Jury given majority direction in trial of US woman accused of murder plot
The jury in the trial of Aimee Betro, who denies conspiracy to murder, possessing a self-loading pistol and a charge of fraudulently evading the prohibition on importing ammunition, first retired to consider its verdicts on Wednesday last week.
Prosecutors allege Betro, who is originally from West Allis in Wisconsin but was living in Armenia until earlier this year, flew to Britain in August 2019 to take part in a plot orchestrated by co-conspirators Mohammed Aslam, 56, and his son Mohammed Nabil Nazir, 31, to attack another family as part of a 'violent' feud.
The Crown also claims the 45-year-old graduate hid her face using a niqab when she got out of a Mercedes and tried to shoot Sikander Ali at point-blank range outside his home in Measham Grove, Yardley, Birmingham.
The attempted shooting took place shortly after 8pm on September 7 2019, jurors have heard, but the handgun jammed, allowing Mr Ali to flee in his car.
Giving evidence during her trial, Betro suggested that the perpetrator was 'another American woman' who sounded similar to her, used the same phone and wore the same sort of trainers.
Betro also told jurors that it was 'all just a terrible coincidence' that she was around the corner from the scene of the attempted assassination six minutes later.
Jurors have so far been in retirement for more than 15 hours over four days.
After the jury confirmed on Monday that it had yet to reach unanimous verdicts on any of the counts faced by Betro, Judge Simon Drew KC gave the panel a majority direction.
Before inviting jurors to resume their discussions, the judge told them: 'I ask you to continue to deliberate and to continue to try to reach verdicts on which you are all agreed.'
The judge said he could now accept verdicts or either guilty or not guilty on which at least 10 of the 12 jurors agreed.
The judge added: 'But it cannot be less than that (10).'
The court has heard Aslam and Nazir, who were jailed last year for their part in the assassination plot, were involved in a feud with Mr Ali's father, Aslat Mahumad.
Nazir and Aslam, both of Elms Avenue in Derby, had been injured during disorder at Mr Mahumad's clothing boutique in Birmingham in July 2018, jurors have been told, leading them to conspire to have someone kill him or a member of his family.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
How long can overstretched Met Police cope if Palestine Action protests continue?
In 2024, a total of 248 people were arrested in Britain for terrorist-related activity. Within a matter of hours on Saturday, the Metropolitan Police arrested more than double that as 522 protesters were handcuffed under terror laws for holding placards declaring: 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.' Half of those arrested – who face up to 14 years in prison if they are convicted under the Terrorism Act for supporting a proscribed organisation – were over 60 years old, including 15 octogenarians. Many were applauded by onlookers as they were hauled away by officers. The scale of the challenge forced the Met to use a 'street bail' system to prevent police stations from being overwhelmed by what was described by organisers as a 'momentous act of collective defiance' in Parliament Square. The force used two processing points in Westminster to deal with 320 protesters, who were asked to confirm their details before being released and ordered to appear at a police station at a future date. A total of 212 were transported to police custody, likely because they refused to confirm their identity or were already on police bail. The Met said they were aware of online photos and footage suggesting some people returned to Parliament Square after being released on bail, but conceded it would be 'entirely unrealistic' to recognise these individuals. Over the coming weeks, officers from the Met's Counter Terrorism Command will work to put together case files and secure charges against those arrested. In some instances, charges will also require approval by the Attorney General Lord Hermer. But the threat of arrest and prison appears to be doing little to deter supporters who have vowed to continue to defy home secretary Yvette Cooper's controversial decision to ban the direct-action group with monthly protests, organised by Defend Our Juries, ahead of a High Court legal challenge November. The Met says they proved they can respond to 'significant protest' requiring many arrests, adding: 'We will do so again if we are required to.' However, the toll of hundreds of terror arrests on a force already grappling with a £260million funding shortfall, a staff recruitment crisis and regular large-scale rallies linked to the Israel-Gaza conflict, should not be underestimated. Paula Dodds, chairman of the Met Police Federation, warned 'tiredness is setting in' for officers. 'Officers are overstretched, rest days are being cancelled,' she told The Independent. 'Leave may be cancelled in the coming weeks as we try to ensure that we have resources to police protests as well as business as usual to keep London safe. 'We will need to call on more mutual aid officers to assist if these protesters continue to come out in numbers. It has just been relentless, and I think we are going to see that for a while yet.' She warned the workload of processing arrests, investigating offences and building files to be passed to the CPS increases demand across all departments at a time when the force is already under strain. In the coming weeks alone, officers face the threat of more anti-migrant protests at hotels housing asylum seekers, the restart of the football season and managing Notting Hill Carnival. She said 'only time will tell' if the resulting pressures result in increased levels of sickness or more officers leaving the force. Saturday's protest comes on the back of 221 similar arrests across the country, including dozens in London, in the weeks since Palestine Action was banned after activists broke into RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire and sprayed two military planes with red paint. Last week, the first three people were charged for flouting the ban. They are due to appear at Westminster Magistrates' Court in September. Ms Cooper has continued to defend proscribing the direct-action group, repeating claims that an assessment found evidence of 'ideas for further attacks' which cannot be reported due to ongoing legal proceedings. 'Many people may not yet know the reality of this organisation, but the assessments are very clear - this is not a non-violent organisation,' she said. 'UK national security and public safety must always be our top priority.' Palestine Action co-founder Huda Ammori claimed the latest demonstration was 'humiliating' for Ms Cooper and would 'go down in our country's history as a momentous act of collective defiance of an unprecedented attack on our fundamental freedoms'. She said the fact most of those arrested at the protest were 'given street bail and allowed to go home' proved the current ban was 'unenforceable'. 'It's clear that more and more ordinary people appalled by this anti-democratic, authoritarian ban will defy it en-masse and it is simply not possible to arrest them all,' she added.
