Garda recruitment unlikely to hit targets, Policing Authority warned Minister for Justice
Garda
numbers will hit the levels pledged by the
Coalition
earlier this year under recruitment policies, the
Policing Authority
warned earlier this year.
The stark message is contained in correspondence from the body's chairwoman to
Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan
sent in March.
It outlines that with retirements projected to 'significantly increase' in the coming decade, the programme for government commitment to recruit at least 5,000 gardaí by 2029 is endangered.
The letter, released under Freedom of Information laws, also warns that gardaí are managing complex and serious investigations while 'relying primarily on manual spreadsheets or paper-based systems'.
READ MORE
Policing Authority chairwoman Elaine Byrne told Mr O'Callaghan that, 'in the absence of radical and meaningful reform' of recruitment, it is highly unlikely the target of at least 5,000 gardaí, as set out in the programme for government, will be met.
She wrote that it was similarly 'unlikely' that recruitment pipelines will result in sufficient new members 'to meet the natural attrition and current or increased demand'.
It is among a litany of issues outlined by the Policing Authority, which was subsumed along with the Garda Síochána Inspectorate into the new Policing and Community Safety Authority (PCSA) in April.
Ms Byrne wrote that workforce recruitment, the sufficiency of budgeting and investment in the force were 'fundamental and now urgent challenges'.
She outlined a 'pressing need' for continued and enhanced investment in technology for the Garda, including priorities in finance and human resource management, despite improvements in recent years.
'It cannot be the case that the Garda Síochána continues to manage complex and serious investigations, an organisation of 18,000 people, and a budget of €2.48 billion relying primarily on manual spreadsheets or paper-based systems.'
Labour Party justice spokesman Alan Kelly said the correspondence was 'extraordinary' and suggested Government recruitment plans 'are basically impossible'.
Mr Kelly said the letter was a 'slap in the face to Government, to the Minister for Justice, telling him the direction they're going in is not sufficient and is not going to work'.
In the annual letter, which is sent advising the likely financial requirements of the Garda, Ms Byrne also outlined 'structural weaknesses' in budgeting arrangements for the force, leading to bailouts to meet the cost of paying for overtime.
Annual overtime budgets as initially allocated are 'insufficient to run the organisation', she said. This is 'known to be insufficient' at the start of every year, she added, outlining that the 2025 budget was for €150 million, but the bill came to €200 million last year.
A PCSA spokesman said it noted concerns raised by the Policing Authority and that Garda numbers and workforce modernisation 'continue to be key challenges for An Garda Síochána [and] ... will be matters that the PCSA keeps under close review.'
In response, a Department of Justice spokesman said the Minister 'intends to deliver on the programme for government commitment to increase recruitment'.
He said the overall Garda workforce is higher than ever and that increased training allowances, a higher maximum entry age and retirement age have been introduced to boost recruitment and retention.
A dedicated group has been established to examine the issue, which is due to report in the coming weeks. A Garda recruitment campaign ran earlier this year and will be followed by a second one later in the year.
Some 370 trainees entered Templemore in March and June this year, said the spokesman.
'The Minister acknowledges the vital role of the Policing and Community Safety Authority ... as the statutory agency responsible for the oversight of An Garda Síochána, and welcomes the efforts of that organisation to support greater recruitment to and continuous improvement of policing services in Ireland.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
14 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Gang who smuggled €60m of cannabis into Ireland and Britain ‘dismantled', say Spanish police
A conspiracy to smuggle cannabis from Spain to Ireland inside bags of animal feed has been uncovered as part of a policing operation led by the Spanish police and involving gardaí and the UK's National Crime Agency (NCA). As well as 13 arrests in Spain following raids in Madrid, Malaga and Seville, one man was detained by An Garda Síochána in Co Louth. The volume of drugs moved through the network's smuggling routes, based on comments by Spain's Policia Nacional, are valued at about €60 million. Spanish police said that at their end of the operation, involving 12 searches, they also seized almost €100,000 in cash, 630 marijuana plants, a firearm and three detonators. READ MORE They also confiscated high-end vehicles and luxury watches and froze assets valued at about €2 million. Spanish police say they've carried out raids, arrested 13 people (video) re smuggling of cannabis to Ireland, since 2019, inside bags of animal feed Also one arrest in Ireland - Co Louth In Spain, crops of cannabis have been found, a gun, cash, assets seized etc — Conor Lally (@conormlally) The international policing operation started in January, resulting in arrests in Ireland and Spain and the seizure of 300kg of herbal cannabis valued at almost €6 million. Spanish authorities say herbal cannabis had been smuggled from Spain to Ireland and Britain since 2019. They said up to three tonnes of drugs have been shipped in monthly consignments over the past six years. The Policia Nacional said on Thursday its operation with the Garda and NCA had 'dismantled a criminal organisation that shipped marijuana to Ireland hidden in sacks of animal feed'. The international inquiry began when the smuggling operation was discovered in January and involved suspects from Spain, Ireland and Britain, it said. The herbal cannabis was hidden in the animal feed in Spain then transported to Ireland and Britain on pallets. International freight forwarders were used to arrange the logistics. The 12 searches in Spain involved armed police officers breaking their way into properties, carrying out searches and arresting suspects. There were 10 searches in Malaga, one in Seville, both southern Spain, and another in the capital Madrid. The Policia Nacional described the suspect arrested by the Garda in Co Louth as 'another person belonging to the criminal structure'. It was unclear when the arrest took place. As well as a semi-automatic pistol found in one of the searches in Spain, three blank-calibre pistols were also discovered with 11 vehicles and six luxury watches valued at more than €200,000. Electronic devices were also taken for analysis.
