
'Felt like forever': pilot details crash scene at trial
Michael Burbidge, pilot and director of Remote Helicopters, gave evidence at Wright's trial in the Supreme Court in Darwin on Friday.
The Crown has alleged Wright wanted to look behind the console to check if the Hobbs flight-hour recording meter was disconnected.
It's alleged Wright and his pilots regularly disconnected the meters to extend helicopter flying hours beyond official thresholds and falsified logbooks and maintenance releases.
Mr Wilson was in a sling under a helicopter on a crocodile egg collecting mission when it crashed on February 28, 2022, killing him and injuring pilot Sebastian Robinson, who is now a paraplegic.
Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice following the February 2022 crash in a remote part of Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory.
The crown case is that Wright did not properly record helicopter flying hours and was concerned crash investigators would uncover the issue.
Crown prosecutor Jason Gullaci SC has told the jury the charges did not relate to the cause of the accident and it was not alleged Wright was responsible for the crash or death.
Mr Burbidge, flying his own helicopter for egg collecting, was first at the crash scene after contact was lost with Mr Robinson's chopper.
He told the jury he landed near the crash site to find Mr Wilson dead and Mr Robinson critically injured.
He said he was on the scene for maybe an hour before other pilots and egg collectors arrived but "it felt like forever".
Wright later flew in on his chopper with then police officer Neil Mellon, who removed items from Mr Wilson's body, including his phone and a handgun.
Mr Burbidge said he was given the mobile and said to Mr Mellon "Dani doesn't need to see what's on the phone", referring to Mr Wilson's partner Dani Wilson.
He agreed he had "ditched" the phone on his way home.
Mr Burbidge told the court he was later charged and fined for disposing of the phone after pleading guilty.
He said he had no recollection of inspecting the crashed chopper's fuel tank or detaching the console with Wright.
He said he did not disconnect Hobbs meters, but he had heard of the practice.
The court was played a covertly recorded phone call in which Mr Burbidge told Wright he had heard there had been "shit written" in a chopper's logbook saying "clock found disconnected again".
Mr Burbidge told Mr Gullaci the August 2022 call was just between friends about a rumour and he was concerned about putting the records right.
Defence barrister David Edwardson KC has told the jury Wright had engaged in disconnecting Hobbs meters and it was common practice in the NT helicopter industry.
The practice is said by the prosecution to be the motive for his client's alleged offending but Wright "emphatically denied" it, Mr Edwardson said.
Timothy Luck, who worked for Wright in 2022 as an egg collector, told the court on Friday he had flown in Wright's choppers that had their Hobbs meters disconnected.
Mr Luck said he had once seen Mr Robinson working under a helicopter's dashboard to disconnect the meter as Mr Wilson jokingly pretended to take a photograph of him.
The court has heard disputed evidence about whether the helicopter had run out of fuel when it crashed but Mr Luck, who was on the same egg-collecting mission, said he couldn't believe that.
"I know that that helicopter didn't run out of fuel ... because I filled that to the top about 20 minutes prior," he said.
Mr Edwardson said Wright "emphatically denied" trying to get Mr Robinson to falsify flight records or telling an associate to "torch" a maintenance release.
The trial before acting Justice Allan Blow is expected to take up to five weeks.
A bush pilot says he can't recall helping reality TV star Matt Wright look under the dashboard of a helicopter that had just crashed, killing Outback Wrangler's Chris "Willow" Wilson.
Michael Burbidge, pilot and director of Remote Helicopters, gave evidence at Wright's trial in the Supreme Court in Darwin on Friday.
The Crown has alleged Wright wanted to look behind the console to check if the Hobbs flight-hour recording meter was disconnected.
It's alleged Wright and his pilots regularly disconnected the meters to extend helicopter flying hours beyond official thresholds and falsified logbooks and maintenance releases.
Mr Wilson was in a sling under a helicopter on a crocodile egg collecting mission when it crashed on February 28, 2022, killing him and injuring pilot Sebastian Robinson, who is now a paraplegic.
Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice following the February 2022 crash in a remote part of Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory.
The crown case is that Wright did not properly record helicopter flying hours and was concerned crash investigators would uncover the issue.
Crown prosecutor Jason Gullaci SC has told the jury the charges did not relate to the cause of the accident and it was not alleged Wright was responsible for the crash or death.
Mr Burbidge, flying his own helicopter for egg collecting, was first at the crash scene after contact was lost with Mr Robinson's chopper.
