Councillor resigns over 'lack of transparency' on George building collapse
The scene of the five-storey building that claimed 34 lives when it collapsed in George.
Image: Ayanda Ndamane / Independent Newspapers
GEORGE councillor, Chantelle Kyd has resigned from Planning and Development Mayoral Committee over what she says is the DA-led municipality's lack of transparency over the confidential tabling of reports on the George building collapse.
More than a year since the May 6 tragedy, several investigations and numerous promises of accountability have yet to result in any justice for the families of the victims of the George building collapse, which claimed the lives of 34 workers and left dozens injured.
The GOOD councillor on Friday tendered her resignation, saying it was not an easy decision but that she could not stay in an executive role where 'truth is suppressed, accountability is avoided, and coalition partners are treated with contempt rather than respect'.
Kyd said: 'The DA-led coalition in George has increasingly demonstrated a deep disregard for the principles of co-governance. There has been a consistent and deliberate pattern of sidelining, marginalising, and censoring coalition partners. This pattern extends to matters of national importance, such as the investigation into the building collapse, an issue I have been centrally involved in. Despite being the MMC responsible for Planning, I was effectively gagged (in council) from speaking on the very matter I was mandated to lead on.
'It is unacceptable that the DA would choose to table critical reports behind closed doors, bar the media, and deny coalition partners the opportunity to address the public truthfully. This behaviour is authoritarian, and it erodes the foundation of partnership and accountability upon which coalitions should be built.'
Kyd accused the DA of expecting coalition partners to 'simply fall in line, regardless of principle, process, or public interest'.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
DA Western Cape leader Tertuis Simmers said the position to table the item as confidential was a 'collective decision'.
'Contrary to their statement, the position on the specific item in question was adopted by the Joint Coalition Caucus as all parties agreed to its recommendations - which included GOOD's participation - not solely by the DA caucus. This was a collective decision that all coalition partners were thus expected to uphold.
"Furthermore, as GOOD communicated in recent weeks on the matter publicly, GOOD was informed that it could issue a party-political statement on the matter following the council meeting. So in no way were GOOD George sidelined, marginalised or censored while a member of the coalition government. The DA remains firmly committed to stable, principled, and effective coalition governance we form part off and wherever we serve, guided by the spirit and terms of the agreed upon coalition agreement which binds all parties that are part of the coalition government,' said Simmers.
The George municipality did not respond to further requests for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
When we think about hunger we don't think about peace — here's why we should
Hunger isn't just about food. It's about power. It's about who gets to eat, who decides and who is heard. If we're serious about justice, then no one should be hungry. In South Africa, hunger is not just about empty stomachs, but also about unequal systems. It exists in crèches that exclude children whose parents can't pay fees, in homes where grant applications fail quietly, and in the lives of people with disabilities navigating systems that overlook their most basic needs. The student who is excluded from funding because they are considered too poor to afford university, yet not poor enough to qualify for state assistance, caught in the gap of eligibility. The woman who sits at the traffic lights with her child asking for small change or food. The problem is not that the country does not produce enough food, the problem is about who eats and who does not. Hunger is not just about food, it is about power, it is about peace, and it is deeply gendered. Women, especially Black women, carry the heaviest load in South Africa's food crisis. They cook, stretch budgets, sell in the informal economy and absorb the emotional violence of food insecurity. They go hungry so children can eat. And when food runs out, so does safety. As we've seen time and again, from the Covid lockdowns to the July KwaZulu-Natal unrest, scarcity breeds violence and is expressed against Black bodies. Despite producing enough food to feed everyone, South Africa has more than 63.5% of households facing food insecurity. We live in a country with one of the world's most progressive constitutions, in which section 27 guarantees the right to food and water. Yet every day millions go hungry. And too often we forget who exactly is being left behind. Hunger is a multidimensional crisis that undermines health through malnutrition, poor disease resistance and skipped medication. It fractures social cohesion, creating stigma, shame and desperation, worsening economic outcomes, especially for women and young people already at the margins. Women in informal settlements skip antiretrovirals because they can't take them on an empty stomach. The missing population that is not reported on include those not in employment, education