Why Coalition not sold on NDIS move
Health Minister Mark Butler said children with the moderate conditions would be shifted to a yet-to-be-designed Thriving Kids program, slated to begin mid-2027, as the government attempts to reign in unsustainable costs of the $46bn NDIS program.
While $2bn of funding has been earmarked for the program, Mr Butler's address on Wednesday was the first time states, territories and stakeholders had been told of the imminent changes.
Although the opposition has backed changes to make the scheme more sustainable, it says more information is needed. Coalition health spokeswoman Anne Ruston said families 'deserve better than the uncertainty that they're getting at the moment'. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia
'Yesterday, we saw another new program announced by the Health Minister … (but) we still don't know what's happening with foundational supports, which was an announcement about a change to the NDIS program last year,' Ms Ruston said.
'So we've got another announcement with no details and no certainty and no pathway through by which the minister has announced that he's actually going to deliver what he said.'
Senator Ruston said the uncertainty had created 'great distress' for families.
'So we're asking the minister to come out and provide that level of certainty because we can't be sure that these programs are right or otherwise unless we have that sort of detail,' she said.
'So we're calling on the government for more detail because these children deserve better than the uncertainty that they're getting at the moment.' Mark Butler's announcement on Wednesday to move children with mild autism and developmental delays off the NDIS was the first time states, territories and stakeholders had been told of the changes. NewsWire/ Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia
Sussan Ley said bipartisan support for reducing the growth of the NDIS wasn't a 'blank cheque for the government'.
'It's so important that these families don't feel left out on a limb,' the Opposition Leader said. said.
'Yes, there are changed arrangements but they need to have the confidence that works for them and their family, and they're not hearing that from the government.'
She said she understood concern from parents following Mr Butler's announcement on Wednesday.
'As we know, phase 1 of this approach hasn't worked very well, and we've now got another whole level of changes that families are being asked to come to terms with,' Ms Ley said.
'So Prime Minister, you need to get this right. You need to make sure these kids don't fall through the cracks.'
Mr Butler said children with moderate development delays and autism receiving NDIS support had ballooned beyond forecast figures, with children under 15 representing nearly half of people entering the scheme.
He said the Thriving Kids program would give families support that currently did not exist, leaving parents with 'no alternative' but the NDIS.
'As I said today, it's really been the only port in a storm for parents who are worried about their kid not hitting milestones. We should have an alternative system in place for those parents and for those kids, and that's what I committed to building today a system to support those children to thrive.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AU Financial Review
7 hours ago
- AU Financial Review
Mental health conditions could also face cuts under NDIS overhaul
Federal Labor's plan to reduce the cost of the NDIS by removing children with mild autism and developmental delays is also expected to strip away some participants with mental health conditions, including anxiety, depression and bipolar disorder, which add almost $6 billion a year in spending to the scheme. Former NDIS directors and executives said the second phase of Health Minister Mark Butler's proposal to cut the scheme's growth rate must tackle the significant number of participants with psychosocial disabilities; conditions the scheme was not intended to fund when it was set up.
The Age
7 hours ago
- The Age
No child should lose from changes to NDIS
To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@ Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published. HEALTH AND DISABILITY In looking at the issues surrounding the National Disability Insurance Scheme it is important not to lose sight of history and also to recognise how significant a reform it was when introduced. It has been swamped by pent-up demand and, in particular, demand for services for Autism Spectrum Disorders, accentuated by its private provider model, which has created a honeypot for dodgy providers. For much of my career when giving the diagnosis of a disability to parents, a significant part of the conversation had to be the warning that they would face a battle getting services, especially services which allowed integration into the mainstream. It was often a soul-destroying battle against a rigid Education Department and other bureaucracies, with arbitrary and unfair testing cut-offs for funding and great reluctance by mainstream schools to take children, as they knew full well that the Education Department would never provide enough, forcing them to share the resources one child may have obtained among three or four others. For children with 'mild to moderate' ASD and other conditions, the provision of adequate services is just as life transforming as for those with greater needs, not least because the ultimate goal of independence in the community is more easily attainable. Governments have profited for decades from the underfunding of such services. Any cuts to NDIS cannot be contemplated until there are robust and well-funded services for those excluded from NDIS. Dr Andrew Watkins, Olinda Not only the young at risk of losing NDIS I can understand Health and Disability Minister Mark Butler's concern about sustainability of the NDIS. The figures for autism and developmental problems particularly among young boys are alarming. (One out of every 10 six-year-olds are on the NDIS, including 16 per cent of six-year-old boys). In contrast, the percentage of beneficiaries who have a permanent acquired brain injury (ABI) is 3 per cent. I have a boy; he has an ABI which is the result of contracting meningitis two years ago. My boy is 66 and I am 95. He's been rejected for NDIS benefits because his 65th birthday was the arbitrary cut-off date on which a patient suddenly becomes ineligible and is packed off to a nursing home. My boy is physically healthy and eager to participate in the community – eg. voluntary work with the assistance of a private carer. Expensive stuff without NDIS finance and our resources are running low. His medical advisers think he would deteriorate in aged care. The Age gave me a