The familiar issues frustrating England and their fans
Another thumping defeat
As England's fate was sealed on day five, Edgbaston was alive to the beat of an Indian drum."England get battered everywhere they go," sang the tourists' support. This 336-run defeat can be added to the 423-run loss in Hamilton, the nine-wicket thrashing in Rawalpindi, the meek eight-wicket loss at the hands of a poor Sri Lanka at The Oval or the 434-run thrashing by India in Rajkot last February.When England lose, they lose badly.Two of those, against New Zealand and Sri Lanka, could be written off as dead rubbers. Were the list shorter, you could put them down to the odd bad day.But until the trend of one England hammering a series is ruled out, they are not going to get to where they want to go.Series wins could come - they may beat India over five matches here - but some have been talking about this team going on to become the best England side since the one Andrew Strauss led to the top of the world rankings.Head coach Brendon McCullum told his team to "shoot for the stars" at the start of the summer. Fail to change and their ship may not leave Earth's atmosphere.
England's Pope fasts again
No-one represents England's feast or famine better than Ollie Pope.After a fine century in Leeds, he made a duck and 24 in his two innings at Edgbaston.It is a familiar problem for a batter who did not make a fifty in the four Tests in India at the start of last year after his epic 196 in the first Test.Before play on day five he was working with batting coach Marcus Trescothick on his head position, attempting to prevent himself falling to the off side before contact, as he did when edging Akash Deep in the first innings.With its slope, Lord's is not the ideal place to have such issues.Zak Crawley is another batter unable to break free of his own troubles.His 65 in the first Test, which followed 124 against Zimbabwe, was crucial to England's win but his wild drive in the second over of England's chase was the worst dismissal in an otherwise sensible quest for a draw.He is averaging just 21 when seamers pitch the ball up to him since the start of 2022. If India weren't aware of that weakness before, they are now.
What to do about Bashir?
The Test also resulted in some ugly numbers for England spinner Shoaib Bashir.The 21-year-old's match figures of 5-286 are the most expensive for England since 1950 and the third-most costly in his side's Test history.No Test spinner who has bowled as many overs (679.1) as Bashir has as high an economy rate (3.80). Not pretty.England's Bashir experiment is at an interesting phase. Picked for his debut last year after just 10 first-class matches and still unable to get a game for his county, he has been picked on potential.Against Zimbabwe at the start of the summer, he looked to be finding success by bowling tighter to the stumps, resulting in a more accurate line, while he was also bowling a fuller length.He deserves credit for working on a 'carrom ball' – an off-spinner's mystery delivery which is flicked from the hand and turns from right to left – which he bowled at least three times in the first innings.But six of his eight wickets in this series have come caught in the deep. The others were a lower-order stumping and a top-edged slog he caught himself.Bashir needs a good week in London for himself if nothing else.
England's pace pickle
That leads nicely to England's pace bowlers. Having opted to pick an unchanged side for Edgbaston, Chris Woakes, Brydon Carse and Josh Tongue have now bowled 82, 77 and 81 overs respectively.Mohammed Siraj is the only India quick to have bowled more than 62.All three of England's pacemen struggled at times in Birmingham. Woakes was not as threatening after his new-ball spell while Tongue has been played well by India's top order and was not as successful against the tail as in the first Test.Change will surely come at Lord's given three days off is little time to recover and Jofra Archer is waiting in the wings. Could England conceivably leave out all three? Gus Atkinson, who has not played since May because of a hamstring injury, is back in the squad but it would be a risk to play Atkinson and Archer, who has bowled in two innings in a match once in four years, in the same XI. Woakes, 36, may need a rest but England like variety in their attack and he averages 12.9 at Lord's – the best of any bowler in Test history.England would also need to replace his batting at number eight if he is left out – even more so if Carse, an able batter, was also absent at number nine.Sam Cook is the Woakes replacement in England's squad but does not offer that same batting depth. Do not rule out bowling all-rounder Jamie Overton adding to his one Test cap, which was earned in 2022.
