Grieving Scots mum calls for probe into scandal hit Glasgow hospital's baby unit
A grieving mum who lost her baby son at a scandal-hit hospital has called for a wider probe into the troubled site.
Carolanne Baxter wants the neonatal unit at Glasgow's Royal Hospital for Children to be included in the ongoing Scottish Hospitals Inquiry looking into the problems at the facility and adjoining Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH).
Since she first learned about the wider concerns about the QEUH campus, she has been plagued with doubt about the circumstances of her son William's deterioration and death.
We revealed last week that more than £78million has been spent investigating and repairing the QEUH since it opened a decade ago, including £10million being spent to fix ventilation in a child cancer ward, £6million for tap filters and £880,000 for water and air testing.
Now, the 42-year-old mum of three from Glasgow, who lost William in 2019, has now told for the first time of her heartbreaking experience.
Carolanne said: 'I have to do this for my son because I have to get answers for him. The inquiry always looks at the child cancer wards but I was in the neonatal intensive care unit with William and things weren't right there either.
'We were told not to drink tap water, only bottled water. If there were no issues with the water supply, then why was that?'
William was born premature at 28 weeks and five days old on January 29, 2019. He never left the hospital and died there on July 18 that year.
Carolanne said he developed several infections while at the hospital and was given three types of medication, which she claimed she didn't know about.
She fears the infections could have been linked to the environment. Carolanne said: 'He had cannulas [tubes for giving medication and fluid] all over him – in his arms, legs, even in his head.
'We know those are areas where infections could get in easily. He was born in good condition but two weeks later he got an infection and developed sepsis.'
According to William's medical notes, he had been 'colonised with serratia', a type of bacteria previously investigated at the neonatal unit years earlier after a number of babies were found to have it.
He was also found to have been infected with two other bacteria called staphylococcus aureus and Klebsiella pneumoniae, resulting in sepsis. His medical records also state that his central line – another type of tube used for giving medicines – was infected and had 'blocked and burst' and had to be replaced.
As he was born so prematurely, William had various complex health problems and was due to have heart surgery but this was cancelled.
Carolanne said: 'They kept having to cancel the operations because he had infections. He would fight back from the infections but something would come again. He never got the surgery in the end.'
Along with infections, William had several broken ribs and a broken arm, which Carolanne claims medics failed to explain or tell her about until days after they discovered the injuries.
She said: 'It took them three days to tell me he had broken ribs and a broken arm. They said it was because he was premature and it could have been when he was being handled.
'I don't know why I wasn't told straight away.' Carolanne insists she had not realised there were concerns about infections in other parts of the site.
She said: 'It wasn't until two years later and my mum said there had been problems with the QEUH and infections. I started reading into it and realised it was when I was there with William. It made me question everything and made me think about why certain things were happening.
'We were moved out of rooms, told not to drink the tap water. William had got infections when he was in the hospital and he never left there, so were any of them related to the environment?
'It was like a double whammy, it hit me all over again.' In 2022, Carolanne was diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder as a result of what happened to William.
She said: 'I had to give up work, I wasn't able to be a good mum to the rest of my children. It goes round and round in my head, what could I have done differently? What did I not notice?'
Carolanne is a witness at the public inquiry looking into the QEUH campus problems but said there has been no focus on the neonatal unit and potential problems there. She said: 'That's why I wanted to give a statement, in the hope they would take it into account too because I know things were not right there.'
An NHSGGC spokesman said: 'The NICU is part of the older, retained estate on the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital campus and has a separate water and ventilation system. It does not form part of the new-build hospitals covered by the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry's terms of reference.
'We have carried out, and continue to take, significant action to reduce environmental risks in our hospitals to help us to provide high quality care.'
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
9 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Tourist's life-changing injuries 'after swimming in filthy hotel pool'
Alexis Williams, 23, went for a swim at the Residence Inn Downtown Ann Arbor Hotel while staying in Michigan - but hours later she was struck down with 'excruciating pain', her lawyers say A woman suffered horrific injuries after swimming in an untreated hotel pool, her lawyers say. Alexis Williams, 23, was visiting her grandma while she was undergoing medical treatment in Michigan in June and had decided to stay at the nearby Residence Inn Downtown Ann Arbor Hotel. While there, she and her cousins went for a swim in the hotel's pool - but soon became violently ill, she claims. Alexis says she later found out that scraping her knee while swimming had led her to contract a rare infection known as MRSA - Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus. It comes after a man claimed 'I died for seven minutes in hospital - here's exactly what I saw on the other side'. The infection is particularly dangerous because it's resistant to most antibiotics - which means it can spread easily to the point it becomes a threat to life. Just hours after taking a dip, Alexis was struck down with "excruciating" pain and found herself unable to walk. Speaking to Fox 2 Detroit, she explained: "It was outrageous. The pain was excruciating. I had to get poked a lot with a whole bunch of needles, and being prescribed medications I never thought I'd be prescribed to." What followed was three gruelling rounds of surgery on her leg and the intravenous administration of potent antibiotics, her lawyer Ven Johnson said. Alexis - who now receives constant medication through an IV, and even needs a walker to move around - was terrified doctors would amputate her leg. "I've gone through a lot of pain and suffering, and still currently am," she told the Detroit Free Press. "I'm very frightened, very nervous and just appalled by everything." After making a request to the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy, Alexis' lawyers learned of the disgusting condition of the pool. Her lawyers said inspections from June 12, June 27 and July 8 showed neither chlorine no bromine had been put in the water. The case centres around claims the hotel was fully aware the swimming pool "had a Standard Plate Count that exceeded 200 CFU/ml". This reading would indicate a "dangerous level of bacteria present in the swimming pool and poor disinfection", the complaint reads. Alexis' legal team alleges the hotel disregarded public safety and was aware of the unsafe environment it had created for guests. "Alexis started developing this infection within several hours of coming into contact with this water," Michael Freifeld, one of her attorneys, told the Detroit Free Press. "We have no doubt, given the records we have and the experts that we are going to hire, that the infection Alexis experienced, and is experiencing, was clearly connected to the pool." Mr Freifeld said doctors warned they may have to amputate her leg if the infection is not brought under control by her current treatments. "For anybody, let alone a 23-year-old young person, it's a very scary, uncertain prognosis," Mr Johnson said. Alexis and her team are seeking $25,000 (£18,820) in damages The Mirror has contacted the owner of the Residence Inn for further comment.