He told the jury he landed near the crash site to find Mr Wilson dead and Mr Robinson critically injured.
He said he was on the scene for maybe an hour before other pilots and egg collectors arrived but "it felt like forever".
Wright later flew in on his chopper with then police officer Neil Mellon, who removed items from Mr Wilson's body, including his phone and a handgun.
Mr Burbidge said he was given the mobile and said to Mr Mellon "Dani doesn't need to see what's on the phone", referring to Mr Wilson's partner Dani Wilson.
He agreed he had "ditched" the phone on his way home.
Mr Burbidge told the court he was later charged and fined for disposing of the phone after pleading guilty.
He said he had no recollection of inspecting the crashed chopper's fuel tank or detaching the console with Wright.
He said he did not disconnect Hobbs meters, but he had heard of the practice.
The court was played a covertly recorded phone call in which Mr Burbidge told Wright he had heard there had been "shit written" in a chopper's logbook saying "clock found disconnected again".
Mr Burbidge told Mr Gullaci the August 2022 call was just between friends about a rumour and he was concerned about putting the records right.
Defence barrister David Edwardson KC has told the jury Wright had engaged in disconnecting Hobbs meters and it was common practice in the NT helicopter industry.
The practice is said by the prosecution to be the motive for his client's alleged offending but Wright "emphatically denied" it, Mr Edwardson said.
Timothy Luck, who worked for Wright in 2022 as an egg collector, told the court on Friday he had flown in Wright's choppers that had their Hobbs meters disconnected.
Mr Luck said he had once seen Mr Robinson working under a helicopter's dashboard to disconnect the meter as Mr Wilson jokingly pretended to take a photograph of him.
The court has heard disputed evidence about whether the helicopter had run out of fuel when it crashed but Mr Luck, who was on the same egg-collecting mission, said he couldn't believe that.
"I know that that helicopter didn't run out of fuel ... because I filled that to the top about 20 minutes prior," he said.
Mr Edwardson said Wright "emphatically denied" trying to get Mr Robinson to falsify flight records or telling an associate to "torch" a maintenance release.
The trial before acting Justice Allan Blow is expected to take up to five weeks.
A bush pilot says he can't recall helping reality TV star Matt Wright look under the dashboard of a helicopter that had just crashed, killing Outback Wrangler's Chris "Willow" Wilson.
Michael Burbidge, pilot and director of Remote Helicopters, gave evidence at Wright's trial in the Supreme Court in Darwin on Friday.
The Crown has alleged Wright wanted to look behind the console to check if the Hobbs flight-hour recording meter was disconnected.
It's alleged Wright and his pilots regularly disconnected the meters to extend helicopter flying hours beyond official thresholds and falsified logbooks and maintenance releases.
Mr Wilson was in a sling under a helicopter on a crocodile egg collecting mission when it crashed on February 28, 2022, killing him and injuring pilot Sebastian Robinson, who is now a paraplegic.
Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice following the February 2022 crash in a remote part of Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory.
The crown case is that Wright did not properly record helicopter flying hours and was concerned crash investigators would uncover the issue.
Crown prosecutor Jason Gullaci SC has told the jury the charges did not relate to the cause of the accident and it was not alleged Wright was responsible for the crash or death.
Mr Burbidge, flying his own helicopter for egg collecting, was first at the crash scene after contact was lost with Mr Robinson's chopper.
He told the jury he landed near the crash site to find Mr Wilson dead and Mr Robinson critically injured.
He said he was on the scene for maybe an hour before other pilots and egg collectors arrived but "it felt like forever".
Wright later flew in on his chopper with then police officer Neil Mellon, who removed items from Mr Wilson's body, including his phone and a handgun.
Mr Burbidge said he was given the mobile and said to Mr Mellon "Dani doesn't need to see what's on the phone", referring to Mr Wilson's partner Dani Wilson.
He agreed he had "ditched" the phone on his way home.
Mr Burbidge told the court he was later charged and fined for disposing of the phone after pleading guilty.
He said he had no recollection of inspecting the crashed chopper's fuel tank or detaching the console with Wright.
He said he did not disconnect Hobbs meters, but he had heard of the practice.
The court was played a covertly recorded phone call in which Mr Burbidge told Wright he had heard there had been "shit written" in a chopper's logbook saying "clock found disconnected again".
Mr Burbidge told Mr Gullaci the August 2022 call was just between friends about a rumour and he was concerned about putting the records right.
