logo
Wearables take center stage in RFK Jr.'s personal health push

Wearables take center stage in RFK Jr.'s personal health push

Axios03-07-2025
Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. envisions Americans becoming healthier by using wearable health devices that track heart rates, blood sugar and other vitals — offering real-time feedback on how food affects their bodies.
Why it matters: It's a buzzy component of a health care agenda that emphasizes self-empowerment — and self-responsibility — over relying on clinicians.
But some doctors and ethicists say the push could backfire if the devices spit out faulty data or jeopardize the safety of sensitive, personal health data.
Driving the news: Kennedy said he'd like to see every American using wearables within the next four years, while testifying before the House in late June.
He later clarified in a statement to Axios that "they are not for everyone because of concerns like cost and personal privacy."
Last month, Health and Human Services solicited applications for contractors to design a multimillion-dollar marketing campaign that will include"populariz[ing] technology like wearables as cool, modern tools for measuring diet impact and taking control of your health."
The campaign won't be about wearables specifically, Kennedy later told Axios. Rather, HHS is looking for something focused on "inspiring Americans to stop eating ultra-processed foods and reclaim control of their health," he said.
"This campaign will empower Americans to take personal responsibility for their health, including choosing what tools are right for them," he added.
Zoom out: "Wearables" refer to a wide range of electronics that people wear on their bodies to monitor health metrics — or even aid in diagnosis.
Food and Drug Administration-approved wearable medical devices are becoming increasingly common in patient care and provide valuable clinical data for both individual treatment and public health, says Andrew Brightman, a professor of engineering practice at Purdue University who researches biomedical ethics.
The wearables umbrella also includes consumer products, like Oura Rings or Fitbits, that track health metrics but in most uses don't require government approval for safety and effectiveness.
Between the lines: "Providing individuals with reliable, accurate, useful medical information is critically important to support health and well-being," Brightman says.
"But the contrary is providing people with unreliable, inaccurate and confusing information, no matter how digitized or quantified or how sexy the tech looks to people and is fun to use," he says. "It can lead them to make poor choices about their health."
For example, a tracker might conclude someone is in good health because they're getting plenty of sleep and exercising. That could give the user a false sense of security and lead them to delay a visit to the doctor.
Supporting wearables is a good strategy to promote health and well-being — if it also comes with more resources and funding to bolster government oversight and regulation of the devices in the market, Brightman says.
Expanding the use of wearables also increases health data risks.
The main federal health privacy law, HIPAA, protects health data when it's used by a covered entity, like a provider or insurer. But when a consumer enters data into a health app or allows a wearable to track health metrics, their data isn't subject to HIPAA, says Lisa Pierce Reisz, a partner at law firm Epstein Becker Green.
Companies have to honor the privacy policies they've created, but terms and conditions aren't standardized and can change — and few people stop to read those policies before allowing their data to be collected anyway.
"We lose a lot of control of our data once we input it," Reisz says. "People think, 'Oh, it's just my steps,' or 'It's just my heart rate,' but it potentially is so much more when you look at location information, or if you start to add details about menstrual periods."
That's sensitive information that, if leaked or exposed, could endanger people's safety or be used against them.
The growing threat of cyberattacks also complicates the picture.
Hackers could break into wearable device companies' systems and access troves of people's personal health data.
"I am fully aware of the dangers mass data collection poses to personal freedoms, and I do not advise anyone to purchase a wearable that does not provide ironclad privacy protections," Kennedy said in his statement to Axios.
What we're watching: Not everyone in Kennedy's core "Make America Healthy Again" base is on board with wearables, and some prominent supporters of his agenda are sounding the alarm about the data risks of the devices, The Bulwark reported.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Leading pediatrician group recommends COVID vaccine for infants, toddlers in contrast with RFK Jr.

time3 hours ago

Leading pediatrician group recommends COVID vaccine for infants, toddlers in contrast with RFK Jr.

