logo
Samy Cohen: Israel's military actions in Gaza contain 'a dimension of revenge'

Samy Cohen: Israel's military actions in Gaza contain 'a dimension of revenge'

LeMonde27-07-2025
Samy Cohen is a professor of political science at Sciences Po Paris and research director at the Center for International Studies (CERI). An expert on Israeli society, he is the author of Tuer ou laisser vivre. Israël et la morale de la guerre ("To Kill or Let Live: Israel and the Morality of War").
What do the daily newspaper Haaretz 's revelations about the orders soldiers were given to fire on Palestinians who had gathered to receive humanitarian aid signify for you?
This exposes a deeper phenomenon that has been visible since the day after October 7. The general staff has granted considerable autonomy to unit, division, brigade and battalion commanders regarding when to open fire. Previously, the rules of engagement were strict and, if civilians were present near enemy combatants, required approval from a relatively high level. Before October 7, if a residential building had to be destroyed, prior authorization from the chief of the general staff of the army was required. Today, a local commander can request air support and have an entire building demolished if they judge that their troops are threatened, without referring the matter to the top levels of command.
The rules laid out by the general staff are clear and precise, drafted under the supervision of the military prosecutor general and conveyed orally. However, most of the time, unit commanders do as they wish. They see protecting their soldiers as the absolute priority. Thus, some commanders in certain so-called "sterile" zones have decided, on their own, that anyone who enters should be killed without warning, which violates international law and the army's ethical code.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ship with hundreds of tonnes of aid for Gaza nears Israeli port
Ship with hundreds of tonnes of aid for Gaza nears Israeli port

Euronews

time2 hours ago

  • Euronews

Ship with hundreds of tonnes of aid for Gaza nears Israeli port

A ship loaded with 1,200 tonnes of food for Gaza approached the Israeli port of Ashdod on Tuesday in a renewed effort to alleviate the worsening humanitarian crisis in the Strip as famine threatens the territory. The Panamanian-flagged vessel was screened by Israeli officials at the Cypriot port of Limassol before departing. It's carrying food aid such as pasta, rice, baby food and canned goods. Around 700 tonnes of the aid is from Cyprus, purchased with money donated by the United Arab Emirates to the so-called Amalthea Fund, set up last year for donors to help with seaborne aid. The rest comes from Italy, the Maltese government, a Catholic religious order in Malta and the Kuwaiti nongovernmental organisation Al Salam Association. Cyprus' Foreign Ministry said the aid effort is being led by the United Nations but is a coordinated effort. Once offloaded in Israel, UN employees would arrange for the aid to be trucked to storage areas and food stations operated by the World Central Kitchen. The charity is widely trusted in Gaza and was behind the first aid shipment to Gaza from Cyprus last year aboard a tug-towed barge. Shipborne deliveries can bring in much larger quantities of aid than the air drops several countries have been making into Gaza. Dozens killed in Gaza At least 26 people were killed in Gaza on Tuesday, according to local hospitals. That figure reportedly includes at least eight people killed in Israeli attacks on tents housing displaced people in Khan Younis and four more in an attack on a tent in Deir al-Balah. The deaths come the day after a Hamas source said the group had accepted the latest ceasefire proposal in Gaza. Israeli officials have not yet responded. Israel had announced plans to occupy Gaza City and other heavily populated areas after ceasefire talks stalled last month. The move drew international condemnation and raised fears of a worsening humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, which experts say is sliding into famine. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has dismissed reports of starvation as "lies" spread by Hamas. However, the UN last week warned that levels of malnutrition in Gaza are at their highest since the war began. Record number of aid workers killed Meanwhile, a record 383 aid workers were killed across the world in 2024, with nearly half of them killed in Gaza, the UN humanitarian office said on Tuesday. UN humanitarian chief Tom Fletcher said the record number of killings must be a wakeup call to protect civilians in conflict zones as well as those trying to help them. "Attacks on this scale, with zero accountability, are a shameful indictment of international inaction and apathy," Fletcher said in a statement. "As the humanitarian community, we demand – again – that those with power and influence act for humanity, protect civilians and aid workers and hold perpetrators to account." President of the Palestine Red Crescent Society, Younis al-Khatib, said in a video posted on X that: "The Palestinian humanitarian mission and aid workers have been deliberately targeted in Palestine. More than any other war, Palestinian humanitarians have been killed." "No state should enjoy impunity. No state should be above the law. The international community is obliged to protect humanitarians and to stop and to ensure protection for humanity." The Aid Worker Security Database said the number of aid worker killings rose from 293 in 2023 to 383 in 2024, including over 180 in Gaza. The figures this year show no sign of a reversal of the upward trend, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA). There have been 245 major attacks since the year began and 265 aid workers have been killed so far, according to the database. One of the deadliest attacks of 2025 took place on March 23 in the southern Gazan city of Rafah. Israeli troops killed 15 medics and emergency responders. Their bodies were later uncovered in what the UN described as a "mass grave."