Defence barrister David Edwardson KC has told the jury Wright had engaged in disconnecting Hobbs meters and it was common practice in the NT helicopter industry.
The practice is said by the prosecution to be the motive for his client's alleged offending but Wright "emphatically denied" it, Mr Edwardson said.
Timothy Luck, who worked for Wright in 2022 as an egg collector, told the court on Friday he had flown in Wright's choppers that had their Hobbs meters disconnected.
Mr Luck said he had once seen Mr Robinson working under a helicopter's dashboard to disconnect the meter as Mr Wilson jokingly pretended to take a photograph of him.
The court has heard disputed evidence about whether the helicopter had run out of fuel when it crashed but Mr Luck, who was on the same egg-collecting mission, said he couldn't believe that.
"I know that that helicopter didn't run out of fuel ... because I filled that to the top about 20 minutes prior," he said.
Mr Edwardson said Wright "emphatically denied" trying to get Mr Robinson to falsify flight records or telling an associate to "torch" a maintenance release.
The trial before acting Justice Allan Blow is expected to take up to five weeks.
A bush pilot says he can't recall helping reality TV star Matt Wright look under the dashboard of a helicopter that had just crashed, killing Outback Wrangler's Chris "Willow" Wilson.
Michael Burbidge, pilot and director of Remote Helicopters, gave evidence at Wright's trial in the Supreme Court in Darwin on Friday.
The Crown has alleged Wright wanted to look behind the console to check if the Hobbs flight-hour recording meter was disconnected.
It's alleged Wright and his pilots regularly disconnected the meters to extend helicopter flying hours beyond official thresholds and falsified logbooks and maintenance releases.
Mr Wilson was in a sling under a helicopter on a crocodile egg collecting mission when it crashed on February 28, 2022, killing him and injuring pilot Sebastian Robinson, who is now a paraplegic.
Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice following the February 2022 crash in a remote part of Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory.
The crown case is that Wright did not properly record helicopter flying hours and was concerned crash investigators would uncover the issue.
Crown prosecutor Jason Gullaci SC has told the jury the charges did not relate to the cause of the accident and it was not alleged Wright was responsible for the crash or death.
Mr Burbidge, flying his own helicopter for egg collecting, was first at the crash scene after contact was lost with Mr Robinson's chopper.
He told the jury he landed near the crash site to find Mr Wilson dead and Mr Robinson critically injured.
He said he was on the scene for maybe an hour before other pilots and egg collectors arrived but "it felt like forever".
Wright later flew in on his chopper with then police officer Neil Mellon, who removed items from Mr Wilson's body, including his phone and a handgun.
Mr Burbidge said he was given the mobile and said to Mr Mellon "Dani doesn't need to see what's on the phone", referring to Mr Wilson's partner Dani Wilson.
He agreed he had "ditched" the phone on his way home.
Mr Burbidge told the court he was later charged and fined for disposing of the phone after pleading guilty.
He said he had no recollection of inspecting the crashed chopper's fuel tank or detaching the console with Wright.
He said he did not disconnect Hobbs meters, but he had heard of the practice.
The court was played a covertly recorded phone call in which Mr Burbidge told Wright he had heard there had been "shit written" in a chopper's logbook saying "clock found disconnected again".
Mr Burbidge told Mr Gullaci the August 2022 call was just between friends about a rumour and he was concerned about putting the records right.
Defence barrister David Edwardson KC has told the jury Wright had engaged in disconnecting Hobbs meters and it was common practice in the NT helicopter industry.
The practice is said by the prosecution to be the motive for his client's alleged offending but Wright "emphatically denied" it, Mr Edwardson said.
Timothy Luck, who worked for Wright in 2022 as an egg collector, told the court on Friday he had flown in Wright's choppers that had their Hobbs meters disconnected.
Mr Luck said he had once seen Mr Robinson working under a helicopter's dashboard to disconnect the meter as Mr Wilson jokingly pretended to take a photograph of him.
The court has heard disputed evidence about whether the helicopter had run out of fuel when it crashed but Mr Luck, who was on the same egg-collecting mission, said he couldn't believe that.
"I know that that helicopter didn't run out of fuel ... because I filled that to the top about 20 minutes prior," he said.
Mr Edwardson said Wright "emphatically denied" trying to get Mr Robinson to falsify flight records or telling an associate to "torch" a maintenance release.
