logo
PH Election Day Marred By Disenfranchisement, Violence, Technical Failures, Says Rights-Led Observer Mission

PH Election Day Marred By Disenfranchisement, Violence, Technical Failures, Says Rights-Led Observer Mission

Scoop12-05-2025

May 13, 2025
As polls closed in the Philippines, the International Observer Mission (IOM), a delegation of human rights advocates from across the globe, released initial findings that raise urgent red flags over the credibility of the 2025 midterm elections.
The mission flagged severe voter disenfranchisement due to malfunctioning automated counting machines (ACMs), reports of ballots being wrongly read as overvotes, effectively nullifying valid votes, and a troubling, unexplained software update on the machines.
'These aren't just technical glitches, we are seeing failures that are disenfranchising thousands of Filipinos at a critical democratic moment,' said Commissioner Lee Rhiannon, a former Australian Senator. 'Our rights-based methodology has revealed violations of civil and political rights, including the right to vote, occurring on and around election day. Our mission is to document and to amplify what the Filipino people are already bravely calling out.'
IOM on-ground teams have observed trends of disenfranchisement alongside local partner Vote Report PH and Kontra Daya, flagging multiple verified issues on election day. The teams have documented irregularities in the polling centers by interviewing respondents who voted in respective areas.
In Cordillera and Northern Mindanao, ground teams monitored instances of vote-buying before and during polling hours. Similar issues were reported in the Bicol region, where, in addition to vote-buying, there were reports of pre-shaded ballots that affected voters. At one polling center in Southern Tagalog, more than 900 people lined up for only one ACM. This led to voters waiting in line for several hours, with reports of individuals giving up their right to vote.
Due to the absence of ACMs, priority voters in Negros were asked to hand their ballots to polling officers. Instead of voters personally casting and verifying their vote, these ballots were placed inside a cardboard box. This case was documented by foreign observers, where respondents expressed concerns about whether their votes were counted and if any tampering occurred. In some precincts in Zamboanga, voters complained of not seeing the name of the partylist they voted for in the receipts.
A disturbing pattern: electoral violence
Beyond the failures in the voting technology, the IOM has noted an intensification of election-related violence and rights violations. Initial reports documented election-day riots, armed attacks, and multiple fatalities in the weeks leading up to May 12.
As of May 12, Vote Report PH, a watchdog and partner of the 2025 IOM, recorded 1,445 incidents of red-tagging, making it the most frequently reported violation in their monitoring. Observers documented widespread cases throughout the campaign period in regions such as Cordillera, Southern Tagalog, Southern Luzon, Negros, and across Mindanao. The attacks intensified on election day, with red-tagging flyers and posters targeting progressive candidates and partylists still being circulated.
'We've observed a disturbing pattern: escalating violence, red-tagging of candidates and supporters, and coordinated disinformation against progressive voices,' said IOM Commissioner Colleen Moore, Director of Peace with Justice at the General Board of Church and Society. 'These are not isolated incidents. They form a chilling atmosphere that compromises the safety and freedom of voters.'
On election day, several incidents of violence occurred across the country.
Despite a nationwide gun ban, killings and shootings were reported in the provinces of Abra, Negros Occidental, Davao del Norte, Davao Occidental and Zamboanga del Sur. The Bangsamoro Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) was hit the most, with all of its provinces experiencing varying levels of violence.
It ranged from fist fights and riots between supporters of rival candidates to gunfights and shootings resulting in killings. Among the worst of these occurred in Basilan, where three people, including a poll watcher, were killed and two others wounded in a predawn boat clash near Hadji Muhtamad town, hours before the polls opened.
Machine malfunctions, anomalous software update
All international observers deployed across the country monitored widespread cases of malfunctioning ACMs, causing delays in voting. News outlets have also reported on machine glitches across the Philippines. The sheer magnitude and scope of the incidents likely point to thousands of voters affected nationwide.
The Mission also indicated that it will recommend an investigation of the unexplained ACMs running version 3.5.0 software, rather than the publicly certified version 3.4.0. 'We are collaborating with our partners in the Philippines to look into this irregularity,' Moore added.
Final report in two weeks
'While these findings remain initial, our mission expresses deep concern over the conditions under which the 2025 midterm elections were held,' says Rhiannon.
'The convergence of political violence, widespread disenfranchisement, harassment, and unexplained technical irregularities point to systemic vulnerabilities that risk undermining public trust in the electoral process.'
According to the Commissioners, the IOM will continue to verify and analyze trends from the data and case studies they have collected. A final report detailing its observations and offering recommendations grounded in its human rights approach will be released within two weeks.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Northern Ireland hit by third night of violence
Northern Ireland hit by third night of violence