Irish Times
39 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Clonskeagh Imam Sheikh Hussein Halawa fails in High Court bid
Imam Sheikh Hussein Halawa, who has, among others, been locked out of the Islamic Cultural Centre in Clonskeagh, Dublin, since April, has been refused a High Court order requiring the Islamic Cultural Foundation of Ireland to restore him to aspects of his position and duties that do not require the chained-up mosque to be reopened. Ms Justice Leonie Reynolds instead made directions regarding the exchange of written evidence in the proceedings and put the matter back to mid-September. She also directed that the foundation address the health and safety concerns that had given rise to the closure of the mosque. Judge Reynolds told Mr Halawa's legal team he had seriously delayed in bringing the proceedings since the closure in April. Mediation talks had terminated on Wednesday and his application was being brought without proper notice to the foundation. The court also held that the request allowing Mr Halawa, who is 69 and approaching retirement, to perform duties outside the mosque had not been made through correspondence and the foundation had not had an opportunity to set out the reasons for the closure because it had not been served with papers backing up his application. READ MORE Barrister Niall O'Huiginn, for the Islamic Cultural Foundation, told Judge Reynolds that Mr Halawa's application was not an appropriate one to have been brought to court. He said he had not been involved in the mediation that had failed to deliver a successful outcome. He said there had been no evidence of urgency to have brought such an application during the legal vacation and Mr Halawa was continuing to be paid even though the mosque had been closed due to unfortunate circumstances. Cliona Kimber SC, for Mr Halawa, said her client was unable to minister to his parishioners and his reputation was being very publicly damaged. He had been left sitting at home without invitation to public ceremonies that included the President of Ireland, the Taoiseach and Government Ministers. Judge Reynolds said there was no reason why the parties could not decide to return to mediation to resolve the issues and she was concerned there may be an ongoing garda investigation. Mr O'Huiginn said certain incidents had certainly been reported to the gardaí. She said she was not disposed to granting interim injunctions to Mr Halawa and there were other avenues available to him such as defamation proceedings. She would afford the foundation to put in a replying affidavit to that of the plaintiff and a number of weeks and days for a further exchange of documents.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
John Hume's life provides lessons for addressing Palestine-Israel conflict
Having worked for and with the former leader of the SDLP , John Hume , I often get asked about how he might respond to the challenges of today. On the fifth anniversary of Hume's death, a new appreciation of the transformation he brought to the lives of so many offers space to consider how his political ethic and method could be used to address the appalling situation in the Middle East . In response to doubts, frustration and the emotional impact of atrocious events, Hume would revert to: 'If the underlying problem has not changed then the underlying solution has not changed.' He would stress that the dimensions of the problem had to be at least matched by the dimensions of any purported solution. Hume looked at problems through two lenses – rights and relationships. He also applied the light of responsibility to better discern salient issues and duties – both moral and legal – of agency. READ MORE He used the line 'you cannot be reconciled with someone whose boot is on your neck' to stress the essential requirement for the protection of rights, equal human dignity and respect for difference. [ John Hume: His life and times Opens in new window ] He would also allude to the maxim of Olof Palme that we cannot really be secure against each other, we can only achieve true security with each other. Such ethical instincts would, I believe, have guided (in his thinking prime) Hume's empathy, analysis and laser logic if looking at the dire suffering of Palestine today. Like others, he cautioned against superficially equating different situations and conditions of conflict but he would cite some comparable precepts. I think that Hume's strong lines on the global community's obligations of human solidarity and international law against Apartheid in South Africa would be amplified in the current context. (Kader Asmal acclaimed Hume's groundbreaking justification of sanctions against Apartheid South Africa as not just means of marking moral distance and/or trying to exert some economic leverage but also to manifest solidarity with the struggle for democracy in South Africa). If 'the underlying solution' that has not changed in the Middle East is a two-state solution, would that not have better chance of advancement if there was more semblance of a two-state process? The Hume-promoted schema for our peace process saw negotiations convened by both governments, deliberately inclusive of all parties, in an absence of violence, framed on three institutional strands, also addressing rights, equality and the valid democratic contest of legitimate constitutional preferences. That delivered an agreed outcome which spanned all those ambits even though different