TSMC could face $1 billion or more fine from U.S. probe, sources say
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. (TSMC) could face a penalty of $1 billion or more to settle a U.S. export control investigation over a chip it made that ended up inside a Huawei artificial intelligence processor, according to two people familiar with the matter.
The U.S. Department of Commerce has been investigating the world's biggest contract chipmaker's work for China-based Sophgo, the sources said. The design company's TSMC-made chip matched one found in Huawei's high-end Ascend 910B artificial intelligence processor, according to the people, who requested anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly about the matter.
Huawei — a company at the center of China's AI chip ambitions that has been accused of sanctions busting and trade secret theft — is on a U.S. trade list that restricts it from receiving goods made with U.S. technology. TSMC made nearly 3 million chips in recent years that matched the design ordered by Sophgo and likely ended up with Huawei, according to Lennart Heim, a researcher at RAND's Technology and Security and Policy Center in Arlington, Virginia, who is tracking Chinese developments in AI.
The $1 billion-plus potential penalty comes from export control regulations allowing for a fine of up to twice the value of transactions that violate the rules, the sources said.
Because TSMC's chipmaking equipment includes U.S. technology, the company's Taiwan factories are within reach of U.S. export controls that prevent it from making chips for Huawei, or producing certain advanced chips for any customer in China without a U.S. license.
Heim said that based on the design, which is for AI applications, TSMC should not have made the chip for a company headquartered in China, especially given the risk that it could be diverted to a restricted entity such as Huawei.
Shares of TSMC traded in the U.S. erased a nearly 3% gain to trade slightly lower after the news.
Penalizing TSMC comes at a critical moment for U.S.-Taiwan relations as the two begin renegotiating their trading relationship after Trump last week slapped a 32% levy on imports from Taipei. The tariffs exclude chips, but Trump has said his team is looking at levies on semiconductors. In March, TSMC said at the White House that it plans to make a fresh $100 billion investment in the United States that includes building five additional chip facilities in coming years.
It could not be determined how the Trump administration will proceed with TSMC or when the matter would be resolved. Top officials have said they plan to seek higher penalties for export violations. A spokesperson for the Commerce Department declined comment.
TSMC spokesperson Nina Kao said in a statement that the company is committed to complying with the law. She added that TSMC has not supplied to Huawei since mid-September 2020 and that they are cooperating with the Commerce Department.
No public action has been taken against TSMC. But typically, the Commerce Department issues a "proposed charging letter" to a company it believes has engaged in prohibited conduct. The letter usually cites the dates alleged violations took place, the value, and the formula for a civil penalty, and it gives the company 30 days to respond.
At a conference in Washington last month, U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick spoke about the role of export control enforcement in addressing the threat from China. "We are going to seek in this administration a dramatic increase in enforcement and fines for people who break the rules," Lutnick said. "We have had enough of people trying to make a dollar supporting the people who seek to destroy our way of life."
Jeffrey Kessler, who was confirmed in March as Under Secretary of Commerce for Industry and Security to oversee U.S. export controls, was more targeted at his Feb. 27 nomination hearing, saying that reports of TSMC chips going to Huawei was "a huge concern" and that "strong enforcement" was critical. A 10-figure fine for export control violations would be rare.
In 2023, BIS imposed a $300 million penalty on Seagate Technology Holdings as part of a settlement over its shipping of over $1.1 billion worth of hard disk drives to Huawei. TSMC first came under scrutiny last fall.
TechInsights, a Canadian tech research firm, took apart a Huawei 910B AI accelerator and found a TSMC die, as it's also called, in the multi-chip system.
After the TechInsights finding, TSMC suspended shipments to Sophgo and, in November, the Commerce Department ordered the chipmaker to halt shipments to China of seven-nanometer or more advanced chips that could be used in AI applications.
In January, Sophgo, which in October denied any business relationship with Huawei, was placed on the same Commerce Department restricted trade list as Huawei. Sophgo could not be reached for comment.
