X criticises Online Safety Act - and warns it's putting free speech in the UK at risk
The Online Safety Act is putting free speech at risk and needs significant adjustments, Elon Musk's social network X has warned.
New rules that came into force last week require platforms such as Facebook, YouTube, TikTok and X - as well as sites hosting pornography - to bring in measures to prove that someone using them is over the age of 18.
The Online Safety Act requires sites to protect children and to remove illegal content, but critics have said that the rules have been implemented too broadly, resulting in the censorship of legal content.
X has warned the act's laudable intentions were "at risk of being overshadowed by the breadth of its regulatory reach".
It said: "When lawmakers approved these measures, they made a conscientious decision to increase censorship in the name of 'online safety'.
"It is fair to ask if UK citizens were equally aware of the trade-off being made."
3:53
X claims the timetable for platforms to meet mandatory measures had been unnecessarily tight - and despite complying, sites still faced threats of enforcement and fines, "encouraging over-censorship".
"A balanced approach is the only way to protect individual liberties, encourage innovation and safeguard children. It's safe to say that significant changes must take place to achieve these objectives in the UK," it said.
A UK government spokesperson said it is "demonstrably false" that the Online Safety Act compromises free speech.
"As well as legal duties to keep children safe, the very same law places clear and unequivocal duties on platforms to protect freedom of expression," they added.
Users have complained about age checks that require personal data to be uploaded to access sites that show pornography, and 468,000 people have already signed a petition asking for the new law to be repealed.
In response to the petition, the government said it had "no plans" to reverse the Online Safety Act.
5:23
Reform UK's leader Nigel Farage likened the new rules to "state suppression of genuine free speech" and said his party would ditch the regulations.
Technology Secretary Peter Kyle said on Tuesday that those who wanted to overturn the act were "on the side of predators" - to which Mr Farage demanded an apology, calling Mr Kyle's comments "absolutely disgusting".
Regulator Ofcom said on Thursday it had launched an investigation into how four companies - that collectively run 34 pornography sites - are complying with new age-check requirements.
These companies - 8579 LLC, AVS Group Ltd, Kick Online Entertainment S.A. and Trendio Ltd - run dozens of sites, and collectively have more than nine million unique monthly UK visitors, the internet watchdog said.
The regulator said it prioritised the companies based on the risk of harm posed by the services they operated and their user numbers.
It adds to the 11 investigations already in progress into 4chan, as well as an unnamed online suicide forum, seven file-sharing services, and two adult websites.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
Trump threatens India with 'substantial' tariff hike for buying Russian oil
Donald Trump has threatened to "substantially" raise tariffs against India over its purchase of oil from Russia."They [India] don't care how many people in Ukraine are being killed by the Russian War Machine," the US president wrote on his online platform, Truth Social, on is currently among the largest buyers of Russian oil. It has become an important export market for Moscow after several European countries cut trade when Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in did not specify what the new tariff would be, but it comes just days after he unveiled a hefty 25% levy on India. Delhi called Trump's warning "unjustified and unreasonable". In a statement, a spokesman for India's foreign ministry, Randhir Jaiswal, said the US had encouraged India to import Russian gas at the start of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, "for strengthening global energy markets stability".He said India "began importing from Russia because traditional supplies were diverted to Europe after the outbreak of the conflict".India also criticised the US - its largest trading partner - for introducing the tariffs, when the US itself is still doing trade with Russia. Last year, the US traded goods worth an estimated $3.5bn (£2.6bn) with Russia, despite tough sanctions and tariffs. "Like any major economy, India will take all necessary measures to safeguard its national interests and economic security," the foreign ministry statement week, Trump had described India as a "friend" whose tariffs on US products "are far too high". His latest Truth Social post again struck a critical tone."India is not only buying massive amounts of Russian Oil, they are then, for much of the Oil purchased, selling it on the Open Market for big profits," he Minister Narendra Modi has not ordered India's oil refineries to stop buying Russian oil, Bloomberg reported, citing people familiar with the Srivastava, a former Indian trade official and head of the Global Trade Research Initiative (GTRI), a Delhi-based think tank, said Trump's claims about India's oil trade with Russia are misleading for several reasons. He told the BBC that the trade has been transparent and broadly understood by the US. Mr Srivastava said India ramped up purchases of oil to help stabilise global markets after Western sanctions disrupted supplies - helping to stop a global oil price shock. He also said that India's oil refineries - both public and private - decide where to buy crude oil based on factors like price, supply security, and export rules. They operate independently of the government and do not need its approval to buy from Russia or other countries. I'm 'disappointed but not done' with Putin, Trump tells BBCThough relations between the US and Russia warmed after Trump returned to the White house in January, the US president has more recently toughened his rhetoric against the Kremlin and Russian President Vladimir has questioned whether Putin is truly committed to peace with Ukraine. In Monday's Truth Social post he used stern language, describing the Russian military as the "Russian War Machine". Russia's leader has repeatedly said he is ready for peace but only if Kyiv meets certain conditions, such as recognising Ukrainian territories that Russia has occupied. Trump has threatened Moscow with severe tariffs targeting its oil and other exports if a ceasefire with Ukraine is not agreed by 8 envoy Steve Witkoff is due to visit Russia later this week, where he is expected to meet Putin.
