Ed Miliband's neighbours in uproar over heat pump noise fear
Six 'noisy' heat pumps are at the centre of a neighbourhood row involving Ed Miliband's wife, The Telegraph can reveal.
The energy secretary is spearheading the mass adoption of heat pumps and has a target of installing 600,000 a year in Britain by 2028.
However, dozens of Mr Miliband's North London neighbours have objected to a planned five-storey block of flats over noise pollution concerns related to the heat pumps included in the designs.
Mr Miliband's wife, Justine Thornton, is among those to object to Camden Council about the development in Dartmouth Park, a wealthy suburb in the Prime Minister's constituency. Sherlock actor Benedict Cumberbatch has also opposed the plans.
She previously called the design 'too tall, too bulky and too dense', although she has not commented specifically on the inclusion of heat pumps.
But the eco devices come up several times in objections lodged by neighbours and published on Camden Council's website.
Local resident Kim Roper said: 'The inclusion of six ground-level heat pumps near adjoining residences raises serious concerns about long-term noise pollution.'
Jerome Gautrais similarly raised concerns over 'noise pollution risks from six external heat pumps close to living spaces.'
Katrina Silver said: 'Six noisy heat pumps and space for bicycles is simply 'greenwashing'.'
Mr Miliband has already been left red-faced by his wife's involvement in the so-called 'Nimbyism' row over the flats as it goes against the Labour's repeated promises to end 'challenge culture' whereby communities block new developments.
Sir Keir Starmer previously pledged to 'take on the Nimbys.'
But, the latest revelation offers fresh embarrassment to Mr Miliband, who has sought to quash anxieties around heat pumps and even has one installed in his own home.
Air source heat pumps, which are positioned outside a home, can produce a low constant hum of between 40 and 60 decibels, which is similar to the level of noise made by a fridge or dishwasher. They will typically run continuously throughout winter.
A noise impact assessment by ALN Acoustic Design found that it would be possible to achieve a low level of noise at the Dartmouth Park development. It said it would 'avoid causing any significant impact at the neighbouring residential properties.'
But, resident Harry Raikes called the noise impact assessment 'inadequate'.
He added: 'It does not properly evaluate the potential for continuous or intermittent noise, particularly affecting neighbouring gardens and internal living spaces.
'Without robust mitigation measures and clear assurances that noise levels will remain within acceptable limits, this element of the development poses a risk of ongoing noise pollution, further impacting residents' quality of life.'
It comes months after The Telegraph revealed that Parliament paused a planned rollout of heat pumps amid concerns over their noise and effectiveness,
Camden Council and the Energy Department were approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
32 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Reform's new chairman is Most Haunted TV star
Reform UK's new chairman is a former TV presenter known for fronting a reality show about hunting ghosts. Dr David Bull, who is also an ex-hospital doctor, will take over from Zia Yusuf, who dramatically resigned from the party last week before rejoining just two days later. Dr Bull is a former deputy leader of Reform, having held the role from 2021 to 2024, when he was replaced by Richard Tice on Nigel Farage's return as leader. For around a year, the 56-year-old shared the job with Ben Habib, who has since quit the party and become an outspoken supporter of Reform critic Rupert Lowe. Before entering politics, Dr Bull worked as a TV host, starting as an on-screen doctor for Sky TV in the mid-1990s before joining Newsround, the children's news show, and going on to present the paranormal series Most Haunted Live. He has also appeared on BBC's Watchdog, going on to host the spin-off Watchdog Healthcheck and the live science show Tomorrow's World. He is now a presenter on TalkTV, the news channel owned by Rupert Murdoch, which went online-only last year. Dr Bull, who reportedly backs 'binning the burka', was revealed as Reform's new chairman by the Daily Mail. He will replace Mr Yusuf, who stepped down from his position in spectacular fashion last Thursday before rejoining in a new role on Saturday. His resignation followed a disagreement within the party over whether to ban the burka, an idea he branded 'dumb'. Senior Reform figures also said that Mr Yusuf's professional style, born of his former career as a Goldman Sachs banker, had led to personality clashes at the top of the party. The former chairman will now lead Reform's so-called UK Doge team, inspired by the US Department of Government Efficiency set up by Donald Trump and run by Elon Musk. Dr Bull is also a former doctor and has written two books: Cool and Celibate? Sex and No Sex and What Every Girl Should Know. According to his website, he qualified as a doctor in 1993 and went on to work for the NHS at St Mary's Hospital, Ealing Hospital and the Whittington Hospital, all in London, in the fields of general medicine, emergency medicine and general practice. He was briefly a Brexit Party MEP and initially ran as the Tory candidate for Brighton Pavilion in 2009 before stepping down to lead a Conservative policy review on sexual health. A Reform source told the Daily Mail: 'He looks and sounds good and he's been out and proud for years, so we have no worries about any skeletons in his closet.'