Huawei's Ascend 910B has been viewed as the most advanced mass-produced AI chip available from a Chinese company, providing an alternative to California-based industry leader Nvidia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Asahi Shimbun
42 minutes ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Residents fight Chinese owner over rising rent, ‘broken' elevator
A notice from the owner of an apartment building in Tokyo's Itabashi Ward says rent will rise by 2.6 times. (Yosuke Takashima) Frustrated and angry, the remaining residents at an apartment building in Tokyo said they are determined to continue fighting a new Chinese owner who has made their lives unbearable. According to the tenants, the building owner has demanded exorbitant rent increases, halted the use of a workable elevator, and operated an illegal accommodation business. An official of the Chinese company denied trying to evict the residents or running an illegal operation. But many residents have already vacated the premises, and those still there are at their wit's end. RENT MORE THAN DOUBLES The conflict started in late January, when all residents of the 40-plus-year-old, seven-story building in Itabashi Ward received a 'notice of rent increase' in their mailboxes. They would have to pay more than double the current rates. One resident in his 50s said his monthly rent will increase 2.6-fold from 72,500 yen ($500) to 190,000 yen starting in August, according to the notice. The notice cited 'the increase in various expenses caused by the rise in utility rates and other prices.' The name of the company on the notice was not the one with which the man had signed the lease. A few days later, the man received a letter informing him of a change in ownership of the apartment building. The new owner was the company named in the rent-hike notice. 'How could such an extreme rent increase be acceptable?' the man said he wondered at the time. To find out, the man visited a consultation desk at a housing and building transaction business association. He was told that under law, the landlord and tenant must agree on a rent increase, and if they do not, the current rent will be maintained. The matter can then be decided in court or through other means. But basically, a rent increase significantly higher than the market rate would not be approved in court, the man was told. Taking into consideration the high cost of living and market prices of nearby properties, a rent increase of up to 1.2 times would be reasonable, he was told. The man sent a letter to the new owner, rejecting the rent revision. When the man made inquiries around the building, he learned that all residents had been informed that their rents would increase to 190,000 yen a month, double to triple their current rents. The register of the owner company showed its head office was located in an apartment in Tokyo's Koto Ward. The company's activities were listed as real estate transactions, as well as internet-related businesses, books, finance and food and beverage services. A name that appeared to be Chinese was listed as the 'representative employee of the company,' along with an address in Liaoning province, China. 100,000-YEN OFFER TO LEAVE A female resident of the building received an unexpected knock on her door at around 8:30 p.m. in mid-February. A man who claimed to be the owner of the apartment asked her, in broken Japanese, 'Do you know about the rent increase?' He continued: 'We will raise it from next month. If you move out this month, we will pay you 100,000 yen. Do you want to leave?' The woman was surprised at the sudden demand and repeatedly told the man, 'I haven't heard of anything about it.' She asked for his business card, but the man said, 'I don't have it.' Instead, he gave her a piece of paper with the company name and a phone number scribbled on it. At around this time, some residents started to relocate, growing distrustful of the new owner. HEAVY TRAFFIC IN 'VACANT' ROOM In early March, a resident in his 40s noticed something unusual: two double beds had been delivered to a room across the hallway, which was supposed to be vacant. From mid-March, other tenants saw what appeared to be tourists from around Asia with large suitcases entering and leaving the supposedly vacant apartment every day. The resident across the hallway suspected the owner was operating a 'minpaku' private lodging business there. So, he entered the address of the apartment on an accommodation reservation website, searched, and found listings for two rooms in the building. The photos posted as the exterior of the accommodations matched that of the apartment building. The price was about 25,000 yen per night for two people. Minpaku businesses must have external signage for such operations. There were no such signs on the apartment building. The Itabashi Ward Office also said there were no reports of a minpaku business being run in the apartment. A security camera recorded various people frequently entering and leaving one of the rooms. The resident across the hall provided the footage to the ward office. In response, the ward, through the Japan Tourism Agency, asked the accommodation reservation website to remove the apartment's rooms. The rooms were delisted, and reservations were no longer available on the site in late March. However, people who appeared to be minpaku guests continued to come and go until late April, according to the residents. They were believed to have made reservations before the delisting. During that time, residents who lived under the two rooms were bothered by the noise from the 'guests' and moved out. ELEVATOR DOWN FOR 6 MONTHS The remaining residents were informed in writing that the owner company would also be responsible for management of the building from May 11. Still distrustful, the residents formed a group on a social networking site to exchange information. They became aware of similar situations in Osaka and other cities, where a change in ownership and management company abruptly led to a more than doubling of rents. The residents in Itabashi Ward did not really know each other's faces or names until the rent-hike notice in January. They were hoping that cooperation would make it easier to negotiate with the owner. However, the new owner had another apparent strategy to empty the rooms. On the door of each unit and at the elevator doors on every floor, a piece of paper said, 'Notice of elevator outage.' 'Parts of the door have been damaged, making operation impossible,' the notice said. 'Defects have been found in the electrical system, raising the possibility of electrical discharges.' The notice said 'use of the elevator will be suspended for the time being' and 'it is expected to take more than six months for new parts to be made.' One resident who was immediately suspicious contacted the elevator manufacturer directly. The company said a routine inspection in late February revealed no defects or malfunctions in the elevator. The company also said that even if elevator parts needed to be replaced, it would only take about a week to do so. This information was immediately shared among residents on social media. 'I can only think that the (owner) is trying to force the elevator to shut down and drive us out,' said one resident. The residents' distrust turned to anger. 'MATTER OF LIFE AND DEATH' A woman in her late 70s who lives on the seventh floor is now forced to use the emergency stairs, which have about 90 steps between floors. The strain on her body is heavy, especially her knees. Until then, she had been going out several times a day, but now there are days when she has to stay at home. '(The owner's) arrogant behavior has deprived me of a peaceful living environment,' she said. 'It is a matter of life and death because the temperature is going to rise from now.' She is also concerned about a man in his 80s who lives alone on the same seventh floor. 'It's too late to do anything after something happens,' she said. 'But what should I do?' DENIALS FROM OWNER It is estimated that about half of all residents have left or will be leaving the building. The phone number of the apartment's management company listed on the elevator notice was for a cellphone. An Asahi Shimbun reporter sent a message to the number on June 5 and was told that another person was handling the matter. A different cellphone number was provided. When the reporter called the number, a man answered and identified himself as the owner's representative. 'The owner is Chinese, and he is in China,' the man said. He also said the company 'did not know the market rate for rent' and it 'has no intention of evicting the residents.' He also denied operating a minpaku, but said, 'There was a time when I rented a room to a friend.' He said he did not know how the friend used the room. Regarding the elevator, the man said problems have arisen, and it is being inspected, but no timetable had been set for resuming its use. The Asahi Shimbun called the phone number several times thereafter but received no response.
