Fremantle Dockers ‘undervalued' in AFLW competition as Victorian teams favoured by bias
That is, according to leading commentator and former AFLW star Kate McCarthy, who believes Fremantle are 'undervalued' in the competition despite winning a final last year.
Just days out from the start of the 2025 season, the Dockers are far from the bookmakers' darling for the premiership, paying $34, according to TABTouch.
It comes after not a single club captain predicted Fremantle would win the grand final this season, with reigning premiers and heavy flag favourites North Melbourne receiving 10 votes.
WATCH FREMANTLE V PORT ADELAIDE AT 2PM SUNDAY ON SEVEN AND 7PLUS
'I hate it but it exists, the Victorian bias, for sure,' McCarthy told The West Australian.
'Coming from Brisbane myself, it's very evident and I think the only reason we see sort of less of that is because of the powerhouses that Brisbane and Adelaide have been in the women's comp as well.
'And that's no disrespect to North Melbourne, they absolutely deserve to be the premiership favourites, considering what they did last year, and a ball hasn't been bounced yet for 2025.
'But I think Fremantle have been definitely a little bit undervalued from the wider media.
'They did have a number of injuries last year, and I think what Lisa Webb is building at the Fremantle Dockers is something that's very special.'
Fremantle's best-ever player Kiara Bowers is set to make her highly-anticipated return against Port Adelaide on Sunday after missing last season due to pregnancy.
The four-time club champion, three-time All-Australian and 2021 best and fairest winner will also play her 50th game for the club.
Captain Ange Stannett, who did not play a game in her first season as skipper following an ACL injury, is also set to return in another huge boost for the Dockers' flag hopes.
'I'm really looking forward to actually seeing their progression from last year to this year,' McCarthy said of Fremantle.
'Obviously had a number of injuries to their forward line on the run, which is really hard to cover mid season. 'Getting Kiara Bowers back is a huge one, she's pretty irreplaceable. I think they're going to be really competitive.
'And they showed last year that their best is good enough to match it with some of the best teams in the competition.'
Star ruck Mim Strom is firming for another huge season following a maiden All-Australian blazer.
McCarthy said the reigning club champion, who led the league for hit-outs in 2024, had 'weapons that were pretty hard to stop'.
'No matter how much homework you do into Mim and her ability, either at the rough contest or around the ground, it's going to be pretty hard to stop her,' she said.
'And as we see key position players, they do take a little bit of time to develop and she's still really young, so I only see her game improving year on year from here out.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Courier-Mail
an hour ago
- Courier-Mail
AFL: Carlton Blues blow Collingwood away in season opening AFLW statement
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Carlton kicked off the AFLW's 10th season on a perfect note with a comfortable 24-point win over arch rivals Collingwood. The Pies started the night strongly with the first two goals, but the Blues would kick six of the next seven to cruise to victory at Ikon Park, 6.9 (45) to 3.3 (21). Watch every match of the 2025 NAB AFL Women's Season LIVE ad-break free during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. Mimi Hill starred for the Blues in the midfield with a game-high 32 disposals and Erone Fitzpatrick bagged two goals as Carlton opened its account with a win in a campaign captain Kerryn Peterson will miss due to the birth of her first child. 'They'll be really pleased with the electricity of their footy,' Herald Sun reporter Lauren Wood said on Fox Footy. 'Particularly without their captain. Carlton's Poppy Scholz celebrates after kicking her first goal. (Photo by James Wiltshire/AFL Photos via Getty Images) Mimi Hill (right) starred for the Blues. (Photo by James Wiltshire/AFL Photos via Getty Images) 'Naturally when you're without your skipper, you would have that sense of unknown. But led by Mimi Hill, they were pretty seamless without her.' Former AFLW Carlton coach Daniel Harford said Hill was 'allowed to do whatever the hell she liked' and 'took full advantage of that'. 'Really set the game alight, she was enormous,' he said on Fox Footy. Harford also praised Carlton's 'slick' ball movement, but noted Collingwood 'had no answers' in a disappointing start to the season for last year's wooden spooners, who have dropped 13 of their last 14 games. Over 25 debutants to be named in round 1 Video Player is loading. Play Video This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Text Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Caption Area Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Opacity Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Drop shadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. X Learn More Loaded : 5.20% 0:00 00:00 / 00:00 Close Modal Dialog This is a modal window. This modal can be closed by pressing the Escape key or activating the close button. 03:09 SUBSCRIBER ONLY Over 25 debutants to be named in round 1 AFLW: Over 25 young guns are set to be handed their AFLW debuts in the opening round of season ten. 'There's a few questions about the Magpies on the back of that and what they're trying to do and look like,' he added. 'They didn't show too much tonight, sadly for Magpies fans.' Collingwood fans had one moment in particular to cheer about, with No. 1 pick Ash Centra kicking her first goal with her first disposal in the second term. But further souring the loss for the Pies was Irish rookie Kellyann Hogan's night ending prematurely due to a shoulder issue. Originally published as Carlton make a statement in 'enormous' Pies beat down as rivals kick-off new season
