Navy veteran's $500M defamation lawsuit against Associated Press advances with first hearing
Young successfully sued CNN for defamation earlier this year after saying the network smeared him by implying he illegally profited from helping people flee Afghanistan on the 'black market' during the Biden administration's disastrous 2021 military withdrawal.
Advertisement
When covering the trial in January, Associated Press media reporter David Bauder wrote that 'Young's business helped smuggle people out of Afghanistan.'
Young's legal team has said that the Associated Press article 'went even further than CNN's falsehoods,' and the veteran is seeking nearly $500 million in a defamation suit against the AP.
On Monday, Young's legal team responded to the AP's motion to dismiss the suit.
The AP had insisted Young's complaint is 'without merit' and unjustly challenges the outlet's free speech rights, but the Navy veteran's legal team believes the motion failed to address 'core issues.'
Advertisement
'It does not dispute that the term 'human smuggling' implies criminal conduct, nor does it offer any valid explanation for its use of that term, even though a court previously ruled that Mr. Young committed no crime. AP's own Stylebook defines 'smuggling' as illegal,' Young's attorney, Daniel Lustig, wrote.
3 Former U.S. Navy Veteran Zachary Young continued his high-stakes defamation lawsuit against the Associated Press to clear his name of the report that he smuggled people out of Afghanistan.
FOX News
'Dozens of AP articles reflect that usage. Just days before this filing, AP published a story about a man sentenced to 25 years in prison for 'smuggling people,' reinforcing that understanding,' Lustig continued.
'Even after receiving notice, AP refused to retract or revise the statement, not even to use a more accurate term such as 'evacuate' or 'rescue.''
Advertisement
3 Young was able to successfully sue CNN and is seeking nearly $500 million in a defamation suit against the AP.
AP
Young's attorney believes the most 'notable' part of the AP's motion to dismiss is that it never denied that 'smuggling' refers to a criminal act.
'Instead, it argues that the statement, in context, was not defamatory. That is not a defense, it is a concession. Under Florida law, if a statement is reasonably capable of a defamatory meaning, it is a question for the jury, not one to be resolved on a motion to dismiss. AP's attempt to invoke the anti-SLAPP statute to shield such a statement is both legally unsupported and fundamentally flawed,' Lustig wrote.
Young's legal team has also filed a motion to amend the complaint to include punitive damages.
Advertisement
3 Young's attorney Daniel Lustig said, the most 'notable' part of the AP's motion to dismiss is that it never denied that 'smuggling' refers to a criminal act.
FOX News
The 242-page filing suggested this case 'exemplifies the very scenario in which punitive damages are warranted to punish and deter such consciously indifferent conduct by a media organization.'
On Tuesday, each side appeared for the first hearing in front of 14th Judicial Circuit Court Judge William S. Henry, who also presided over the CNN trial.
The Case Management Conference, conducted over Zoom, was largely procedural and offered a chance for each party to explain why respective motions should be heard.
Judge Henry scheduled the next hearing for July 3. He is expected to rule on both the AP's motion to dismiss and Young's amended complaint.
The AP has referred to the lawsuit as 'frivolous' in past statements to the press.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
29 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Los Angeles school year begins amid fears over immigration enforcement
LOS ANGELES (AP) — Los Angeles students and teachers return to class for the new academic year Thursday under a cloud of apprehension after a summer filled with immigration raids and amid worries that schools could become a target in the Trump administration's aggressive crackdown. Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Alberto Carvalho has urged immigration authorities not to conduct enforcement activity within a two-block radius around schools starting an hour before the school day begins and until one hour after it classes let out. 'Hungry children, children in fear, cannot learn well,' Carvalho said in a news conference. He also announced a number of measures intended to protect students and families, including adding or altering bus routes to accommodate more students. The district is to distribute a family preparedness packet that includes know-your-rights information, emergency contact updates and tips on designating a backup caregiver in case a parent is detained. The sprawling district, which covers more than two dozen cities, is the nation's second largest with more than 500,000 students. According to the teachers' union, 30,000 students are immigrants, and an estimated quarter of them are without legal status. While immigration agents have not detained anyone inside a school, a 15-year-old boy was pulled from a car and handcuffed outside Arleta High School in northern Los Angeles on Monday, Carvalho said. He had significant disabilities and was released after a bystander intervened in the case of 'mistaken identity,' the superintendent said. 'This is the exact type of incident that traumatizes our communities; it cannot repeat itself,' he added. Administrators at two elementary schools previously denied entry to officials from the Department of Homeland Security in April, and immigration agents have been seen in vehicles outside schools. DHS did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Carvalho said that while staffers and district police officers cannot interfere with immigration enforcement and do not have jurisdiction beyond school property, they have had conversations with federal agents parked in front of schools that resulted in them leaving. The district is partnering with local law enforcement in some cities and forming a 'rapid response' network to disseminate information about the presence of federal agents, he said. Educators worry about attendance Teachers say they are concerned some students might not show up the first day. Lupe Carrasco Cardona, a high school social studies and English teacher at the Roybal Learning Center, said attendance saw a small dip in January when President Donald Trump took office. The raids ramped up in June right before graduations, putting a damper on ceremonies. One raid at a Home Depot near MacArthur Park, an area with many immigrant families from Central America, took place the same morning as an 8th grade graduation at a nearby middle school. 'People were crying, for the actual graduation ceremony there were hardly any parents there,' Cardona said. The next week, at her high school graduation, the school rented two buses to transport parents to the ceremony downtown. Ultimately many of the seats were empty, unlike other graduations. One 11th grader, who spoke on the condition that her last name not be published because she is in the country without legal permission and fears being targeted, said she is afraid to return to school. 