Falling sales offer few signs of end to China's property slump
FALLING property sales over the first five months of 2025 show how China's economically important real estate market remained stuck in a slump this year despite signs of heat in the markets in higher-tier cities.
Cumulative sales of China's top 100 property developers from January to May fell 7.1 per cent year-on-year to 1.3 trillion yuan (S$233.2 billion), accelerating from the 6.7 per cent drop for the January-to-April period, according to figures published Saturday by China Real Estate Information Corp (CRIC).
The CRIC report measures sales from projects directly managed by the top 100 developers, excluding projects including those run by external partners.
Figures released by another data provider for the industry, China Index Holdings (CIH), painted a similar picture.
Total sales of the top 100 property developers for the first five months were down 10.8 per cent year-on-year to 1.4 trillion yuan, according to a recent CIH report. In the CIH report, sales included revenue from projects managed by both developers' in-house sales teams and those outsourced.
For May alone, sales by top developers fell 8.6 per cent year-on-year to nearly 295 billion yuan, although the total was up 3.5 per cent on a month-on-month basis, according to CRIC figures. The CIH data showed an even steeper year-on-year sales drop of 17.3 per cent for May, with the decline widening from 16.8 per cent in April.
A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU
Tuesday, 12 pm Property Insights
Get an exclusive analysis of real estate and property news in Singapore and beyond.
Sign Up
Sign Up
To put the scale of the downturn in perspective, sales of 1.3 trillion yuan amount to less than 30 per cent of the total made over the first five months of 2021, before the slump began.
The May sales figures offer a broader view of a national real estate market that has grown increasingly bifurcated. Analysts have been highlighting the difference in demand between metropolises such as Beijing and Shanghai and in lower-tier Chinese cities.
In Shanghai, demand looks to be heating up. According to a report by EH Consulting, a real estate industry research institute, multiple residential projects managed to sell out in a single day in May.
In one example, a local subsidiary of developer Greentown China Holdings sold all 120 units of a project on the same day it was put on the market, the report said. The homes sold for 195,000 yuan per square meter, generating nearly 7 billion yuan in revenue.
It's a different story in some of China's lesser-known and less wealthy cities. The vast majority of property developments in third and fourth-tier cities have far more supply than demand, said a senior sales executive at a leading property developer who did not wish to be named.
Two factors have long helped drive China's property market: the need for new homes and the belief that housing was a sure-fire investment.
Since the downturn, however, residential property has lost its appeal as an investment in many third- and fourth-tier cities, the executive said. In addition, basic housing needs have already been met in those areas.
With the populations of many of the cities already starting to shrink and with the average household already owning two or three homes, a slowdown in home sales was inevitable
'In the long run, we believe the property market will eventually stabilise,' the executive said. 'But in the near term, market divergence will persist.'
Addressing the disparity requires tackling the problem from both the supply and demand sides, market insiders said.
The CRIC report noted that the current new housing supply has fallen significantly, particularly in hot markets such as Shanghai, Shenzhen, Hangzhou and Chengdu. The situation has limited the potential for a surge in sales volume in those cities.
Changes to government policy could help. The EH Consulting report recommended shifting from broad-based stimulus to more targeted, nuanced regulation over the property market. That would help different parts of the market achieve a better balance between supply and demand that would eventually stabilise prices.
CIH expects housing market policy to remain accommodative in June. With the mid-year sales window approaching, property developers are likely to accelerate project launches and increase their marketing efforts, the report said.
