Five quick takeaways from Nicola Sturgeon's new memoir
Ms Sturgeon writes that while she is 'ultra-liberal on matters of sex and relationships', she was 'furious on behalf of Shona [Robison]', Hosie's wife and one of her closest friends. Ms Robison, then Health Secretary, was 'humiliated' and spent much of the day tearfully in Ms Sturgeon's office.
'I did not speak to Stewart for days, even though he was my deputy.'
The drama reignited memories of a 2007 controversy involving Mr MacNeil and two teenage girls and, according to Ms Sturgeon, showed the dangers of political loyalty blinding judgment.
David Mundell's mother feared Sturgeon 'might eat him alive'
When she was Deputy First Minister, Ms Sturgeon met David Mundell, then a UK Government Scotland Office minister, ahead of the independence referendum.
During their meeting, Mr Mundell's mobile phone rang — it was his mother, calling to check he was okay. He explained she had been worried Sturgeon 'might eat him alive'.
Ms Sturgeon writes that the moment made her realise 'my reputation exceeded my self-confidence by a considerable margin'. The meeting, she says, was constructive, and she left confident an agreement could be reached, though not 'on any terms'.
Boris Johnson asked if fiscal autonomy would 'buy off' SNP
Nicola Sturgeon has revealed Boris Johnson once asked her whether granting Scotland full fiscal autonomy would be enough to 'buy off' the SNP.
In a conversation in May 2015, after a VE Day service at Westminster Abbey, Mr Johnson — then still Mayor of London but newly returned to the Commons — walked with her to a post-service reception as crowds shouted 'Boris' and 'Nicola'.
Part of their chat 'stuck with me so strongly', Ms Sturgeon writes, that she recalls it 'almost verbatim'. Mr Johnson asked: 'What would it take to buy you lot in the SNP off? Would full fiscal autonomy shut you up?'
Ms Sturgeon says she told him that, on the right terms, fiscal autonomy 'would certainly be welcome' and 'a step in the right direction' — but would not 'buy us off' because 'we believed in independence'.
She adds: 'I could sense him struggling to process this strange notion of politicians who actually believed in something.'
Former first minister wants to write fiction and live abroad — briefly
After attending multiple book festivals and writing her memoir, Nicola Sturgeon says she wants to pursue a career as a writer, possibly moving beyond factual and political work.
In the final pages of her book, she writes: 'I want to write more, maybe even fiction.'
She also claims she is 'determined to see the world', adding: 'I might live outside of Scotland for a period. A perspective shift would be good for me.'
However, she says she cannot imagine staying away for 'very long' as 'Scotland is where I belong'.
Corbyn's 'sneering superiority' rubbed her the wrong way
Nicola Sturgeon has previously spoken about her dislike for former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn.
In her memoir, she appears to go further. About Mr Corbyn, she writes: 'He exuded the same aura of aloofness and sneering superiority that I have detected in many men on the far left over the years, particularly around women.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
17 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Scottish Greens must broaden appeal beyond middle-class urbanites, says leadership candidate
The Scottish Greens have to broaden their appeal beyond middle-class urbanites by talking to voters in industrial towns facing wholesale job losses, a Green leadership candidate has said. Gillian Mackay is one of four Scottish Greens bidding to win two co-leader posts after Patrick Harvie, the UK's longest-serving party leader, quit as co-convener earlier this year. The pro-independence Scottish Greens are currently Holyrood's fourth largest party, with seven MSPs, and could play a key role in the devolved parliament after next year's elections. The Greens prop up the Scottish National party government in Edinburgh, which does not have a majority at Holyrood and is expected to form a minority administration again next year. Recent polls place the Greens as high as 15%, suggesting they could win several more seats. Mackay said her area around Falkirk had been devastated by industrial decline, including the closure of Grangemouth oil refinery earlier this year, yet the Scottish Greens historically had failed to connect with local voters. The Scottish and UK governments knew Grangemouth would close, affecting several thousand jobs in the region, but had failed to put in place an industrial strategy to guarantee green jobs, she said. Two factories owned by Alexander Dennis making electric buses were also expected to close within weeks and their jobs to shift to Nottinghamshire. Farmers and workers dependent on the oil industry around Aberdeen also felt excluded. That meant the just transition from fossil fuel industries to sustainable jobs had failed, Mackay said. 'The Green narrative of green jobs and green industry actually needs to have teeth,' she said. The party was very good at the 'high-level' policy but poor at making it meaningful to people directly affected. 'What matters to our voters is what they see, feel and hear in their communities and I don't think we're quite cutting through at that level.' Voting for the two co-convener posts opened on Wednesday, with about 7,500 party members eligible to vote before a result is declared on Friday 29 August. Alongside Mackay, the candidates are Lorna Slater, Harvie's current co-convener, who had a torrid time as a Scottish government minister in the Greens' power-sharing deal with the SNP, Ross Greer, a backbencher, and Dominic Ashmole, a party activist in the Scottish Borders who is vying to become a councillor for the first time. Unlike Green party elections in England and Wales, Scottish rules make it harder for two candidates to run on joint tickets, because their names cannot appear on the ballot paper as joint candidates. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion And for the first time, the Scottish Greens have also dropped a rule that requires the party to elect at least one woman as co-leader, after legal advice partly influenced by the UK supreme court ruling on the Equality Act's definition of a woman. Greer, who has called for free travel on all of Scotland's buses, is widely seen as a favourite to win one of the two posts. With Ashmole considered a rank outsider, the contest for the second post is between Slater and Mackay. Given her almost three years as a junior minister, Slater is presenting herself as the most experienced continuity candidate, who has told party members she believes co-conveners are their delegates and are not in overall control. Her critics point to the intense controversy surrounding her failed bid to introduce a wide-ranging deposit return scheme for drinks containers in Scotland before the rest of the UK. Greer, an architect of the Bute House power-sharing agreement with the SNP, believes the party needs stronger political leadership and has to be much clearer on its core policies, on poverty, climate and nature. 'We need to nail down which voters we're trying to speak to and what we're trying to achieve,' he said.
Telegraph
17 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Scots receive a record £2,669 more public spending each than UK average
Scots receive nearly £2,700 more public spending each than the UK average, according to official figures revealing that the gap has widened to record levels. A major report, published by SNP ministers, showed total spending by the UK and Scottish Governments equated to £21,192 per person in Scotland in the 2024/25 financial year. This compared with an average £18,523 of public spending per person across the UK as a whole – £2,669 lower than the figure for Scotland. The cross-border spending gap was by far the largest on record, £2,311 up on the previous year and having nearly doubled over the previous decade. The Scottish Government's annual Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland report also found public spending accounted for a record 52 per cent of the country's GDP, compared with 44.4 per cent of the UK as a whole. This was more than five points higher than before the pandemic. And Scotland's deficit – the difference between total revenue and expenditure – has surged to 11.7 per cent of GDP. This was more than double the UK figure of 5.1 per cent and higher than anywhere else in Europe. The report was published after SNP ministers recently confirmed they backed full fiscal autonomy, with Scotland getting control over all taxes and the abolition of the Barnett formula that provides the higher spending from Westminster. But Ian Murray, the UK Government's Scottish Secretary, said that would mean a funding gap of more than £14bn, resulting in 'turbo-charged austerity and economic chaos for Scotland'. He said: 'These figures underline the collective economic strength of the United Kingdom and how Scotland benefits from the redistribution of wealth inside the UK. 'By sharing resources with each other across the UK, Scots benefit by £2,669 more per head in public spending than the UK average. It also means that devolved governments have the financial heft of the wider UK behind them when taking decisions.' Mr Murray added that Scots want to see 'better outcomes' from the extra money the SNP has to spend on schools, hospitals and policing. Craig Hoy, the Scottish Tories' shadow finance secretary, said: 'The SNP Government's own figures highlight the huge, and rising, Union dividend that Scots enjoy thanks to being in a strong United Kingdom. 'Every single person in the country is almost £2,600 better off because we are part of the UK. If we lost that – as we would if the SNP achieved their goal of Scottish independence – it would have a catastrophic impact on the nation's finances.' He said the figures also demonstrated the 'economic lunacy' of Sir Keir Starmer's opposition to allowing new exploration licences to be issued for the North Sea. Oil and gas revenues in Scotland's geographic share of the UK's waters fell by £800m last year to £4.1bn. The Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland report is produced by Scottish Government economists and calculates public spending on devolved services, such as health and education, by SNP ministers and local authorities. Scotland is also allocated a population share of spending by the UK Government on reserved policy areas such as defence and debt interest. The report said the main reason for Scotland's deficit increasing from 9.7 per cent to 11.7 per cent was 'Scottish revenue growing more slowly and Scottish expenditure growing more quickly than the UK'. Oil and gas raise tax revenue total Public spending in Scotland rose by £6.2bn to £117.6bn last year, the report said, with the cost of benefits rising more quickly than across the UK. This was partly thanks to the Scottish Government's more generous welfare system. Tax revenues north of the border totalled nearly £91.4bn, £91 per person higher than the UK average. However, they were £578 per person lower when oil and gas were excluded. Scotland's 11. per cent notional deficit amounted to £26.5bn, a rise of more than £5bn compared to the previous year. The next highest deficits in the EU were recorded in Romania (9.3 per cent of GDP), Poland (6.6 per cent) and France (5.8 per cent). Shona Robison, the Scottish finance secretary, said: 'The decisions we have taken here in Scotland are helping support sustainable public finances. For the fourth year in a row, devolved revenues have grown faster than devolved expenditure. 'Scotland's public finances are better than many other parts of the UK, with the third highest revenue per person in the UK, behind only London and the South East.' But Struan Stevenson, the chief executive of the pro-Union Scottish Business UK group, said: 'The sharp rise of the 'Union dividend' once again in the Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland figures show that independence would be a disastrous calamity for Scotland, costing us tens of billions and almost bankrupting the nation at a stroke.'
