Pulitzer accused of ‘desecrating the memory' of Oct 7 victims by freed hostage
The Pulitzer Prize has been accused of 'desecrating the memory' of Oct 7 victims after awarding a journalist who suggested Israelis could not be hostages.
Mosab Abu Toha, a Palestinian poet, was recognised by the Pulitzer committee for his 'essays on the physical and emotional carnage in Gaza'.
However, Honest Reporting, a watchdog that monitors for anti-Israel bias, found Mr Toha had posted a string of social media posts in which he disparaged Israeli hostages.
In one he questioned how British-Israeli citizen Emily Damari, who was shot and abducted on Oct 7 2023 in the Kfar Aza kibbutz after Hamas gunmen stormed her home, could be considered a hostage.
'So this girl is called a 'hostage?' This soldier who was close to the border with a city that she and her country have been occupying is called a 'hostage?',' he wrote.
Ms Damari, who was released in January after more than 500 days held captive, responded by accusing Pulitzer of having 'chosen to elevate a voice that denies truth, erases victims, and desecrates the memory of the murdered'.
'Mosab Abu Toha is not a courageous writer. He is the modern-day equivalent of a Holocaust denier. And by honouring him, you have joined him in the shadows of denial,' the 29-year-old wrote on X.
'This is not a question of politics. This is a question of humanity. And today, you have failed it.'
Mr Toha is one of several controversial journalists recognised by Pulitzer in this year's awards, which The Washington Free Beacon, a Right-wing website, said indicate the body's 'obsession with woke politics'.
Other critics pointed out that none of the prize-winners tackled the alleged mental decline of Joe Biden, the former US president who ended his re-election campaign last year following a disastrous debate performance.
The Hill's Robby Soave praised the 'good work' of newspapers including The New York Times and Washington Post but was 'struck by what's missing'.
'There is not a single winner that focuses on president Joe Biden's cognitive decline… was it not one of the biggest stories of 2024?' he continued.
Mr Soave continued: 'The Pulitzer Prize board perhaps was overlooking good reporting on Biden's cognitive decline because of its own bias.
'Or perhaps there wasn't enough good journalism on this subject to evaluate because everyone ignored it. Neither thought is particularly comforting to me.'
Tim Graham, executive editor of the Right-wing blog NewsBusters, wrote in an opinion piece: 'The 2025 Pulitzer announcement underlined that there was not a single reporting prize over the last four years for exposing anything about President Biden or his administration's actions.'
Four prizes were awarded for investigating Donald Trump during his first term in the White House, notably for allegations about Russian collusion with his 2016 presidential campaign, he added.
ProPublica, an investigative news outlet, was also given a Pulitzer for its series on how abortion bans in several states, in the aftermath of the overturning of Roe v Wade, had led to preventable deaths.
While judges praised its 'urgent reporting', the conservative National Review said the work suffered from 'misrepresentations stemming from the authors' evident bias for abortion rights''.
Two women who died after taking mifepristone and were featured in the series were not killed by 'pro-life legislation', it argued, but because the abortion pill is 'incredibly dangerous' in the first seven weeks of a pregnancy.
The choice to award Mark Warren, who earned Esquire magazine its first-ever Pulitzer Prize, also came in for criticism.
Warren's piece, described by Esquire as 'a deeply moving account' told the story of Bubba Copeland, a 'beloved Baptist pastor and mayor in a small town in Alabama'.
Copeland took his own life after being exposed by a Right-wing news website for posting pictures of children from his community online and encouraging them to transition.
The pastor, of whom cross-dressing pictures were also posted, is also said to have shared images of local women to porn websites.
Posting on X about the award, Genevieve Cluck, founder of the satirical website Reductress, wrote: 'Hey @PulitzerPrizes. You've just given an award to an article that lionises a sexual predator.
'A man who preyed on women in his own community, and made 'sissy captions' using photos of minors.'
Ann Telnaes, the former Washington Post cartoonist who resigned after her sketch depicting Jeff Bezos – the newspaper's billionaire owner – grovelling before Mr Trump was not published, also received an award.
