Some local authorities inspecting ‘just 10%' of new builds for compliance with safety regulations
The Construction Bar Association annual conference heard on Friday that local authorities require greater resources to ensure compliance with building safety regulations.
Deirdre Ní Fhloinn, a barrister specialising in construction law, said statistics of historical building defects in Ireland do not suggest there were a 'few bad eggs in the industry' but instead, there was a 'systemic problem'.
She cited a 2022 report that found that up to 100,000 of the 125,000 apartments built between 1991 and 2013 had defects concerning fire safety, water ingress issues or structural safety issues.
READ MORE
The total cost of repairing the homes is estimated to be in the billions, with Ms Ní Fhloinn saying the taxpayer has become the 'insurer of last resort for building defects'.
Noting that rules and regulations were adequate at the time of their construction, Ms Ní Fhloinn said enforcement was a 'huge part' of the problem.
Speaking on the value of 'robust regulation', she welcomed the fact that Government approval has been received to draft a general scheme to establish a Building Standards Regulatory Authority.
She said about a quarter of new buildings are being inspected by local authorities, adding that this figure itself is inflated by larger authorities that inspect upwards of 70 to 80 per cent of new buildings.
On the other hand, some authorities are inspecting 'virtually none', she said.
Property developer Michael O'Flynn, meanwhile, said building control regulations in Ireland have 'great standards' but agreed enforcement of the regulations was a 'key weakness'.
Inspection levels vary significantly among local authorities, he said, with some inspecting just 10 per cent of new buildings.
'There is no huge shortage of existing regulation, the question is, is it happening? Are people doing what they're supposed to be doing?'
'Local authorities are inspecting, unfortunately, a very low percentage. There has to be a consistent standard,' he said, adding that resourcing and upskilling is a must to ensure adequate enforcement.
Mr O'Flynn added that there is currently no balance between regulation and planning, saying the Irish planning system was suffering from an 'existing enormous backlog'.
He cited 2023 figures in which 22,000 housing planning applications were caught in a backlog in
An Bord Pleanála
, which had an average waiting time of 79 weeks.
He described waiting times generally as 'quite frightening' and a 'really serious issue'.
'Our planning system is in a very bad place,' he said.
'We can't ignore these things, because if we do, we will continue to fail a generation of people who are unable to buy homes,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Muted opposition to latest Clonliffe College apartments plan
A renewed bid by the Irish arm of property firm, Hines , to construct a €646 million large-scale apartment scheme on the grounds of the former Holy Cross College in Drumcondra has met only limited opposition. Hines partner fund, CWTC Multi-Family ICAV, lodged plans last month with Dublin City Council for a 10-year planning permission for the 1,131-home scheme that includes a 13-storey apartment block for the site on Clonliffe Rd. The new application comes four years after Hines lodged its original plan for 1,614 apartment units under the Strategic Housing Development (SHD) framework to An Bord Pleanála . Only three local residents have called for outright refusal of the latest application but the developer. READ MORE More than 120 submissions were made on the original build-to-rent scheme, including an objection from Sinn Féin party leader, Mary Lou McDonald . She stated that if planning is approved, it would only further exacerbate the housing crisis . An Bord Pleanála granted planning permission for the original development but that permission was quashed by the High Court after a challenge was brought by Fionnuala Sherwin from Foxrock, Dublin 18. With the date for third party submissions on the latest plan now closed, the city council has received just eight submissions with only three calling for a refusal of planning permission for the entire development. The 1,131 apartments in the new scheme would be built across 12 apartment blocks ranging in height from three to 13 storeys. Local resident Alison Hay is one of those who has called on Dublin City Council to reject the entire scheme, arguing that 'a building height of 13 storeys is incongruent and sets an unwanted precedent for further developments. This is further amplified by having multiple apartment blocks of similar heights close together near Drumcondra Road'. Denis McGee of Distillery Rd said the scheme was inappropriate and 'will completely destroy residential amenity in the immediate area in the short, medium, and long term'. Broadly welcoming the proposal, Dublin Central Labour TD, Marie Sherlock said in a submission that 'this site must be used to provide housing'. 'In the context of a housing crisis both in our city and in the country at large, it is vital that sites such as this be converted into space for new homes,' she said. 'However, it is just as vital that the homes constructed are sustainable, high-quality and affordable. These homes must also be integrated meaningfully within the existing community and provide real options for people to put down roots and live in the area long-term if they wish.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Appeal Court overturns requirement for councils to get members' consent before defending legal actions