Daily Record
2 days ago
- Daily Record
Scots NHS spent £75k on controversial report clearing superhospital of infection links
Families and experts have questioned the report which NHSGGC submitted to a public inquiry. NHS chiefs have been criticised after it emerged they paid £75,000 of public money for a controversial report clearing a scandal-hit hospital of links to infection outbreaks. The Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH) is at the centre of a public inquiry after dozens of patients became infected with rare bugs. A government-ordered independent review published in 2021 stated 109 infections in 84 patients had 'possible or probable' links to the £842million superhospital's environment and two children's infections were a probable cause of their death. But it has now emerged NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (NHSGGC) paid £75,000 to commission a report of their own which cleared the hospital of links to any of the infections and even went to court to ensure it was accepted into evidence at the ongoing inquiry. Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar said: 'It is simply astonishing that the rotten leadership of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde spent £75,000 of public money on a sham of a report to clear their name. 'The scandal at the QEUH is the greatest in the history of devolution and those responsible must be held to account. 'It is unforgivable that the health board leadership – aided and abetted by the SNP – have put their reputation before the safety of patients and staff. I'll not stop campaigning side by side with the families affected until justice is served.' The health board's report states the independent review took a 'flawed approach' and had a 'preconceived view' patients' infections came from the hospital environment. It claims data on infections 'doesn't support' the idea the hospital had a contaminated water system or the 'environment at the QEUH is playing a significant role in harbouring and transmitting pathogens' to adults and children. It goes on to state that the data doesn't support the theory that water or ventilation at the QEUH and adjoining Royal Hospital for Children presents an 'additional avoidable risk of infection' and concludes: 'The data does not demonstrate a link between the water or ventilation systems and patient infections.' However, the report has been rebuffed by the scientists who completed the original independent review of 118 cases at the QEUH and RHC, as well as by families. The inquiry's own solicitors, who are not representing either side, have also said they believed the ventilation system is still not safe today. Lawyers representing former cancer patient Molly Cuddihy and her family also raised concerns the health board's report excluded data about a rare bacteria called Mycobacterium chelonae. Molly, along with fellow child cancer patient Stevie-Jo Kirkpatrick, were infected with the bug at the QEUH campus. The Cuddihys lawyer said: 'This omission is especially critical given the documented presence of M. chelonae in hospital water systems across multiple wards and its direct association with severe infections in [child cancer patients].' They said report authors didn't use data on the current state of the hospital environment in its conclusions and called it 'non-sensical' and 'indefensible'. NHSGGC said: 'We are committed to supporting the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry in their ongoing investigations. 'The report will be considered as part of the wider inquiry and report experts Professor Hawkey, Dr Agrawal, and Dr Drumwright, now take instruction from Scottish Hospitals Inquiry.' Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
Telegraph
2 days ago
- Telegraph
This royal biography is clutching at straws
She points out that the late Queen's sister, who died in 2002 aged 72, had stunted growth, struggled to learn how to write and suffered mood swings as well as painful migraines. But isn't this yet another case of trying to medicalise everyday problems? Margaret had none of the more obvious symptoms of FAS, such as smooth lip philtrum, small eyes, and a flattened mid she was small, at 5 ft 1, but her mother was only an inch taller. FAS sufferers have difficulties with social skills, but the princess was the life and soul of any party. They also have difficulty with fine motor skills and yet Margaret was an accomplished pianist. Sure, she was impulsive and would 'blurt out the truth' – but the same can probably be said of most royals and aristocrats of her era! While the Queen Mother did enjoy 'a tipple' later in life, as attested by her official biographer William Shawcross, there is no evidence she was an alcoholic – least of all when she gave birth to her daughters in 1926 and 1930. Indeed, in a 1925 letter to her husband, cited by Secrest, she reveals that she has lost her appetite for wine in pregnancy, joking: 'It will be a tragedy if I never recover my drinking powers.' Despite enjoying gin and Dubonnet, wine, port and martinis, she lived to 101. Very heavy drinkers don't tend to become centenarians!