The trial before acting Justice Allan Blow is expected to take up to five weeks.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

ABC News
2 hours ago
- ABC News
Pilot to give evidence in trial of crocodile wrangler
The pilot who survived a fatal helicopter accident in February 2022 which claimed the life of Chris "Willow" Wilson, is expected to give evidence today in the Supreme Court trial of celebrity crocodile wrangler, Matt Wright. Mr Wright has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice for his alleged interference with an investigation into the crash. The pilot - Sebastian Robinson - survived the accident but sustained lifelong injuries.


Perth Now
13 hours ago
- Perth Now
Judge ruled to split Patterson trial to avoid prejudice
Triple murderer Erin Patterson would have been unfairly prejudiced if a jury heard allegations she tried to kill her ex-husband in the years before a deadly mushroom lunch. Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale made the decision on March 14, ruling Patterson would have to face a separate trial for the three attempted murder offences. Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges in relation to Simon Patterson just before the triple-murder trial started in Morwell. Patterson was on July 7 found guilty of killing Simon's parents, Don and Gail, 70, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, along with the attempted murder of her husband Ian Wilkinson. Justice Beale's redacted pre-trial rulings were released to media on Monday evening after Patterson lost her bid to keep the evidence a secret to preserve her appeal rights. The details around the alleged attempted murders of Simon Patterson were revealed for the first time on Friday. Prosecutors had alleged Patterson tried to poison Simon several times between 2021 and 2022. The first was a penne pasta Patterson cooked him before leaving for a camping trip in November 2021, which led to a five-day hospital stay for Simon. He also ended up in a coma after a camping trip in late May 2022 where he allegedly ate a chicken korma curry Patterson had made him. Simon had to undergo surgery to remove a large portion of his bowel after eating the curry, he told the Supreme Court during pre-trial hearings. It was also alleged he fell ill in September 2022 after eating a wrap Patterson prepared for him while camping together at Wilsons Promontory. The prosecution claimed the allegations could be used as coincidence evidence to show the similarities between what allegedly happened to Simon and the mushroom lunch guests. But Justice Beale ruled the charges should be heard in a separate trial to prevent jurors from "misusing or overvaluing" the evidence in relation to Simon. He determined if a jury found Patterson had deliberately poisoned her four lunch guests in July 2023, there was a risk they would wrongly assess the charges relating to Simon. "I am not persuaded that its probative value substantially outweighs the significant danger or risk of unfair prejudice to the accused," Justice Beale said in his written reasons. The judge also made pre-trial rulings in relation to documents about poisoning found on devices police seized from Patterson's home. Justice Beale ruled the documents failed the relevance test because the evidence could only go as high as Patterson possibly accessed the file. The judge also stopped the jury from seeing a Facebook post Patterson made to a poisons page, where she claimed her cat had chewed on a mushroom and was vomiting. Justice Beale noted the post was made 18 months before the first allegation in relation to Simon. "In my view, even if the evidence of this post shows an interest in poisons, it is temporally remote," the judge said in his reasons. Patterson will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing later in August, during which she will listen to statements from the Pattersons and Wilkinsons. She will have 28 days to appeal after she is sentenced.


