How RFK Jr. Could Disrupt Insurance Coverage Of Preventive Healthcare
In a recently decided case, the Supreme Court upheld the authority of the Secretary of Health and Human Services to appoint members of the United States Preventive Services Task Force, rather than requiring presidential nomination and corresponding Senate confirmation hearings and a vote. The Task Force is tasked with making key recommendations on which preventive healthcare services and technologies must be covered by health insurers by law. While this ruling preserves the current structure of the Task Force and ensures that its recommendations remain valid, it offers HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. broad latitude to reshape what's covered as he can hire and fire the expert panel, which in turn can lead to modified guidance.
In the case before the court, the lead plaintiff, Braidwood Management, objected to the Affordable Care Act's requirement to cover HIV prevention medications, arguing that this mandate violated its religious beliefs. Braidwood further maintained that the Task Force is unconstitutional, specifically with regard to the procedure used to appoint members.
The Task Force is in charge of recommending preventive healthcare services and technologies that ought to be covered by insurers, such as cancer screenings, cholesterol medications and HIV prevention drugs or pre-exposure prophylaxis, at no cost to patients. PrEP is a highly effective preventive medication for people who do not have HIV but are at high risk of exposure through sexual contact or injection drug use. It can be taken as a daily pill or as an injectable every two or six months.
Under the ACA, PrEP products approved by the Food and Drug Administration must be reimbursed by insurers without any out-of-pocket charges to patients for the medications, clinic visits or laboratory tests. For the uninsured, there are programs available that can provide PrEP at reduced costs or for free.
The Task Force's expert panel evaluates the best available scientific evidence to figure out whether a preventive health intervention is beneficial to patients. In the case of PrEP, soon after the first product was approved more than a decade ago, the Task Force recommended its coverage based on a review of the data submitted to the FDA.
The Supreme Court ruled that the present structure of the Task Force is constitutional. As such, its decision reaffirms the ability of Kennedy to appoint and supervise officers under the aegis of the Department of HHS. But in light of Kennedy's evident distrust of established expertise and traditional scientific institutions in government decision-making, this could give pause.
Besides holding vaccine-skeptic views, Kennedy has questioned whether HIV is the sole cause of AIDS, advocated on behalf of lifting of raw milk restrictions and removing flouride from drinking water.
Challenging what he calls 'orthodoxies,' HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has repeatedly made statements suggesting a skeptical viewpoint with respect to sole reliance on experts in making policy decisions, especially in the realm of public health. During an interview with Fox News, Kennedy said that 'trusting the experts is not a function of science or democracy, but of totalitarianism and religion.'
What happened last month at the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, when the entire panel of experts was ousted and replaced, could offer clues as to how Kennedy may act, given that he has a similar authority to appoint and remove Task Force members. And this extends to his right to review and block their guidance before it takes effect.
ACIP provides recommendations on vaccines to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Positive advice for a vaccine implies health insurers must cover it free of charge. Kennedy oversees ACIP and can sack and appoint members. Kennedy dismissed the entire 17-member ACIP and appointed seven members to the advisory committee, several of whom have no vaccine or immunology pedigree while others include like-minded vaccine skeptics. It's unknown what changes the newly formed committee will recommend regarding scheduling of standard vaccinations. But it stands to reason that scheduling could be modified.
Independently of ACIP, Kennedy has already made changes to COVID-19 vaccine policy, no longer recommending the vaccine to health children and pregnant women. STAT News reports that a lawsuit filed on July 7th alleges that 'HHS changed federal guidance outside of established processes, undermining trust.'
And, earlier this year, another agency under Kennedy's control, the National Institutes of Health, dismantled the entire National Cancer Institute's Board of Scientific Advisors, which had 28 members.
If something similar were to happen to the Task Force as what occurred to ACIP, experts suggest it could undermine the public and scientific community's trust in the panel and its recommendations. Moreover, it could result in restrictions in insurance coverage of certain preventive interventions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump gives FEMA funds for catastrophic flooding as agency's future is up in the air
Tampa, Fla. (WFLA) — President Donald Trump has repeatedly said that he planned to start 'phasing out' the Federal Emergency Management Agency after the hurricane in Texas on Friday and meeting with first responders and grieving families, the president was questioned on the federal response to last week's deadly flooding and the future of FEMA. President Trump did not address the agency's future. Close Thanks for signing up! Watch for us in your inbox. Subscribe Now A White House official told NewsNation that a FEMA review council now plans to 'reform' the agency. Trump surveyed the aftermath of last week's catastrophic flooding that left more than 100 people dead.'I have never seen anything like this,' he comes amid the administration facing scrutiny over FEMA's future. Since the start of his second term, the president has made this promise. 'We want to wean off of FEMA, and we want to bring it down from the state level,' he previously has an annual budget of around $30 billion and, prior to layoffs, employed more than 20,000 people. On Sunday, Trump signed a major declaration for Texas, making federal funding available for Kerr County and expanding to now cover five surrounding counties.'My administration is doing everything in its power to help Texas,' Trump said.'Immediately when I made a request for a disaster declaration, you and your administration granted that,' Texas Gov. Greg Abbott said. 'This is the fastest that I am aware of any administration responding.'Abbott said this declaration will allow his state to more effectively respond and rebuild. Florida Democratic Rep. Jared Moskowitz said he's alarmed by how Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem handled last week's tragedy. 'Emergencies and disasters are always locally executed, the state manages them, and the federal government comes in and supports that what we are doing here, sir, empowering the state and the local officials to make the best decision for their people because they know their people and their community,' Noem said. 'When they come in and ask, we support people.' Moskowitz is calling for an investigation into what he said is FEMA's delayed response. With the administration's previous pledge to get rid of FEMA and 'bring it down to the state level,' Pinellas County residents, who repeatedly experienced flooding, fear that if FEMA funds aren't available, how will they get help and from whom?'It's probably going to come in some form of tax, it always does right?' questioned Cody McGehe, Shore Acres Resident. 'I don't know if property insurance will go up or homeowners' insurance will just increase to offset that, but certainly it will come back to us. It always does, like there's no way it doesn't.' President Trump created a 12-member FEMA review council to determine the agency's future role. The council is expected to release a report in November on how to improve federal disaster response. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
