‘Strong GDP, weak pulse': India's growth masks deep economic faultlines, says report
NEW DELHI: India's GDP growth for the January-March quarter of FY25 may have surprised on the upside, but a new report warns that the robust headline figure masks an economy still struggling under the surface.
Systematix Research, in a sharp critique, said the 4QFY25 growth 'continues to be dependent on public spending-led construction,' while key indicators point to deeper structural weaknesses. 'The upside surprise in Indian GDP growth makes a robust headline, but it masks underlying weaknesses,' the report stated.
Cracks behind the headline numbers
Among the red flags, the report noted that money supply grew much slower than nominal GDP, raising concerns about the credibility of the growth data.
Additionally, personal consumption expenditure grew faster than the actual sales volume of consumer goods, indicating a disconnect between reported demand and real consumption.
While government capital spending surged, private investment likely contracted. 'Public spending is not crowding in private investment,' the report noted, suggesting that the government's infrastructure push is failing to stimulate broader economic momentum.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Gentle Japanese hair growth method for men and women's scalp
Hair's Rich
Learn More
Undo
Demand still fragile
Household income remains under stress, retail lending growth has slowed, and reduced government subsidies have added to the pressure. Net indirect taxes rose to their highest level since June 2018, which the report said has further squeezed demand.
Meanwhile, even as the current account deficit narrowed, the total trade contraction signals weakening domestic and global demand. 'There is a growing disconnect between reported GDP figures and the on-ground economic situation,' the report said.
Outlook hinges on rural consumption
Systematix points to rural demand revival and agricultural strength as key to future growth. But with private capex still elusive and global uncertainties mounting, a meaningful recovery may remain sluggish.
While the Reserve Bank of India may step in with easing measures if inflation stays low, the report warns that low inflation itself reflects weak incomes and demand, not price stability.
Global headwinds ahead
On the international front, the report cautioned that panic buying in global trade, in anticipation of possible tariffs under a second Trump administration, could push the US towards stagflation, a risk that would ripple through emerging markets like India. With India's trade-to-GDP ratio already falling, the country may find itself exposed to external shocks without the cushion of strong export performance.
'In the absence of a turnaround in productive employment,' the report concludes, 'India's growth story risks becoming increasingly imbalanced and fragile.'
Stay informed with the latest
business
news, updates on
bank holidays
and
public holidays
.
AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
21 minutes ago
- India Today
Sebi issues attachment order against Mehul Choksi for non-payment of penalties
The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) on Friday issued a recovery attachment order against absconding diamond merchant Mehul Choksi, who is a co-accused in the Rs 13,850-crore Punjab National Bank (PNB) fraud case, which is one of the biggest banking scams in India's recovery officer has been assigned the task of taking action on the attachment order, issued on June 4 by the financial agency's Mumbai action against the fugitive diamond merchant had been initiated due to the non-payment of a Rs 1.5 crore penalty imposed by Sebi on January 31, 2022. Sebi went ahead with the attachment as it believed that Choksi might dispose of funds, thus obstructing the recovery of the total dues amounting to Rs 2.10 who has been wanted in India since 2018, was arrested in Belgium in April. His arrest, which took place on April 12, was made by Belgian authorities after a request from Indian agencies like the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED).He was detained in a hospital in Belgium, where he was said to be receiving medical PNB SCAMThe Rs 13,850-crore PNB scam involved Choksi and his nephew Nirav Modi, who is currently languishing in a jail in the UK and is soon to be extradited to they were able to take loans from foreign banks using Letters of Undertaking (LoUs) issued by PNB's Brady House branch in Mumbai. An LoU is a bank guarantee which allows customers to get short-term credit from overseas 2011 to 2018, Choksi, Modi and their companies used these LoUs without following the normal procedures. Some bank officials were involved and allowed the LoUs to be issued without entering them into the bank's main system. This helped the fraud go unnoticed for funds, which were shown as being used for importing goods, were mostly never returned. Instead, new LoUs were taken to repay the earlier ones, and the money was used for business and personal total value of the fraud reached around Rs 13,850 crore. Out of this, Nirav Modi's companies were linked to Rs 6,498 crore and Choksi's Gitanjali Group to Rs 6,097 crore. The remaining amount includes interest and other Watch IN THIS STORY#Mumbai Indians
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Donald Trump not interested in talking to Elon Musk as feud gets nasty - here's what could happen next
