
Surgeon sues McLaren after he was left with brain injury after crash on £24,000 snowmobile safari trip
Andrew Cannestra's snowmobile crashed near Ivalo, northern Finland, on February 2 2020, during a four-night 'Pure McLaren Arctic Experience' arranged by McLaren Automotive Events.
The Florida native, 54, who specialises in spinal surgery, is alleging the company was in breach of contract and negligent after the crash left him with a trembling hand which he previously said would mean he will have to retire prematurely.
Barristers for surgeon told the first day of a trial in London that Mr Cannestra and his then-partner, Kaitlin Mealor, were given a safety briefing, but this did not include information on the layout of the track or the emergency stop button and tether cord on the snowmobile.
The motorsports group is defending the legal action, with its lawyers saying there was 'no evidence' that the briefing did not meet safety standards and that the 'irreducible risk' of the activity was 'reasonably controlled'.
Opening the trial on Wednesday, Neil Block KC, for Mr Cannestra, said his client and Ms Mealor were 'absolute novices' on snowmobiles, and that 'a duty was owed by McLaren to use reasonable care'.
He said that while Mr Cannestra's case was not 'that the track was inherently unsafe', he and Ms Mealor 'did need to receive a proper and adequate briefing, and proper and adequate guiding'.
In written submissions, Mr Block said: 'The briefing did not include any information about the layout of the track, the position of potentially hazardous bends, corners or other hazards.
'It seems to be McLaren's case that this was not required.
'It is common sense that this was required, and the failure to do so must be a breach of duty.'
Mr Block told the court that Mr Cannestra and Ms Mealor's 'couples package' cost almost £24,000 before flights, with activities including driving a McLaren car on ice, and optional events such as snowmobiling.
Mr Cannestra and Ms Mealor used a 'dedicated snowmobile track' about four kilometres long, and signed a driver declaration, a waiver and a self-liability form beforehand.
They were given a safety briefing by two guides - Arto Pitkanen and Jouni Satta - which Mr Block said lasted 'approximately five minutes', with the barrister adding: 'There is an issue about what it actually included.'
Mr Block said the Lynx Xtrim 900 snowmobiles had three modes - eco, standard and sport - with the tour beginning in eco mode, which had a top speed of 40kph.
A few hundred metres into the activity, Mr Block said the group stopped, and Mr Pitkanen approached Mr Cannestra and changed the mode, which increased its top speed and was 'not appropriate'.
Mr Pitkanen is alleged to have then set off at speeds of up to 60kph, causing Mr Cannestra to lose sight of him and speed up as he 'did not want to be on his own', Mr Block said.
Mr Cannestra then lost control of the snowmobile on a bend, with the vehicle veering off the track into deep snow and hitting a tree, leaving him with a 'very significant' brain injury and 'orthopaedic injuries'.
Matthew Chapman KC, for McLaren, said in his written submissions that the turn where Mr Cannestra crashed was 'quite safe if negotiated at an appropriate speed' and that the court 'can confidently conclude that reasonable care and skill was exercised' in organising the outing.
He continued that Mr Pitkanen changed the snowmobile's mode as Mr Cannestra was 'eager' for this to happen and that he 'explained the switch' to him.
He added that Mr Cannestra's speed was 'wholly within his control', and claims that Mr Pitkanen had driven too far in front 'cannot sensibly succeed'.
He said: 'In this case, there was a well-organised, risk-assessed activity which was delivered by well-trained and experienced guides who complied with the local standard.
'The irreducible risk was, in other words, reasonably controlled.'
While acknowledging that the content of the safety briefing was 'contentious', Mr Chapman said it included the hand signal to stop, how to use the throttle and brake, starting the engine and 'bodyweight shifting/leaning for turns'.
The trial before Mr Justice Ritchie, which is only dealing with the issue of liability, is expected to conclude this month, with a written judgment expected at a later date.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Reuters
9 hours ago
- Reuters
Scarred Norris has a nose for success
SPA-FRANCORCHAMPS, Belgium, July 24 (Reuters) - Formula One title contender Lando Norris is scarred by success. He also has a nose for it. The McLaren driver now sports two scars on his nose, each a memento of a career milestone, and the Briton is not altogether unhappy about it. The first cut was acquired in Amsterdam last year on a broken glass while on a party weekend, days before he took his breakthrough maiden career F1 victory in Miami. The second injury came at Silverstone this month while he was celebrating a first home win in front of fans at the British Grand Prix and a mesh fence partially collapsed and a photographer fell on him. "It's healing nicely now," Norris, laughing, told reporters when asked at the Belgian Grand Prix about the latest facial injury. "I got a more professional repair on this one. "But both are great memories of mine. So if I ever want to look in the mirror and think of something great, I just look at my nose. It was a little shame because at that moment I wanted to stand on the pit straight and all the fans were there, so I missed out a little bit on a nice moment. My nose is unlucky at the moment." Norris is second in the championship at the midpoint, eight points adrift of Australian teammate Oscar Piastri. He has won four times this season, including the showcase Monaco Grand Prix.


