Defence secretary revealed sensitive Afghan data breach details - but media still banned from reporting it
John Healey offered a 'sincere apology' on behalf of the British Government for a massive leak which shared information about Afghans seeking to escape to the UK because of their links to British troops and could only be reported after a two-year fight to lift an unprecedented superinjunction.
But in his address to MPs, Mr Healey disclosed details that the media still cannot publish because a second gagging order remains in place.
Media organisations, including The Independent, are seeking to overturn that order at the High Court, which would allow information that has previously been kept secret to finally be revealed.
The catastrophic breach, made by a Ministry of Defence official in February 2022, triggered a covert government operation that saw 16,000 Afghans evacuated to Britain, with some 8,000 still to come.
The whole operation was kept secret from MPs and the public, with ministers even deciding to hide the true reason for the evacuation from parliament, after the MoD claimed the release of information could put those named in the database at risk of reprisals from the Taliban.
Lifting the superinjunction on Tuesday, High Court judge Mr Justice Chamberlain called for further investigation after an official review into the data leak 'fundamentally undermined the evidential basis' on which the superinjunction had been based.
Media organisations, including The Independent, the Daily Mail and The Times, were hit with a fresh injunction on Tuesday, which banned any mention of certain information, over fears it could risk national security.
But despite MoD lawyers arguing the information should never be shared, Mr Healey revealed some of the details to MPs in Parliament.
That prompted Mr Justice Chamberlain to call an emergency hearing on Tuesday to address whether the second injunction should now be lifted.
He told the court, in a public hearing, that MoD lawyers were pushing for it to remain in place, arguing that any release of the information would result in 'damage to national security'.
'The MoD has asked for time to produce evidence of this... I have reached the provisional view that if evidence will be produced, it will have to be produced very quickly', he added.
The judge has now given time for media defendants and the MoD to attempt to agree on what information can be published and what must remain secret.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
Rachel Reeves should exempt defence pledge from budget rules, says Gordon Brown
Gordon Brown has said Chancellor Rachel Reeves should exempt the Government's defence spending pledge from her borrowing rules to help free up economic headroom. The former prime minister said the commitment to spend 5% of GDP on national security by 2035 should be dealt with jointly as a ' Nato initiative', with costs shared across Europe. Leading economists have warned the Chancellor will likely have to raise taxes in the autumn budget to plug a £51 billion black hole in the public finances. Ms Reeves is currently on track to miss one of her borrowing rules by £41.2 billion and needs to rebuild a fiscal buffer of nearly £10 billion that has been wiped out, the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (Niesr). Mr Brown, who served as chancellor for a decade in Sir Tony Blair's Labour administration, said on Thursday that the rise in defence spending should be treated as 'exceptional', as it has been in Germany. 'When you come to the fiscal position, look, there's one thing that's happened over the last few months that has been quite unprecedented – to spend 5% on defence expenditure as we want to spend by the 2030s,' he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme. 'But this is a Nato initiative, this is a European initiative. We should be doing this jointly. 'We should have either jointly issued bonds or a Nato defence fund, and we should be sharing the cost across the continent, and that should be regarded as something extraordinary and exceptional, outside the fiscal rules. 'That would create the kind of headroom that Rachel Reeves needs.' Germany has exempted some defence spending from its strict borrowing rules – the so-called 'debt brake' – to allow an increase in expenditure. When she entered the Treasury, Ms Reeves set out two key fiscal restrictions which she has said are 'non-negotiable'. The first rule is to ensure that day-to-day spending is matched by tax revenues so the Government only borrows to invest, and the second is to reduce net financial debt as a share of the economy. Ministers have already announced a cut to overseas aid to fund a boost in defence spending but economists have said the new Nato target of 5% by 2035 could increase expenditure by a further £38.6 billion. The Treasury has been contacted for comment.
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘One in, one out' deal now active with first migrants detained
The first migrants to cross the English Channel have been detained under a new 'one in, one out' deal. The detentions began on Wednesday, the initial day the pilot scheme became active, for people arriving in Dover. The agreement, announced by Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron, stipulates that adult migrants crossing the Channel risk return if their asylum claim is deemed inadmissible. Under the scheme, for each small boat migrant returned to France, an asylum seeker will be allowed to enter the UK from France via a legal route. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said that this sends a clear message to migrants and organised crime gangs.
STV News
13 minutes ago
- STV News
First small boat migrants detained under 'one-in, one-out' treaty with France
The first small boat migrants have been detained under the new 'one-in, one-out' UK-France migrant treaty on Thursday. The returns deal will see those who cross the Channel in small boats exchanged with France for asylum seekers in a 'controlled and legal' way. On Thursday, the Home Office announced that the first migrants have been detained under the scheme. The Home Office has said those who arrive in the UK on a small boat will be held in removal centres pending return. In exchange, migrants in France can apply to come to the UK on a 'one-to-one exchange basis' – subject to strict criteria and security checks being met. The scheme will be reviewed to tackle any issues as the scale and speed of returns increase. Starmer previously said 'hard-headed aggressive action' was needed on all fronts to 'break' the migrant gangs' business model, secure UK borders, and show that attempting to reach the UK by small boat 'will only end in failure, detention, and return'. The prime minister has not said how the scheme will select the individuals who will be returned to France, and the Home Office has not confirmed how many people the deal would see returned. However, Le Monde reported that the two nations reportedly agreed to exchange 50 people per week under the treaty. Starmer did not deny the figure. If the numbers are anything like the 50 reportedly being agreed on, the deal will result in the return of only a fraction of the 21,000 people who have made the Channel crossing so far in 2025, a record for this point in a year. The deal will also not see the net migration figure fall on its own, but the hope is that it will serve as a deterrent for more people hoping to make the trip by boat. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