parties had rejected various inherent premises. It might be observed from Irish experience that qualitative 'givens' of a diplomatically desired solution gain better prospect of agreed outcome if they are insinuated as working givens of the negotiating process. Hume knew the folly of parties turning objectives into their preconditions. However, he strongly canvassed the conditioning value for dialogue of key affirmations by duly involved governments and authoritative indications from other international actors. Lateral interests leaning in supportively with valid, balanced and principled influence proved to be beneficent even though their motivation or modes were rejected or resented by given parties. Hume's dictum that 'the framework of the problem has to be matched by the framework for a solution' could usefully extend to include 'the framework of the process'. This can provide a distinctive accent on Ireland's cogent rationale for state recognition. It might be commended to a UK government which claims part credit for our Belfast Agreement. Recognising the state of Palestine is one way of other states leaning in to underscore a fundamental premise for a solution rooted in international law. [ Gaza is also a war on the human instinct for compassion Opens in new window ] Many tributes after Hume's death on August 3rd, 2020 recognised a resilient single-mindedness, both in repudiation of violence from any source and steadfast pursuit of political developments which could bring us out of the deepening rut of division and destructive conflict. However, Hume never really saw his work of leadership towards dialogue and agreement as a single-handed role or achievement. His Nobel Prize acceptance speech paid tribute to other party leaderships, both Irish and British governments – including successive administrations – US and EU support and the people's resilience. This showed an ethic that believed in the efficacy of dialogue and the value of inclusion underpinned by the compelling assertion of rights. That generous acknowledgment understandably sidestepped the frustrating and tragic reality that many of those parties had persistently repudiated his analysis of the 'three sets of relationships'; rejected his regard to the equal legitimacy of nationalist and unionist aspirations; dismissed the value or validity of signal engagement between the two governments; and/or resisted concepts around institutional democratic partnership and North-South political co-operation. All of these precepts – plus more that Hume had long espoused – were framed into the Belfast Agreement. Stones that wreckers had rejected from the builder had become the cornerstones. The agreement was capstoned by its overwhelming ratification in island-wide referendums: the form of articulated self-determination conceived by Hume to endorse a model of agreed Ireland that could allow further democratic change. [ From the archive: Nationalist leader who championed 'agreed Ireland' Opens in new window ] The Belfast Agreement embodies much more than a few days' word-craft from 'the hand of history' in April 1998. It compacted layers of understanding achieved in many earlier initiatives, events or efforts, including some tagged 'failed' in media commentary. Indeed more of its text is upcycled from earlier process drafts, previous documents or formal declarations than is often acknowledged. Perhaps in Beckett's spirit of 'Try again. Fail again. Fail better', numerous hands and strands should be credited for such milestones. Not for today a cast and credits list for such as Sunningdale, the New Ireland Forum, Anglo-Irish Agreement, Hume-Adams dialogue/papers, the Brooke/Mayhew talks, Downing Street Declaration, Forum for Peace and Reconciliation, framework documents, Mitchell principles, ground rules (renegotiated) for multi-party talks etc. The single common determinator in all these – and more – was Hume. His long pathfinding mission that entailed close collaboration with successive governments and serious engagement with his political counterparts also personally cultivated influential US involvements and harnessed EU relevance and effectiveness. That knack of purposeful partnership and productive rapport with other political and diplomatic players can be overlooked in some appraisals of his singular contribution. It was interactive as well as iterative. His constancy of robust analysis did allow for adjustment or refinement of argument, hearing other takes and refiling his ordered ideas. No account could exaggerate the partnership importance of his wife Pat Hume – an alchemist of optimism – to John's famous 'stickability'. [ John Hume: The mesmerising persuader the public rarely got to see Opens in new window ] Scanning today's wider political domain, it would be hard to speculate how a leader who used to warn us about the risks of 'falling into reacting to reaction' might cope in an age where prejudicial political communication sets agendas and narrows debate. A Denis Lehane line observes that people like sides, not subtleties. John Hume could both address sides and express subtleties in a way that few could match. If infective invective sets the heat and beat of polarising exchange rather than respectful, cooler, logical challenge, such signal leadership as Hume's will struggle for traction in what still passes for public discourse. Mark Durkan is a former leader of the SDLP and served as Northern Ireland's Deputy First Minister between 2001 and 2002.
