
Southport inquiry live: Mother saw CCTV of daughter being 'dragged back into building' - before being stabbed 20 more times
12:14:32
Inquiry ends
Now that we've heard all four impact statements, we're pausing our live coverage of the Southport inquiry.
The parents of survivors of the attack revealed the "untold stories" of how their "hero" children escaped - you can scroll down in this blog to read their statements.
The inquiry has now been adjourned until 8 September. Barrister Nicholas Moss says there is now a "great deal of critical work to be done".
"Nobody should think that this is now a summer break for the inquiry or legal teams," he says.
"The inquiry team will be continuing to work intensely for the rest of this month and August ahead of the resumption in September."
11:59:02
'Were people not kind to him?' Mother reveals daughter's empathy for attacker
The mother says she is "painfully aware" of how close she came to losing her daughter that day and in the days after.
She says she and her husband "have to second guess every moment to try and protect everyone" and "put massive scaffolding in place" to give their daughter some sense of normality.
She also describes how pointed knives have been removed from their home and swapped for blunt tipped ones.
"This doesn't remove the trauma though - we still don't use them, or have them in the cutlery drawer," she says.
"Life is full of constant triggers that we try to protect her and ourselves, from."
But sometimes the child "recalls the noise the knife made and the force that felt like punching".
"Her body shudders sporadically through the day and she looks at me," the mother says.
"I know that she's having a flashback and feeling it all over again.
"She does this often when she looks at her scars. Her scars are painful reminders of how brutally her body was violated."
The mother says she sometimes "gets mad" at herself for encouraging her daughter to accept the scars on her body.
"She didn't ask for them. They weren't put there through surgery, or something she had any say over, or understanding of. Her body was stolen from her," she says.
The mother says despite what her daughter carries "she manages to show incredible empathy and so much maturity in her thoughts of what happened that day".
She says: "She asks about the other girls and how everyone is coping. She tells me it's not my fault that she was there, and that she knows I'd just tried to plan something nice.
"It completely shatters me to hear that. She tries to understand how someone could do this, to children?"
And when it comes to the perpetrator, the mother says "some days she is able to hold so much empathy and space for what he perhaps was feeling or went through".
She adds: "What his life may have been like to do this. 'Did he have friends? Were people not kind to him?' She asks me, confused, 'Could he not talk to his parents if he had big feelings. Why did no one help him?'
"'How did he get the knife? Did his parents know? Why didn't he get stopped? Did the police know?'
"I am left to parent her through questions with impossibly difficult answers."
The mother says she hasn't found the words for these conversations yet, but that one day her daughter will learn the outcome of this inquiry and she is "terrified that it will be earth shattering for her and we will have to begin her recovery again".
11:52:06
Mother saw CCTV of daughter being 'dragged back into building' after trying to escape - before being stabbed 20 more times
C1's mother details how her daughter managed to briefly escape before she endured "another attack of more than twenty stab wounds to her back and shoulders".
This, she says, was captured on CCTV and shown at sentencing, where the court and public listened to the "horrific details of her injuries and were shown CCTV footage of her being dragged back into the building, after trying to escape".
"That is how she became known in this nightmare. The girl that was dragged back in," the mother says. "But she is so much more than that moment on CCTV."
The 'uncomfortable truth'
Wiping away tears, C1's mother says the "uncomfortable and often unspoken truth of our own reality is that, when the adults left in those first moments, our daughter had to save herself".
"It is these untold stories of remarkable strength and bravery that are missing when we have heard other accounts of this day. I think it is vitally important that those girls are now heard - so that the inquiry can understand the complexities of this experience for everyone."
11:45:01
Girl who shielded other children from danger was stabbed 33 times
The final impact statement is from the parents of C1, who say their daughter is a "beautiful, articulate, fun-loving little girl".
They say this inquiry "must bring meaningful, substantial change to ensure no child will ever share C1's experience again".
Recalling the moment of the attack, C1 told her parents that "she had tried to find a way out" of The Hart Space but was left "trapped and huddled with two other children" at the top of the stairs.