Telegraph
33 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Reeves to give speech ahead of Spending Review
Rachel Reeves is set to deliver a speech at the GMB union conference as the Chancellor prepares to unveil her eagerly-awaited Spending Review tomorrow. Ms Reeves is expected to use the address to the union in Brighton today to hail the Government's new £16.7 billion commitment to nuclear power projects. The Chancellor has signed off on £14.2 billion of investment to build the new Sizewell C nuclear plant in Suffolk. Meanwhile, Rolls-Royce has been named as the preferred bidder to build small modular reactors (SMRs) in a programme backed by £2.5 billion of taxpayers' cash. The funding is part of a wider programme of infrastructure investment worth tens of billions of pounds over the next decade which the Chancellor will confirm at the Spending Review in the House of Commons tomorrow. The review is expected to set out real-terms funding cuts for numerous Whitehall departments and the Chancellor's speech in Brighton will be watched closely for any clues about where the squeeze could be felt the most.
Telegraph
33 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Labour won't apologise for winter fuel chaos, says Miliband
Labour will not apologise for its handling of the winter fuel payment cut, Ed Miliband has said. The Energy Security and Net Zero Secretary defended the original decision taken last year to strip the support from 10 million pensioners. However he said Rachel Reeves, the Chancellor, had done the 'right thing' by backtracking after she announced on Monday she was restoring the payment to approximately three quarters of pensioners in England and Wales. The original decision plunged millions of pensioners into uncertainty, but Mr Miliband said the Government will not be saying sorry. Asked if the Government was willing to apologise and admit it had got the original decision wrong, Mr Miliband told Times Radio: 'We're not going to apologise for the actions we took to stabilise the economy. That's what happened last year. 'The Chancellor came into office, saw a massive black hole in the nation's finances. She took a whole series of measures. 'Now, what's happened since then is two things. One, we have stabilised the public finances and secondly, we've listened to people.' Mr Miliband added that Labour still believes that the benefit should be means-tested, but they have 'listened to the people' on how high the threshold should be to qualify for the winter fuel allowance. 'Personally, I think it's the right thing that the Chancellor has done. We have listened and we've changed the policy,' he said. Told that pensioners probably wanted the Government to admit it had got the original decision wrong, Mr Miliband said: 'I've talked to lots of people on doorsteps about the winter fuel allowance. I can't remember anyone who said, 'you should apologise'. People wanted us to change the policy and that's what we've done.' The decision to limit the winter fuel payment to only those who claimed pension credit was one of Labour's first acts in government. Ms Reeves argued it was a necessary step to help fill an alleged £22 billion 'black hole' in the public finances, which Labour claimed the Tories had left behind. Ferocious backlash The original decision meant the number of pensioners receiving the payment, worth up to £300 per year, was reduced by around 10 million. The total number of recipients of benefit has fallen from 11.4 million to 1.5 million. The move prompted a ferocious backlash and the issue contributed to Labour's drubbing at last month's local elections. Sir Keir Starmer then announced Labour was backtracking on the policy and Ms Reeves confirmed the details on Monday. The payment will be restored to the vast majority of pensioners who previously received it because anyone with an income of under £35,000 a year will now get the support automatically. Pensioners with an income above the £35,000 threshold will also receive the payment, but it will then be reclaimed from them in tax. Campaigners called it a massive over-complication of the system and raised fears of a 'widow's tax', as pensioner couples will be able to keep the allowance if their individual incomes are both below £35,000. If one dies, and the income is transferred over to the partner under a defined benefit pension scheme, it could push the surviving spouse's income past the £35,000 threshold, meaning they will have to hand the payment back.
