What Ukrainians think about Trump's peace plan
What Ukrainians think about Trump's peace plan
US President Donald
Trump
is urging
Ukraine
to make major concessions to end the war with Russia. Many Ukrainians reject his proposal. What do analysts have to say about the US peace plan?
Is US President Donald Trump's proposal for a peaceful end to the Ukraine conflict too Russia friendly? Axios news platform and other Western media outlets report that Trump's peace plan entails US recognition of Moscow's de jure control over Ukraine's Crimean Peninsula — which was annexed by Russia — as well as recognizing Moscow's de facto occupation of parts of Ukraine's Luhansk, Donetsk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions.
Trump's proposal also includes a promise that Ukraine will not become a Nato member but may possibly join the EU. It also envisions lifting sanctions imposed on Russia since 2014, as well as boosting economic cooperation with the US, particularly in the energy and industrial sectors.
According to Axios, Trump's plan involves freezing Ukrainian frontlines and granting Ukraine security guarantees. So far, however, no details have been given as to what these guarantees would entail. Ukraine will be offered the return of a small part of the Russian-occupied Kharkiv region and will be granted unhindered passage along the Dnipro River, which runs along Ukraine's southern frontline.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Free Lasik Consultation @ The Eye Foundation Bangalore
The Eye Foundation
Book Now
Undo
What is Ukraine's actual situation?
Serhii Kuzan, who heads the Ukrainian Center for Security and Cooperation think tank, told DW Ukraine's outlook is not as bad as Trump thinks. "The Ukrainian armed forces are achieving tactical successes in certain sections along the front, the country's arms industry is growing, and Ukraine's European partners are backing and supporting it even more. Our situation is much better than it was a year ago."
Even so, Kuzan conceded that Russia had also achieved tactical battlefield successes, made some advances and captured a few small Ukrainian towns in the east of the country. Yet none of this, Kuzan said, was of strategic importance.
"Russian claims that our defense is collapsing and that they will occupy the whole of Ukraine is wishful thinking," Kuzan told DW. "They simply do not have the reserves for that."
Hanna Shelest of the Ukrainian Prism think tank Prism believes that whenever US President Trump's special envoy Steve Witkoff returns from Moscow, he does so with a "Russian version of reality" according to which Russia is stronger and can continue the war for longer than Ukraine, which is supposedly weak and not needed by anybody.
"That's why Trump is firmly convinced he's doing something good for Ukraine," Shelest told DW. For this same reason she urges anyone visiting the White House and meeting Trump to explain Ukraine's perspective to him.
What does the future hold for Ukraine?
Observers agree that Trump's proposals to legally recognize Crimea as Russian territory will be widely rejected. The situation is more complicated when it comes to barring Ukraine from joining Nato.
"Pressure will be exerted on Ukraine to dissuade it from joining Nato," Shelest told DW. "It would be best for us if this question remained open. If it were not clearly stated that Ukraine has a right to join Nato, then one could unofficially promise Ukraine membership, which would not happen immediately. The political situation in Washington and Moscow, after all, could also change at some point."
Ukrainian political scientist Volodymyr Fesenko, meanwhile, believes that the US is on the wrong track because it is pressuring Ukraine to make significant concessions. At the same time, the US is accommodating Russia, even though both warring parties appear equally strong on the frontlines, Fesenko says, regardless of what Trump thinks.
As the US has so far failed to force Ukraine into an unfavorable peace agreement, Washington could try to take a break from negotiations until a more favorable moment arises, Fesenko says. "That's bad for us, but definitely not any worse than recognizing Crimea as Russian, because what would follow would be even worse: further regions and demands."
Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko, meanwhile, told the BBC that Ukraine may need to cede territory. "There is a lot of discussion about a possible settlement," Klitschko told the outlet. "One of the scenarios is the cession of territory. That is unfair. But for the sake of peace, a temporary peace, this could perhaps be a temporary solution."
Klitschko also said Ukrainian President
Zelensky
may be "forced to make a painful decision" as US President Trump increases the pressure on Ukraine.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Opening of Galwan Valley for tourists on 5th anniversary of India-China troops clash delayed
Galwan Memorial (Photo: ANI) SRINAGAR: Plans to open Galwan Valley hot springs in Ladakh for tourists on the fifth anniversary of the deadly clash between Indian and Chinese troops have been delayed, as construction of the war memorial needs further work. 'We have deferred the official opening of the Galwan Valley until the memorial is completed in perfection, as that will be the main attraction. It is about to be completed, but needs a finishing touch,' Tashi Gyalson, chief executive councillor of Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council (LAHDC), told TOI. Gyalson said LAHDC was also working on amending permit regulations to allow visitors without special permission. 'It is just a matter of a few days before Galwan Valley is opened to tourists,' he said. The Ladakh administration, in collaboration with the Indian Army, is at present working to build supporting infrastructure in the area. The Galwan Valley hot springs near the Line of Actual Control were set to open on June 15 as part of a battlefield tourism initiative. The date was meant to mark the fifth anniversary of the 2020 clash between Indian and PLA troops. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like One of the Most Successful Investors of All Time, Warren Buffett, Recommends: 5 Books for Turning... Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Click Here Undo Twenty Indian soldiers, including a commanding officer, and an unspecified number of PLA men were killed in the hand-to-hand combat, which was one of the most serious military confrontations between the two countries in decades. Meanwhile, the Army on Monday paid tribute to soldiers who died in the Galwan clash with China. In a post on X, Ladakh based Fire and Fury Corps 'paid heartfelt tribute to the valour and supreme sacrifice of our bravehearts who stood resolute in the face of adversity'. 'The indomitable courage in Galwan Valley forever resonates in the hearts of every Indian. Nation honours their families with deep respect. Their sacrifice continues to inspire generations,' it added.