"She talks quietly of how she put her arms around the girls as he began to attack them," C1's mother explains.
"She tells me with such clarity that a moment came where one of the girls was able to get up, she put the girl's hand on the handrail and told her to go - to get down the stairs - and she did.
"The attack continued, she was still holding another girl, 'I crouched over the top of her', she says. 'I told her it would be okay'.
"She recalls this with such purpose and determination, like it was her responsibility. 'It happened so fast, but I helped them, I'm glad I could help them, mum,' she tells me."
11:34:01
Mother says daughter 'constantly scans people and places for danger'
Describing the impact the attack has had on her daughter, the mother in her statement says she is "still hypervigilant".
She says: "She must always know where the exits are. She constantly scans people and places for danger.
"One time she saw a newspaper in a shop with the perpetrator's photo in school uniform and since then groups of school children, especially older boys in uniform are a major trigger.
"We have been unable to get on public transport to and from school since September for this reason."
The mother also says her daughter's "sleep remains a huge issue".
She says C8 "struggles to fall asleep and it is often very late when she does".
"When she does she continues to suffer from frequent nightmares and wakes in distress," she says.
"Doctors visits are now traumatic, she is terrified of needles, the feeling of something sharp being close to her cannot be managed.
"She is hyper aware of people she doesn't know, and has expressed fear of men, particularly those who are black, influenced by the traumatic associations she made during the incident.
"This has led to difficult but necessary conversations about race."
The mother also says school has been a "real challenge" and she "often has to leave the classroom when overwhelmed or upset".
"She tells me her mind wanders during lessons, she has felt scared that something is going to happen and unable to focus," she says.
The mother says her daughter "was once an independent and joyful child" and she "now needs constant support, reassurance and protection".
"I have suffered from PTSD, flashbacks and anxiety. As well as insomnia, sleep paralysis and constant emotional exhaustion," she adds.
"For a long time every phone call sent me in to a panic. Therapy has helped me to cope better but I still have a long road ahead."
11:28:01
'That moment, the sound of fear in her voice and the panic I felt will never leave me'
We're now hearing from the mother of C8, who says she was "like any other seven-year-old little girl" before the attack.
"She had an incredible energy and was full of life. She was kind-hearted, always looking out for others, and especially sensitive to anyone being left out."
She says that day last July "changed everything" after what was meant to be "a fun way to start the summer holidays".
"I was at work when I received a panicked phone call from her friend's mum. She couldn't find C8 or her daughter. That moment, the sound of fear in her voice and the panic I felt will never leave me.
"I rushed to the scene and what I saw is something no parent should ever see. C8 had sustained serious physical injuries including a stab wound to her arm and a cut to her face and chin.
"She remembers the attack vividly - how he tried to get her face, how she saw other girls being hurt.
"She told me later she thought it had to be fake, because she couldn't believe something that terrible could really be happening."
'She couldn't even go into the toilet alone'
In the aftermath, C8's mother says she cannot be left alone and only feels safe with immediate family or very close friends.
"Where she was once eager to go off with her friends, she now needs my support if it is somewhere public or unknown. Simple days out now need a level of safety planning that we would never have considered before.
"Immediately after the incident, C8 could not even go into the toilet at home alone. She had heard someone say he had gone into the toilets and whilst we know that to not be true, her fear was real."
11:23:01
'Some days continue to feel so difficult'
The statement goes on to say changes have been made at school and child Q now sits where she can see the door so she can always be aware of who is entering the classroom.
On a few occasions, Q has been unable to attend school due to her anxiety, explaining this as her "tummy feels funny and hiding under the dining table at home".
Regular therapy sessions were arranged for the child through victim support and she was "able to build a strong relationship with her caseworker and felt confident enough to talk openly about her emotions and worries".
In her statement, the mother says her daughter "is continuing to move forward".
"I too have had regular therapy sessions since the incident; this is currently ongoing," she explains.
The mother says she initially took some time off work to support Q and has since changed her job role to one that fits more with school hours so she can be there for her child.
