours of stressful and disgusting work" shifting the tenant's rubbish and possessions, although the decision noted the flatmate also helped. Taking into account betterment and depreciation, the tribunal ordered that Duffy, who didn't attend the hearing, pay $4822 to the landlord for the costs they'd incurred. That included rent arrears, rubbish removal, replacing carpet, curtains, and repairs to the window and downpipe, garage door, and replacement locks. - This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .
RNZ News
30-07-2025
- RNZ News
Dunedin City Council warned of 'slumlords' exploiting students
Photo: RNZ / Nate McKinnon A Dunedin student flat horror story is prompting a call to action to prevent others from falling prey to bad landlords and filthy flats. The Dunedin City Council was warned about 'slumlords' exploiting students and vulnerable people and presented with a possible solution to the perpetual problem during a meeting on Wednesday. The council also voted to ask the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) to share how it planned to monitor and enforce the Healthy Home rules in Dunedin to ensure rentals were fully compliant. Zoe Eckhoff was hoping to have a classic Otago flatting experience with her two friends this year, instead it turned into a horror story. The second year student shared her story during public forum, saying that when she and her friends inspected the flat last year, people were living there and it was messy. But she thought it would be clean by the time they moved in so they signed the lease and paid rent for a month. "We found the house in a pretty shocking state, it was mouldy, filthy and completely unprepared," she said. "The landlord refused to engage with us, entered without permission continuously and ignored our concerns." They then discovered their landlord had gone to the Tenancy Tribunal more than 20 times. Things quickly escalated and eventually the police became involved, she said. They went to the tribunal to challenge the unsafe conditions and serious incidents including the landlord screaming at them. Despite this, the students were unable to get out of their lease. But they did not give up. "Only after hiring a lawyer and installing cameras and recording her entering 85 times in 10 days at all hours of the day and night, including about three in the morning while we were still paying rent, were we able to get out of the lease," Eckhoff said. It was lucky they were all locals and had somewhere else to go but it took a big toll on them and their families, she said. "We paid over $5000 for a house we never lived in. We lost study time and faced serious stress and trauma. "All we wanted was a safe, lawful and respectful tenancy and instead we were exploited by a landlord and let down by a system that's supposed to protect us, and we're just one of many student groups that this has happened to and continues to happen to." Zoe's mum Pip Eckhoff said it was stressful going through the Tenancy Tribunal process. "We had an abusive landlord ... and a property that we couldn't move into and the adjudicator made no mention of how to allow us to move in and have the property ready so it really set us up to fail," she said. They did receive $5000 as part of the process. But it was not just one landlord, it was a much wider problem, she said. "Dunedin's housing is declining and unsafe. We have a broken enforcement system and slumlords are exploiting vulnerable people. The impact of ratepayers includes, but is not limited to, fewer students, businesses and families choosing Dunedin as a place to study and live," Eckhoff said. Parent and ratepayer Amanda Dyer said they sought help from nearly every support group across the city, but none could hold the landlord accountable or genuinely help them. The Tenancy Tribunal was not fit for purpose, Dyer said. "It's inaccessible, it's emotionally exhausting and inconsistent. Our case was riddled with factual errors and contradictions. The adjudicator appeared frustrated, even blaming our young adults for submitting the wrong kind of application," she said. The fines for landlords were minimal and did not deter bad behaviour, Dyer said. "Why spend $20,000 fixing up a property when the risk is just a $2000 fine? The fines determined case-by-case by the local Tribunal demonstrate how the system's enabling the slumlords and others repeat offending." Pip Eckhoff asked the council to be part of the solution by boosting its capacity to provide independent housing condition reports. "These reports would help tenants inspect properties like you'd do before buying a house, help tenants in disputes, support MBIE and Tribunal cases and build a report card history on problem landlords," she said. Earlier this year, MBIE's tenancy compliance and investigations teams inspected more than 50 Dunedin rentals, finding that students often discovered problems with the properties soon after moving in. Councillor Marie Laufiso put forward the motion asking the ministry to share how it planned to ensure rentals met the Healthy Homes rules. The Healthy Homes standards - which became law in 2019 and kicked in earlier this month - introduced a new benchmark for heating, insulation, ventilation, moisture barriers and drainage, and draught stopping in rental properties. Laufiso said she saw the toll it took on the tenants and their families to take action against this landlord and this was a way to take action and represent their residents. Councillor David Benson-Pope said it was a sensible decision as the city had a real problem with cold, damp housing. "This isn't just about one appalling