News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
Carlton make a statement in ‘enormous' Pies beat down as rivals kick-off new season
Carlton kicked off the AFLW's 10th season on a perfect note with a comfortable 24-point win over arch rivals Collingwood. The Pies started the night strongly with the first two goals, but the Blues would kick six of the next seven to cruise to victory at Ikon Park, 6.9 (45) to 3.3 (21). Mimi Hill starred for the Blues in the midfield with a game-high 32 disposals and Erone Fitzpatrick bagged two goals as Carlton opened its account with a win in a campaign captain Kerryn Peterson will miss due to the birth of her first child. 'They'll be really pleased with the electricity of their footy,' Herald Sun reporter Lauren Wood said on Fox Footy. 'Particularly without their captain. 'Naturally when you're without your skipper, you would have that sense of unknown. But led by Mimi Hill, they were pretty seamless without her.' Former AFLW Carlton coach Daniel Harford said Hill was 'allowed to do whatever the hell she liked' and 'took full advantage of that'. 'Really set the game alight, she was enormous,' he said on Fox Footy. Harford also praised Carlton's 'slick' ball movement, but noted Collingwood 'had no answers' in a disappointing start to the season for last year's wooden spooners, who have dropped 13 of their last 14 games. 'There's a few questions about the Magpies on the back of that and what they're trying to do and look like,' he added. 'They didn't show too much tonight, sadly for Magpies fans.' Collingwood fans had one moment in particular to cheer about, with No. 1 pick Ash Centra kicking her first goal with her first disposal in the second term. But further souring the loss for the Pies was Irish rookie Kellyann Hogan's night ending prematurely due to a shoulder issue.
The Advertiser
4 hours ago
- The Advertiser
'Rage' drives 'Punky' as end looms for Hawthorn great
Luke Breust may, or may not, be familiar with the work of iconic Welsh poet Dylan Thomas. They certainly share the same sentiment, with the three-time Hawthorn premiership forward determined to "rage, rage against the dying of the light". The 34-year-old, a two-time All-Australian and one of the best small forwards of his generation, announced on Thursday this season will be his last. Former teammate and current Hawks coach Sam Mitchell has no doubt Breust will stay in the game, probably as a coach, but there is unfinished business, with the Hawks seventh on the ladder and yet to confirm a finals berth. "He spoke really nicely and gently (to teammates) ... until we started talking about the rest of the season. He had just that little bit of rage behind his eyes," Mitchell said. "He's still burning to make sure he can achieve as much and help us achieve as much as we can." Known as "Punky", Breust is the game's ultimate cult figure and Mitchell added he was the rarest of beasts - an AFL player with no enemies. Hawks fans sound as though they are booing when they roar his name after he kicks a goal. Breust was in tears several times when he told teammates that his time will soon be up. He later noted half his life has been spent at Hawthorn. "They completely changed my life for the better," Breust said of the Hawks. "The relationships and the memories ... I will cherish forever. "The three minutes after the final siren goes on grand final day, you'll never feel anything like that in your life." Among the many people Breust thanked, he noted how Mitchell took him under his wing when he first came to the club. "I don't know what the hell you saw in me," Breust said. He also singled out Jack Gunston, who shared All-Australian honours with him in 2018. The two forwards are the only veterans on their list to play in Hawthorn premierships. Breust and Gunston played in the 2012-15 grand finals, winning three flags. "(We are) the biggest rivals you could imagine, but also great mates at the same time ... he's been so important to my career," Breust said. The small forward returned to the senior team for last week's win over Collingwood for a career total of 306 games. He is among nine Hawks to reach 300 games, and his 307th this Saturday in the game against Melbourne at the MCG will put him equal with Mitchell at third on the club list. Breust has kicked 552 goals, seventh-highest at Hawthorn, and made the 2014 and 2018 All-Australian teams. But his impact at Hawthorn goes well beyond his significant on-field exploits. "If you could make your culture around the type of club you want to be and the type of person you want to be, Luke Breust is perfect,' Mitchell said. Hailing from the small NSW country town of Temora, Breust proved a bargain-basement selection when the Hawks recruited him with the No.47 pick in the 2008 rookie draft. He did not make his debut until 2011. Mitchell said for all the support Breust received when he was starting, he has paid that forward 10-fold. "I said to the players 'who has he helped?' Every player put his hand up, no hesitation, straight away," he added. Luke Breust may, or may not, be familiar with the work of iconic Welsh poet Dylan Thomas. They certainly share the same sentiment, with the three-time Hawthorn premiership forward determined to "rage, rage against the dying of the light". The 34-year-old, a two-time All-Australian and one of the best small forwards of his generation, announced on Thursday this season will be his last. Former teammate and current Hawks coach Sam Mitchell has no doubt Breust will stay in the game, probably