or training, outside of the Not in Education, Employment or Training (Neets) active or inactive. There are people who are not in employment who are not receiving social grants and are not in the youth category, including children who are not in early childhood development, and are left without resources to access food. Despite policy interventions such as school feeding schemes, social grants and the 2023 SAHRC-led right-to-food study commissioned by the Department of Agriculture, significant structural gaps remain. Many interventions are not reaching those outside formal systems – such as children excluded from early childhood development programmes or people with disabilities navigating inaccessible services. These omissions reveal a deeper issue: our food security mechanisms are not designed with the most marginalised in mind, reinforcing cycles of invisibility and exclusion. This is not just a failure of delivery. It is a failure of vision. If we think of hunger only as a developmental or nutritional issue, we miss its full impact. Hunger is relational. It creates shame, fuels desperation and destabilises communities. We need to stop treating hunger like an economic inconvenience and start addressing it as a political and peace issue, one that is deeply gendered. The Centre for Social Justice, under the leadership of Professor Thuli Madonsela, has reframed hunger as a constitutional crisis. In the recent expert symposium I attended on 10 April in Pniel discussions rightly rooted the right to food in section 27 of the Constitution, making the case for structural change that is systems-based and a rights-driven approach to food insecurity. The research on Gendered Dimensions of Hunger and Peacebuilding by the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation and University College Dublin drives the conversation further, urging for a widened lens where food security is a catalyst for peace. Because hunger, when it intersects with gender, exclusion and poverty, becomes something even more dangerous – a disruptor of peace. A participant in the ongoing research said that in one of the dialogues they conducted a man asked: 'How do you expect me and my people to engage on peace when we are hungry?' Let's be clear: we have the policy tools, we have the research and we have the constitutional mandate. What's needed now is a shift in mindset from hunger as a welfare issue to hunger as a peace and justice imperative. When hunger intersects with gender inequality, disability and exclusion, it fuels gender-based violence, erodes trust in the state and drives protests, looting and resentment. As the UN Security Council warned in 2025, hunger isn't just a consequence of conflict. It's a cause. We must act like it. That means embedding gender, peace and inclusion into every food policy. It means tracking how hunger affects social cohesion, how it exacerbates violence, how it chips away at democratic trust. It means giving voice and space to those most affected not after the fact, but as architects of the solutions. If we are serious about building a future rooted in justice and peace, then we must start treating hunger as both a political emergency and a moral failure. This means going beyond food parcels and short-term aid. We need women-led food and peace councils that place care, equity and lived experience at the heart of decision-making. We need disability-sensitive food access tools that acknowledge the everyday barriers disabled people face in reaching nourishment. And above all, we must ensure that no child goes invisible simply because their stomach is empty outside of school hours. Hunger is not just a symptom it is a warning signal. And ignoring it now means paying the price in conflict, unrest and fractured futures. Hunger isn't just about food. It's about power. It's about who gets to eat, who decides and who is heard. If we're serious about justice, then no one should be hungry – not a mother, not a child, not a person navigating hunger with a disability. Because food justice is peace work. Because peace doesn't start in Parliament – a place where conflict should be dealt with – it starts in homes where children eat, with women who aren't forced to trade their bodies for bread, and with the ability of persons with disabilities to access food without stigma. Where food security is not a charity but a human right. So, what would it look like to build a hunger strategy rooted in gender justice and peace? We are at a turning point. With the National Food and Nutrition Security Plan (2024-29) in development, and a government of national unity on the table, the political moment is ripe. But the question remains: will we continue with business-as-usual? Or will we reimagine hunger as the crisis of dignity, justice and peace that it is? As one working at the intersection of gender, hunger, and peace, I say this: until hunger is addressed as a breach of peace and women are recognised as leaders in healing it, our democratic promises remain half-written. We don't often think of food when we talk about peace. But we must – because in every empty stomach lies a silent protest against injustice. If we want peace to flourish, it must begin with food security, dignified women and inclusive food systems. DM Naledi Joyi is a gender programme officer at the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation. Her work focuses on the intersections of gender-based violence, food systems and structural inequality. She has conducted research across rural and urban South Africa and post-conflict Liberia, exploring how violence is embedded in institutions, economies and everyday survival.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Mkhwanazi is a great example of servant leadership