'Instead of feeling excited, really what I'm feeling is concern,' said Madelyn, a 17-year-old from Central America. 'I am very, very scared, and there is a lot of pressure.' She added that she takes public transportation to school but fears being targeted on the bus by immigration agents because of her skin color. 'We are simply young people with dreams who want to study, move forward and contribute to this country as well,' she said. Madelyn joined a club that provides support and community for immigrant students and said she intends to persevere in that work. 'I plan to continue supporting other students who need it very much, even if I feel scared,' she said. 'But I have to be brave.' Some families who decide that the risk is too great to show up in-person have opted for online learning instead, according to Carvalho, with virtual enrollment up 7% this year. The district has also contacted at least 10,000 parents and visited more than 800 families over the summer to provide information about resources like transportation, legal and financial support and are deploying 1,000 workers from the district's central office on the first day of classes to 'critical areas' that have seen immigration raids. 'We want no one to stay home as a result of fears,' Carvalho said.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Bryan Kohberger called his mom on way home from Idaho killings, again on his way to visit crime scene: report
Bryan Kohberger called his mother twice in the hours after he butchered four University of Idaho students in their off-campus home — including on his way to revisit the scene of the murders, according to a report. Kohberger, 30, phoned his mom, Maryann Kohberger, at 6:17 a.m. on Nov. 13, 2022, when arriving at his Washington State University campus home after the quadruple homicide, PEOPLE magazine reported, citing information from case investigator Heather Barnhart. The convicted killer called his mother first at 6:13 a.m., then immediately called his father when she did not answer, Barnhart told the outlet. 3 Kohberger called his mother, Maryann Kohberger, at 6:17 a.m. on Nov. 13, 2022, when arriving at his Washington State University campus home after the quadruple killing AP She eventually picked up the phone and the two talked for 36 minutes, the outlet said. Kohberger commonly reached out to his father as soon as his mother would not respond to him, the investigator explained. 'And he would go back and forth texting: 'Father, why did mother not respond? Why is she not answering the phone?' Barnhart told the outlet. Then, at 8:03 a.m. that day, Kohberger called his mother again and the two spoke for 54 minutes, Barnhart said. The timing of the call suggests he was chatting with his mom on his drive back to the crime scene at the Moscow home. Kohberger spent roughly 10 minutes there at around 9 a.m., Latah Prosecuting Attorney Bill Thompson revealed at his plea hearing. Just minutes after their conversation, Kohberger reached out to her again at 9 a.m. and the call lasted 10 minutes, when he was likely close or nearing the scene, the outlet said. 3 In total, the mother-son duo spoke on the phone for roughly three hours during separate calls. AP The mother-son duo had another brief two-minute call at 4:05 p.m. and a final 96-minute marathon call at 5:53 p.m., the outlet reported. In total, the two spoke on the phone for roughly three hours the day of the murders, Barnhart, who was tasked with examining Kohberger's phone and hard drive, said. The former criminology PhD student sometimes called his mother as early as 4 a.m., according to phone records. He made all the calls from a Samsung Galaxy Phone purchased in June, the outlet said. Kohberger completely powered off his phone during the slayings, between 2:54 a.m. and 4:48 a.m., likely to protect himself. The discovery was a 'pretty awesome' and incredibly revealing moment for investigators, Barnhart recalled. 'When he powered it off, it was from a human pressing a button, and the battery was at 100 percent charged,' Barnhart said. This means his defense was unable to claim his phone had simply died during the time of the killings. Kohberger also had no text records with any friends outside of his family, she said. Kohberger last month unexpectedly copped to the Nov. 13, 2022, murders of Xana Kernodle, Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, and Ethan Chapin at their off-campus house in Moscow — earning him life in prison. 3 Kohberger completely powered off his phone during the murders, between 2:54 a.m. and 4:48 a.m., likely to protect himself. The controversial deal he struck with prosecutors allowed him to avoid the death penalty and dodge a trial where victims' loved ones might have gotten a look into the motivation for the heinous stabbings — the lack of which drew ire from some victims' families. The cold-blooded quadruple murderer had no words for his mom, Maryann, and sister, Amanda, as he was hauled out of the courtroom in cuffs during his sentencing. He is currently being held at the Idaho Maximum Security Institution in Kuna.
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
FBI returns stolen Hernán Cortés manuscript to Mexico
MEXICO CITY (AP) — Nearly five centuries after Spanish conquistador Hernán Cortés signed it and decades after someone swiped it from Mexico's national archives, the FBI returned a priceless manuscript page to Mexico on Wednesday. The FBI said in a statement that the document had changed hands various times over the years, so no one will be charged. 'This is an original manuscript page that was actually signed by Hernán Cortés on February 20, 1527,' said Special Agent Jessica Dittmer, a member of the FBI's Art Crime Team. By then, Cortés had conquered the Aztec empire in 1521, two years after landing in present-day Mexico. While archivists at Mexico's General Archive of the Nation were microfilming their collection of documents signed by Cortés in 1993, they discovered that 15 pages of the manuscript were missing. They believe it was stolen between 1985 and 1993. Mexico requested the help of the FBI's Art Crime Team last year for this particular page. The FBI eventually narrowed the search to the United States and located the document, though the agency did not say who had it. The New York City Police Department, U.S. Department of Justice and Mexico's government were all involved in the investigation. It is the second Cortés document the FBI has returned to the Mexican government. In 2023, the agency returned a 16th-century letter from Cortes. 'Pieces like this are considered protected cultural property and represent valuable moments in Mexico's history, so this is something that the Mexicans have in their archives for the purpose of understanding history better,' she said.