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Brothers jailed after rioting outside asylum seeker hotel
Two brothers have each been jailed for three years for their part in rioting outside a hotel housing asylum seekers last summer. Scott and Jason McGuire were at the forefront of the disorder which engulfed the Holiday Inn Express near Rotherham, on August 4, 2024, Sheffield Crown Court heard on Monday. The brothers were jailed along with two others men – Keethan Reeve-Lawson and Daniel Kazemi. This is understood to have brought the total number of people sentenced for the Rotherham violence to 104. Judge Jeremy Richardson KC outlined how the McGuire brothers were at the forefront of the 'mob' during the most serious part of the disorder on that Sunday afternoon. The judge has heard over dozens of hearings how the hotel was besieged for around 12 hours. Police officers and the hotel itself were pelted with missiles as more than 200 asylum seekers and 22 staff were trapped inside. At one point, the rioters smashed their way into the building and a burning wheelie-bin was pushed against a fire door. A total of 64 officers were injured in the violence along with police horses and a dog. Judge Richardson said it was his 'misfortune' to have sentenced most of those arrested after the disorder and said he was very familiar with video footage of the violence shown in court. He said: 'Each time I see this exceptionally serious disturbance represented in the footage of these events I feel, as I'm sure many others feel, profound shame that such shocking disorder should occur in this country.' The judge said: 'The venom of racism and racially motivated violence suffuses the events from first to last.' Judge Richardson told the defendants: 'Several hundred people were intent on mob rule. That will never be tolerated in this country.' And he added: 'All of those police officers are deserving of the highest praise for the way in which they resisted provocation and handled an immensely challenging situation with bravery, professionalism and skill.' Judge Richardson described how Scott McGuire was captured arriving at the scene with what appeared to be his partner and a child in a pushchair. He was later pictured in the mob at various times during the disorder and is seen dismantling safety barriers in front of the riot police as well as kicking items which were then thrown at the officers by others. The judge said: 'You were involved in fierce attacks on police officers close to the hotel. 'You were well to the fore and your participation was of a high order.' Judge Richardson said Jason McGuire was filmed throwing missiles at officers and a police van as well as at the hotel building, while wearing a mask. He was also filmed tearing down fencing which was used by others to throw at the police lines and fuel the fire which was set outside the building. The judge said: 'Your involvement was well to the fore in the most serious aspects of the episodes that afternoon.' The court heard how Jason McGuire was jailed for four years in 2015 for a drugs offence and for 10 years in 2018 for a machete attack. Judge Richardson jailed Reeve-Lawson and Kazemi for 22 months each after hearing how they were involved in later incidents once police had managed to push the mob away from immediately outside the hotel. Kazemi was filmed throwing a can of beer at officers, which smashed against their shields, and the judge noted that he was 'visibly happy' when another man threw a metal bar at police. Richard Barradell, defending Kazemi, said 'like many others' his client joined in 'once the pack mentality started'. He said: 'He cannot for the life of him explain why.' Mr Barradell said his client was 'bitterly embarrassed' and wanted to apologise to everyone involved. Scott McGuire, 35, and Jason McGuire, 31, both of Schofield Street, Mexborough; Reeve-Lawson, 22, of Mount Vernon Road, Worsbrough Common, Barnsley, and Kazemi, 35, of Edna Street, Bolton-upon-Dearne, all admitted violent disorder at a previous hearing.
BBC News
25 minutes ago
- BBC News
Flytipper fined after being caught on camera
A man has been fined for fly-tipping after he was filmed on a police bodycam following a tip-off from a member of the public. Chunlin Zheng, of Philip Lane in London, pleaded guilty at Swindon Magistrates' Court on Friday to fly-tipping wood in a layby on the A361 near Trowbridge, was ordered to pay a total of £1,114 - including a fine, costs and a victim surcharge - and was told to carry out 200 hours of unpaid community work. Councillor Martin Smith, cabinet member for highways, streetscene and flooding at Wiltshire Council, said: "Fly-tipping is a serious environmental crime that blights our communities, and we continue to take it very seriously." Zheng was seen dumping waste from a van by a member of public on 22 January, who then called the police and stayed at the scene until officers arrived, Wiltshire Council said. When confronted by police, Zheng told officers he had been paid £150 to dispose of the wood, but could not take it to the household recycling centre as he was using a commercial vehicle and would have been charged. However, when he was investigated by a council team, Zheng said he was actually paid £350 and was working as a removal person, even though he did not hold a waste carrier's licence. Mr Smith added: "Choosing to fly-tip as the cheaper option has resulted in a heftier fine payment and a criminal record."I hope that he has learned his lesson."Zheng was initially issued a £1,000 fixed penalty notice in March but this was not paid. Part of his unpaid community work may involve litter collecting around Wiltshire.