Time of India
28 minutes ago
- Time of India
Our skies were filled with drones: Indian students in Tehran recall horror amid Israel-Iran conflict
As tensions continue to rise in West Asia, Indian students in Tehran recalled the initial hours of the conflict between Israel and Iran. Noting that around 140 Indian students were present at the Tehran University of Medical Sciences on the first day of military action by Israel, the students talked of the support provided by the senior officials of the varsity but also appealed for their evacuation in the wake of uncertainty over the situation amid rising tensions. Students spoke to are pursuing MBBS at the Tehran University of Medical Sciences and the Islamic Azad University and talked about their experience since the military action began. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Current Administration Approved the 2025 Food Card for Seniors HealthyWallet Learn More Undo "The condition was getting worse here every minute," one of the students recalled. (Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates) "On Friday dawn, at around 3:20 am, we heard a blast. It was a huge sound. When we looked out of our windows, there was black smoke and when we went downstairs, we heard more blasts," another student said. Live Events "After 2-3 hours, we heard boom of fighter jets. We have been really scared... Our skies were filled with the (Friday) evening to the next day's morning, we heard sounds continuously. There was a complete blackout and were sitting under the dormitory," the student added. The students said that they received support from the university authorities. "Our University (Tehran University of Medical Sciences) has been very helpful. As soon as the blasts happened, our Vice-Dean came to check upon us and calmed us. By the evening our Dean also arrived and assured us that nothing will happen. That was a very dangerous night which we faced. We don't have the heart the spend one more night here," a student said. The students, who come from different parts of India, have been pursuing their education for varied periods of time. The students said they have been in touch with the Indian Embassy and have been assured all support. The students said they want to be evacuated at the earliest. "We trust in India's power and really want to be evacuated," a student said. They recalled the government's efforts to bring back Indian students during Russia-Ukraine conflict. On Sunday, the Embassy of India in Iran issued several helpline numbers and created a Telegram Link for communication with Indian nationals currently in Iran. The Embassy shared details in a series of posts on X, saying that the Telegram link is "ONLY" for Indian nationals in Iran. "We request everyone in Iran to join the below given Telegram Link to receive updates on the situation from the Embassy. Kindly note that this Telegram Link is ONLY for those Indian Nationals who are currently in Iran. it said on X. Asking the nationals not to give into panic, the Embassy asked people to exercise caution and remain in contact with the Embassy in Tehran. Tensions have been rising between Israel and Iran in West Asia. On June 13, Israel launched a massive airstrike on Iranian military and nuclear sites, dubbed " Operation Rising Lion ". Earlier, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that Israel has launched Operation Rising Lion, a targeted military operation to roll back the "Iranian threat to Israel's very survival" adding that the mission would continue "for as many days as it takes to remove this threat." In response, Iranian News Agency IRNA said the Islamic Revolution Guard Corps (IRGC), in response to the Israeli aggression, has launched a large-scale drone and missile operation 'Operation True Promise 3' targeting Israeli fighter jet fuel production facilities and energy supply centres. The strikes were conducted in direct retaliation against Israeli "aggression".
Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
How America's new plan to cut China's supply chain for Apple, Google, Samsung and other technology companies has worried Vietnam
The United States reportedly has another plan to cut China's hardware and components supply chain of Apple, Google, Samsung, Meta and other technology companies. According to a report in Reuters, America is urging Vietnam to reduce Chinese technology in devices assembled in the country and exported to America. Vietnam, a hub for tech giants like Apple and Samsung, relies heavily on Chinese components, with Meta and Google also producing goods like VR headsets and smartphones there. Vietnam has held meetings with local businesses to increase the use of Vietnamese parts, with firms expressing willingness but noting the need for time and technology, one source told Reuters. Trump Tariffs: 46% tariff threat and ... The Trump administration has threatened 46% tariffs, which could disrupt Vietnam's export-driven economy. One source said that Vietnam was asked to "reduce its dependency on Chinese high-tech" to restructure supply chains and lessen US reliance on Chinese components. Another source highlighted the US goal of accelerating decoupling from Chinese tech while boosting Vietnam's industrial capacity, citing VR devices as an example. With a US-imposed tariff deadline of July 8 looming, the scope and timing of a potential deal reportedly remain uncertain. Sources emphasized that reducing Chinese high-tech content in exports is a US priority. Last year, China exported $44 billion in tech goods to Vietnam, 30% of its total exports there, while Vietnam shipped $33 billion in tech goods to the US, per Vietnam's customs data. The US also wants Vietnam to address Chinese goods mislabeled as "Made in Vietnam" to evade higher duties. Vietnam's trade ministry noted progress in recent Washington talks but said key issues remain unresolved. What is Vietnam's big worry Vietnam's Communist Party chief, To Lam, may meet President Trump in late June, though no date is confirmed, sources told Reuters. Local companies have shown willingness to adapt but warned that rapid changes could "destroy business," one source said. Industry experts note that Vietnam's supply chain lags China's by 15–20 years but is progressing in sectors like electronics. Abrupt shifts could strain Vietnam's ties with China, a key investor and also lead to security concerns.