Ms Telnaes, who had worked for the liberal newspaper for almost two decades, said it was the first time she 'had a cartoon killed because of who or what I chose to aim my pen at'.
She was praised for her 'piercing commentary' and 'fearlessness' by the Pulitzer board.
Meanwhile, Percival Everett won in the fiction category for James, a 'reconsideration' of Adventures of Huckleberry Finn told from the slave's perspective, while Susie Ibarra won the Pulitzer Prize for music for Sky Islands, a 'musical call to action' about climate change and biodiversity.
The Telegraph has contacted the Pulitzer Prize for comment.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
11 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jessica Ramos endorsing Andrew Cuomo for NYC mayor weeks after questioning his ‘mental acuity'
NEW YORK — In an extraordinary about-face, back-of-the-pack mayoral candidate Jessica Ramos is endorsing her front-running rival Andrew Cuomo — just weeks after questioning his 'mental acuity' and comparing his mental state to former President Joe Biden's. Ramos, a Queens state senator who was also among scores of lawmakers to call for Cuomo's 2021 resignation as governor over sexual misconduct accusations, is expected to formally throw her political weight behind his mayoral bid at a press conference in Manhattan on Friday morning, sources confirmed to the Daily News. Ramos and her campaign didn't immediately return multiple calls. But she told the New York Times, which first reported her surprising decision, that she's going with Cuomo because 'he's the one best positioned right now to protect this city.' Cuomo, who's polling as the favorite to win the June 24 Democratic mayoral primary, 'knows how to hold the line and deliver under pressure,' she added, citing uncertainty caused by President Donald Trump. Ramos, who identifies as a progressive Democrat, said she's not dropping out and her name will still appear on the primary ballot. But her endorsement of the centrist Cuomo is an effective acknowledgement she has no path to victory. Most polls of the mayoral race have shown Ramos pulling 1% or less in support. On the fundraising side, she hasn't taken in enough cash to qualify for matching funds and her latest filing from last month showed she had just about $9,000 in her war chest. The Cuomo nod marks a drastic flip-flop for Ramos, who said in April she believes Cuomo's 'mental acuity is in decline.' 'I don't think the City of New York can afford a Joe Biden moment,' she said at the time, referring to the former president who ended his reelection bid last year after serious concerns emerged about his mental fitness. 'I think that there are real reasons why [Cuomo is] not answering questions.' In response to her mental fitness broadsides against Cuomo, his spokesman Rich Azzopardi shot back in April: 'Was she sober when she said it?' Azzopardi didn't immediately return a request for comment Friday. Ramos has been a harsh critic of the centrist Cuomo on a number of other fronts, too. 'People may want to be courteous to Cuomo's face but they don't forget the people he sent to die, the women he touched or the people he left in our streets needing mental health care and housing,' Ramos wrote on X in March, referring to accusations that Cuomo mismanaged the COVID pandemic, sexually harassed more than 10 women and shuttered psychiatric institutions statewide as governor. Cuomo has denied the sexual harassment and pandemic mismanagement claims. Ramos' change of heart comes just days after the progressive Working Families Party ranked her its No. 5 candidate as part of an anti-Cuomo mayoral endorsement slate. On Friday, the party, which has had a rocky relationship with Ramos over the years, said it's 'sad and disappointed' by Ramos' announcement, but vowed to not 'be distracted by this desperate move.' Party leaders declined to immediately say whether they will formally remove Ramos from the slate. Ramos, the chair of the State Senate's Labor Committee, was the first woman to enter the 2025 mayoral race and had hoped to build a coalition rooted in union and Latino communities. But she never gained momentum on the campaign trail, as other progressives in the race, like runner-up candidate Zohran Mamdani, capitalized on a surge in enthusiasm for left-wing politics among young voters. During the first mayoral debate this week, Ramos lobbed a barb at Mamdani, Cuomo's top rival in the race, saying she wished she had run for mayor in 2021. 'I thought I needed more experience, but turns out you just need to make good videos,' she said, a reference to Mamdani's social media strategy. -----------
Yahoo
12 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Karoline Leavitt Snaps in Wake of Trump's Brutal Court Loss