The Sun
8 minutes ago
- The Sun
While Trump showed the world how to handle Brussels, Starmer waves the white flag on Brexit
PM's Brexit exit DONALD Trump showed the world how to force a deal with the EU. Terrify them with threats of the loss of billions in lost trade and tens of thousands of jobs … and watch Brussels beg for business. 1 Sadly, Sir Keir Starmer took the opposite approach with his sellout 'reset' deal. Now jubilant European leaders are bent on bullying the UK into accepting their tyranny all over again thanks to its terms. A total reversal of Brexit is closer than ever. The PM has repeatedly promised never to take the UK back into the EU's Customs Union and Single Market. Yet that is effectively what the EU Commission demands as the price of its agreement. Britain must take all EU regulations on food without any say in those rules — and pay penalties for not doing so. We couldn't even import food from outside the EU without its meddling. Technically, there is still time during last-minute negotiations for our dyed-in-the-wool Remainer PM to stop this gross betrayal of Brexit. But on current form he seems vanishingly unlikely to do so. Keir Starmer- hopes for reset with EU do not mean 'reversing Brexit' Boiling over VOTER rage at the immigration explosion is close to boiling point. And even the OBR says public services are seriously stretched because of Britain's over-reliance on migration. Yet tin-eared Labour ministers still lecture protesters outside asylum hotels by telling them 'anger doesn't get you anywhere'. They don't get that Nigel Farage's current success comes from speaking real people's language. Similarly, useless cops appear to have learned nothing from the handling of the identity of the Southport killer. — as Warwickshire police did in the case of an Afghan accused of raping a 12-year-old girl — are an affront to justice. The immigration status and nationality of all offenders should be published for each crime. It's the only way to restore trust. Cell out WHY is the Left's answer to prison overcrowding always to release prisoners or cut sentences? Ex-Chief Inspector of Prisons and human rights activist Dame Anne Owers says a near meltdown in the system means even mandatory life sentences for murder should be scrapped. How about, instead of letting thousands of dangerous criminals back on to the streets, Labour does what the Tories so abjectly failed to do.
Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
SNP in disarray as Deputy First Minister becomes latest to flee sinking ship
The SNP is in disarray after the Deputy First Minister announced she will quit at next year's elections, sparking claims she is deserting a 'sinking ship'. Kate Forbes announced her decision not to seek re-election as her daughter turned three, saying she does not want to 'miss any more of the precious early years of family life'. Allies of Ms Forbes claimed that her decision to quit may have been partly down to 'disgraceful' treatment during her leadership contest against Humza Yousaf, when senior figures including Mr Swinney and Nicola Sturgeon raised concerns about her stance on issues like same-sex marriage. Her announcement is a further blow to Mr Swinney ahead of the election, as she is widely regarded as one of his most capable ministers and has helped try to repair the SNP's relationship with the business community. Scottish Conservative MSP Meghan Gallacher said: 'Despite our political differences I completely understand and appreciate Kate Forbes reasons for standing down. I wish her and her family well for the future. 'However, the departure of his Deputy First Minister will come as a hammer blow to John Swinney ahead of next year's election. 'He made the choice to bring her back into the heart of the government last year and would have wanted her to play a key role in the campaign. 'Kate Forbes is the latest senior figure to desert the SNP's sinking ship and clearly has no wish to hear voters' anger after 18 years of the nationalists' failing Scots on so many issues. 'If Scotland is to move on from the SNP's never-ending obsession with independence, then we must remove them from office next year and get the focus back on Scotland's real priorities.' Fergus Ewing, who backed Ms Forbes' previous leadership bid and is now an independent MSP, suggested that her treatment by senior figures in the previous contest, including Mr Swinney questioning whether her opposition to same-sex marriage made her an appropriate candidate to be First Minister, had played a part in her decision. Mr Ewing said: 'With Alex Salmond's death the SNP lost the best leader it has ever had, with Kate Forbes' decision to stand down the SNP has lost the best leader it should have chosen. 'As a dear friend of Kate's, I absolutely understand her decisions to bring up her family but the way that Kate was treated during the leadership election between herself and Yousaf was disgraceful. 'Yet despite being attacked by John Swinney and Nicola Sturgeon during that campaign because essentially they argued her Christian beliefs somehow disqualified her from being SNP leader, Kate turned the other cheek and did so with astonishingly good grace. 