"Some days continue to feel so difficult, trying to process everything happening around us.
"There were times when I didn't know which way to turn."
She goes on to describe her daughter as a "strong, brave and beautiful little girl who has so much love and support around her to get her through the tough days".
11:20:01
'How will I ever be normal again?'
The inquiry resumes with an impact statement written by the mother of Child Q and read out by a representative of the family.
She says that Child Q has always been an "anxious little girl" who "struggled socially", especially outside school.
This made her attendance at the Southport dance class a "significant step for her", her mother writes.
"It took a great deal of encouragement on our part to help her feel confident enough to go. She went into the venue feeling happy and I remember leaving with a sense of pride knowing that she had overcome the initial worries that she had felt."
She then writes that witnessing children "running from the building, screaming and fearing for their lives" was "the most horrific experience of my life".
"What I saw on that day will stick with me forever, I constantly have flashbacks and re-live what happened."
She writes that her daughter has become "very withdrawn" since the attack and has asked her parents, "How will I ever be normal again?"
"She is even more anxious about not being with us or being dropped off at another event without us. She is scared when she hears a siren or sees an emergency vehicle.
"She is still unable to sleep alone and struggles with falling asleep. She always asks for doors to be closed when we enter or leave a room, this helps her to feel safe."
11:04:01
'Our daughter is our hero'
Addressing the impact of the attack, the father of C3 says his daughter still "bears the scars, both physically and emotionally, of that terrible day".
"We know that she is only a small way down the path that life will take her, and that obstacles will continue to present themselves along the way," he says.
He says his daughter has had difficulty going to sleep at night, a fear of loud noises, that she experiences flashbacks of the attack and feels the need to look over her shoulder scanning for potential danger when she leaves the house.
"Life is certainly not like it was before," he adds. "Some days are good, and others less so.
"We remain a strong family unit, but dealing with what happened that day has been unbelievably challenging for every member of our family."
He says that despite what C3 has been through, she remains "the positive, caring, funny, enthusiastic, courageous girl she always was".
"She has no self-pity about what happened to her. She wears her scars with a dignity and defiance that is remarkable. We have said from the beginning that this trauma will not define our daughter."
He adds: "We couldn't be prouder of her. She is our hero."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


North Wales Chronicle
15 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Councils consider legal bids as ministers face Epping hotel ruling aftermath
Ministers are now bracing for further legal challenges from councils after Epping Forest District Council was granted a temporary injunction by the High Court on Tuesday. The ruling blocks asylum seekers from being housed at the Bell Hotel in the Essex town, and current residents must be removed by September 12. On Wednesday, some Conservative and Reform UK-led authorities said they were looking at their options to take similar action. Conservative-run Broxbourne Council in Hertfordshire has said it was taking legal advice 'as a matter of urgency', while Tory-run East Lindsey District Council in Lincolnshire said officers are investigating and 'will take appropriate action'. Reform UK-led councils, West Northamptonshire Council and Staffordshire County Council, also said the authorities would look at the options available after the High Court ruling. When Robert Jenrick was immigration minister he grew the number of illegal migrants living in free hotels to 56,000. He is no friend of Epping. — Nigel Farage MP (@Nigel_Farage) August 20, 2025 Ian Cooper, leader of Staffordshire County Council, said: 'The control and protection of our country's borders is a national issue, but the impact of central government policy is felt in communities across Staffordshire.' It comes as Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has indicated that councils run by his party will consider their own legal