Qantas cyber attack: Kiwis cannot join Aussie legal complaint but can complain in NZ, expert says
He said the office would consider the complaint and ask: 'Is this an actionable privacy breach in New Zealand?'
Shaw said a privacy breach in this context meant a person had access to or misused personal information without consent.
'Then the question from there is, if it's a privacy breach, what has somebody suffered effectively?'
The Office of the Privacy Commissioner would try to resolve that issue and ask if mediation was possible.
'Ultimately the Human Rights Review Tribunal considers it.'
The New Zealand process for data breaches has generated some criticism.
Consumer NZ chief executive Jon Duffy earlier this month said Qantas would face much stiffer penalties under Australian privacy regulations than it would if it were a New Zealand company.
However, Shaw said the system in New Zealand could punish people or entities for data breaches.
'The system in New Zealand is good. The Privacy Commissioner and the act have real teeth. The criticism I would have is the delay, the delay in having the matter heard by the Human Rights Review Tribunal.'
He said the tribunal could award substantial damages.
Shaw said Lane Neave was not suing Qantas but New Zealand had some litigation funders and some no-win no-fee practitioners who might consider the case.
The Office of the Privacy Commissioner has been approached for comment.
Qantas said it was aware Maurice Blackburn in Australia had lodged a complaint on behalf of some affected customers in relation to the cyber incident.
'Our focus continues to be on supporting our customers and providing ongoing access to specialist identity protection advice and resources,' a Qantas spokesman said.
'In an effort to further protect our customers, Qantas has obtained an injunction in the New South Wales Supreme Court which prevents the stolen data from being accessed, viewed, released, used, transmitted or published by anyone, including by any third parties.'
Maurice Blackburn said the complaint was made to the Australian privacy commissioner, who did not have jurisdiction over New Zealanders' personal information.
Some 1.3 million residential or business addresses were among the affected Qantas data, including hotels for misplaced baggage delivery.
Four million customer records stolen in the attack contained names, email addresses and Qantas Frequent Flyer numbers.
John Weekes is a business journalist mostly covering aviation and courts. He has reported on Catholic Church abuse and the Abuse in Care Royal Commission of Inquiry since 2019 and on Dilworth survivors since 2021.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
2 hours ago
- The Spinoff
Could changing the incentives for power companies make electricity cheaper?
High power prices now seem normal in New Zealand, especially in winter. Could incentivising power companies to invest in generation capacity, rather than return dividends to the government, lower costs for individuals and businesses alike? One sign that electricity in New Zealand is expensive? The Powerswitch website, a service that lets you input some information and figure out if you could be getting a better deal with another plan. 'In June, we saw double the previous month's record for users,' says Paul Fuge, who runs Powerswitch on behalf of Consumer NZ, with funding from the Electricity Authority. Thousands of people are logging on every day – many of whom, Fuge says, find they could be paying up to $500 less a year just by switching plans. Retail power prices have increased 11% over the course of the year, Consumer says, partly because of changes in transmission costs and revenue limits for lines companies. There's a flow-on effect, Fuge says. 'Lots of people underheat their homes to save money but it's a false economy. People get cold and sick, end up in hospital, more kids don't go to school – it costs New Zealand more and makes it harder to participate in the economy.' It's not just individuals and households being affected by high power prices. When retail prices increase, wholesale power is pricier, too, although the cost fluctuates a lot more than a household plan. Manufacturers across New Zealand have said that power costs threaten their businesses; Winstone Pulp and Oji Fibre Solutions, paper mills that closed last year, said that the cost of electricity in New Zealand was one reason they couldn't continue. 'We should be in a position where our country has abundant renewable energy that is low cost and secure,' said Karen Boyes, the executive director of the Major Electricity Users Group, in an interview on Q + A in July. Fluctuating power prices make it hard for businesses to plan for the future. 'You need certainty for more than three to six years if you're going to keep investing in infrastructure,' she said. Headlines about expensive power are a kind of déjà vu; back every winter, as reliable as plunging temperatures and grey skies. Fuge, who gets a firsthand look at how much power prices hurt people through Powerswitch, feels this. 