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) said on Tuesday that children ages 6 months to 23 months should receive a COVID-19 vaccine, in contrast with federal health officials. The recommendations are part of the AAP's annual childhood immunization schedule, which includes guidance for COVID, flu and RSV vaccines for those aged 18 and younger. The AAP has been releasing its own recommendations since the 1930s, but in a rare occurrence, the recommendations differ from those put out by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The group also recommended Americans age 18 and under receive a COVID vaccine if they are at high risk of severe COVID, live in a long-term care facility or congregate setting, if they have never been vaccinated against COVID or if they live with someone at high risk for severe COVID. It comes after Health and Human Services secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced in late May that the CDC would no longer recommend the COVID vaccine for healthy children. The CDC, which is under Kennedy's purview, later updated the guidance to a " shared clinical decision making" model -- leaving the decision to vaccinate children to parents alongside advice from a doctor. The prior recommendations were that everyone aged 6 months and older get vaccinated against COVID with the most up-to-date shot. The contrasting vaccine recommendations highlight the growing rift between federal health officials and medical organizations on vaccine policy. "The academy has been making pediatric immunization recommendations since the 1930s, that has not changed," Dr. Susan J. Kressly, president of the AAP, told ABC News. "But what has changed is that this year, we're doing it in the environment of misinformation, which makes it more important than ever that we provide clear and confident guidance, because the majority of American families really depend on us for this guidance." Children between 6 months old and 23 months old are at the highest risk of severe COVID-19, and the vaccine can protect against serious illness, according to the AAP. "We know that this age group, that's the highest risk for severe disease," Kressly said. "And so we want to make sure that those children who are at highest risk and did not live through the pandemic -- they were not exposed to COVID viruses during the pandemic -- we want to make sure that they are protected as best as possible." Although medical organizations may differ in their vaccine recommendations, insurers often rely on the CDC's vaccine panel, known as the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), recommendations to determine what they will and won't cover. If certain vaccines aren't recommended by the ACIP, it may lead to parents or guardians facing out-of-pocket costs if their children receive the shot. It could also mean the shots aren't covered by the Vaccines for Children (VFC) program, a federally funded program that provides no-cost vaccines to eligible children. "We need to work with our like-minded policy makers who understand the importance of keeping VFC vaccines available in every community for those children who depend on them," Kressly said. "At the same time, there are children in this country whose vaccines are paid for through commercial insurance, and we are having continuing conversations with major payers to make sure that those can be vaccines are available as well. Vaccination is part of high-quality preventive care, and we are confident that we can work with the payers to make sure that translated into policy."

What we know about Keely Farms Dairy in NSB, accused of selling raw milk, sickening 21
What we know about Keely Farms Dairy in NSB, accused of selling raw milk, sickening 21

USA Today

time6 hours ago

  • USA Today

What we know about Keely Farms Dairy in NSB, accused of selling raw milk, sickening 21

While the Florida Department of Health cited Keely Farms Dairy in New Smyrna Beach as the source of raw milk that sickened 21 people, supporters have taken to social media to comment on their own experience with the family business. Keely Farms also wrote on Facebook Aug. 7 that it hadn't heard from the Department of Health and had no idea it was even being investigated. "We were not contacted by the Department of Health prior to or regarding their statement this morning," the post said. "The Florida Department of Health has not informed Keely Farms of any investigation or administrative action. The Department of Health has not indicated to Keely Farms that it committed any wrongdoing, so its press release has blindsided us." The dairy's owners deny being notified of any safety issues by the state health department, and posted on Facebook Aug. 4 that "The ag inspector visited last month. We passed, as always." The farm did not respond to phone and email messages from The News-Journal. What is Keely Farms Dairy? Raw, or unpasteurized, milk consumption is nothing new, and is usually popular among those wanting less processed foods in their diet. But on Aug. 4, the Department of Health said nearly two dozen people, including six children, became sick from Campylobacter and Shiga toxin-producing E. coli after consuming unpasteurized milk produced by Keely Farms Dairy. The reported cases date back to January. Here's what we know about Keely Farms. Keely Farms Dairy is a small, family business located on about 100 acres on South Glencoe Road in New Smyrna Beach. It is owned and operated by Keely Exum and her husband; the couple has several young children. On its website, Keely Farms Dairy says it believes in "responsible, sustainable farming," and grows much of its own feed locally for its heritage-sized Jersey cows. Its raw milk is priced at $12 a gallon, while the farm also offers Greek yogurt, kefir and feta cheese. The dairy farm sells and delivers its products to Brevard, Lake, Volusia, and Seminole counties and most of the greater Orlando area; some southeast Florida stores carry Keely Farms products. What food safety practices does Keely Farms Dairy use? In Florida, selling raw milk for human consumption is illegal. However, raw milk can be sold legally as pet food or animal feed. Dairy farms selling raw milk must register with the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, according to the FDACS website. On the Keely Farms Dairy website, the owners state: "Our raw milk is milked and then processed in a clean environment with American-made, stainless-steel, grade-A quality equipment. We use in-line filters during milking to be sure no dirt gets into our milk. We chill the milk immediately after it leaves the cow. We test our cows frequently. We test at our dairy lab to assess milk quality." Keely Farms also raises questions about customers' own use of the raw milk produced at the farm, noting the following on Facebook: "Raw milk is sold in Florida 'not for human consumption.' It is clearly stated on our labels as required by law. Due to legal requirements, in spite of the quality of the equipment used for processing and cleanliness of the facility, this milk is sold only as pet or livestock food." Is raw milk safe? Florida dairy farm identified as source of raw milk E. coli outbreak. Why is the FDOH concerned with Keely Farms Dairy's practices? In its statement this week, the Department of Health said: 'Sanitation practices in this farm are of concern due to the number of cases," adding, 'The Florida Department of Health will continue working with Keely Farms Dairy to ensure that effective sanitation practices are implemented consistently across every batch.' The FDOH has not responded to The News-Journal's requests for comment. Customers speak out about Keely Farms Dairy on Facebook Hundreds of comments left on the Keely Farms Dairy Facebook page — many from customers — take a more skeptical response to the health department's findings. From Yeshua Logos: "Cleanest wonderful milk and all dairy products; we've visited the farm several times and have purchased multiple products. ... Lord Jesus bring truth to light expand this wonderful honest superb business." Brit Richards posted: "Question: Did Keely Farms Dairy know about about any of the cases of sickness? I'm wondering if the farm was made aware by any of the customers?" "We've been customers for 10 years, I believe now," wrote Matt-Abby Riba. "Wouldn't change a thing and refuse to purchase from commercial industry. So thankful for the Keelys! From Barry McCarty: "I love Keely Farms Dairy! I have been to the farm plenty of times, I have watched them milk they sanitize every cow before milking super clean, and I've been inside of their bulk tank room which is spotless. What you see on the outside is a farm and there's dirt, but everything on the inside is tested and shipped. I grew up on a farm and have been drinking raw milk my whole entire life. I think they're doing a great job!" Others, like Bridget Manard, were not as positive: "You shouldn't be selling raw milk anyway. Go pasteurize it. You may have done some real damage to someone." From Amanda Luciano: "I was buying off of your farm for many years until recently your milk started to get our family sick as well. Once we stopped purchasing from you and started getting off another farm the random 'food poisoning' symptoms stopped. I don't believe this farm is being targeted; I genuinely believe they may be having a hard time keeping up with their demand and slacking on their hygiene in result to keep up with orders." Posted by Starla Black: "If it was in fact your milk — I see too many people re-selling it. When that is done, quality control goes out the window. There is no way to guarantee it was kept cold or that it's fresh."