Gill eyeing Bradman's record
That it is England with selection problems is a remarkable turnaround from six days ago. India came into the second Test facing endless questions around their XI.Their big calls have been proven right, however.Picking batting all-rounder Washington Sundar at number eight looked a defensive move but he shared an important stand of 144 with his captain, Shubman Gill, in the first innings and had Stokes lbw shortly before lunch with his off-spin on the final day.The other big call was to rest Jasprit Bumrah. His replacement Akash Deep was majestic and took 10 in the match.In truth, Gill could not have asked for a better week.Some questioned his declaration on day four but its timing meant England faced Deep with the new ball late on and again when it was still hard the next morning. The result was two wickets in each spell.With 585 runs in two matches, Gill now needs a further 389 across the remaining three Tests to break the legendary record for most runs in a series set by the great Australian Don Bradman, who made 974 in the 1930 Ashes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
10 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Jofra Archer's England return is pure box-office as four years of frustration melt away in a beautiful moment of catharsis, writes OLIVER HOLT
Father Time, stooped over a wicket on his vantage point above the Mound Stand, is facing towards Maida Vale. The clock beneath him reads 2.45pm when Jofra Archer wanders over from mid-off, removes his cap and hands it to umpire Sharfuddoula. A cheer of anticipation rings around Lord's. An elderly man in the lower level of the Grandstand, who has been berating Chris Woakes during the first over of India 's innings, which costs 13 runs, stills and locks his hands behind his head as Archer walks back towards his mark at the Pavilion End. It has been more than four years since Archer last bowled a ball in Test cricket, against India in Ahmedabad in February 2021, four years that have been damned by serious elbow and back injuries and agonies of uncertainty and the torture of wondering what might have been. He was 25 when we last saw him in the longer format of the game, about to enter his prime, fresh from delivering the Super Over that won England the World Cup here in July 2019, a player who seemed destined to be the spearhead of the attack for as long as he wished. How different would he be now to that player? Framed by that august pavilion and its denizens, sweltering in the heat, Archer begins his run-up and gathers speed before unleashing his first ball at Yashasvi Jaiswal. It squares up India's accomplished young opener but he gets his bat on it and pushes it into the off side. England have grown used to bleeding runs in this series. They have had to accept the impotence of their bowling attack and chasing huge totals. Already, there is a different energy about this over. The ground starts to come alive. Archer, 30, glides in for his second ball. Jaiswal plays at it outside the line of off stump but the pace and the movement beat him and the ball whistles through to Jamie Smith, who catches it somewhere just below his midriff. Now the crowd is agog. The big screen between the Tavern Stand and the Pavilion shows Ben Stokes smiling. This is what England have been missing. We can already feel it. This sense of danger that Archer brings. This pace. This sense that we are watching a duel between a batter and a bowler. As he runs up for his third delivery, the crowd claps and cheers and hollers as he quickens his stride. Archer arrows the ball at Jaiswal's stumps and it beats him for speed. The ball finds his leading edge and flies towards Harry Brook at second slip. Lord's holds its breath for a split second. Brook takes the catch. The crowd erupts with joy. And Archer wheels away, his face full of elation. It is a moment of sheer release. A moment when four years of frustration and pain and worry fall away in one beautiful rush of catharsis. Archer runs into the outstretched arms of Shoaib Bashir at backward square leg. And soon he is mobbed by the rest of his team-mates, who are celebrating and rejoicing and laughing at the glorious theatre of it all. His third ball after four years and now this. Only sport can do this. Archer wheels away, his face full of elation - it is a moment of sheer release for the bowler Eventually, Archer returns to his mark. Spectators who have taken a break from the heat after the end of England's innings are thronging the walkways behind the Grandstand to try to get back to their seats to witness this. Usually, it is batters who are supposed to clear out bars but Archer's return is pure box-office. A gasp goes around the ground. It shows that Archer's wicket ball was measured at just shy of 90mph. Archer runs in for his fourth ball. More clapping, and even louder cheering. The new batter is Karun Nair, who is not in the best of form. He plays at the ball outside his off stump and misses it. There is a fever inside this grand old arena now. Everyone is gripped. It is taking us back six years to when Archer made his Test debut here and engaged Steve Smith in what turned into a battle for survival for the former Australia skipper. This over is a spectacle, too. It contains that element that England's attack has often been missing since Archer's injury woes began: fear. Fear and intimidation, those great friends of fast bowlers everywhere. Mark Wood can call on them, too. He has also been unlucky with injuries. The big screen flashes up in big figures that Archer's fourth ball was measured at 93mph. There is another gasp of delight and awe. The ground is in tumult. Archer runs in. The applause is even more raucous. Nair tries to fend the ball away to the off side but it squirts away towards midwicket. One more ball of the over to go. The heat is unsparing but Archer is relishing every moment. Even when he was clean bowled by Jasprit Bumrah towards the end of England's innings, he raised his eyes to the sky and smiled at the craft of his opponent. He is back in the arena, back in the thick of it, back on the biggest stage, back in the hearts of the England fans who have been longing for his return. Nair gets behind his sixth ball and prods it nervously into the leg side. The over is done. It is a wicket maiden. Archer turns and takes his cap from umpire Sharfuddoula. Up on his plinth, Father Time has turned to face St John's Wood, but he is still removing the bails from his wicket.
