Eight international protection accommodation contracts terminated in first four months of 2024
Seven International Protection Accommodation Services (IPAS) contracts with commercial accommodation providers were ended in the first four months of the year for reasons including noncompliance with planning, fire safety and other regulations, the Minister for Justice, Jim O'Callaghan, has said.
More than 90 per cent of all international protection accommodation is provided on a commercial basis, with hotels, B&Bs and other centres taking up contracts to provide beds for people arriving in the State seeking asylum.
This reliance on private providers led to the Government spending more than €1 billion on international protection accommodation last year. The budget for this year is €1.2 billion.
Concerns have been raised about standards at some private accommodation centres, which are not all subject to independent inspections.
READ MORE
Mr O'Callaghan has said his preference is for international protection applicants to be housed in State-owned accommodation.
Figures released by his department in response to a parliamentary question from Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon show that between January 1st and May 7th last, eight contracts with private accommodation providers were terminated. This represented 140 bed spaces.
The department said seven of the contracts were ended by the State side, with one terminated by the provider.
'I am informed that reasons for termination can vary but can include noncompliance with contractual terms or with regulatory requirements like building and fire regulations or planning matters,' Mr O'Callaghan said.
'In the same period, 12 new IPAS accommodation contracts have been agreed, accounting for capacity of up to 848 bed spaces.'
[
International protection overhaul an 'important step' in wider reform, Minister says
Opens in new window
]
Mr O'Callaghan said the commissioning of emergency commercial accommodation 'will continue to be necessary' in the short to medium term, but it is being contracted on a short-term basis to allow the 'State to decommission this capacity with agility as contracts expire or demand fluctuates'.
Mr Gannon said he had sought figures on the numbers of IPAS contracts that were ending following a media interview given by Mr O'Callaghan last month.
Speaking on RTÉ's Today with Claire Byrne, the Minister said 'many' of the agreements with private providers were 'now being terminated'. He said this was 'because if the numbers are going down, we don't need to have as many places for accommodation as provided before'.
Mr Gannon said the figures released to him showed there had, in reality, been more contracts created than ended this year.
'So, far from winding things down, the system is expanding,' Mr Gannon said.
While he welcomed planned reforms such as faster processing times for international protection applications, Mr Gannon said the fairness of the system matters 'just as much' as the speed of it.
'The truth is, Ireland is already failing to meet its legal obligations. In December, over 3,000 asylum seekers were left homeless,' he said.
'In April, the European Court of Justice confirmed that housing shortages are no excuse for denying basic care. We can't afford to play politics with facts, or with people's lives. The real issue isn't too many beds, it's too little planning, too much reliance on the private sector, and not enough focus on human rights and dignity at the core of the system.'
In April, the Office of the Protected Disclosures Commissioner said IPAS centres had been the subject of six whistleblowing allegations last year. It said these centres were an 'emerging theme' for the office and it raised concerns about 'the lack of uniformity of the inspection regime' for them.
The Department of Justice said: 'Owing to the protected nature of protected disclosures, the department does not comment on whether such disclosures have been made in any specific instance.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
42 minutes ago
- The Journal
Children deported this week are 'victims for a state wanting to look tough', Dublin TD says
A DUBLIN TD has said that children should not face deportations from the state as outcry continues over the removal of a number of kids on a chartered flight to Nigeria by the Irish government this week. Social Democrats deputy Gary Gannon said that children were being made 'victims for a state wanting to look tough', adding that Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan has 'serious questions to answer' over this week's deportations. It comes after the principal of St James school in Dublin 8 that saw two of its pupils deported to Nigeria on Wednesday night criticised the decision to deport , saying that staff and pupils have been left 'devastated'. Five children and thirty adults were removed from Ireland on the chartered flight as part of the Department of Justice's new crackdown on immigration. School principal Ciarán Cronin had told The Journal that two of the children who were removed from the state had been pupils at his school for three years, and have in that time become an integral part of the community there. 'They've been part of our football team, part of our school fabric, part of our school lives,' he said yesterday. Defending the use of the flights yesterday, O'Callaghan said that deportations 'aren't a very pleasant part of the job,' but said the system becomes 'meaningless' if it won't make a difference whether people are granted asylum or not. Gannon told RTÉ Radio One's Today with Claire Byrne that there should be a regularisation scheme for children who have been in Ireland for a year, allowing them to stay here. 'If the system doesn't working at the moment we cannot punish the children that are over here,' he said, adding that a 'compassionate' approach was needed. Gannon also sought information on how many children are currently on deportation lists in Ireland. Advertisement He said the deportation of the children this week was 'devastating', especially for kids who were in Ireland for the past three and four years who have little 'The children on that flight, in the St James school in the Red Cow, they shouldn't be the victims for a state looking to look tough.' 'The consequences are not only for those on the deportation flight, it's for the other 20 odd children,' Gannon said, referring to St James School, describing it 'momentously painful' for the children involved. 'They have the right to come here, if the system is taking too long that is a failure of the state, not a failure of those parents,' Gannon said. Sinn Féin frontbench TD Eoin Ó Broin told reporters this morning that Ireland needs an international protection system that is compassionate, that is human rights based, that takes decisions in a timely manner. Asked whether he believes it's right to deport children who have residing in Ireland over recent years, he said that 'the real problem here is nobody should be waiting for three, four or five years for those decisions to be made'. 'I think if the government took the advice that ourselves and many others, including advocacy groups for people seeking international protection, to ensure decisions were made in a timely manner, then we wouldn't have the kind of challenges that we've seen this week,' the Dublin Mid-West TD said. 'But ultimately international protection has to do what it says. You're either granted international protection, you get your right to remain in the state, or if you're not granted international protection, you lose an appeal, and you lose the application to remain.' Asked about criticism that the government may be trying to appear more aggressive towards migration, he said the issue was that the government had 'made a complete mess' of the international protection system. 'Just like they've made a mess of housing, whether it's housing vacancy or housing more generally, they've made a mess of international protection, and therefore we will continue to raise the concerns that we have always raised with government until they get the system right.' With reporting from Mairead Maguire Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