KZN Provincial Commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi. Image: Tumi Pakkies/ Independent Newspapers KWAZULU-NATAL Provincial Police Commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi must be extraordinarily proud and elated with his work and that of the men in blue he proudly leads. Who can not? Rarely does the whole country agree on one thing. If there is a person who is respected, admired and loved by the majority of South Africans, it definitely has to be the KZN commissioner. It is selfless dedication to his work that has endeared him to millions of South Africans. Jackie Robinson puts it aptly when he says, 'A life is not important except in the impact it has on other lives.' Undoubtedly, Mkhwanazi has impacted people's lives positively. Mkhwanazi is a leader that inspires respect and admiration for his ability to grasp and work through complex issues. He is a leader who is revered for being smart, articulate and forthright. He stands out as a voice of reason, who listens rather than arousing emotions and mediates rather than infuriates. In the cauldron of politics, Mkhwanazi has earned respect across party lines and commands respect across the political spectrum. Indeed, Mkhwanazi is, in Dante's words, maestro and autore: mentor, exemplar and a leader. A transcendent quality of Mkhwanazi's is his personal humility and support for the raising up of others. He takes care to mentor those he leads and creates opportunities for their leadership, recognition, and advancement. He has his own way of both exercising and demonstrating what it meant to lead. Mkhwanazi is known for his gentle disposition, a quality that makes him a very agreeable colleague and an influential mentor. His trademark ability to engage directly with respect and optimism are qualities that make him a rare public official. He understands that one of his fundamental responsibilities as a leader is to treat all those he works with and leads with respect. Never to denigrate or humiliate his subordinates, because to do so is much more a reflection on one's lack of personal discipline than it is on the shortcomings of someone one mistreats. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Lieutenant-General Nhlanhla Mkhwanzi Image: Archives Mkhwanazi is a visionary in understanding the role that Saps could play at this critical moment in our country where crime is rampant. I have watched Mkhwanazi observe numerous contentious debates with volleys of conflicting ideas and opinions flying back and forth, then raising his hand to quietly move the discussion in a positive direction. I have also witnessed time and again the persuasive power of Mkhwanazi's intellect and the respect afforded him by the others assembled. His skills of bringing the relevant parties together and achieving agreement on what is important are what have made him successful and endeared him to millions of South Africans. For me, Mkhwanazi is a rare cocktail of brilliance, dogged determination and foresight, compassion and respect, and tolerance. Armed with an imperturbable demeanour and self-effacing humility, Shamase, which is Mkhwanazi's clan name, is also the epitome of architect Wies von Ludwig's aphorism, "Build, don't talk." What distinguishes Mkhwanazi is his sharp mind and remarkable skill at making good arguments. He has a rare gift – an intuitive ability to distinguish good arguments from silly ones. Together with countless men and women in blue, they are a formidable team that share the passion for the welfare and safety of the residents of KwaZulu-Natal. Simply put, Mkhwanazi and the police force are on a mission to make KwaZulu-Natal a better place. What they are doing is just fundamental but comprehensive. Mkhwanazi has come to enjoy great success and well-deserved admiration as one of the best-performing and no-nonsense provincial commissioners. His career has many deserving milestones. There is one quality of Mkhwanazi that impresses one. It is his preternatural ability to nurture and inspire everyone he works with. It is an open secret that the police in KwaZulu-Natal at some stage did not inspire confidence. They did not always operate as a well-oiled machine. The great Mkhwanazi has since changed that perception. He has energised the police, seen the value in what others bring to the team, and worked effectively together. He has encouraged and challenged all the police, teaching them to focus on the real objective and always strive to do their best. And when their best isn't good enough, their first concern is that you would have let Mkhwanazi down. Indeed, Mkhwanazi has an ability to take the personal out of disagreements. I don't know how he does it, but he could make differences of opinion not about one or about me, but about the organisation and getting the job done. He inspires us on a daily basis. Mkhwanazi's secret, I think, is that, while a proud man, he is without guile or gall. A bright, quick study, he could home in on what is important and never, ever, find it necessary to build himself up at the expense of others. He is, quite simply, utterly