Daily Mail
10 hours ago
- Daily Mail
The England star who could be boosted up the batting order and why Lord's are struggling to get the crowd in: BUMBLE AT THE TEST
The third Test between England and India is finely poised after KL Rahul helped steer the visitors to 145-3 at the close of the second day, despite Jofra Acher's best efforts. Archer returned to the side for his first game in four years, and picked up a wicket wit his third ball of the innings. After Joe Root made 100, Chris Woakes and Ben Stokes also struck, but India offered solid resistance. After a tightly-fought second day at Lord's, Mail Sport delivers its latest edition of BUMBLE AT THE TEST. A good night's sleep Schoolboy error from myself as I wandered up to Primrose Hill after play and kicked off with a very quaffable neck oil. It was so good, I had a few more and life became a bit of a blur after that. I then finished up with Philip Tufnell, Simon Jones and Richard Blakey, who is the author of that wonderful book 'Taking it From Behind'. Anyways, I slept very well. Leave the ladybirds alone! As I was going about my business in the morning, the swarm of ladybirds appeared again and the ground staff were dispersed to all parts in combat. Is dealing with ladybirds in the job description? As an avid gardener, I can reveal that pollinators like ladybirds are excellent for the environment and must be left well alone. Not belted with a cricket bat! The place to be.. or not Lord's has always been a social scene. The place to be and the place to be seen. The Harris Garden is gorgeous and packed with picnickers, sunbathers and chatters. That now extends to the Nursery Ground, where a section is cordoned off for picnics. It's marvellous. However, the stands are half empty because they're all elsewhere. Is that a good thing? Discuss… Back with a bang Well, he is back. Archer got a wonderful warm reception when he came to bat but they were here to watch him bowl. You could see the emotion when he dismissed Yashasvi Jaiswal with a beauty and the genuine affection from all of his team-mates. As The Everly Brothers said at the Royal Albert Hall in 1983, 'It's good to be back.' A collector's item I attended a charity event for 'Cricket Beyond Boundaries' who bring underprivileged Indian cricketers to England. I gave the founder, Dr Samir Pathak, a book to auction off and said to him 'You'll want to have a look inside'. He duly did and inside was the signature of Mr Sachin Tendulkar. The Doctor was chuffed. Back when I'd tour, I'd always get a good book and get one of the best players from that country to sign it. The good old days. Get him up the order! Brydon Carse is settling in nicely with this England side. From his showing during the 84-run partnership with Jamie Smith, he seems a far better batter than a No 9. Carse looked assured at the crease, with an array of proper shots and he can defend. If he continues in the same manner, he will turn into a genuine all-rounder. He has an array of shots and can defend and could turn himself into a genuine all-rounder Better than meets the stats The more I see of KL Rahul, the more I like. He seems to be an unflappable opening batter. Rahul weathered the Archer storm admirably, especially the short stuff and he shows such a calmness at the crease. So I was staggered to discover that such an accomplished player, with 60 Test caps, only averages 34. Those numbers do not reflect his elegance with the bat.
Daily Mail
11 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Are the Dukes balls good enough? We are constantly having to change them and it's a nonsense - BUMBLE ON THE TEST
The utterly farcical situation with the ball has had us all in a frenzy, with India requesting a change of the Dukes after just 63 balls of the second new ball. It was then changed after another 48 balls. So you have to ask the question. Are these cricket balls of a good enough standard? Because we are constantly having to change them. Stuart Broad summed it up perfectly: 'The cricket ball should be like a fine wicketkeeper. Barely noticed. We are having to talk about the ball too much because it is such an issue and being changed virtually every innings. Unacceptable. Dukes have a problem. They need to fix it. A ball should last 80 overs. Not 10.' England's innings lasted 112.3 overs and we went through five balls. So there is clearly an issue with the quality but the modern-day player also needs to crack on. Both captains complained pre-match about it but surely you can find one you like, lads. As a former umpire, I've got a good idea of the procedure. The ground authority, Lord's in this case, will provide an assortment of replacements that have varying degrees of wear and tear. When you've got a box of brand new balls, they will all go through the ring which is used as a measuring gauge. When the ball is in play, it starts to expand and if it can't go through the ring, a change is granted. Jasprit Bumrah was making the second new ball go round corners in the morning with sublime skill. He bowled Ben Stokes, Joe Root and had Chris Woakes caught behind. Yet a few overs later, India complained about the ball and wanted it changed. For the life in me, I can't think why. The replacement did nothing so India complained vociferously at the drinks break through the captain Shubman Gill and very quickly got their way. Now you can't say 'can we have the other ball back' so we had three different balls in the morning session. That is nonsense, chaps. The farce is compounded because the game is stopped, momentum goes and the paying public, at £120 to £175 a pop, are left to watch grass grow and umpires carrying balls. It's becoming a real problem when 15 overs of the allotted 90 remain unbowled at the close. Root weighed in last night with a suggestion on how to stop it: limit appeals to change the ball to three per 80 overs in line with the decision review system. I go back to when I was an umpire and we would very rarely change. Umpires of yesteryear would say: 'Look, you chose it.' We'd tell them to crack on and throw it back to the fielding side, telling them that it would get knocked in shape. And we didn't carry the ring. Now it's very easy for teams to ask for the ball to be checked and get it changed. Steve Harmison told me how Andrew Flintoff with his big hands and strength would squeeze the ball until it went out of shape to get it replaced. A ball change is understandable if it's a rarity but it is far too common now. That said, it's worth noting the numbers. Wickets have come at an average of 86.09 between overs 31 to 80 in the series. That's the highest average in England since ball-by-ball records began and nobody wants a one-sided contest. We tried to get in touch with Mr Dukes, Dilip Jajodia, but I think he was out with the duchess.