White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt went on yet another angry tirade against federal judges who rule against Donald Trump. During an appearance on Fox News Thursday night, Leavitt was asked to respond to a federal judge who blocked the removal of the wife and five children of a man charged in a firebombing attack against peaceful protesters in Boulder, Colorado. Immigration and Customs Enforcement had the family arrested despite having no evidence that they were involved in the attack. Leavitt, who regularly rails against anyone who opposes Trump, was predictably incensed. 'Well, this is just another rogue decision by a rogue judge who is trying to be—I don't know—the president of the United States? The secretary of state? The secretary of homeland security?' Leavitt said. 'Surely, these important matters of both homeland security and national security do not belong to lower district, local judges in these districts across the country.' Leavitt's insistence that federal judges, whom she attempted to dismiss as 'local,' don't have the jurisdiction to rule against Trump betrays a failure to grasp the whole 'checks and balances' part of the U.S. Constitution. Leavitt continued, once again complaining about another federal judge who had blocked the unlawful deportation of immigrants to South Sudan, and supposedly stranded some ICE agents in a 'dangerous part of the world.' (The judge did not specifically say that the agents needed to stay overseas, which means the government is choosing not to bring them back.) 'Lower district court judges do not get to dictate the foreign policy and the national security interests of the United States of America. We can't run a country if the executive is not allowed to freely exercise its powers, and that's what we're seeing take place,' Leavitt said. Unfortunately for the Trump administration, the hits to its illegal immigration agenda just keep on coming. A federal judge on Thursday blocked the arrest and removal of Yunseo Chung, a Columbia University student and green card holder who was targeted by the administration over her involvement in pro-Palestinian protests. In a brutal hearing, U.S. District Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald called the government's position 'disturbing' and 'disappointing.' 'This is a new world. I'm a little taken aback,' Reice Buchwald said.
12 minutes ago
FBI, DHS warn of 'elevated threat' to Jewish community in new PSA
The FBI and Department of Homeland Security are warning of an "elevated threat" facing the Jewish community in the wake of two attacks: Sunday's Molotov cocktail assault in Boulder, Colorado, and last month's killing of two Israeli Embassy staff members in Washington, D.C. The Israel-Hamas conflict "may motivate other violent extremists and hate crime perpetrators with similar grievances to conduct violence against Jewish and Israeli communities and their supporters," the FBI and DHS said in a public service announcement issued Thursday night. "Foreign terrorist organizations also may try to exploit narratives related to the conflict to inspire attacks in the United States." The public should "remain vigilant" and "report any threats of violence or suspicious activity to law enforcement," the agencies said. The PSA references Sunday's attack in Boulder when Mohamed Soliman allegedly threw Molotov cocktails at a group of marchers advocating for the release of Israeli hostages, according to prosecutors. Fifteen people, including a Holocaust survivor, were injured, officials said. Soliman, who was arrested at the scene, allegedly yelled "Free Palestine" during the attack, the FBI said. Soliman later told police "he wanted to kill all Zionist people," court documents said. He "said this had nothing to do with the Jewish community and was specific in the Zionist group supporting the killings of people on his land (Palestine)," documents said. Soliman has been charged with a federal hate crime as well as 118 state charges, including attempted murder, assault and explosives charges. He has not entered a plea in either case. The PSA also mentions the May 21 killings of two Israeli Embassy staff members. Yaron Lischinsky and Sarah Lynn Milgrim were fatally shot as they left an event at the Capital Jewish Museum in D.C. When the suspect was arrested, he began to chant, "free, free Palestine," according to police. The Anti-Defamation League has documented a dramatic rise in acts of hate targeting Jewish people in the U.S. since the Oct. 7, 2023, terror attack in Israel. In 2024, the ADL said it recorded a record high of 9,354 antisemitic incidents in the U.S., marking a 344% increase over the past five years and a 893% increase over the past 10 years. "I am angry," ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt said a news conference in Boulder on Wednesday. 'It's way past time for our political leaders, community groups, media outlets, tech platforms, faith leaders to take action before more Jewish blood is spilled. And it's way past time to stop excusing antisemitic rhetoric," he said. Greenblatt urged the public to speak out against hate and shared small, specific actions people can take.
