Driver who killed eight-month-old baby in pram has sentence reduced
Bridget Curtis pressed down on the accelerator of her car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital, killing Mabli Cariad Hall who was sitting in her pushchair
Bridget Curtis killed Mabli Cariad Hall after she pressed down on the accelerator of her automatic BMW 520d car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, on June 21, 2023
(Image: WALES NEWS SERVICE )
A driver who struck and killed an eight-month-old baby in her pram outside a hospital has had her prison sentence reduced at the Court of Appeal, in what judges described as a "truly tragic" case.
Bridget Curtis pressed down on the accelerator of her automatic BMW 520d car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, on June 21 2023, causing it to mount a kerb and collide with the pushchair of Mabli Cariad Hall.
Mabli, who had just said a final goodbye to her paternal grandmother Betty Hall, who was receiving end-of-life care at the hospital, sustained fatal head injuries and died in hospital days later.
Eight-month-old Mabli Cariad Hall, who died when she was struck in her pushchair by driver Bridget Curtis outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire in June 2023.
(Image: Copyright remains with handout provider )
Curtis, who was 69 at the time of the offence and is now 71, pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving last September and was jailed for four years at Swansea Crown Court in January.
At the Court of Appeal on Tuesday, her barrister said the sentence was "manifestly excessive" and should be reduced, stating that the case concerned a "lapse of concentration."
Article continues below
Three senior judges ruled that Curtis's sentence was "manifestly excessive" and reduced it to one of three years, while increasing her disqualification from driving from six years to seven-and-a-half years.
Mr Justice Butcher, sitting with Lord Justice Bean and Judge Richard Marks KC, said: "We say at once that this is a truly tragic case.
"We have read the very moving victim personal statements of Mabli's parents, expressing their grief at the death of their beloved baby.
"No one could fail to sympathise with them for the appalling loss that they have sustained."
Curtis, who attended the appeal via video link from HMP Eastwood Park in Gloucestershire and sat in a wheelchair throughout, had no previous convictions at the time of the incident and had held a clean driving licence for more than 50 years.
Her sentencing hearing at Swansea Crown Court heard that on the day of the collision she had driven her daughter to an outpatient appointment at the hospital.
When her daughter struggled to find her handbag in the rear of the car, Curtis unlocked the door and turned around to assist her.
But as she did so, she pressed down on the accelerator of her car, which had been left running and was not in park mode.
The car reached speeds of more than 29mph and travelled 28 metres in around four seconds, mounting the kerb of a grass seating area and causing Mabli to be thrown out of her pushchair.
The car only stopped when it collided with a tree, having also caused injuries to Mabli's father Rob Hall.
Mabli, the youngest of six siblings, received treatment at the Withybush Hospital, as well as hospitals in Cardiff and Bristol, dying in the arms of her parents on June 25.
Her mother, Gwen Hall, told the sentencing hearing that her daughter was "so bright, so beautiful, so full of love and life."
Mabli Cariad Hall was killed
(Image: PA Media )
She said: "She hadn't crawled yet. She had said 'Mama' for the first time only the day before. We had so much planned with her.
"It was nowhere near the time for her to be taken away from us. She was my baby. My eight-month-old baby."
John Dye, for Curtis, told Swansea Crown Court that she was a mother-of-four and grandmother of 10, who was "absolutely devastated" by the incident.
Appearing again for Curtis at the Court of Appeal on Tuesday, Mr Dye said: "This is a tragic case, but the issue really was one of pedal confusion."
He continued: "Objectively, this is clearly dangerous driving, but in terms of culpability, these four seconds of driving were more akin to, maybe not a momentary lapse, but a lapse of concentration."
Craig Jones, for the Crown Prosecution Service, made no oral submissions to the court.
Reducing the sentence, Mr Justice Butcher said: "True it is that the appellant did not intend to cause any harm, and true also that the mistake was of a short duration, but the driving was well over the threshold of dangerousness."
He continued that Curtis would have known that she had stopped "in a busy area outside a hospital with potentially very vulnerable pedestrians around", and that four or five seconds "is far from being a negligible duration."