at home in his own skin. He is an excellent boss--and a better person. I firmly believe Mkhwanazi is not just the by-product of being the consummate "people person" that he is. It's the mark of a leader, a manager, a guiding star to one and all. It's the essence of a unique person who is always present. I hope and pray the men and women in blue are learning from Mkhwanazi the value of 'being exact, being prepared, being careful – all things that are important to what I do now.' What we need today is to provide servant leader role models for our young so that they realise that celebrity status is not a substitute for knowledge, service, or community building. Our world needs servant leadership practitioners more than ever. Deepening economic woes threaten the American dream for far too many working people. There are precious few servant leaders in our current political environment. Many elected officials are more interested in personal power, individual legacy, and financial gain than in the sacrifice and commitment that servant leadership requires. It is people like Mkhwanazi that the nation expects to empower the youth to purchase the future by the present. Today's leaders have what is called the power to 'empower' others. The author, Henry Miller, expressed this concept best when he wrote: 'No one is great enough or wise enough for any of us to surrender our destiny to. The only way in which anyone can lead us is to restore to us the belief in our own guidance.' Police Commissioner Mkhwanazi's leadership is precisely doing just that, to 'lead us to restore to us the belief in our own guidance.' In the words of Robert F. Kennedy, 'Some men see things as they are and ask, 'Why?' I dream of things that never were and ask, 'Why not?' Why not, Mkhwanazi? May you ignite the spark that will provide the needed and better leadership that our country desperately needs. Dr Vusi Shongwe works in the KZN Department of Sports, Arts and Culture and writes in his personal capacity. His views don't necessarily reflect those of the Sunday Tribune or IOL SUNDAY TRIBUNE
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
The R13 million library in Orange Farm: A year of unfulfilled promises
The Drieziek Community Library has not seen opened its doors to the community since it was officially inaugurated by the Gauteng provincial government over a year ago. Image: Supplied A state-of-the-art R13 million public library in Drieziek, south of Johannesburg, opened by the Gauteng provincial government five days before the May 2024 national and provincial elections, remains unused. This emerged this week in correspondence sent by DA member of the Gauteng provincial legislature, Kingsol Chabalala, to the province's Sport, Arts, Culture and Recreation MEC Matome Chiloane, demanding that the abandoned facility in Orange Farm be finally opened. Inside the Drieziek Community Library in Orange Farm. Image: Supplied Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Chabalala said construction of the library started in February 2014, with a total cost of over R13m. Chiloane's predecessor as Sport, Arts, Culture and Recreation MEC, Morakane Mosupyoe, who is now the speaker of the Gauteng provincial legislature, on May 24, 2024, officially opened the library five days before last year's elections on May 29. The DA is demanding answers on why the Drieziek Community Library has still not opened a year later. Image: Supplied It was scheduled to open to the public on May 27 and offer lending services (print and online), reference service and research support, study space and support with access to dedicated study areas and programme implementation, including reading development programmes such as the Battle of the Books and the Story Skirmish starting from July last year. Other promised offerings included e-learning programmes such as digital skills and basic coding for children of all ages, children's services, including homework assistance, story hours, and holiday programmes, as well as photocopying services. The Drieziek library was also meant to fulfil various community-centred roles, such as a community centre, which would be a place for learning, socialising, meetings, business, research, and education for children. There would be an entertainment space offering fiction, audiobooks, and online resources for community enjoyment, an empowerment centre providing digital skills training, reading and learning skills, and assistance with online job applications. Other services were a knowledge and information centre supporting lifelong learning through various print and online resources, an education space encouraging quiet reading, learning and research, and community discussions. However, Chabalala complained that a year later, it remains inaccessible and unbeneficial to Orange Farm residents, while funds are wasted on security and maintenance. He said that when the provincial legislature's Portfolio Committee on Sport, Arts, Culture and Recreation conducted an unannounced oversight visit on May 21 this year, members found only a security guard present. 'The DA has tabled questions in the legislature to Chiloane, to determine why this facility is closed to the public and inquire about the amount spent on security and maintenance,' said Chabalala, adding that residents were frustrated because they must commute to nearby townships to access libraries while their own is gathering dust.