challenges. However, a number of these councils do not have responsibility for planning permission, which may limit their ability to launch legal challenges. Epping Forest District Council had asked a judge to issue an interim injunction stopping migrants from being accommodated at the Bell Hotel after it had been at the centre of protests in recent weeks. The demonstrations came after an asylum seeker, who was staying there, was charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl. He denies the charge and is due to stand trial later this month. The Home Office had warned the judge that an injunction could 'interfere' with the department's legal obligations, and lawyers representing the hotel's owner argued it would set a 'precedent'. Reacting to the ruling on Wednesday, security minister Dan Jarvis told Times Radio: 'We're looking at a range of different contingency options following from a legal ruling that took place yesterday, and we'll look closely at what we're able to do.' Asked whether other migrant hotels have the proper planning permission, Mr Jarvis said: 'Well, we'll see over the next few days and weeks. 'Other local authorities will be considering whether they wish to act in the same way that Epping (Forest) District Council have. A STATEMENT FROM NIGEL FARAGE This is a victory for the parents and concerned residents of Epping. They do not want their young women being assaulted on the streets. This community stood up bravely, despite being slandered as far right, and have won. They represent the vast… — Nigel Farage MP (@Nigel_Farage) August 19, 2025 'I think the important point to make is that nobody really thinks that hotels are a sustainable location to accommodate asylum seekers. 'That's precisely why the Government has made a commitment that, by the end of this Parliament, we would have phased out the use of them.' On Wednesday shadow home secretary Chris Philp also pressed ministers not to re-house the asylum seekers at the Bell Hotel into other hotels or flats 'sorely needed by young people'. In a letter to Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Mr Philp wrote: 'Up and down the country people are furious about the number of illegal migrants being housed in hotels – which rose in the nine months following the election under Labour. Following the ruling in Epping and the ongoing migrant crisis I have written to Yvette Cooper calling for: 1. An emergency cabinet meeting (they had one for recognising Palestine recently) to bring forward plans for the immediate deportation of all illegal immigrants upon… — Chris Philp MP (@CPhilpOfficial) August 20, 2025 'People are also concerned that you are now moving people from hotels into apartments and other accommodation which is sorely needed by young people here who are struggling under this Labour Government.' The Conservative MP also called for an emergency Cabinet meeting to set up plans to deport migrants crossing the Channel on arrival. Meanwhile Mr Farage has called for peaceful protests outside hotels housing asylum seekers to put pressure on local authorities to take the same route as Epping Forest. Writing in The Telegraph, he said: 'Now the good people of Epping must inspire similar protests around Britain. 'Wherever people are concerned about the threat posed by young undocumented males living in local hotels and who are free to walk their streets, they should follow the example of the town in Essex. 'Let's hold peaceful protests outside the migrant hotels, and put pressure on local councils to go to court to try and get the illegal immigrants out; we now know that together we can win.' Our work with international partners is vital to stopping small boat crossings to the UK. A joint intelligence unit involving the @NCA_UK and French counterparts has helped dismantle at least 52 organised immigration crime gangs operating in France. — Home Office (@ukhomeoffice) August 17, 2025 The latest Home Office data showed there were 32,345 asylum seekers being housed temporarily in UK hotels at the end of March. This was down 15% from the end of December, when the total was 38,079, and 6% lower than the 34,530 at the same point a year earlier. New figures – published among the usual quarterly immigration data release – are expected on Thursday, showing numbers in hotels at the end of June. Figures for hotels published by the Home Office date back to December 2022 and showed numbers hit a peak at the end of September 2023 when there were 56,042 asylum seekers in hotels.