It added that the market in core cities is expected to continue its recovery, although divergences between cities are likely to continue. CAIXIN GLOBAL
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
China says it may speed up rare earths application approvals from EU
A mining machine is seen at a mine containing rare earth minerals in Inner Mongolia, China. PHOTO: REUTERS China says it may speed up rare earths application approvals from EU SHANGHAI – China is willing to accelerate the examination and approval of rare earth exports to European Union firms and will also deliver a verdict on its trade investigation of EU brandy imports by July 5, its Commerce Ministry said on June 7. Price commitment consultations between China and the EU on Chinese-made electric vehicles exported to the EU have also entered a final stage, but efforts from both sides are still needed, according to a statement on the ministry's website. The issues were discussed between Chinese Commerce Minister Wang Wentao and EU Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic in Paris on June 3, according to the statement. The comments mark progress on matters that have vexed China's relationship with the EU over the past year. Most recently, China's decision in April to suspend exports of a wide range of rare earths and related magnets has upended the supply chains central to automakers, aerospace manufacturers, semiconductor companies and military contractors around the world. The Commerce Ministry said China attached great importance to the EU's concerns and 'was willing to establish a green channel for qualified applications to speed up the approval process'. Mr Wang during the meeting 'expressed the hope that the EU will meet us halfway and take effective measures to facilitate, safeguard and promote compliant trade in high-tech products to China', according to the statement. Chinese anti-dumping measures that applied duties of up to 39 per cent on imports of European brandy – with French cognac bearing the brunt – have also strained relations between Paris and Beijing. The brandy duties were enforced days after the EU took action against Chinese-made electric vehicle imports to shield its local industry, prompting France's President Emmanuel Macron to accuse Beijing of 'pure retaliation'. The Chinese duties have dented sales of brands, including LVMH's Hennessy, Pernod Ricard's Martell and Remy Cointreau. Beijing was initially meant to make a final decision on the brandy duties by January, but extended the deadline to April and then again to July 5. China's Commerce Ministry said on June 7 French companies and relevant associations have proactively submitted applications on price commitments for brandy to China, and that Chinese investigators have reached an agreement with them on the core terms. The Chinese authorities were now reviewing the complete text on those commitments and would issue a final announcement before July 5, it said. In April, the European Commission said the EU and China also agreed to look into setting minimum prices of Chinese-made electric vehicles instead of tariffs imposed by the EU last year. China's Commerce Ministry said the EU also proposed exploring 'new technical paths' relating to EVs, which the Chinese side was now evaluating. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Online Citizen
3 hours ago
- Online Citizen
Over 300 workers retrenched without pay as CCIC Singapore enters liquidation after US sanctions
Over 300 employees of CCIC Singapore, a subsidiary of a Chinese state-owned enterprise, China Certification and Inspection Group (CCIC), have been retrenched without receiving their May 2025 salaries, following the company's abrupt move into liquidation after being blacklisted by the United States. The sanctions, announced on 13 May 2025, targeted 15 companies, including CCIC Singapore, which the US Treasury Department accused of helping obscure the origin of Iranian oil shipped to China. The firm reportedly provided inspection services during ship-to-ship transfers of sanctioned oil cargo, including one involving 2 million barrels of Iranian oil. CCIC Singapore, founded in 1989 and located at Singapore Science Park, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of China Certification & Inspection Group (CCIC), a Chinese state-owned firm under China's State-Owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission. Affected employees were formally notified of their retrenchment on 30 May, with terminations effective the next day. According to three employees who spoke to CNA, most of CCIC Singapore's workforce—estimated to number over 300 in Singapore alone—is now jobless. Employees said they were informed that the firm's liquidation process was underway, and retrenchment benefits would only be fully paid by 30 June 2026. In the meantime, workers remain unpaid for May and received only two weeks' salary for every year of service completed. Surveyors and operations staff expressed frustration over the severance arrangement, noting that many relied on overtime and allowances to supplement basic pay. Junior surveyors earn less than S$1,000 monthly in base salary, with senior surveyors earning up to S$1,500. Speaking anonymously, employees expressed anger over the handling of the retrenchments. They described communication from management as inconsistent, citing internal emails that promised job continuity and transfers to a new entity—only to be contradicted within a day. On 14 May, an email from human resources assured employees of legal support and plans to establish a new company, backed by the Beijing headquarters. Staff were told they would be transferred without disruption. However, the following day, a second email urged recipients to disregard the earlier message. Subsequent internal communication revealed the company was downsizing and unable to pay retrenchment benefits due to frozen bank accounts. The firm's managing director later travelled to Beijing for discussions, though staff were not informed of any resolutions before receiving their termination notices. In an email sent to media on 6 June by a staff representative, employees highlighted several grievances: non-payment of wages, inadequate severance packages, lack of transparency, and absence of support for job placement. The letter described the situation as a breach of Singapore's Employment Act. 'Over 300 individuals and their families face immediate financial distress,' the letter read. 'This situation causes significant anxiety and hardship.' The letter further alleged that the offered severance—two weeks per year of service—fell well below Singapore's prevailing retrenchment standards, which can range from one to three months' pay per year of service. Employees also criticised the firm's leadership for failing to provide any apology or assurance, and questioned why CCIC's parent company had not intervened to ensure obligations to Singapore staff were met. 'This is a foreign company. They act like high and mighty, but they leave us in the lurch,' one employee told CNA. 'The top man doesn't even see us, talk to us.' As of now, the Ministry of Manpower, the National Trades Union Congress (NTUC), and the Tripartite Alliance for Dispute Management (TADM) have been approached by affected staff for assistance. CNA has also reached out to CCIC Singapore, its parent company CCIC in China, and relevant authorities for comment. No responses have been published as of the date of this report. The sanctions imposed by the US include a freeze on all US-linked assets of sanctioned entities and block any business engagement involving the US financial system. The US Treasury claims that Iran's illicit oil trade supports weapons development and terrorism, and CCIC Singapore was directly involved in enabling these operations by providing falsified documentation and inspection services. With Singapore-based assets unfrozen, affected employees have also questioned why local resources cannot be used to cover immediate financial obligations, such as salary arrears.