Otago Daily Times

time7 hours ago

  • Otago Daily Times

Northern Ireland hit by third night of violence

Violence erupted in different parts of Northern Ireland for the third successive night on Wednesday, with masked youths starting a fire in a leisure centre but unrest in the primary flashpoint of Ballymena was notably smaller in scale. Hundreds of masked rioters attacked police and set homes and cars on fire in Ballymena, a town of 30,000 people 45km from Belfast, on Tuesday night in what police condemned as "racist thuggery." The violence flared on Monday after two 14-year-old boys were arrested and appeared in court earlier that day, accused of a serious sexual assault on a teenage girl in the town. The charges were read via a Romanian interpreter to the boys, whose lawyer told the court that they denied the charge, the BBC reported. Police are investigating the damaging of properties on Monday and Tuesday in Ballymena, which has a relatively large migrant population, as racially-motivated hate crimes. Two Filipino families told Reuters they fled their home in Ballymena on Tuesday night after fearing for their safety when their car was set on fire outside the house. A few dozen masked youths threw some rocks, fireworks and petrol bombs at police after officers in riot gear and armoured vans blocked roads in the town on Wednesday evening. Police deployed water cannon against the crowd for the second successive night but the clashes were nothing like the previous night that left 17 officers injured and led to five arrests. Much of the crowd had left the streets before midnight. A small number of riot police were also in the town of Larne 30km west where masked youths smashed the windows of a leisure centre before starting fires in the lobby, BBC footage showed. Swimming classes were taking place when bricks were thrown through the windows and staff had to barricade themselves in before running out the back door, a local Alliance Party lawmaker, Danny Donnelly, told the BBC. Northern Ireland's Communities Minister Gordon Lyons had earlier posted on Facebook that a number of people had been temporarily moved to the leisure centre following the disturbances in Ballymena, before then being moved out of Larne. The comments drew sharp criticism from other political parties for identifying a location used to shelter families seeking refuge from anti-immigrant violence. Lyons condemned the attacks on the centre. Police said youths also set fires at a roundabout in the town of Newtownabbey, a flashpoint for sectarian violence that sporadically flares up in the British-run region 27 years after a peace deal largely ended three decades of bloodshed. Debris was also set alight at a barricade in Coleraine, the Belfast Telegraph reported. The British and Irish governments as well as local politicians have condemned the violence.

Collins coy over possible Aukus pact review
Collins coy over possible Aukus pact review

Otago Daily Times

time14 hours ago

  • Otago Daily Times

Collins coy over possible Aukus pact review

Defence Minister Judith Collins. Photo: RNZ The Defence Minister says there's no reason for New Zealand to comment on reports the Pentagon is reviewing the Aukus defence alliance. A US defence official told Reuters the review was part of ensuring the security pact was aligned with US President Donald Trump's America First agenda. The strategic pact between the US, UK and Australia had long been a talking point in New Zealand, with consecutive governments pondering whether to join parts of the alliance. Aukus was formed in 2021 to address shared worries about China's growing power. Under the pact, Australia would be armed with nuclear submarines at a cost of $A350 billion ($NZ377 billion). In a statement, Defence Minister Judith Collins said the US review was about Aukus Pillar One, which New Zealand had never been a part of. New Zealand has had ongoing discussions about joining Pillar Two of the alliance, but any decisions on whether to join Pillar Two would be a matter for Cabinet, Collins said. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has not received any reports or advice on what the Trump administration reviewing the Aukus security pact might mean for New Zealand. Luxon told RNZ he was not concerned the review could spell the end for Pillar Two "It's been left very open-ended. We're exploring Pillar Two - it's been to be honest quite slow going. "We are yet to be invited to partipate in Pillar Two." Luxon said the review was for Australia, the US, and the UK to work through. Australia was last week told by US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to significantly boost its defence spending. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said he would not be dictated to on defence spending. He he noted Australia's defence spending was already set to increase from 2 percent to 2.3 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) over the next eight years. Collins has denied any allies have put pressure on the government to up defence spending. Foreign Minister Winston Peters previously said New Zealand's trading partners would judge us if we did not "step up" and play our role by increasing defence spending.