'We think markets are good for consumers, they drive innovation – but the results we're seeing aren't what you'd expect from a thriving competitive market,' he says. One response from the government has been to commission a review of the electricity sector, which began in February this year and is reportedly completed but yet to be made public. It follows a review of electricity prices conducted under the previous Labour government in 2018-19, and a review of the wholesale market in 2021. New Zealand's electricity market operates as a group of private companies, with generators Contact, Meridian, Genesis and Mercury publicly listed and traded on the New Zealand (and for some also the Australian) stock exchange. But the New Zealand government owns 51% of each company (except Contact, which is fully privately owned), meaning it gets paid dividends from electricity profits. Ed Miller, an economist, has calculated that the government gets nearly a billion dollars of returns from dividends and taxes from electricity generation each year – the figure was $980m in 2024. The companies also return money to their private shareholders, $655.8m in 2024. That's money that isn't being invested in generation – and, Miller argues, means individuals and businesses will continue to experience high electricity prices. The scarcity drives the price of electricity up, decreasing how much generating companies are willing to invest in increasing the amount of power they make. The power companies exist under the State-Owned Enterprises Act, which expects them to maximise returns, without the government making business decisions. 'That's a function of the market – the incentives to build [generation] relative to the risks aren't right,' Fuge says. It's worth noting that generators are investing in growing how much power they make as well as figuring out ways to make existing assets more efficient. Better batteries will increase Meridian's solar output; Genesis opened a new solar farm in Canterbury in April; Contact's geothermal plant near Taupō, which cost $924m to build, has been running at full capacity since November 2024; Mercury is building dozens of new wind turbines in Northland, and there are myriad other projects which have been approved or designed, though construction hasn't started yet. But after Meridian, Genesis and Mercury were partially privatised in the early 2010s, there were three years of the power companies making no investments in new renewable generation. As of 2024, the companies had spent $1.38bn since being publicly listed on new renewable energy projects, while paying out $9bn of dividends. Spending on generation has increased since 2019, and the companies have also invested lots of money in maintaining existing electricity infrastructure, which is often ageing. 'The new generation capacity is essentially late – we have a six to seven-year investment debit,' Miller says. Making electricity more abundant could lead to cheaper prices. 'You could have a lot more compassion in the system – lower-income users get cheaper electricity, you have more flexibility to support businesses in serious financial distress with cheaper electricity,' Miller says. 'The rules of the market presented to the gentailers are not to change generation or have the retailers price cheaper,' Fuge says. 'But if you don't like the rugby being played, you don't blame the players, you change the rules.' Miller says that increasing the incentives for gentailers would require reimagining the State-Owned Enterprise Act, which mentions dividends rather than profit. In the law, there's no reason for companies to reinvest profits to grow generation, or to support electricity users in need, whether they are low-income people or struggling businesses. Instead of David Seymour's vision of asset sales, the state would have to retain partial ownership of the electricity companies, rather than selling off its remaining 51% share. 'As long as electricity is a private market, we will contend with this,' he says. 'There's no single magic bullet,' Fuge points out. But with an estimated 40,000 people having had their power cut off in the last year due to not paying bills, there are lots of reasons to rethink the system that sells electricity.
The Spinoff
2 hours ago
- The Spinoff
More people want to be the mayor of Dunedin than anywhere else. So who are they?
Meet the record-breaking 16 candidates vying to lead Ōtepoti. An impressive 16 citizens have put themselves forward to become mayor of Dunedin, proudly bucking the national trend of New Zealanders not giving a shit about local body politics. It's a record number of candidates (up from 11 in 2022) for Dunedin and the biggest mayoral race in the country this year, doubling Christchurch's measly eight candidates and comfortably beating Auckland, Wellington and Hamilton, who each have 12. Great work, Dunedin, but also, calm down, Dunedin! What makes the job of mayor the hottest gig in town, and more importantly, why don't all of these mayoral candidates have websites promoting their campaigns? Here's a quick rundown of the 16 contenders, from the candidate who wants to reset the city like it's a computer to the candidate who really, truly, lives in a castle. Lync Aronson Independent candidate Aronson says he has quit his job to 'dedicate himself full-time to fighting our city's future'. He's campaigning for a fully funded city council, lower rates, better services with AI and real community investment, and promises a 'practical, hands-on approach'. Sophie Barker Barker has been a city councillor since 2019 and previously ran for mayor in 2022. Her goal is to make Dunedin the most liveable city in New Zealand, focusing on transformation, liveability and partnerships. Barker was deputy mayor in 2022-23 before resigning due to difficulties working with current mayor Jules Radich, and – after she was recently endorsed by two of his former Team Dunedin allies – looks to be Radich's strongest competition. She's probably the only mayoral candidate to have grown up in a castle, her family having owned Larnach Castle since 1967. Doug Hall Hall runs a local IT business. 