landlord, there's a nest of them and they're not just in the campus area," he said. When his son was a student, he lived with his mates in an "ice box" with a little bit of insulation around the manhole but nothing anywhere else, Benson-Pope said. Now that the rules were in place, he wanted to see them enforced. Councillor Christine Garey said she was sadly not surprised to see photos of Eckhoff's flat. Students had raised concerns about speaking up and "rocking the boat" part way through a lease and possibly missing out on the next flat, she said. Migrants and refugees were also vulnerable, Garey said. She had heard of a property manager asking a tenant to sign that their property had the Healthy Home standards in place, only for one of the tenants to find that one of the standards had not been met. The tenant had refused to sign until it was completed, but she said that took courage and could be a difficult step to take. Councillor Jim O'Malley said he previously had to clean spiderwebs off the outside of a house and clean the carpet to get a deposit back. He was then told the carpet was not clean enough - despite cleaning it twice - and did not get his deposit back, he said. He also had to intervene after landlords tried to charge his daughter and her flatmates for damages done long before they moved in, and it was only after he threatened to take them to court that they paid the deposit back, O'Malley said. "Landlord abuse of tenants is around." Councillor Andrew Whiley, who is a landlord, said anything that improved healthy homes in Dunedin was important to do and it would only make good landlords look better. There were five ministry inspectors who were already in town and had started doing inspections, he said. Landlords had their "heads in the sand" if they only started preparing to follow the rules just before the deadline, he said. Deputy mayor Cherry Lucas said they needed to signal that they wanted a city of good, healthy rentals. Councillor Lee Vandervis said the Tenancy Tribunal's job was to ensure properties were fully compliant when there was an issue and they were already doing it. He did not support the motion. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
20-07-2025
- NZ Herald
On The Up: Napier cyclist Strat Ellingham's inspiring recovery after devastating crash
On July 3, 2024, Ellingham was riding in the cycle lane on Napier's Marine Parade, preparing for a race, when the car beside him turned left into Ellingham's bike, sending him flying. 'I was riding along, basically, I could see 'there's the Sound Shell, TNG building, Six Sisters, and bang',' Ellingham said. Strat Ellingham crosses the finish line at the 2019 TDU Challenge Ride in Adelaide. 'Then I'm looking up at two paramedics in an ambulance with a whole lot of police and I thought, this is not good. 'And the second thought was, I'm alive, that is good.' Unable to move, Ellingham was sent via helicopter from Napier to Wellington, then on to Christchurch Hospital for around 36 hours' worth of investigations, X-rays, MRIs and CT scans. Then the doctors operated on him. 'The big damage was to my C3 and C4 [vertebrae], that was badly fractured,' he said. The person who drove into Ellingham was charged with careless or inconsiderate vehicle operation causing injury, ordered to pay $10,000 reparation and disqualified from driving for six months. Doctors removed Ellingham's disc fragments and replaced it with hip bone fragments and inserted bolts and plates and put him in a neck brace. Ellingham then spent five days in ICU and a further seven days in the trauma ward before being transferred to the Burwood Hospital Spinal Unit, a unit Ellingham described as 'brilliant'. 'The nurses, doctors, physios, everyone at Burwood is very supportive and encouraging,' he said. When he arrived at Burwood, Ellingham had no movement available to him, but after spending five months at the hospital, he relearned how to walk in the hospital's pool, and how to sit and to stand, thanks to physio work and getting in the gym on specialised equipment. After five months at Burwood, Ellingham returned to his home in Napier in December 2024 with much better movement available to him, but he still had a way to go. 'I didn't know how badly damaged I'd be, because I think I naively said in August, 'I think I'll need some assistance when I get home',' he said. 'But it was good to be home.' Ellingham said his wife and three children had been immensely helpful and supportive of his recovery journey, as well as his team of carers and his cycling friends Ben and Nat, who created 'Strat-man' socks to raise funds for him while he was in Burwood. Strat Ellingham in his Napier home, standing on his own. Photo / Jack Riddell Now rehabbing at the Hawke's Bay Community Fitness Centre at Mitre 10 Park in Hastings, and at his home, Ellingham is moving in a positive direction and hitting his stride, walking 1.5km in the pool last week. 'It's just one step at a time, really,' he said. Last week, he bumped into one of the paramedics who helped him after his crash, and he thanked her for helping save his life. Ellingham said anyone finding themselves in a similar position to him should have hope of recovery and be encouraged by others. 'With the support and the care that I've had, I've been able to improve. 'My friends have been unreal, my cycling friends coming to visit me so that's been amazing and very encouraging. 'But if I can help people find hope, that's what it's all about.' Jack Riddell is a multimedia journalist with Hawke's Bay Today and has worked in radio and media in Auckland, London, Berlin, and Napier.