Rhyl Journal
15 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Councils consider legal bids as ministers face Epping hotel ruling aftermath
Ministers are now bracing for further legal challenges from councils after Epping Forest District Council was granted a temporary injunction by the High Court on Tuesday. The ruling blocks asylum seekers from being housed at the Bell Hotel in the Essex town, and current residents must be removed by September 12. On Wednesday, some Conservative and Reform UK-led authorities said they were looking at their options to take similar action. Conservative-run Broxbourne Council in Hertfordshire has said it was taking legal advice 'as a matter of urgency', while Tory-run East Lindsey District Council in Lincolnshire said officers are investigating and 'will take appropriate action'. Reform UK-led councils, West Northamptonshire Council and Staffordshire County Council, also said the authorities would look at the options available after the High Court ruling. When Robert Jenrick was immigration minister he grew the number of illegal migrants living in free hotels to 56,000. He is no friend of Epping. — Nigel Farage MP (@Nigel_Farage) August 20, 2025 Ian Cooper, leader of Staffordshire County Council, said: 'The control and protection of our country's borders is a national issue, but the impact of central government policy is felt in communities across Staffordshire.' It comes as Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has indicated that councils run by his party will consider their own legal challenges. However, a number of these councils do not have responsibility for planning permission, which may limit their ability to launch legal challenges. Epping Forest District Council had asked a judge to issue an interim injunction stopping migrants from being accommodated at the Bell Hotel after it had been at the centre of protests in recent weeks. The demonstrations came after an asylum seeker, who was staying there, was charged with sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl. He denies the charge and is due to stand trial later this month. The Home Office had warned the judge that an injunction could 'interfere' with the department's legal obligations, and lawyers representing the hotel's owner argued it would set a 'precedent'. Reacting to the ruling on Wednesday, security minister Dan Jarvis told Times Radio: 'We're looking at a range of different contingency options following from a legal ruling that took place yesterday, and we'll look closely at what we're able to do.' Asked whether other migrant hotels have the proper planning permission, Mr Jarvis said: 'Well, we'll see over the next few days and weeks. 'Other local authorities will be considering whether they wish to act in the same way that Epping (Forest) District Council have. A STATEMENT FROM NIGEL FARAGE This is a victory for the parents and concerned residents of Epping. They do not want their young women being assaulted on the streets. This community stood up bravely, despite being slandered as far right, and have won. They represent the vast… — Nigel Farage MP (@Nigel_Farage) August 19, 2025 'I think the important point to make is that nobody really thinks that hotels are a sustainable location to accommodate asylum seekers. 'That's precisely why the Government has made a commitment that, by the end of this Parliament, we would have phased out the use of them.' On Wednesday shadow home secretary Chris Philp also pressed ministers not to re-house the asylum seekers at the Bell Hotel into other hotels or flats 'sorely needed by young people'. In a letter to Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Mr Philp wrote: 'Up and down the country people are furious about the number of illegal migrants being housed in hotels – which rose in the nine months following the election under Labour. Following the ruling in Epping and the ongoing migrant crisis I have written to Yvette Cooper calling for: 1. An emergency cabinet meeting (they had one for recognising Palestine recently) to bring forward plans for the immediate deportation of all illegal immigrants upon… — Chris Philp MP (@CPhilpOfficial) August 20, 2025 'People are also concerned that you are now moving people from hotels into apartments and other accommodation which is sorely needed by young people here who are struggling under this Labour Government.' The Conservative MP also called for an emergency Cabinet meeting to set up plans to deport migrants crossing the Channel on arrival. Meanwhile Mr Farage has called for peaceful protests outside hotels housing asylum seekers to put pressure on local authorities to take the same route as Epping Forest. Writing in The Telegraph, he said: 'Now the good people of Epping must inspire similar protests around Britain. 'Wherever people are concerned about the threat posed by young undocumented males living in local hotels and who are free to walk their streets, they should follow the example of the town in Essex. 'Let's hold peaceful protests outside the migrant hotels, and put pressure on local councils to go to court to try and get the illegal immigrants out; we now know that together we can win.' Our work with international partners is vital to stopping small boat crossings to the UK. A joint intelligence unit involving the @NCA_UK and French counterparts has helped dismantle at least 52 organised immigration crime gangs operating in France. — Home Office (@ukhomeoffice) August 17, 2025 The latest Home Office data showed there were 32,345 asylum seekers being housed temporarily in UK hotels at the end of March. This was down 15% from the end of December, when the total was 38,079, and 6% lower than the 34,530 at the same point a year earlier. New figures – published among the usual quarterly immigration data release – are expected on Thursday, showing numbers in hotels at the end of June. Figures for hotels published by the Home Office date back to December 2022 and showed numbers hit a peak at the end of September 2023 when there were 56,042 asylum seekers in hotels.