'I've spent all my life troubleshooting computer problems, and I would like to think that I'll be able to use those skills to troubleshoot Dunedin's Problems, and to reboot the city,' his campaign website says. Just turn it off and on again, surely? Carmen Houlahan A Dunedin city councillor since 2019, Houlahan was censured for breaching the council's code of conduct in 2023 after repeatedly calling and messaging Sophie Barker, who had laid a complaint against Radich. A former journalist and arts publicist, Houlahan previously ran for mayor in 2022. She wants to see strengthened relationships between the council, University of Otago, mana whenua and the business sector, and wants the city to be vibrant and affordable. Marie Laufiso Laufiso became a city councillor in 2016, making her Dunedin's first ever Pasifika councillor. Laufiso is standing for mayor under the 'Building Kotahitaka' ticket, and wants to advocate for the interests of Dunedin's most vulnerable and at-risk communities and families. 'I'm interested in out-of-the-box solutions and approaches,' she told the Otago Daily Times. Lianna MacFarlane There's little online about MacFarlane's campaign, other than her hypnotherapy and life-coaching business website which reveals she has 'a 25+ year history in natural health, relationship counselling and finance'. Mandy Mayhem A former circus ringleader, Mayhem served on the Waitati Community Board for six years before becoming a Dunedin city councillor in 2022. Mayhem wants to build a welcoming, inclusive and accessible city where all residents feel valued and listened to. She also has a black belt in taekwondo and a great hat game. David Milne Company director Milne ran for mayor in 2022, but there's no information online about his current campaign. Thus, we must rely on Toby Manhire's description of him from a mayoral debate about the arts held three years ago: 'David Milne was upbeat, bushy-tailed and at times looked as if he'd accidentally walked into the room, like the guy who was mistakenly put in a live BBC studio to talk about a legal battle in the music industry. 'I love acting,' Milne said. 'I love actors. So I've got a lot of great ideas for what you want.'' Flynn (Nisvett) Nisbett With Mayhem's ringmaster pōtae and Nisvett's silly hat, could this be the great hat vote-off Dunedin has been waiting for? Nisvett – the leader ('king') of the Aotearoa New Zealand Silly Hat Party – mostly wants to make Dunedin warm. 'I refuse to believe Dunedin needs to be this cold all of the time. Sometimes it's okay, but it never suits the people who live here and we've had enough,' Nisvett says. Benedict Ong Ong is a former international banker who recently returned to his birthplace of Dunedin. He promises bold economic leadership to increase jobs and wages, as well as no rate rises thanks to a 'first-of-its-kind financial innovation' that draws on his global corporate financial expertise. Jules Radich The incumbent. Radich was elected as mayor in 2022 with a significant majority, and says his first term has been defined by a focus on practical skills. His critics would say his first term has been marred by controversy (see Sophie Barker above), and his campaign statement that he 'didn't hesitate to push back' against government cuts to the New Dunedin Hospital was quickly disputed by several councillors. Radich says he's standing again for mayor because he has unfinished business, and his priorities involve strengthening Dunedin's sustainability and fostering growth. Zenith Rose-Wills Climate activist Rose-Wills is also known as Ruthven Allimrac, and is standing for The Radical Action Faction. Andrew Simms Car salesman Simms leads the well-organised Future Dunedin ticket, which includes eight candidates standing for council and advocates for 14 different priorities from lowering rates to heritage to supporting Dunedin railways. While he doesn't have city council experience, Simms is the current chair of the Mosgiel-Taieri community board. Pamela Taylor Conspiracy theorist Taylor ran for mayor in 2022. Mickey Treadwell More Reading Treadwell is a video game programmer and a part-time lecturer, and is standing on a Green Party ticket. Treadwell wants to build the city's long-term resilience against climate change and an unstable international economy. Lee Vandervis 2025 marks Vandervis's eighth attempt at being elected mayor of Dunedin. He's been a city councillor since 2004 and has had a contentious time around the council table, including taking the Dunedin City Council to the Supreme Court over a $12 parking ticket and calling a mural designed by local school children ' woke' and full of 'crass ideology '. His mayoral plans to control rates, debt and bureaucracy include cancelling carbon zero and cycleway spending budgets.
Newsroom
2 hours ago
- Newsroom
Charting who and where is worst hit by labour market slump
Aucklanders, along with those looking for casual and part-time work, are among those suffering in a soft labour market, latest data shows. Seasonally adjusted employment figures released by Stats NZ on Wednesday showed the national rate of unemployment ticked up 0.1 percentage points to 5.2 percent in the June 2025 quarter, marking an 11.1 percent rise in joblessness with 158,000 New Zealanders out of work. This is the highest rate since 2020 and in line with the Reserve Bank's expectations, but lower than the 5.3 percent widely forecast by economists.