Kyodo News
an hour ago
- Kyodo News
Japan's top negotiator eyes U.S. trip this week for 6th tariff talks
KYODO NEWS - 4 hours ago - 13:30 | All, Japan Japan's top tariff negotiator is arranging a visit to the United States later this week for a sixth round of ministerial-level talks aimed at securing concessions over a series of tariffs imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump, a government source said Monday. The fourth trip in as many weeks by Ryosei Akazawa, minister in charge of economic and fiscal policy, would come ahead of an envisioned meeting between the leaders of Japan and the United States at the time of the three-day Group of Seven summit in Canada from June 15. Akazawa is expected to meet U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick again, after holding talks with them last week in Washington, the source said. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba's government is urging the Trump administration to remove the additional tariffs, saying they are having a serious impact on Japan's export-oriented economy, which has been languishing as an important national election looms this summer. Following the fifth round of talks with U.S. officials, Akazawa told reporters that discussions on tariff issues between Japan and the United States are progressing, but the two sides have "yet to find common ground." After returning to Tokyo on Sunday, Akazawa pledged to continue "intensive" deliberations on trade expansion, non-tariff barriers and bilateral cooperation on economic security, with Trump expected to continue pursuing protectionist policies. Akazawa, who met with Ishiba on the day of his return to report the outcome of his visit, said the Japanese and U.S. leaders may talk directly once the ministerial-level negotiations reach a point where an agreement is in sight. Under Trump's so-called reciprocal tariff regime, announced on April 2, nearly every nation in the world has been hit with a baseline duty of 10 percent, with Japan facing an additional country-specific tariff of 14 percent for a total rate of 24 percent. Japan has also been affected by Trump's extra 25 percent tariff on automobiles, along with other sector-specific levies imposed on national security grounds. Tokyo presented a package of proposals to Washington over the period since the first ministerial meeting in mid-April. The package includes joint supply chain efforts on semiconductors and critical minerals, cooperation in shipbuilding, greater U.S. farm imports and streamlined safety rules for foreign-made cars, sources close to the matter said. Related coverage: Japan, U.S. yet to find common ground on tariffs but want quick deal Japan, EU eye launch of "competitive alliance" scheme to boost trade Japan calls for tariff rethink in talks with U.S. commerce chief
The Mainichi
2 hours ago
- The Mainichi
US and China are holding trade talks in London after Trump-Xi phone call
LONDON (AP) -- High-level delegations from the United States and China are meeting in London on Monday to try and shore up a fragile truce in a trade dispute that has roiled the global economy, A Chinese delegation led by Vice Premier He Lifeng is due to meet U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Trade Representative Jamieson Greer at an undisclosed location in the city. The talks are due to last at least a day. They follow negotiations in Geneva last month that brought a temporary respite in the trade war. The two countries announced May 12 they had agreed to a 90-day suspension of most of the 100%-plus tariffs they had imposed on each other in an escalating trade war that had sparked fears of recession. Since then, the U.S. and China have exchanged angry words over advanced semiconductors that power artificial intelligence, "rare earths" that are vital to carmakers and other industries, and visas for Chinese students at American universities. President Donald Trump spoke at length with Chinese leader Xi Jinping by phone last Thursday in an attempt to put relations back on track. Trump announced on social media the next day that trade talks would be held on Monday in London. The U.K. government says it is providing the venue and logistics but is not involved in the talks. "We are a nation that champions free trade and have always been clear that a trade war is in nobody's interests, so we welcome these talks," the British government said in a statement.