The Independent
15 minutes ago
- The Independent
Vicar who led rave-style ‘cult' in Church of England found guilty of assaulting female followers
A former priest accused of leading a rave-style evangelical cult in the Church of England has been found guilty of sexually assaulting his female followers. A trial heard Christopher Brain, who led the progressive Nine O-Clock Service (NOS) in Sheffield in the 80s and 90s, surrounded himself with women who wore lingerie or revealing clothes as part of his 'homebase team' who kept his house 'spotlessly clean'. The court heard the women – sometimes referred to as 'the Lycra Lovelies' or 'the Lycra Nuns' – were on a rota to help then-Reverend Brain with his every need. Some gave him 'sensual' massages which he told the jury were to relieve tension headaches. He was charged with one count of rape and 36 counts of indecent assault relating to 13 women between 1981 and 1995. On Wednesday, jurors at Inner London Crown Court found him guilty of 17 counts of indecent assault against nine women. However he was acquitted of another 15 charges of indecent assault against two women. The jury is still deliberating the rape charge and four further counts of indecent assault. The six-week trial heard how Brain, 68, was praised by the Archbishop of Canterbury after his 'club culture' inspired services at St Thomas' Church in Crookes, Sheffield, and later Ponds Forge leisure centre, drew hundreds of young congregants. He was fast tracked for Holy Orders as the movement took off, but it collapsed in controversy in 1995 after women alleged their charismatic leader had been sexually assaulting them, in some cases claiming he was helping to heal their sexual repression. Prosecutor Tim Clark KC told the court he 'abused his position first as a leader and then as an ordained priest to sexually assault a staggering number of women'. When Brain was first confronted over claims he had abused up to 40 women, he replied: 'I thought it was more,' the court heard. Mr Clark said NOS became a cult in which members, who were vetted and organised into 'discipleship' groups, were isolated from their friends and families. 'Members of NOS became utterly dependent on NOS and desperate for the attention and praise of the defendant,' he added. 'They were encouraged to give up their time, finances and, eventually, their sense of self to this organisation and its leader.' One woman who first joined the church as a teenager said she viewed Brain as a 'form of prophet' who told her their contact was part of her 'sexual healing'. 'She found it impossible to leave, she made an effort one time but was talked out of it,' Mr Clark said. 'She describes becoming severely depressed. She stated that she engaged in the sexual activity, or more precisely submitted to it occurring, in order to survive.' Another woman said she 'viewed him as almost a God'. The prosecutor said Brain would suddenly appear in the lives of female members of NOS, often picking them up in his car whilst they were walking along. Women who did not keep the defendant happy would find themselves estranged from the group, he added. One female congregant, who believes she was 'brainwashed' by the priest, alleged he invited her to his home while his wife was away in 1983 or 1984, where he pinned her down and raped her. She told the jury she was moving her head 'from side to side' and 'saying no', adding: 'I couldn't get him off me.' Another woman said she had to be available to 'put him to bed'. On those occasions, he would undress and rub himself against her as she massaged him while wearing only her underwear, the court heard. Mr Clark said: 'She described going into a 'robotic' state doing this, she dreaded receiving his phone calls.' The jury was told Brain admitted to 'improper sexual conduct with a number of women' in the church in a bombshell 1995 BBC documentary, but denied this was abuse. He resigned from Holy Orders the same year. Giving evidence in his defence, Brain admitted he received back massages from women in the movement despite being married with a young child. Asked by his lawyer, Iain Simkins KC, 'what on earth possessed you to have a back massage from another woman', he responded: 'Why not?' He told the jury he suffered from 'terrible' tension headaches. He said people in the homebase team, formed to free up his time to take the religious movement on the road, were 'personal friends' and the massages were not part of their duties. He admitted to having sexual contact with up to six of his accusers, but insisted it was consensual. Some of the other alleged assaults simply did not happen, he claimed. He told the jury, 'I was the most radical ordained vicar there was' as he defended his actions, adding: 'I wasn't a traditional vicar, I was someone on a journey of radical research and experimentation.' He insisted NOS was a 'free, open, really caring, very fun environment' and as they started to develop their own theology around 1990, some members became interested in tantric celibacy. He added: "With some of my closest friends, it would be kissing sometimes, occasionally massaging, stroking. Anything more than that, we would back off.'