Local authorities do not have to seek the approval of councillors before deciding to enter a defence to a court challenge to council decisions, the Court of Appeal has held. The three-judge court's decision overturns a High Court ruling from June last year that found councils must take the 'positive step' of securing express authorisation from elected members before defending a case. The question of whether authorisation from councillors is required has been raised in several High Court challenges related to decisions of elected members, such as votes on local development plans. Every local authority must have a development plan, a document with maps that guides how certain areas should be zoned and developed. READ MORE It is used to guide planning decisions in those areas, but is sometimes the subject of litigation by interested parties who could be affected by any changes. In this case, developer Oceanscape Unlimited Company brought a legal challenge over the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council development plan and the decision to rezone its lands at Stillorgan Business Park for educational facilities. Oceanscape contended the rezoning amounted to a 'sterilisation' of its site and would cause the company 'serious and irreparable' harm as well as costing it millions of euro. The council filed legal documents opposing the developer's claim, but Oceanscape argued the local authority had no power to do this as it had not sought prior authorisation from elected members, which it argued was required under the Local Government Act, 2001. It asked the court to strike out the council's opposition statement on these grounds. Section 153(2) of the Act states that where a legal action relates to the performance of functions reserved to the elected members, the chief executive 'shall' act with the 'express authorisation of the elected council'. It provides that such authorisation 'shall be deemed to have been given unless or until the contrary is shown'. The council asked the court to interpret the section which, it said, relies on an assumption that the chief executive has a 'deemed authorisation' that is lost only where elected members actively direct him not to do something in a case. It said no formal resolution was passed by elected members, but they were aware of the proceedings and were formally briefed on them in March 2023. The High Court had ruled in Oceanscape's favour, finding the required authorisation was not secured in this case. Soon afterwards, the High Court introduced new practice rules requiring local authorities to inform the court early on whether councillors had given express authorisation to defend a challenge to their decision. However, the Court of Appeal has now overturned the High Court decision and has ruled in favour of the council in a recently published judgment. Explaining the appeal judges' rationale, Ms Justice Nuala Butler said entering into litigation was an 'executive function' and could be taken by the chief executive without requiring a vote of elected councillors. 'In these circumstances, the appeal taken by the local authority will be allowed and the order striking out its statement of opposition will be set aside,' she said.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Would-be homebuyers urged not to hold off in expectation of lower mortgage rates
Borrowers and would-be homebuyers should be wary of making financial decisions 'based on the hope that European Central Bank (ECB) rates will drop further or indefinitely'. That's according to Trevor Grant , chairman and co-founder of Irish Mortgage Advisors. Mr Grant was speaking after the Central Bank published its latest monthly data on interest rates in Wednesday, showing Ireland remained one of the more expensive jurisdictions in the euro zone for mortgages . The regulator's latest monthly data indicated that the weighted average interest rate on new mortgages here fell marginally to 3.6 per cent in June. READ MORE This was down one basis point from 3.61 in May and 51 basis points lower in annual terms. The equivalent euro zone average was 3.29 per cent, the Central Bank said, making Ireland the seventh most expensive jurisdiction in the bloc. The latest figures come after last month's decision by the ECB to pause a recent run of interest rate cuts. Analysts now anticipate that there might be just one more cut this year, in December. 'This significant shift in ECB policy could not only mark the end of its rate cutting cycle, it could also herald that ECB rate hikes might be on the cards in late 2026, particularly if inflation starts to edge upwards in the EU again,' Mr Grant said. 'So mortgage borrowers and would-be house buyers should be mindful that the pace of further mortgage rate cuts is likely to slow or even come to an end,' he said. 'Borrowers should therefore avoid making large financial decisions based on the hope that ECB rates will drop further or indefinitely.' He said there were many reasons why Ireland remains one of the more expensive euro zone countries for mortgages. 'For example, Irish lenders are required to hold more capital than many of their European peers,' he said. 'Also, when a borrower defaults on a mortgage, Irish lenders have stated that they often find it more difficult than other European lenders to take control of and sell off the assets that were pledged as collateral to secure the mortgage,' he said. 'Notwithstanding all this, there is still room for improvement and slowly competition is bringing rates down.' Rachel McGovern , deputy chief executive at industry group Brokers Ireland , said while more competition is entering the mortgage market the benefit may become more evident later in the year. The Central Bank figures also show that Irish consumers had €166 billion in savings with Irish banks as of last month. Of that, over 85 per cent – or over €142 billion – is held in overnight deposit accounts which are attracting a meagre 0.13 per cent in interest on average. Retail banks here have been criticised for failing to increase their deposit rates in line with ECB levels while reporting big annual profits. The figures also show that an increasing number of new mortgage holders are opting for fixed rates, which now constitute 85 per cent of all new mortgage contracts. 'Mortgage borrowers are seeking security,' Ms McGovern said. 'With property prices continuing to increase, they are taking on ever higher levels of debt.'