as a coach, but there is unfinished business, with the Hawks seventh on the ladder and yet to confirm a finals berth. "He spoke really nicely and gently (to teammates) ... until we started talking about the rest of the season. He had just that little bit of rage behind his eyes," Mitchell said. "He's still burning to make sure he can achieve as much and help us achieve as much as we can." Known as "Punky", Breust is the game's ultimate cult figure and Mitchell added he was the rarest of beasts - an AFL player with no enemies. Hawks fans sound as though they are booing when they roar his name after he kicks a goal. Breust was in tears several times when he told teammates that his time will soon be up. He later noted half his life has been spent at Hawthorn. "They completely changed my life for the better," Breust said of the Hawks. "The relationships and the memories ... I will cherish forever. "The three minutes after the final siren goes on grand final day, you'll never feel anything like that in your life." Among the many people Breust thanked, he noted how Mitchell took him under his wing when he first came to the club. "I don't know what the hell you saw in me," Breust said. He also singled out Jack Gunston, who shared All-Australian honours with him in 2018. The two forwards are the only veterans on their list to play in Hawthorn premierships. Breust and Gunston played in the 2012-15 grand finals, winning three flags. "(We are) the biggest rivals you could imagine, but also great mates at the same time ... he's been so important to my career," Breust said. The small forward returned to the senior team for last week's win over Collingwood for a career total of 306 games. He is among nine Hawks to reach 300 games, and his 307th this Saturday in the game against Melbourne at the MCG will put him equal with Mitchell at third on the club list. Breust has kicked 552 goals, seventh-highest at Hawthorn, and made the 2014 and 2018 All-Australian teams. But his impact at Hawthorn goes well beyond his significant on-field exploits. "If you could make your culture around the type of club you want to be and the type of person you want to be, Luke Breust is perfect,' Mitchell said. Hailing from the small NSW country town of Temora, Breust proved a bargain-basement selection when the Hawks recruited him with the No.47 pick in the 2008 rookie draft. He did not make his debut until 2011. Mitchell said for all the support Breust received when he was starting, he has paid that forward 10-fold. "I said to the players 'who has he helped?' Every player put his hand up, no hesitation, straight away," he added. Luke Breust may, or may not, be familiar with the work of iconic Welsh poet Dylan Thomas. They certainly share the same sentiment, with the three-time Hawthorn premiership forward determined to "rage, rage against the dying of the light". The 34-year-old, a two-time All-Australian and one of the best small forwards of his generation, announced on Thursday this season will be his last. Former teammate and current Hawks coach Sam Mitchell has no doubt Breust will stay in the game, probably as a coach, but there is unfinished business, with the Hawks seventh on the ladder and yet to confirm a finals berth. "He spoke really nicely and gently (to teammates) ... until we started talking about the rest of the season. He had just that little bit of rage behind his eyes," Mitchell said. "He's still burning to make sure he can achieve as much and help us achieve as much as we can." Known as "Punky", Breust is the game's ultimate cult figure and Mitchell added he was the rarest of beasts - an AFL player with no enemies. Hawks fans sound as though they are booing when they roar his name after he kicks a goal. Breust was in tears several times when he told teammates that his time will soon be up. He later noted half his life has been spent at Hawthorn. "They completely changed my life for the better," Breust said of the Hawks. "The relationships and the memories ... I will cherish forever. "The three minutes after the final siren goes on grand final day, you'll never feel anything like that in your life." Among the many people Breust thanked, he noted how Mitchell took him under his wing when he first came to the club. "I don't know what the hell you saw in me," Breust said. He also singled out Jack Gunston, who shared All-Australian honours with him in 2018. The two forwards are the only veterans on their list to play in Hawthorn premierships. Breust and Gunston played in the 2012-15 grand finals, winning three flags. "(We are) the biggest rivals you could imagine, but also great mates at the same time ... he's been so important to my career," Breust said. The small forward returned to the senior team for last week's win over Collingwood for a career total of 306 games. He is among nine Hawks to reach 300 games, and his 307th this Saturday in the game against Melbourne at the MCG will put him equal with Mitchell at third on the club list. Breust has kicked 552 goals, seventh-highest at Hawthorn, and made the 2014 and 2018 All-Australian teams. But his impact at Hawthorn goes well beyond his significant on-field exploits. "If you could make your culture around the type of club you want to be and the type of person you want to be, Luke Breust is perfect,' Mitchell said. Hailing from the small NSW country town of Temora, Breust proved a bargain-basement selection when the Hawks recruited him with the No.47 pick in the 2008 rookie draft. He did not make his debut until 2011. Mitchell said for all the support Breust received when he was starting, he has paid that forward 10-fold. "I said to the players 'who has he helped?' Every player put his hand up, no hesitation, straight away," he added.
