EPA drafts rule to strike down landmark climate finding
The 'endangerment finding,' which determined that greenhouse gas emissions endanger public health and welfare, provides the legal justification for regulating them under the Clean Air Act.
In March, EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said the agency would reconsider the finding, among dozens of potential environmental rollbacks announced on what he called 'the most consequential day of deregulation in American history.' Zeldin has previously said he aims to strike a balance between economic concerns and protecting the environment.
'After 16 years, EPA will formally reconsider the Endangerment Finding,' Zeldin said in a statement at the time. 'The Trump Administration will not sacrifice national prosperity, energy security, and the freedom of our people for an agenda that throttles our industries, our mobility, and our consumer choice while benefiting adversaries overseas.'
A decision to completely rescind the endangerment finding is still a draft proposal and could be subject to change, according to the two individuals. The draft would also eliminate all resulting limits on motor vehicle greenhouse gas emissions, according to one of them, with the second person describing this outcome as likely.
A government website lists the title of a document under review with the Office of Management and Budget called 'Greenhouse Gas Endangerment Finding and Motor Vehicle Reconsideration Rule,' but it gives no details on the proposal, which still must be released for public comment before it is finalized.
David Doniger, a senior attorney at the Natural Resources Defense Council, an advocacy group, said the proposed repeal of the endangerment finding is not justified under the law.
'They're trying to completely defang the Clean Air Act by saying, 'Well, this stuff's just not dangerous,'' Doniger said. 'That claim is just mind-bogglingly contrary to the evidence.'
Thomas Pyle, president of the Institute for Energy Research, a conservative think tank, said he fully supports the administration's efforts to review the endangerment finding, saying that Congress never mandated the EPA to take action on the issue and that the agency instead relied on a single ambiguous Supreme Court case.
'It's long since past the time for an administration to review this,' Pyle said. 'Ultimately Congress should have a say when it's all said and done.'
The draft rule largely avoids making scientific arguments about climate change and instead focuses on making legal arguments saying that the agency does not have the basis to act on climate change under a certain section of the Clean Air Act, the two people familiar with the matter said.
Zeldin's EPA has said that the Biden administration did not properly consider all the policy implications. The finding has allowed for seven regulations on vehicle emissions with a cost of more than $1 trillion, according to the EPA.
Richard Revesz, a law professor at New York University and former Biden administration official, said that repealing the endangerment finding is unlikely to hold up in court but that the move will still affect U.S. climate policy until a final judicial decision is made.
'If the endangerment finding fell, it would call into question essentially all or almost all of EPA's regulation of greenhouse gases,' Revesz said.
The endangerment finding was written in response to a 2007 Supreme Court decision saying that greenhouse gases are an air pollutant, essentially requiring the EPA to regulate them, according to legal experts.
The endangerment finding had been updated and expanded since 2009, effectively serving as the government's understanding of the latest climate science, said Joseph Goffman, who headed the EPA's air office under President Joe Biden.
'Withdrawing the endangerment finding is in effect a repudiation of scientific reality,' Goffman said.
Doniger and other people familiar with the matter said that the Trump administration official Jeffrey Clark, acting administrator in the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, is the primary architect of the proposed repeal of the endangerment finding.
'Since 2009, I've consistently argued that the endangerment finding required a consideration of downstream costs imposed on both mobile sources like cars and stationary sources like factories,' Clark said in the March statement released by the EPA. 'Under the enlightened leadership of President Trump and Administrator Zeldin, the time for fresh thought has finally arrived.'
As a career attorney in the Justice Department during the George W. Bush administration, Clark worked on the case that eventually resulted in the 2007 Supreme Court decision that prompted the EPA to write the endangerment finding.
'He's trying to get revenge,' Doniger said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
GOP Senator Roasted Over This 'Idiot' Take On Manhattan Mass Shooting
Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) joined Fox News on Monday to dismiss legislation aimed at preventing gun violence just hours after a gunman killed four people in an office building in New York City's Midtown Manhattan neighborhood. Kennedy told Fox News' Sean Hannity that 'all you can do in a time like this is be sorry' for the victims of the mass shooting before predicting that some of his colleagues will call for more gun control laws on Tuesday morning. 'We've got hundreds of gun control laws, Sean. Maybe thousands,' he said. He later added, 'We don't need more gun control, we need more idiot control. And I don't know exactly how to do that but I do know this — I don't want to hear anyone feeling sorry for this guy who did this.' Elsewhere in the interview, Kennedy entertained the return of a 'more aggressive' version of the controversial 'stop-and-frisk' policing strategy in New York City, one that was found unconstitutional in 2013 as evidence showed it was used to frequently target Black and Hispanic people. Kennedy has been a gun control opponent and has received a 92% rating or higher from the National Rifle Association since his first successful Senate campaign in 2016, according to the nonprofit Vote Smart. Kennedy has resorted to his 'idiot control' line in response to several instances of gun violence over the years including the Apalachee High School shooting in 2024, the Boulder supermarket shooting in 2021 and the Parkland school shooting in 2018. Monday's slaughter in Midtown Manhattan joins the over 250 mass shootings in the U.S. in 2025, according to the Gun Violence Archive. There have been 8,590 deaths due to gun violence in the U.S. so far this year and 15,704 injuries. The motive of the gunman, who killed himself, remains unclear, officials said. Critics on social media clowned the senator over his call to action. Related... Gunman Opens Fire In Manhattan Office Building, Killing 4 Trump Caps His Scottish Visit By Opening A New Golf Course 'Yikes': Critics Claim Trump Let Out Epic 'Freudian Slip' About Jeffrey Epstein

Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Shelby Lambdin appointed to four-month stint on Spokane City Council
Jul. 28—Shelby Lambdin was appointed to a four-month stint on the Spokane City Council Monday, filling a seat representing south Spokane vacated by former Councilwoman Lili Navarrete, who was herself appointed to the seat in early 2024 and resigned effective July 1 citing health concerns. Lambdin is the population health director at the Community Health Association of Spokane, more commonly known as CHAS Health. She was appointed with a 4-2 vote; Councilmen Jonathan Bingle and Michael Cathcart opposed her appointment. Though voters will have an opportunity in November to choose a successor for a full four-year term — Kate Telis and Alejandro Barrientos are currently vying for the seat — the City Council is responsible for appointing a temporary replacement when a seat is vacated early. Bingle and Cathcart had advocated to appoint Ryan Oelrich, who served on the City Council during a roughly two-month stint in 2023, arguing that the experience would make it easier for Oelrich to hit the ground running as the council prepares to balance the city's budget in the coming months. Ahead of the vote, Councilman Paul Dillon thanked the applicants for the position but said he and Council President Betsy Wilkerson had wanted to bring on a new voice to the council. Lambdin has no political, elected or government experience. During her public interview, Lambdin argued her experience in public health would bring expertise to the council on addressing relevant issues. She advocated for reducing the city's costs by using technology and artificial intelligence to replace personnel and streamline operations. Lambdin also argued in favor of programs to make the city's outdoor recreation more accessible to marginalized communities and for advancing the council's work on making various services available in other languages. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
44 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Viral video showing Trump in Scotland leads to golf cheating accusations
Longstanding accusations of President Donald Trump cheating at golf have resurfaced after a video of him in Scotland over the weekend went viral. Trump golfed with his son Eric Trump and others at the Trump Turnberry resort, according to a pool report. Video footage of Trump on a golf course posted on X July 27 by left-leaning account PatriotTakes has gone viral on social media, with people claiming it shows Trump cheating at golf. (Trump posted his own sizzle reel of his golf swings on his social media platform Truth Social earlier in the weekend.) In the video, Trump pulls his golf cart to a stop in the rough before a sand trap. His caddie, walking ahead of him, appears to drop a golf ball in the grass beside him. Trump approaches the ball, but the video cuts off before Trump hits it. USA TODAY could not immediately verify the time or origin of the video and there is no context or video showing where Trump actually hit his previous shot. The post by PatriotTakes has garnered 4.5 million views on X as of July 28 midday. Trump has long boasted of his golf game and claimed victory in several golf tournaments against seemingly impossible odds. This video is not the first time he has been accused of outright cheating in the sport. More: Trump celebrates golf tournament win and Chelsea FIFA Club World Cup win on same day Trump has been accused of cheating in the past This is not the first time the president has been accused of cheating at golf. In fact, sportswriter Rick Reilly wrote a whole book about it in 2019: "Commander in Cheat: How Golf Explains Trump." "Trump doesn't just cheat at golf," Reilly wrote. "He throws it, boots it, and moves it. He lies about his lies. He fudges and foozles and fluffs. At Winged Foot, where Trump is a member, the caddies got so used to seeing him kick his ball back onto the fairway they came up with a nickname for him: 'Pele.'' Another Winged Foot member who played with Trump said that Trump would cheat because he thought he was being cheated by other players, too, according to an excerpt from the book as reported by For the Win. Trump often boasts about his golf tournament victories, even when his win seems impossible. He once said he won a club championship when he didn't play the first round. In another instance, he said he won an event with a score lower than many LIV golf pros. In response to USA TODAY's inquiry about the video, White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers pointed to the recent trade deal with the EU and the ceasefire in Thailand and Cambodia. "Instead of covering the news that matters to everyday Americans, the legacy media is peddling a false narrative about the President's legendary golf game," Rogers said in an emailed statement. Why did Donald Trump travel to Scotland? Trump discussed trade with EU and UK leaders on his trip to Scotland as the Aug. 1 deadline approaches for reciprocal tariffs, which were delayed for the second time in early July. On July 27, Trump announced the U.S. had reached a trade deal with the European Union: most goods would be tariffed at 15%, lower than the 30% Trump had previously threatened but higher than the 10% Europeans had hoped for. The Trump Organization also owns two golf courses in Scotland: Trump Turnberry and Trump International Scotland. The Trump International Scotland resort is poised to open a second golf course next month. The resort includes buildings bearing the name of Trump's mother, Mary Anne MacLeod, who emigrated from Scotland to New York in the 1930s. This trip precludes a more elaborate formal state visit in the fall. (This story has been updated with a response from the White House.) Contributing: Tom D'Angelo, Zac Anderson, Savannah Kuchar, Bart Jansen, Medora Lee, USA TODAY Network Kinsey Crowley is the Trump Connect reporter for the USA TODAY Network. Reach her at kcrowley@ Follow her on X and TikTok @kinseycrowley or Bluesky at @ This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Trump cheating at golf? Video, accusations go viral on Scotland trip