State should ease ‘financial burden' for people facing heavy legal costs at public inquiries, report finds
The 'personal financial burden' of appearing before a Commission of Investigation should be eased by the State, the final report of the National Asset Management Agency (Nama) commission has said. The Commission of Investigation into the controversial sale of Project Eagle has called on the Government to change the 'strict' guidelines for covering the legal costs of those who appear before high-profile public inquiries. It said witnesses who 'diligently' give evidence, submissions and documents can end up in the 'very unfortunate situation' of having to personally pay high legal fees for their participation in the process. At the moment, the guidelines for legal costs under the Commissions of Investigation Act 2004 says witnesses can recoup some but not all of their legal fees. The current guidelines do not cover instruction fees, brief fees and legal fees incurred while making submissions. READ MORE In the case of the Nama commission, over two-thirds of the legal bills of the so-called 'bad bank' could not be recovered. It is understood that Nama's total legal costs reached €7.5 million, but it only received €2.4 million of that back from the commission. Thirty-six witnesses on behalf of Nama, including past and present employees, offered evidence and submissions over the seven years of the inquiry. All of these witnesses made claims for the payments of their costs. After assessing the claims for costs from Nama with the help of the State Claims Agency , the commission said it believed the current guidelines on legal costs would 'benefit significantly from review and updating'. 'Engaging with a Commission of Investigation can be an onerous task for private individuals, many of whom understandably seek legal advice and assistance in relation to their interaction with a Commission,' the commission stated in its final report to Taoiseach Micheál Martin . 'Witnesses who diligently provide detailed statements, attend to give evidence, provide documents and make submissions may find themselves in the very unfortunate situation of having to discharge significant fees personally due to the strict confines of the guidelines for payment of legal costs.' The commission, whose sole member is Susan Gilvarry, said Nama had tried to recoup 'substantial legal costs', but the commission wasn't able to consider or direct the recovery of any costs not set out in the current guidelines. It pointed out that the recovery of costs was less important in the case of Nama, where a state agency's costs are 'sought to be recovered from a Government department'. But it said that these 'discrete set of circumstances' would not apply in every case, so it recommended that the 'guidelines are revised and clarified to reflect the personal financial burden that witnesses or third parties may be subjected to by virtue of being requested to engage with a Commission of Investigation'. [ Department of Finance to wind down special bank shareholdings unit Opens in new window ] The Department of the Taoiseach did not respond to requests for comment. The report from the Nama commission said that its final costs, from the point it was established in June 2017 to April 2025, were €10.3 million. This included €4.6 million in legal fees, a salary cost of €1.75 million and administrative costs of €1.4 million. Since the late 1990s, the State has spent more than €600 million on tribunals of inquiry and commissions of investigation, including the €143 million Mahon/Flood Tribunal, the €85 million Commission to inquire into Child Abuse and the €83 million Moriarty Tribunal. In April, the billionaire businessman Denis O'Brien was awarded €5.8 million by the State Claims Agency for the legal costs he faced while a witness for the Moriarty Tribunal between 2001 and 2010.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Robert Pether's wife hopes his release from Iraqi prison will end ‘living nightmare'
An Irish resident who has been in jail in Iraq for the last four years is 'unrecognisable', his wife, Desree Pether, has said. Robert Pether, originally from Australia, was released on bail on Thursday. He was arrested in April 2021 along with an Egyptian colleague Khalid Radwan on suspicion of theft. Mr Pether has been held in a cell with 20 other prisoners. The United Nations says it has been an arbitrary detention. The arrest arose out of a contract dispute. Mr Pether was an engineer working for the Dubai-based engineering firm CME Consulting on rebuilding Iraq's Central Bank headquarters in Baghdad. READ MORE His wife said Mr Pether is 'very sick at the moment' and she wants to bring him back to Ireland. The couple bought a former convent in Elphin, Co Roscommon, five years ago with a view to turning into a herbal therapy centre. She is an Irish citizen through her Dublin-born father. Last night she saw him for the first time in four years on video and it was a 'shock'. 'I was very happy to see him – but also to see the state of him, he was completely unrecognisable'. [ Robert Pether released on bail after four years in Iraqi jail Opens in new window ] 'It's a shock to the system to see how he has declined. He's not well at all. He needs to come home to get the proper medical care he needs.' Ms Pether said it has been a 'a living nightmare' to try and get her husband out from jail. She wants to get a travel ban on Mr Pether lifted so he can return to Ireland. 'I'm hoping there is light at the end of the tunnel. I'm hoping we can get through this. It's been beyond frustrating. It's not over. It's one small step in the right direction,' she told the RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland programme. He has lost a lot of weight as he has been unable to eat properly since being incarcerated, she said. The couple have three children, Flynn, Oscar and daughter Nala. Tánaiste and Minster for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris welcomed Mr Pether's release. Robert Pether with his wife, Desree, who lives in Elphin with their children He was told yesterday evening by Iraq's foreign minister Fuad Hussein that Mr Pether was being released unconditionally. 'This is very welcome news in what has been a long and distressing saga for Robert's wife, three children and his wider family and friends,' the Tánaiste said.
