US judge in brokerage antitrust case faces recusal bid over political donations
March 11 (Reuters) - A national real estate brokerage has asked a U.S. judge in Missouri to withdraw from hearing a major antitrust lawsuit after disclosures showed plaintiffs' lawyers in the case previously donated to political campaigns involving the judge's wife.
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services in a court filing, opens new tab on Monday said ethics rules require the recusal of U.S. District Judge Stephen Bough, whose wife is an attorney and at-large councilmember for Kansas City, Missouri.
Howard Hanna is among several defendants in the lawsuit, which was filed by home sellers in 2023 and accused brokerages of conspiring to inflate the commission that sellers pay in residential real estate sales.
The donations from plaintiffs' lawyers to the judge's wife 'create an appearance of impropriety' for the court, Howard Hanna said. The company has denied violating U.S. antitrust law.
Howard Hanna declined to comment. Lawyers for the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Bough did not immediately respond to a similar request left with his chambers.
Howard Hanna's legal team at WilmerHale includes former Bill Clinton-era U.S. solicitor general Seth Waxman.
Pittsburgh-founded Howard Hanna markets itself as the country's largest family-owned real estate brokerage, employing 15,000 sales associates in nearly 500 offices. The firm said it ended 2023 with more than $37 billion in closed sales volume.
The lawsuit against Howard Hanna and other brokerages was filed by plaintiffs lawyers who had just won a landmark class action jury verdict in Bough's courtroom in a related antitrust lawsuit.
Since that October 2023 verdict, home sellers have secured more than a billion dollars in settlements with major brokerages and the real estate industry's chief trade group. The verdict spurred a wave of similar lawsuits against brokerages around the country.
Bough had disclosed the donations from members of the plaintiffs' team in the earlier class action.
'The ethics rules make it abundantly clear if I know someone is donating to my wife, then I need to put them on the conflicts list,' Bough said at a hearing last year in that case.
He said at the hearing that he had just learned that one of the members of the plaintiff's team had donated to his wife. The judge also said some of the large defense law firms in the Kansas City area donated to his wife.
At the hearing, Bough said he would be 'more than glad to step down,' but none of the parties asked for his recusal at the time.
The case is Don Gibson et al v. National Association of Realtors et al, U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri, No. 4:23-cv-00788-SRB.
Home listing service ends antitrust lawsuit against US realtors' group
Judge approves US realtor group's $418 mln sales commission settlement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
5 hours ago
- The Independent
Grandmother left to die after getting trapped under a car in a hospital parking garage, family alleges
A family is demanding answers after a 79-year-old grandmother died when she became trapped under her car in a hospital parking garage in April. Theresa M Phillips, 79, was driving her husband, Walter, to a doctor's appointment in a Pittsburgh hospital when the tragic accident occurred. Upon entering the parking lot, Phillips turned into the wrong entrance, forcing her to exit her car to retrieve a ticket. Her family's attorney said that the Phillips did not put the car into park, causing it to roll towards her, eventually trapping her underneath. The family's defense attorney, Matthew Scanlon, said her husband attempted 'to lift the car off his wife' but had to watch her be 'crushed to death.' 'Poor Mr. Phillips was trying, I can't imagine having to watch [...] This was absolutely a preventable tragedy,' he said. According to her daughter, Marie Lawton, emergency services took 30 minutes to arrive at the scene. A University of Pittsburgh Medical Center spokesperson said the hospital was 'deeply saddened by the tragic accident.' 'While emergency crews quickly responded, the victim did not survive. Our deepest sympathies are with the family,' the spokesperson added. Philips is survived by her daughter, Marie Lawton; her grandchildren; numerous nieces and nephews; and her sister. According to her obituary, Phillips was a U.S. Army Veteran who 'enjoyed playing video games, her pets, card club, bingo, and shopping.' 'She was very, very active; no grass grew under her feet. She always had something to do. But in the past two months, I've wanted to call my mom 20 times a day about the dumbest things, like 'mom did you hear,' not being able to call her that's the hardest,' Marie Lawton told local station WPXI. Scanlon said the family intends to file a lawsuit to determine what took so long and why no one from the hospital, just a few steps away, stepped in to help Philips. 'The public deserves answers on this, this is a public safety issue, UPMC being the largest provider in the area, we all deserve answers to this,' Scanlon said. 'It's not on the world, it's the impact on me, on my husband, on my grandchildren, on my dad. That's where she left the impact, and we take it out into the world,' Lawton added. The family hopes to file the lawsuit in Allegheny County court within the next month.
Reuters
5 hours ago
- Reuters
China puts six-month limit on its ease of rare-earth export licenses, WSJ reports
June 11 (Reuters) - China is putting a six-month limit on rare-earth export licenses for U.S. automakers and manufacturers, The Wall Street Journal reported on Wednesday citing people familiar with the matter.
Reuters
6 hours ago
- Reuters
IMF, Serbia reach staff-level agreement on 36-month deal
BELGRADE, June 11 (Reuters) - The International Monetary Fund (IMF) and Serbia have reached staff-level agreement on the first review under a 36-month arrangement to help support economic reforms, the fund said in a statement on Wednesday. The so-called Policy Coordination Instrument (PCI) was signed in October to make it easier for the Balkan country to secure lending from other sources. Under the arrangement, Serbian authorities are committed to a fiscal deficit limit of 3% of gross domestic product over three years. The review will be subject to approval by the IMF Executive Board, the fund said in the statement which was issued after its two-week trip to Serbia. It also warned that downside risks for the economy were elevated. The IMF said political tensions over anti-government protests and blockades of state universities launched last November "may weigh on confidence". Serbia has seen months of anti-government rallies after 16 deaths from a railway station roof collapse triggered accusations of widespread corruption and negligence. The IMF warned that a global growth slowdown and increasing "geoeconomic fragmentation could negatively affect exports and foreign direct investment". However, it expects Serbia's economy to grow 3% this year and 4% in 2026. "Serbia has built up substantial buffers to respond to shocks — foreign exchange reserves and government deposits are high, public debt is declining, and banks are well-capitalised and liquid," the IMF said.