Straits Times
5 hours ago
- Straits Times
In a difficult job market, more Chinese workers learn to fly drones
Mr Huang Kunlin, 28, who used to work in the IT department of a large vape maker, hopes to get his drone operator's licence. ST PHOTO: JOYCE ZK LIM - Mr Xu Hui, who used to sell women's clothing online, has grown tired of the long hours and cut-throat competition plaguing the live-stream business. So for the past month, the 28-year-old has trained almost every day for what he hopes will be his next career: a drone operator. At a quiet football field on a weekday afternoon, he and six classmates at a private flying school take turns steering a drone, the size of a nightstand, in figures of eight above mini traffic cones. They are preparing for a test to get a licence to pilot drones transporting anything from bubble tea to medical supplies by air – an increasingly familiar sight in China as it develops this emerging segment of its economy. 'In a way, I am responding to the needs of this era,' said Mr Xu, who decided to pivot to the state-supported drone sector after learning that it had a shortage of skilled workers. He had no prior knowledge of drones, having studied international trade and Chinese literature in school. He is among a growing number of Chinese workers who, faced with a difficult labour market, are chasing new job opportunities born of Beijing's push for high-tech industries to transform its economy. China is stepping up the development of what it calls the 'low-altitude economy', which refers to having more business and industrial activity take place in low-altitude airspace. More unmanned aerial vehicles have in recent years plied the skies of the world's largest drone-maker. China had 2.177 million registered drones as of end-2024, official figures showed, up 98.5 per cent from the year before. They deliver packages without being caught in traffic jams, spray pesticides across vast paddy fields, and put out fires in hard-to-reach forests and buildings. Mr Xu Hui (in green), who is training to become a drone pilot, steers a drone via remote control at a flight class in Shenzhen. It task involves controlling the drone's elevation and direction using two different joysticks. ST PHOTO: JOYCE ZK LIM Meituan , a leading food delivery platform, sends food and drink via drones to more than 50 collection points in major cities such as Shenzhen, Shanghai and Beijing , including one at the Great Wall. The number of drones is expected to grow further as the commercial adoption of drones expands. The market for commercial drones is projected to grow around 19.5 per cent each year for the next five years, to reach about 300 billion yuan by 2029, up from about 121.5 billion yuan in 2024, according to a report released in May by EO Intelligence, the research arm of Chinese information service provider EqualOcean . With this rise in the use of drones comes a growing demand and reasonably attractive salaries for people who can fly them, a skill in short supply. China lacks some one million drone operators, a senior official said in October 2024. The country had about 225,000 licensed drone pilots as of June that year. Mr Xu Hui, 28, who used to sell women's clothing in the highly-competitive live-stream industry, decided to pivot into drones after learning that the sector had a shortage of skilled workers. ST PHOTO: JOYCE ZK LIM In a recent job advertisement, logistics giant offered licensed drone pilots with at least one year's experience a monthly salary of between 7,000 and 12,000 yuan (between S$1,254 and S$2,150). This is higher than the country's average private sector salary of about 5,800 yuan per month in urban areas, according to figures for 2024 from the statistics bureau. The prospect of being early movers in a burgeoning industry is attracting a growing number of Chinese workers, for whom drone-related jobs would barely have existed when they graduated from school. It was only in 2019 that the Chinese government officially recognised drone pilots as an occupation. Other drone-related jobs have been acknowledged since, most recently that of 'drone swarm flight planners' in May. Joining Mr Xu, the former live-stream worker, at his drone-flying class was a group of 20-somethings with diverse backgrounds such as IT and manufacturing. They described being keen to escape their industries' stiff competition, colloquially termed juan, that has led to late nights and depressed wages. Mr Huang Kunlin, 28, who most recently worked in the IT department of a large