Donald Trump and Elon Musk feud has taken a sharp turn as the U.S. President refuses to speak with the Tesla and SpaceX CEO over a controversial tax-cut bill. Trump, frustrated with Musk's opposition to the bill—which adds $2.4 trillion in debt—threatened to cancel SpaceX contracts. The fallout is affecting Tesla shares and political alliances, with Musk pulling back support. Their public rift could impact the 2026 midterms and Republican unity. As Musk questions Trump's spending, their once-close relationship now risks damaging key government programs and conservative efforts. Here's what's really going on behind the scenes of this high-stakes political drama. Donald Trump and Elon Musk clash over tax bill, government contracts, and national debt concerns, shaking up Washington politics, Tesla shares, and the future of SpaceX. Here's what triggered the feud, what's at stake, and what could happen next. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Why did Trump refuse to speak with Elon Musk? What sparked the Trump-Musk fallout? Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads How are Trump's threats affecting SpaceX and Tesla? How does this feud affect the Republican agenda? Could Musk's actions hurt Trump's reelection and Republican control? Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads What comes next if Trump and Musk don't reconcile? FAQs: Donald Trump and Elon Musk feud deepens amid tax bill fight and contract threats. U.S. President Donald Trump has firmly shut the door on a potential conversation with Tesla and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk, escalating a bitter public feud that threatens both Republican unity and key economic legislation. Despite efforts from top White House aides to arrange a call between the two influential figures on Friday, Trump made it clear he wasn't interested. 'I'm not even thinking about Elon. He's got a problem, the poor guy's got a problem,' the president told sharp fallout comes at a time when Trump is pushing to get his sweeping tax-cut and spending bill passed through the Senate. But Musk's vocal opposition to the plan—and Trump's growing frustration with him—could derail the bill and spark broader political and financial to a White House official, speaking anonymously to Reuters, there were early attempts to get the two men on a call. Initially, a different aide had even suggested that a conversation was scheduled. But as tensions mounted, Trump canceled any potential contact and turned his focus has reportedly considered ditching the red Tesla Model S he proudly bought in March after showcasing Musk's vehicles on the White House lawn. The message was clear—he's distancing himself, both politically and the center of the fallout is Trump's signature tax-cut and spending bill, a core part of his domestic agenda. Elon Musk has slammed the proposal, calling it a 'disgusting abomination' that would add $2.4 trillion to the national debt over the next decade. Musk's criticisms have been echoed on his platform, X, where he agreed with posts suggesting Trump's bill could harm Republicans in the upcoming who once described the bill as a 'big beautiful' win for America, was clearly frustrated. After Musk's remarks, Trump responded with his own attacks, threatening to cancel SpaceX and Starlink contracts, a move that would have significant implications for U.S. space tensions immediately impacted Tesla's stock. On Thursday, shares dropped by 14%, wiping out a staggering $150 billion in value—the largest single-day loss in the company's history. On Friday, the stock made a slight recovery, but uncertainty remains Musk warned that if Trump were to follow through with cutting SpaceX contracts, he would start decommissioning the Dragon spacecraft—the only American vehicle currently capable of transporting astronauts to the International Space Station. Although Musk later walked back that threat, it shows how serious the stakes have resistance to Trump's tax and spending plan is more than a personal disagreement—it's a major political hurdle. The bill has already passed the House of Representatives but faces a tougher battle in the Senate, where Republicans hold a slim majority. Without Musk's backing, and possibly his financial support, the party's unity is at Speaker Mike Johnson, who has reportedly been texting with Musk, hopes the issue will resolve. 'I don't argue with him about how to build rockets, and I wish he wouldn't argue with me about how to craft legislation and pass it,' Johnson told who funded a large part of Trump's 2024 presidential campaign, has already hinted at pulling back. Last week, he said he'd reduce political spending, and just this Tuesday, he called for voters to 'fire all politicians who betrayed the American people.'The public feud also opens the door to more disruption within the GOP, especially as Silicon Valley donors and business leaders closely watch the spat. Some fear Musk may not just stop his support—he could actively mobilize against Trump's James Fishback, one of Musk's few vocal allies, called on the billionaire to apologize to Trump, noting, 'President Trump has shown grace and patience at a time when Elon's behavior is disappointing and frankly downright disturbing.'There's growing speculation about how this could all play out. Trump remains adamant about pushing his multi-trillion-dollar economic plan, but without the help of one of his most high-profile allies, the road ahead looks the scenes, political analysts warn that the GOP could suffer setbacks in the 2026 midterm elections if the Musk rift grows. While Musk hasn't entirely ruled out making peace—he responded 'You're not wrong' to a post urging reconciliation—it's clear the relationship is at a breaking public split also risks damaging consumer confidence in Tesla and trust in SpaceX's role in government programs. With both sides trading shots, and the economy hanging in the balance, this Trump-Musk feud is more than a headline—it's a high-stakes political and economic clash with far-reaching is upset because Musk criticized his tax-cut bill and its $2.4 trillion debt may cancel SpaceX deals if the conflict with Musk continues.