half-page opinion piece space in March to write about our fears for my boy's future when I die. The ABC followed up my story and over 100 respondents all thought our family is not getting a fair go. There will probably be extensive debate about the autistic youngsters. Will the minister also remember people like my boy – those for whom the NDIS was designed? I believe there are other families like ours where older parents care for adult children and fear the future. I wish they would make their voices heard. Ros Collins, Elwood Divert private school subsidies to NDIS The federal government intends to contribute $2 billion into ″Thriving Kids″, a new program outside the NDIS aimed at supporting children with mild to moderate developmental delays and autism. Perhaps additional funds could also be diverted from federally overfunded 'private schools' to this program. Alternatively, these funds could be provided to fund government schools so they can provide the essential services that are presently not supplied to students with developmental issues. Haydn Moyle, Flemington THE FORUM Liberals don't factor State political editor Chip Le Grand overstates the problems in the Victorian Liberal Party and understates the depth of community feeling against Labor (″ For Victoria, Allan's bounce back is anything but healthy ″, 21/8). Anyone who is not a rusted-on Labor supporter pays little or no heed to the Liberals' internal problems. They only care about how the state is governed and by whom, not the back room machinations of the opposition. Most of them probably couldn't even name the Liberals' leader, but they certainly know who the premier is. She is deeply unpopular, and one poll taken immediately after the release of the populist work from home policy will not change that. Brad Battin has 12 months in the job to remind voters of the flaws of a government that passed its use-by date long ago. Greg Hardy, Upper Ferntree Gully State freefall Working from home is fuelling the 32 per cent primary support for the state Labor Party. Victorians should put aside selfish interests for the good of our state. This incompetent mob in just over 10 years has managed to bring this once vibrant and proud state to its knees. Businesses are going belly up, the crime rate is out of control, huge debt, CFMEU and childcare debacles, and to top it all off, we have become the protest capital of Australia. I know the average Victorian is fairminded and will make the right decision at the next election to stop this freefall. Steve Naumovski, Southbank Don't mention cladding If Merrick Morley (Comment, 21/8) thinks that dealing with maintenance issues in an apartment building is stressful, maybe he should try living in a 19th-century weatherboard built on clay. Along with the usual on-going issues with cracking plaster, sagging stumps and badly fitting windows, he would also have to invest in thermal underwear and extra thick woolly jumpers to see him through the winter while continuing to pay massive energy bills. He would be living alongside neighbours who might or might not be delightful, and his options for dealing with difficult neighbours would be very limited. Having downsized from such a weatherboard to a modern apartment building, I can confirm that maintenance issues, bills, and neighbourly differences of opinion do not go away. But there are ways of raising issues and ways of dealing with them that are not available to the average house owner. There are plenty of horror stories about apartments. Just mention the word ″cladding″. The solutions must include better building standards, architectural designs that bring people together as well as providing privacy and quiet for each apartment, and public discussion of what works and what doesn't. And, a decent range of apartment sizes and a substantial inclusion of social housing in every building. For my partner and I, downsizing has been partly a pre-emptive strike against the possibility of having to go into aged care some time in the future – and so far, we are very happy with our decision. Caroline Williamson, Brunswick
West Australian
7 hours ago
- West Australian
Aussies sending goods to the US to be hit by a tariff rule this month
Australians, e-retailers and businesses exporting items to the US are about to be hit with a new tariff after the Trump administration overturned an exemption on imports valued less than $US800. Australia Post warned on its website that US President Donald Trump's import tariff changes take effect from August 29 and will affect Australians sending items to the States. 'We are actively monitoring for any developments and will continue to provide timely updates as more information becomes available,' the Australia Post notice read. NewsWire understands the new tariff needs to be collected from the country of origin and Australia Post is working to find a solution. An Australia Post spokesman said they were focused on providing a reliable and competitive postal service for customers sending parcels internationally. 'The United States government recently announced significant changes to its import tariff rules that will impact customers sending items from Australia to the US,' a spokesman said. 'Our priority is to keep our customers updated on the changes and what they mean for them.' Items sent to the USA worth less than $US800 have been free from paying any tariffs, but last month President Trump signed an executive order to suspend the duty-free 'de minimus' tariff exemption for low-value shipments from all countries. The change is expected to impact e-retailers around the globe and has already seen some countries suspend shipments to the United States. The order empowers Homeland Security to close a loophole which was used to avoid tariffs and exploited by organised criminals to smuggle drugs into the United States. A Homeland Security spokesman said under the de minimus exemption, countries exploited the system to flood the American market with cheap goods (such as e-commerce retailers Temu and Shein) that undercut American manufacturers and cost jobs. 'Over the past decade the volume of de minimus shipments to the United States exploded, growing from 134 million shipments in 2015 to over 1.36 billion shipments in 2024,' a statement read. 'De minimus shipments accounted for 90 per cent of all cargo seizures in FY 24.' Some European postal services have already paused shipments to the USA following the new tariff rules. Sweden's PostNord said in a statement that the de minimus rule change would considerably impact international postal services and e-retailers. The company halted shipments to the United States and Puerto Rico until a compliant solution was developed and implemented. Australia Post has been contacted for comment.