Spectator
an hour ago
- Spectator
Top five howlers from Sturgeon's memoir
Oh dear. Nicola Sturgeon's memoir Frankly was always going to have its detractors, given how divisive a figure the SNP's former Dear Leader has become. A number of those people will not have read the former first minister's tome in full (for those who want to save themselves the time, Steerpike has compiled a handy list of lowlights here) and so some of the rather, er, fiery criticism may be based more on assertions about Sturgeon's character than the contents of her 450-page project. But it is the litany of factual errors dotted across the book – which appears to be written in American English – that provokes less sympathy from Mr S. Here are some of the worst… Women elected to Holyrood Claim: Sturgeon writes that: 'In fact, more women were elected to the Scottish parliament on 6 May 1999 than had been elected in total to the House of Commons since women had first been allowed to stand in 1918.' Fact check: False. Up until 1999, over 200 women had been elected to the House of Commons since women had been first allowed to stand at the start of the 20th century, compared to the total of 48 women who had been elected to The Scottish parliament on 6 May 1999. Even if the ex-FM had written instead that she meant the number of women sitting 'at any one time' she would have been incorrect, given 120 women were elected in 1997, helped in part by Labour's landslide victory. The youngest person in the Commons Claim: Sturgeon writes that: 'Amongst the newbies was Mhairi Black, precociously talented and, at just twenty years old, the youngest person ever elected to the Commons.' Fact check: False. Christopher Monck, the 2nd Duke of Albemarle, became the Member of Parliament for Devon in February 1667 at, er, just 13 years old. Getting the history right was never Nic's strong point though, eh? Wrong MP! Claim: Sturgeon reminisces on the day after the 2015 general election, where the SNP won 56 of Scotland's 59 Westminster seats. She writes: As I finally boarded the plane to London City, I thought I could at last relax a bit, but as soon as I appeared at the front of the aircraft, passengers started to clap. I found out only much later that one of the Labour MPs we had just defeated had been on the same plane that morning. For Tom Harris, until a few hours earlier the MP for Glasgow Cathcart, my presence must have made an already miserable morning feel even worse. Fact check: Well, luckily Tom Harris himself spotted the anecdote and took to Twitter to point out the inaccuracies. 'It's the only mention I get,' he notes. 'The thing is, it isn't true.' It turns out Sturgeon got Harris mixed up with Jimmy Hood, the ex-MP for Hamilton East and Lanark, as the former Cathcart politician had decided to stay in Glasgow with his family. He adds: 'Apart from writing something based on inaccurate hearsay, what is the point of the anecdote in the first place, other than to crow – again, a decade later – about a defeated opponent?' Stay classy, Nic. With a little help from my friends… Claim: In the first few pages of her chapter on Govan, Sturgeon turns to the issue of the Upper Clyde Shipbuilders – who had been pushed into liquidation after the Conservative government under Edward Heath had withdraw state subsidies from certain industries. But a rather unexpected hero came to the rescue: the Beatles' John Lennon. The ex-FM writes: 'The work-in [staged by the workers to complete orders, instead of going on strike] attracted global attention, including a £5,000 donation from John Lennon.' Fact check: Only it, er, wasn't £5,000 but a £1,000 sum, as reported by the Morning Star. Whatever happened to Sturgeon's fact-checkers?! Govan by-election Claim: Rather bizarrely, the former SNP leader writes in her memoir that her party's victory in the 1988 by-election saw Jim Sillars overturn a Labour majority of 13,000. Fact check: The Labour majority that was overturned was in fact even greater – at 19,500. A missed opportunity to boast there! It's quite the list from a former leader of Scotland, eh? Steerpike encourages readers to write in with more errors they spot…