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
One in four international students in US were from India: At 4.2 lakh Indian students, fuelled surge in numbers during 2024
The total number of active F-1 and M-1 international student SEVIS records in the US were a whopping 15.8 lakh in 2024, marking a 5.3% increase over the previous calendar year. According to a report released by the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) – 'SEVIS by the Numbers 2024', while international students hailed from more than 229 countries, this growth was substantially fuelled by students from India. Asia had the largest number of active international student records in the US, nearly 11 lakh students from this continent accounted for nearly 72% of the total foreign student population. Nearly 4.2 lakh Indian students represented an increase of 11.8% compared to 2023, while the 3.2 lakh foreign student records from China, which is the other major source country, represented a small decrease of 0.25 percent compared to 2023. Indian students constitute nearly 27% of the total foreign student population in 2024, followed by Chinese at 20%. The data in this report is drawn from the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), a web-based system that the Department of Homeland Security uses to maintain and manage information on foreign students and exchange visitors. While the F-1 visa is held by those undergoing academic study courses, the M-1 visa is given to students undergoing vocational programs. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Tìm hiểu thêm Undo According to the ICE-report, more than 90% or to be precise 14.3 lakh international students were enrolled in higher education degree programs, California enrolled the largest number of foreign students at 2.37 lakh, followed by New York at 1.72 lakh. attracted the maximum number of international students While this ICE-report is based on data for 2024, the recent trends are not as rosy. Chris R. Glass, a professor and higher education specialist at Boston College analysed SEVIS data between March 2024 to March 2025. According to him, 'The overall decline of -11.3% from March 2024 (with 11.53 lakh active students) to March 2025 (with 10.22 lakh active students) is remarkable in both scale and speed.' His study shows that the number of students from India declined by nearly 28% from 3.54 lakh in March 2024 to 2.55 lakh a year later. The number of Chinese students rose marginally by 3.28% to stand at 2.63 lakh as of March 2025. Glass points out that 'The current year-over-year decline is a reflection of an enrollment cycle that began under the Biden administration, so the March 2025 numbers have yet to reflect any impacts of policies implemented under the second Trump administration.' Anecdotal evidence suggests that US is losing its lustre as an attractive study destination for Indian students owing to a multitude of factors such as: The arbitrary termination of SEVIS records and/or F1 visas of international students – which led many to self deport, while others stayed back to battle it out in courts; the uncertainty relating to continuity of the extended optional practical training program (OPT) for STEM students, the temporary suspension of consulate interviews pending release of a social-media scrutiny policy and mass layoffs in corporate America. Thus, the numbers for March 2026 could be much lower. Indian students dominate the STEM field: While international students are eligible for a one year OPT, those from the Science, Technology, Mathematics and Engineering (STEM) fields, post their graduation, get an additional two years of work experience under the OPT program. There were 1.94 lakh OPT students with both an employment authorization document (EAD) and who reported working for an employer in 2024, compared to 1.60 lakh 2023. This marks a 21.1 percent increase from 2023 and the fourth year of consecutive growth, states the ICE-Report. In 2024, nearly 1.65 lakh international students participated in the STEM-OPT extension program. The ICE-report points out that Indian students are particularly prominent in the post-completion OPT- STEM extension program, accounting for a substantial 48.0% of participants. and 20.4% from China.