'The SNP has now lost the outstanding talent of her generation and perhaps that loss resulted from the SNP ceasing to be a broad church, tolerant of different views, and latterly descended into a form of cult or sect where dissent was unacceptable and rational argument was almost absent from debate.' Ms Forbes, who narrowly lost a fractious leadership contest to Humza Yousaf in 2023 but was brought back into government last year as Mr Swinney sought to heal divisions in the party, said she has 'consistently put the public's needs ahead of my family's' and now does not want to 'miss any more of the precious early years of family life'. Including Fergus Ewing and John Mason, who were both elected as SNP candidates in 2021 and have since left the party, Ms Forbes becomes the 25th Nationalist to step down from the party at next year's elections. Others include former First Ministers Nicola Sturgeon and Humza Yousaf. SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn and a score of former failed MPs have been accepted as potential candidates for the 2026 election. Anne McLaughlin, Kirsten Oswald, Anum Qaisar and Tommy Sheppard have also been named on the approved list. It comes after the SNP suffered a damaging defeat in the recent Hamilton by-election. Labour's Davy Russell won the SNP seat with 8,559 votes, a majority of 602 over the Nationalists. The vote followed the death of SNP MSP Christina McKelvie, who had represented the constituency since 2011. Ms Forbes came under attack from a range of SNP MSPs during the 2023 leadership contest for her position on same-sex marriage and other beliefs she holds as a member of the Free Church of Scotland. In a radio interview in 2023, Mr Swinney, then the Deputy First Minister, urged party members 'to decide if someone who holds those views would be an appropriate individual to be SNP leader and first minister'. She had been expected to put her name forward as a candidate to be Mr Yousaf's successor when he resigned but instead agreed to join Mr Swinney's team rather than standing against him, in what opponents billed as a 'stitch-up'. Ms Forbes was a prominent critic of the proposed gender reforms when Ms Sturgeon was First Minister, signed a letter raising concerns about them and said she wouldn't have voted for them. She also recently confirmed that she 'unequivocally' backs the protection of single-sex spaces. Other prominent internal opponents of the SNP's self-ID agenda included Joanna Cherry, who lost her seat in last year's general election and does not intend to stand for Holyrood next year, Ash Regan, who defected to the Alba Party, and Fergus Ewing, who will stand for election as an independent candidate for Inverness and Nairn. Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie thanked Ms Forbes for her service over a decade in parliament and wished her well in future endeavours and spending time with her family, but added: 'But it cannot have escaped the notice of voters that many of the SNP's former rising stars are abandoning the stage, often to be replaced by defeated names of yesteryears and anonymous party apparatchiks. 'Kate Forbes was the future once - but now, like many of her counterparts in the SNP, she can see the writing on the wall. The truth is this is a tired government with no vision and no ideas.' In a statement which shocked Scottish politics yesterday morning, Ms Forbes said she had informed her local constituency association that she would not seek re-election next year. She said she is 'wholly supportive' of Mr Swinney and will campaign for the SNP in next year's election. But the Deputy First Minister, who is also Economy Secretary, said: 'I have grown up in the public eye, getting married, having a baby and raising a young family. I have consistently put the public's needs ahead of my family's during that time. 'I am grateful to them for accommodating the heavy demands of being a political figure. Looking ahead to the future, I do not want to miss any more of the precious early years of family life - which can never be rewound.' In his letter responding to her resignation, Mr Swinney said he is sorry she has taken the decision 'but recognise and understand the reasons for doing so'. He said: 'You have made a huge contribution to public life in Scotland and have been instrumental in making progress on economic issues for my Government. 'You have much to be proud of in all of the work you have undertaken but I am especially heartened by the effect of your leadership on advancing support for the Gaelic language. 'We all wrestle with the inevitable conflicts between family and public life and I sympathise with the dilemmas you have faced. I wish you, Ali and your family well and much happiness in the years ahead.' At an event in June, Ms Forbes admitted she was 'unsuccessfully' trying to juggle bringing up her daughter and her Cabinet job and raised fears that childcare issues may have contributed to many female MSPs leaving politics. She also urged the Scottish Parliament to follow the lead of the House of Commons and set up its own nursery.