vape maker, said his monthly salary had more than halved after six years in the industry, from a high of almost 20,000 yuan to between 7,000 and 8,000 yuan. With an 'over-saturation' of people who can do the job, the IT sector has become 'way too competitive', he said. Faced with limited prospects for advancement, he decided to go into the drone industry, which he believes will give him more work options as the devices become more widely adopted in China. Mr Huang hopes to get his drone operator's licence and then secure a job managing a drone delivery station, which he says pays about 8,000 yuan a month before bonuses. There are also ample opportunities to start his own business down the line, he said. He could buy a drone to deliver goods to and from rural areas that are difficult to access, or even sell drone-related services in croplands overseas, he added. Ms Victoria Li, a 26-year-old nurse, is mulling a move into the drone sector and away from what she saw as a dead-end job with few opportunities to grow. 'I want to go into an up-and-coming industry,' she declared, while checking out the flying lesson that Mr Huang was taking and deciding on her next steps. The flying class that the young Chinese were at is one of many run by Tuopu Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Training Base , a Shenzhen-based company. The firm has seen a surge of interest in its drone lessons, which prepare students to sit a test for a drone operators' licence issued by China's aviation authority, said operations manager Lin Kaibin. Mr Lin Kaibin (centre), operations manager at Tuopu Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Training Base, flanked by two students. His firm has seen a surge of interest in its drone-flying lessons. ST PHOTO: JOYCE ZK LIM In 2024, the company trained about 160 students who went on to receive their licences, he said. In just the first five months of 2025, that number has reached 280. To cater to this rising interest, the company is expanding its training grounds from three to five this year, Mr Lin added. Fees for its 15- to 20-day commercial drone operator courses start from 6,800 yuan. Private operators such as Tuopu which provide drone-flying courses are mushrooming in China. Some driving schools have also branched into offering drone lessons, to capitalise on the rise in demand. The country currently has more than 2,500 drone training institutions, according to a list of these schools maintained by China's aviation authority. This is up from some 1,000 institutions in August 2024, local media reported. Universities and vocational schools in China, too, have been providing more drone-related courses to churn out talent with specialised knowledge in unmanned aerial vehicles. In 2025 , six universities added new programmes in low-altitude technology and engineering to their course offerings. The country has also been overhauling its system of vocational education in recent years, rolling out more majors and courses in emerging industries such as drone technology and artificial intelligence. China's aviation authority has also set aside almost five million yuan in its budget in 2025 to train talent in the low-altitude economy. New jobs generated by these high-tech sectors are a bright spot in a labour market that is otherwise shaping up to be one of China's most difficult in years. A record number of college graduates, more than 12 million in 2025, are searching for work as trade tensions threaten manufacturing jobs and give firms the jitters. Drone-related jobs will be useful in relieving some of the country's employment pressures, said labour economist Liu Erduo of Renmin University in Beijing, even though they will not be able to help everyone. Older workers, for instance, are likely unsuited to become drone pilots. 'Your hands must be fast and agile,' Dr Liu said of the job which involves manipulating two joysticks to control the drones' elevation and direction. Nonetheless, the move by workers to upskill themselves in this sector will help alleviate, to some degree, the structural unemployment afflicting the Chinese economy. Many universities in China have an 'oversupply' of majors in the arts and social sciences, Dr Liu said. 'There really aren't that many jobs in law, finance, history or literature,' he said. 'In future, (more of these graduates) may have to study for a second career, and learn new skills.' Joyce ZK Lim is The Straits Times' China correspondent, based in Shenzhen. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