Article continues below
He added that the court accepted that Curtis's remorse was "genuine", stating: "It was inattention and confusion as to which pedal she was pressing that caused this tragedy."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
13 hours ago
- Times
Having to admit guilt in order to win parole is wrong
Another apparent miscarriage of justice has emerged. This time, it is the case of Clive Freeman, an 82-year-old former soldier who has spent 37 years in prison for a murder that may never have happened. In 1989, Freeman was convicted of killing a vagrant whose partially burnt body was discovered in his home. The prosecution relied on questionable pathology evidence to claim that the victim was suffocated using a 19th-century 'burking' technique. Freeman has always maintained his innocence. His refusal to confess to the crime has ensured his continued incarceration. The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) has now concluded there is 'a real possibility' that the Court of Appeal will quash his conviction. The question is whether justice will come in time for a man who is terminally ill and has been separated from his family for nearly four decades. Freeman's ordeal highlights two chronic failings in our justice system: first, that wrongful convictions happen far more often than the state cares to admit; and second, that our parole system cruelly insists that prisoners convicted of serious offences must admit guilt before they can be released, even when they are protesting innocence. The case of Andrew Malkinson is another recent reminder of what is wrong. Malkinson spent 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit. DNA evidence eventually cleared him, but not before the system had dismissed his appeals, ignored emerging evidence and treated his steadfast claim of innocence as an obstacle to his release. Cases such as Freeman's and Malkinson's are indictments of a process that places too much trust in flawed evidence, resists admitting error and coerces the innocent into impossible moral compromises. How many languish behind bars, wasting years — even lifetimes — because of false allegations, botched investigations, wrongful imprisonment and a state too proud to say it was wrong? The true number is a figure that, if ever revealed, would be difficult for Britain to swallow — and even harder to reconcile with any claim that our country is a paragon of fairness and justice. • Andrew Malkinson: 'What do you think a false rape conviction does to a man's mind?' What should change? First, the requirement for prisoners to admit guilt to qualify for parole must be abolished. Second, the CCRC needs greater independence, resources and powers to compel the disclosure of evidence. It should not take decades for fresh evidence to be properly considered. Third, there must be genuine accountability for police and prosecutors who withhold or distort evidence and for expert witnesses whose flawed testimony helps secure wrongful convictions. Finally, we must change the culture. The justice system must remember that its duty is not to secure convictions at all costs but to seek the truth. That means being willing to revisit cases, admit mistakes and put fairness before finality. Harvey Proctor is a former Conservative MP and the president of Facing Allegations in Contexts of Trust
Western Telegraph
15 hours ago
- Western Telegraph
St Davids man accused of dealing cocaine and cannabis
Rhys Copley, 31, of Noddfa Dewi in St Davids, appeared at Llanelli Magistrates' Court charged with six offences. Copley was alleged to have been in possession of 35.63 grams of cocaine and 391 grams of cannabis in St Davids on July 28 with the intent to supply them. He was also accused of possession of criminal property, relating to £815 in alleged criminal cash on that date. For the latest crime and court news for west Wales, you can join our Facebook group here. Copley was further charged with using threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour and racially aggravated harassment on July 28, and assault by beating following an alleged attack on another man the following day. The case came before the court on July 30 and was sent on to Swansea Crown Court. Copley will appear to enter his pleas on August 29, and was granted bail until that date.
Wales Online
15 hours ago
- Wales Online
She sent a text advertising what she was selling but there was one huge error
She sent a text advertising what she was selling but there was one huge error Rachel Butcher, 45, sent the message to the officer as part of a 'text bomb' including 76 customers Rachel Butcher, 45, unknowingly texted a police officer a message in which she offered to sell cocaine (Image: South Wales Police) A woman was found to be selling cocaine after she inadvertently texted a police officer advertising the drug for sale. She also included her nickname 'Red' in the text which officers were already aware of. Rachel Butcher, 45, of Cardiff, sent the message to the officer on March 10 last year in which she advertised the fact she was selling cocaine to customers. In the "bulk text" she intimated she was active as a dealer and was willing to deliver. A sentencing hearing at Cardiff Crown Court on Wednesday was told the defendant's phone was used to previously contact the police and the police contact had been included in a "text bomb" with 76 customers. For the latest court reports sign up to our crime newsletter. The phone was registered to Butcher's home address and a search warrant was executed at a property in Barry where several electronic items were seized including a Nokia phone. The Nokia phone was described as the Red drugs line which was active between May 5 and July 2, 2024. Between those dates bulk text messages were sent on a frequent basis in which she invited customers to purchase cocaine. Article continues below A second phone, Butcher's personal phone, also contained messages referencing the sale of crack cocaine. Following her arrest the defendant denied she was involved in the sale of cocaine. Butcher, of Malmesmead Road, Llanrumney, Cardiff, later pleaded guilty to being concerned in the supply of Class A drugs. The court heard she has 21 previous convictions, including several convictions for drug possession, but she has no previous convictions for drug trafficking. In mitigation Martha Smith-Higgins said her client had a difficult background and circumstances and described her vulnerability being exploited. The barrister said the defendant's life spiralled after her husband died from cancer in 2018 and she suffered further family trauma after she became addicted to Class A drugs, which she used as a coping mechanism. Article continues below Sentencing, Judge Lucy Crowther said: "Your life has been completely blighted by the use of drugs." Butcher was sentenced to 30 months imprisonment minus the days she has spent on remand on curfew.