The Advertiser
13 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Judge ruled to split Patterson trial to avoid prejudice
Triple murderer Erin Patterson would have been unfairly prejudiced if a jury heard allegations she tried to kill her ex-husband in the years before a deadly mushroom lunch. Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale made the decision on March 14, ruling Patterson would have to face a separate trial for the three attempted murder offences. Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges in relation to Simon Patterson just before the triple-murder trial started in Morwell. Patterson was on July 7 found guilty of killing Simon's parents, Don and Gail, 70, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, along with the attempted murder of her husband Ian Wilkinson. Justice Beale's redacted pre-trial rulings were released to media on Monday evening after Patterson lost her bid to keep the evidence a secret to preserve her appeal rights. The details around the alleged attempted murders of Simon Patterson were revealed for the first time on Friday. Prosecutors had alleged Patterson tried to poison Simon several times between 2021 and 2022. The first was a penne pasta Patterson cooked him before leaving for a camping trip in November 2021, which led to a five-day hospital stay for Simon. He also ended up in a coma after a camping trip in late May 2022 where he allegedly ate a chicken korma curry Patterson had made him. Simon had to undergo surgery to remove a large portion of his bowel after eating the curry, he told the Supreme Court during pre-trial hearings. It was also alleged he fell ill in September 2022 after eating a wrap Patterson prepared for him while camping together at Wilsons Promontory. The prosecution claimed the allegations could be used as coincidence evidence to show the similarities between what allegedly happened to Simon and the mushroom lunch guests. But Justice Beale ruled the charges should be heard in a separate trial to prevent jurors from "misusing or overvaluing" the evidence in relation to Simon. He determined if a jury found Patterson had deliberately poisoned her four lunch guests in July 2023, there was a risk they would wrongly assess the charges relating to Simon. "I am not persuaded that its probative value substantially outweighs the significant danger or risk of unfair prejudice to the accused," Justice Beale said in his written reasons. The judge also made pre-trial rulings in relation to documents about poisoning found on devices police seized from Patterson's home. Justice Beale ruled the documents failed the relevance test because the evidence could only go as high as Patterson possibly accessed the file. The judge also stopped the jury from seeing a Facebook post Patterson made to a poisons page, where she claimed her cat had chewed on a mushroom and was vomiting. Justice Beale noted the post was made 18 months before the first allegation in relation to Simon. "In my view, even if the evidence of this post shows an interest in poisons, it is temporally remote," the judge said in his reasons. Patterson will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing later in August, during which she will listen to statements from the Pattersons and Wilkinsons. She will have 28 days to appeal after she is sentenced. Triple murderer Erin Patterson would have been unfairly prejudiced if a jury heard allegations she tried to kill her ex-husband in the years before a deadly mushroom lunch. Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale made the decision on March 14, ruling Patterson would have to face a separate trial for the three attempted murder offences. Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges in relation to Simon Patterson just before the triple-murder trial started in Morwell. Patterson was on July 7 found guilty of killing Simon's parents, Don and Gail, 70, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, along with the attempted murder of her husband Ian Wilkinson. Justice Beale's redacted pre-trial rulings were released to media on Monday evening after Patterson lost her bid to keep the evidence a secret to preserve her appeal rights. The details around the alleged attempted murders of Simon Patterson were revealed for the first time on Friday. Prosecutors had alleged Patterson tried to poison Simon several times between 2021 and 2022. The first was a penne pasta Patterson cooked him before leaving for a camping trip in November 2021, which led to a five-day hospital stay for Simon. He also ended up in a coma after a camping trip in late May 2022 where he allegedly ate a chicken korma curry Patterson had made him. Simon had to undergo surgery to remove a large portion of his bowel after eating the curry, he told the Supreme Court during pre-trial hearings. It was also alleged he fell ill in September 2022 after eating a wrap Patterson prepared for him while camping together at Wilsons Promontory. The prosecution claimed the allegations could be used as coincidence evidence to show the similarities between what allegedly happened to Simon and the mushroom lunch guests. But Justice Beale ruled the charges should be heard in a separate trial to prevent jurors from "misusing or overvaluing" the evidence in relation to Simon. He determined if a jury found Patterson had deliberately poisoned her four lunch guests in July 2023, there was a risk they would wrongly assess the charges relating to Simon. "I am not persuaded that its probative value substantially outweighs the significant danger or risk of unfair prejudice to the accused," Justice Beale said in his written reasons. The judge also made pre-trial rulings in relation to documents about poisoning found on devices police seized from Patterson's home. Justice Beale ruled the documents failed the relevance test because the evidence could only go as high as Patterson possibly accessed the file. The judge also stopped the jury from seeing a Facebook post Patterson made to a poisons page, where she claimed her cat had chewed on a mushroom and was vomiting. Justice Beale noted the post was made 18 months before the first allegation in relation to Simon. "In my view, even if the evidence of this post shows an interest in poisons, it is temporally remote," the judge said in his reasons. Patterson will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing later in August, during which she will listen to statements from the Pattersons and Wilkinsons. She will have 28 days to appeal after she is sentenced. Triple murderer Erin Patterson would have been unfairly prejudiced if a jury heard allegations she tried to kill her ex-husband in the years before a deadly mushroom lunch. Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale made the decision on March 14, ruling Patterson would have to face a separate trial for the three attempted murder offences. Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges in relation to Simon Patterson just before the triple-murder trial started in Morwell. Patterson was on July 7 found guilty of killing Simon's parents, Don and Gail, 70, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, along with the attempted murder of her husband Ian Wilkinson. Justice Beale's redacted pre-trial rulings were released to media on Monday evening after Patterson lost her bid to keep the evidence a secret to preserve her appeal rights. The details around the alleged attempted murders of Simon Patterson were revealed for the first time on Friday. Prosecutors had alleged Patterson tried to poison Simon several times between 2021 and 2022. The first was a penne pasta Patterson cooked him before leaving for a camping trip in November 2021, which led to a five-day hospital stay for Simon. He also ended up in a coma after a camping trip in late May 2022 where he allegedly ate a chicken korma curry Patterson had made him. Simon had to undergo surgery to remove a large portion of his bowel after eating the curry, he told the Supreme Court during pre-trial hearings. It was also alleged he fell ill in September 2022 after eating a wrap Patterson prepared for him while camping together at Wilsons Promontory. The prosecution claimed the allegations could be used as coincidence evidence to show the similarities between what allegedly happened to Simon and the mushroom lunch guests. But Justice Beale ruled the charges should be heard in a separate trial to prevent jurors from "misusing or overvaluing" the evidence in relation to Simon. He determined if a jury found Patterson had deliberately poisoned her four lunch guests in July 2023, there was a risk they would wrongly assess the charges relating to Simon. "I am not persuaded that its probative value substantially outweighs the significant danger or risk of unfair prejudice to the accused," Justice Beale said in his written reasons. The judge also made pre-trial rulings in relation to documents about poisoning found on devices police seized from Patterson's home. Justice Beale ruled the documents failed the relevance test because the evidence could only go as high as Patterson possibly accessed the file. The judge also stopped the jury from seeing a Facebook post Patterson made to a poisons page, where she claimed her cat had chewed on a mushroom and was vomiting. Justice Beale noted the post was made 18 months before the first allegation in relation to Simon. "In my view, even if the evidence of this post shows an interest in poisons, it is temporally remote," the judge said in his reasons. Patterson will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing later in August, during which she will listen to statements from the Pattersons and Wilkinsons. She will have 28 days to appeal after she is sentenced. Triple murderer Erin Patterson would have been unfairly prejudiced if a jury heard allegations she tried to kill her ex-husband in the years before a deadly mushroom lunch. Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale made the decision on March 14, ruling Patterson would have to face a separate trial for the three attempted murder offences. Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges in relation to Simon Patterson just before the triple-murder trial started in Morwell. Patterson was on July 7 found guilty of killing Simon's parents, Don and Gail, 70, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson, 66, along with the attempted murder of her husband Ian Wilkinson. Justice Beale's redacted pre-trial rulings were released to media on Monday evening after Patterson lost her bid to keep the evidence a secret to preserve her appeal rights. The details around the alleged attempted murders of Simon Patterson were revealed for the first time on Friday. Prosecutors had alleged Patterson tried to poison Simon several times between 2021 and 2022. The first was a penne pasta Patterson cooked him before leaving for a camping trip in November 2021, which led to a five-day hospital stay for Simon. He also ended up in a coma after a camping trip in late May 2022 where he allegedly ate a chicken korma curry Patterson had made him. Simon had to undergo surgery to remove a large portion of his bowel after eating the curry, he told the Supreme Court during pre-trial hearings. It was also alleged he fell ill in September 2022 after eating a wrap Patterson prepared for him while camping together at Wilsons Promontory. The prosecution claimed the allegations could be used as coincidence evidence to show the similarities between what allegedly happened to Simon and the mushroom lunch guests. But Justice Beale ruled the charges should be heard in a separate trial to prevent jurors from "misusing or overvaluing" the evidence in relation to Simon. He determined if a jury found Patterson had deliberately poisoned her four lunch guests in July 2023, there was a risk they would wrongly assess the charges relating to Simon. "I am not persuaded that its probative value substantially outweighs the significant danger or risk of unfair prejudice to the accused," Justice Beale said in his written reasons. The judge also made pre-trial rulings in relation to documents about poisoning found on devices police seized from Patterson's home. Justice Beale ruled the documents failed the relevance test because the evidence could only go as high as Patterson possibly accessed the file. The judge also stopped the jury from seeing a Facebook post Patterson made to a poisons page, where she claimed her cat had chewed on a mushroom and was vomiting. Justice Beale noted the post was made 18 months before the first allegation in relation to Simon. "In my view, even if the evidence of this post shows an interest in poisons, it is temporally remote," the judge said in his reasons. Patterson will face a two-day pre-sentence hearing later in August, during which she will listen to statements from the Pattersons and Wilkinsons. She will have 28 days to appeal after she is sentenced.