Metro
10 hours ago
- Metro
Hamilton goes the extra mile in push to shake up Ferrari
This weekend's Belgian Grand Prix will give us the first glimpse of major management changes that have taken place in the last two weeks. Christian Horner will not be there, having been axed by Red Bull's Austrian HQ in some sort of power struggle. In his place, on the Red Bull Racing pitwall's primo position, is Laurent Mekies, who has been promoted from being team principal of the Racing Bulls to top dog at the senior squad. Racing Bull's new boss has also been promoted from within – Alan Permane, a British F1 engineer with 36 years' experience who previously helped Michael Schumacher and Fernando Alonso to world titles. Spa-Francorchamps is a circuit which challenges the cars, drivers and people's wardrobe choices in equal measure, thanks to its swooping high-speed terrain and bafflingly unpredictable weather. It's a test of aerodynamics and Racing Bulls have brought upgrades they hope will help them cut through the wind. Aston Martin, too, are bringing their biggest upgrade yet. With Nico Hulkenberg's amazing Silverstone podium, Sauber have scaled almost all of the midfield competition. Williams are winning that fight with 59 points but then it's the Swiss scuderia (41), followed by Racing Bulls and Aston (tied on 36), Haas (29), and the struggling equipe Alpine (19). Ferrari are best of the rest compared to the mighty McLaren but there is no doubt Lewis Hamilton and Charles Leclerc hoped to be closer to the front. On the face of it, Spa's characteristics are perfect for the McLaren but Hamilton and Leclerc have strong form here, with theBritish driver last triumphing in 2024 and his team-mate taking his debut victory in 2019. Ferrari will try out a new suspension package but Hamilton doesn't expect it to make much difference this weekend, although it may prove beneficial at other tracks. Overall, he has not been impressed with the regularity of upgrades and is pushing extremely hard behind the scenes to get the team working in a new direction. 'We had an upgraded floor in Bahrain and we didn't get another upgrade until Austria. Pace-wise, we haven't had what I thought we would have. Other teams bring small pieces every single weekend,' said Hamilton. Over the last fortnight he has spent four days in the Maranello factory, sitting down with team principal Fred Vasseur, CEO Benedetto Vigna and chairman John Elkann, as well as each technical head of department, to address what he needs to get back on the top step of the podium. Hamilton revealed he had been submitting his own technical reports, and tested the 2026 car on the simulator last week for the first time. 'It's a big, big push. I've held lots of meetings, talking about the engine for next year, suspension for next year, things I want,' added the 40-year-old. 'After the first few races I submitted a full document to the team. Over this break I did another two documents, so I've gone in to address those. One was about structural adjustments we need to make to get better, and the other was about the issues I have with this current car. There are some things you do want to take on to next year's car, and some you don't. 'The reason for it is I see a huge amount of potential within this team. The passion – nothing comes close. It's a huge organisation with a lot of moving parts, but the parts are not firing on all cylinders like they need to be. That's ultimately why the team hasn't had the success I feel it deserves. 'I'm here to win. It's crunch time for me and I truly believe in the potential of this team, I believe they can win multiple championships. That's my sole goal. 'I feel it's my job to challenge every area and challenge everybody in the team, especially the guys at the top who are making the decisions. If you look at the team in the last 20 years, they've had amazing drivers and yet they didn't win a title with Ferrari. More Trending 'I refuse for that to be the case with me. I'm going the extra mile. I'm fortunate to have had experiences in two other great teams. For sure things are going to be different, it's a different culture, but if you take the same path all the time you're going to get the same result.' It is rumoured Vasseur won't have his contract renewed at the end of this year. Does that leave the door open for Horner? Well, he doesn't speak Italian and though Ferrari may offer to pay him handsomely, they won't offer him equity, which is what he really wants. I also doubt Hamilton would be happy working with him, not least because Horner has been so combative on Max Verstappen's behalf in the past. Three more likely options for Horner are if Toyota buy Haas, Cadillac decide to push current principal Graeme Lowdon out of the way or Alpine are taken over by a rumoured consortium which he may be invited to join. That last one feels the most likely, and I believe Bernie Ecclestone is pulling the strings. Watch this space. MORE: The Metro daily cartoon by Guy Venables MORE: Euro 2025 final: England have done it the hard way but I never lost faith and know they can beat Spain MORE: Wrestling legend Hulk Hogan dies aged 71 'after suffering cardiac arrest'


Reuters
13 hours ago
- Reuters
'I wish him all the best,' Hamilton says of old foe Horner
SPA-FRANCORCHAMPS, Belgium, July 24 (Reuters) - Lewis Hamilton paid a measured tribute to old foe Christian Horner on Thursday as Formula One prepared for its first race in 20 years without the now-dismissed Red Bull team boss. Horner had run Red Bull from 2005, two years before seven times F1 world champion Hamilton made his debut with McLaren, until this month. During that time Red Bull became serial title winners, with Hamilton among the main contenders battling to beat them. Hamilton told reporters ahead of the weekend's Belgian Grand Prix - his 369th race and first without Horner being around - that while the Briton's departure would not change anything in his life, it had been incredible to witness Red Bull's progress. He recalled sitting in Horner's office while still competing in Formula Three and looking into his future options in F2 and beyond. "I wouldn't say we hit it off from the get-go," said the 40-year-old. "To see his progression and his career, I think it was clearly remarkable what he did with the team. With a huge group of amazing people. To really run an organisation that big and that well takes talent and skill. "That's what he brought to the team. I wish him all the best."