10 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Hegseth, Donalds speak to young conservatives in Tampa
TAMPA, Fla. (WFLA) — Turning Point USA is hosting its 2025 Student Action Summit at the Tampa Convention Center. The event attracts high school and college students from across the country. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth spoke about results from DOGE at the Department of Defense. Trump gives FEMA funds for catastrophic flooding as agency's future is up in the air 'We found tens of billions of dollars in savings from contracts we've eliminated, green initiatives that are gone, that we move over to President Trump's priorities,' Hegseth said. Hegseth also promised to help ICE agents who are facing pushback in communities during arrests. 'If they're being attacked, their partners at the defense department are proud to stand alongside them to secure them,' Hegseth said. Southwest Florida Congressman Byron Donalds, who President Trump has endorsed for governor, urged students to stay engaged. 'Political activism is critical for the future. I get it. We are riding high. Donald Trump is on a win streak,' Donalds said. Donalds was also critical of New York City's democratic mayoral nominee Zohran Mamdani. 'I have a responsibility to prepare my state for a lot more New Yorkers,' Donalds said. Donald Trump Junior and conservative podcaster Tucker Carlson were also featured as speakers. Victor DiMaio, who leads the Hillsborough Democratic Caucus, feels some ideas and speakers go too far to the right. He said that it will actually benefit the Democratic Party with support from young independent voters. 'Florida has a lot of huge independent voters,' DiMaio said. 'Those people can be swayed. They make up almost a third of the voting populous.' Protestors planned to meet Saturday afternoon at Tampa City Hall in opposition to the Trump agenda and the Student Action Summit. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Health Line
10 minutes ago
- Health Line
How to Do An Arnold Press
Named after bodybuilding legend Arnold Schwarzenegger, this exercise builds on the traditional shoulder press by adding a rotational movement that increases muscle activation and range of motion. While a typical shoulder press starts with dumbbells at shoulder height and moves straight up, the Arnold press begins with your palms facing you in a supinated position and rotates them outward into a pronated position (palms facing forward) as you press the weights overhead. The Arnold press also increases time under tension and requires more control, especially through the midrange of the movement. This makes it slightly more challenging and beneficial for shoulder development. What does an Arnold press involve? To get started: Sit on a bench with back support or stand with your feet about shoulder-width apart. Hold a dumbbell in each hand at shoulder level, keeping your palms facing your chest and elbows bent in front of you. Engage your core by gently tightening your abdominal muscles to support your spine and maintain upright posture. As you initiate the movement, press the dumbbells upward while gradually rotating your wrists so your palms begin to turn forward. Continue pressing until your arms are fully extended overhead, with your palms now facing away from you at the top of the lift. Slowly reverse the movement. Lower the dumbbells back to shoulder level while rotating your wrists so that your palms return to the starting inward-facing position. Perform 8 to 12 repetitions for 2 to 4 sets, depending on your goals and experience level. Potential modifications Beginner: Start with light dumbbells and perform the exercise seated to increase stability. Focus on mastering the rotation. Intermediate: Increase the weight slightly and consider standing to activate more core muscles. Advanced: Use heavier weights or incorporate the Arnold press into supersets with lateral raises or upright rows. Ensure your shoulder mobility can support heavier loads and full rotation. What muscles does an Arnold press work? The Arnold press primarily targets the shoulder muscles, including: Anterior deltoid: Positioned at the front of the shoulder, this muscle plays a key role throughout the movement, particularly during the initial lifting phase. Lateral deltoid: Located on the side of the shoulder, this muscle becomes more involved as the arms move outward and overhead. Posterior deltoid: This muscle is found at the rear of the shoulder and is activated slightly by the exercise's rotational motion. Triceps brachii: These muscles at the back of the upper arms assist during the pressing portion of the lift. The trapezius and upper back muscles help stabilize the shoulder joint. The core engages to maintain posture and balance, especially when the movement is performed in a standing position. What are the potential benefits of an Arnold press? The Arnold press offers several distinct advantages for shoulder development and overall strength: Greater deltoid engagement: The rotational movement activates more parts of the shoulder than a standard press, contributing to fuller muscle development. Improved shoulder mobility: The exercise helps improve range of motion in the shoulder joint, especially in rotation and flexion. Increased time under tension: The slower, controlled motion places continuous stress on the muscles, which promotes hypertrophy (muscle growth). Better muscle coordination: The Arnold press trains your body to move more fluidly, enhancing control and stability in your upper body. Whether your goal is muscle building, athletic performance, or injury prevention, the Arnold press fits well into a variety of strength programs. The bottom line Incorporating the Arnold press into your routine can help you develop stronger, more balanced shoulders. Its unique combination of rotation and pressing engages the entire deltoid group, making it a superior option compared to standard shoulder presses. With proper form, appropriate progression, and attention to safety, this exercise can boost upper-body strength, enhance mobility, and improve overall performance in athletic and everyday activities.