Why travel with PMs is not for the faint of heart
Why travel with PMs is not for the faint of heart

NZ Herald

timea day ago

  • NZ Herald

Why travel with PMs is not for the faint of heart

Christopher Luxon was loathe to announce the replacement of the RNZAF's passenger jets until last month's budget. Photo / Getty Images New Zealander Bernard Lagan is the Australian correspondent for the Times, London It was a winter Sunday in 1983 above a seething Wellington sea when Robert Muldoon glanced up from The Economist magazine. 'Tell him to have another go,' the then prime minister told an RNZAF flight attendant as the old Andover aircraft's two propellers struggled to haul into the clouds. The pilot had abandoned a second landing attempt against a rollicking gale. Rain stung the trembling fuselage like buckshot. The ashen passengers, a mix of press and Muldoon's staff, looked queasily at each other. None dared countermand the PM. As the hapless flight attendant conveyed the prime minister's wish upfront, I imagine, the flight deck conversation went something like this: 'He wants you to have another run at it, sir.' 'God, really? Then we'll see how much the dear leader wants to keep his lunch down.' The Andover lurched around for a third attempt. With winds gusting ever higher, it see-sawed violently downward. An overhead baggage locker cracked open, spewing its contents. A fire extinguisher tore off a wall, careening onto the floor, the noise terrifying everybody. We landed crazily on one wheel and skewered down the sodden tarmac to a halt. Muldoon never looked up from his Economist. Leaders have conflicted relationships with their VIP aircraft – treating them as a personal fiefdom but fearing public opprobrium when the time comes to spend money on replacements. Like his predecessors, Christopher Luxon was loath to announce the replacement of the RNZAF's current large and embarrassingly unreliable Boeing 757 passenger jets – now well over 30 years old – until last month's Budget. After David Lange came to power in 1984, one of his first acts was to commandeer an air force Boeing 727 jet, bought second-hand from United Airlines and by then 16 years old, and storm across Africa to apologise for New Zealand's hosting in 1981 of the South African rugby team. The aircraft had a limited range, forcing a highly circuitous route to Africa to allow for refuelling. Things soon went spectacularly awry. After refuelling in Melbourne the travelling party –including your correspondent – stopped in Perth for more gas ahead of the 727's planned island hop across the Indian Ocean to Africa. In Perth, Lange learnt the US government, still seething over his anti-nuclear ships policy, had rescinded approval for his aircraft to refuel at its military base on the Indian Ocean island of Diego Garcia. The Africa tour was in early jeopardy until a compromise was reached – Lange's plane would be allowed to land but without journalists. The gaggle of Kiwi reporters – whisked non-stop from Perth to Zimbabwe's capital, Harare, in a new Qantas 747 – were delighted to be on hand, well lunched, for Lange's African arrival a day after their own. Their cockiness was short lived. Apparently alarmed by the burden the travelling press placed on the aircraft's alcohol supplies as Lange toured East Africa's capitals, the air force cut the booze. Other aerial dramas followed. Somewhere above Nigeria, the sight of three alarmed Nigerian air force pilots pounding the instrument cluster of the helicopter carrying the Lange party to a tea plantation preceded a rapid emergency landing. The lumbering old air freighter the Nigerians sent to retrieve us developed an inflight leak of the toilet system – sending a river of stored effluent backwards down the aisle. After arriving to work in Australia, I travelled on then prime minister Bob Hawke's equally ancient Boeing 707 – known to the rowdy travelling press as the 'zoo plane' where wine flowed while Hawke smoked cigars and played poker. Doubtless the shiny new VIP aircraft ordered by Luxon will prove far more reliable – but nowhere near the fun.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store