War in Gaza: Hamas agrees to ceasefire proposal, Israel reviews accord
War in Gaza: Hamas agrees to ceasefire proposal, Israel reviews accord

LeMonde

time2 hours ago

  • LeMonde

War in Gaza: Hamas agrees to ceasefire proposal, Israel reviews accord

Hamas agreed on Monday, August 18, to the terms of a proposed ceasefire by Egypt and Qatar to temporarily end hostilities in the Gaza Strip. The terms include the immediate release of 10 living hostages, the freeing of Palestinian prisoners, an exchange of bodies, and the partial withdrawal of Israeli troops. According to Qatari and Egyptian sources cited by various Arab media outlets, the proposal provides for a 60-day initial period for a temporary ceasefire and the deployment of massive humanitarian aid. During this time, negotiations would be held to end the conflict, with the United States providing guarantees to prevent a breakdown of the accord, as occurred in March when Israel ended the truce by heavily bombing the territory. According to the latest figures from the Gaza health ministry, a number deemed reliable by international organizations, more than 62,000 Gaza residents have been killed since the beginning of Israel's response to Hamas's attack on October 7, 2023. On Tuesday morning, Israel had neither accepted nor rejected the proposal. However, several Hebrew-language media outlets cited a senior, anonymous official who said, "Israel's position has not changed – the release of all hostages and acceptance of all conditions to end the war." On August 14, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reiterated several conditions, including the demilitarization of Gaza and Hamas, the return of all hostages, Israeli security control of Gaza, and a civilian administration of the territory that excludes both Hamas and the Palestinian Authority.

Israel to finalise 'largest' gas supply deal in its history to Egypt
Israel to finalise 'largest' gas supply deal in its history to Egypt

Euronews

time3 hours ago

  • Euronews

Israel to finalise 'largest' gas supply deal in its history to Egypt

The Israeli government is set to finalise a major gas supply agreement with Egypt, involving the export of 22% of resources from Leviathan, Israel's largest gas field, and 13% of the country's total natural gas to Cairo over several years. The deal comes after two years of delays and is expected to be signed in the next two weeks. New Energy, a partner in the Leviathan field, described the agreement as the "largest" in the history of the Hebrew state, noting that it will triple Israeli exports by 2028. The company announced that Egypt will buy 130 billion cubic metres of Israeli gas until 2040, worth up to $35 billion (€30bn). The project is an amendment to the 2019 agreement signed by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, which stipulated the export of only around 60 billion cubic metres by the early 2020s. The project allows Israel to increase natural gas production and export it to Asian and European markets, while at the same time guaranteeing Egypt a stable supply for its power plants and supporting the country's liquefied natural gas (LNG) sector. NewMed Energy (formerly known as Delek Drilling) confirmed that the deal will take place in phases, with Cairo first buying the gas through Egyptian importers Blue Ocean Energy, with 20 billion cubic metres starting in the first half of 2026, and an additional 110 billion cubic metres after the expansion of Leviathan's production is completed, according to the Hebrew newspaper Globes. The company described the deal as pivotal, as it will allow the field's production capacity to expand from 21 billion cubic metres to 23 billion cubic metres per year, strengthening Leviathan's position as one of the most important gas sources in the region. By 2035, Israel will export 60% of the gas produced in the field, while 40% will be allocated to the domestic market to meet the needs of new power plants. In 2024, the field produced about 11 billion cubic metres of gas, 50% of which was exported to Egypt, while the rest was distributed between Israel's domestic economy and Jordan. In terms of gas supply to the Israeli economy, NewMed Energy confirmed that the expansion will ensure that from the 2040s, Leviathan will be Israel's main source of gas, providing the bulk of the country's natural gas consumption until the end of the field's life.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store