Florida surgeon general says raw milk has health benefits. Experts say he's wrong
Florida surgeon general says raw milk has health benefits. Experts say he's wrong

USA Today

time6 hours ago

  • USA Today

Florida surgeon general says raw milk has health benefits. Experts say he's wrong

Florida law says it's illegal to sell raw milk for human consumption, but that's not stopping some of the state's top officials from supporting residents who want to drink it. Some have even made a complete 180, from promoting pasteurized milk to promoting consumer freedom within days. In an Aug. 12 post on X, Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo said Floridians "have the freedom to make informed health choices." Floridians have the freedom to make informed health choices. I support the decision to consume raw milk when sought for potential health benefits and protective factors. Be aware of your source and know the "I support the decision to consume raw milk when sought for potential health benefits and protective factors. Be aware of your source and know the risks," Ladapo wrote. Illness from raw milk can cause diarrhea, stomach cramping and vomiting, and severe complications can lead to paralysis, kidney failure, stroke, or even death, federal authorities say. Interest in raw milk has been growing in recent years. In June 2024, U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said he "only drinks raw milk." Raw milk doesn't cure ailments, experts say Raw milk devotees say it tastes better and is healthier, but according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, the American Medical Association, and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control, raw milk does not contain any extra beneficial bacteria and will not cure or treat asthma, allergies or lactose intolerance. Florida Agriculture Commissioner Wilton Simpson agreed with Ladapo in a statement given to the USA TODAY NETWORK – Florida on Aug. 12: 'State Surgeon General Ladapo and I share the same position on raw milk. People should make informed decisions." To be sure, it's a reversal to what his agency was saying a week ago. In a press release on Aug. 6, the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services encouraged Floridians to drink "only" pasteurized milk. "Florida Commissioner of Agriculture Wilton Simpson and the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (FDACS) are encouraging Floridians to protect their health by only consuming pasteurized milk products," the press release says. 'Florida's pasteurized milk supply is safe, nutritious, and closely controlled from the farm to your local grocery store,' Simpson said in the release. 'There have been no reported illnesses from pasteurized milk products in Florida, so Floridians should continue to buy and enjoy nutritious and wholesome dairy products from Florida farmers.' As previously reported earlier this month, 21 people got sick and seven were hospitalized for bacterial infections, including E. coli, from drinking raw milk from Keely Farms Dairy in New Smyrna Beach. Raw milk: OK as pet food in Florida Raw milk can be sold as pet food in Florida, but it must be clearly labeled "not for human consumption." the Keely Farms' webpage did not mention pets. Six of the infected people were children under age 10, the Florida Department of Health said. The cases were all in Central and Northeast Florida. According to the CDC, improperly handled raw milk is responsible for nearly three times more hospitalizations than any other food-borne disease source. And so far in 2025, there have been seven recalls or outbreaks from raw milk in the United States. More from the Palm Beach Post: Opinion | Floridians can make America healthy again by not drinking raw milk Ana Goñi-Lessan, state watchdog reporter for the USA TODAY Network – Florida, can be reached at agonilessan@

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store