NI NAP proposals labelled ‘challenge' to farmers' way of life
Earlier this month, Minister for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs in Northern Ireland, Andrew Muir launched a public consultation on the NAP for 2026 to 2029, which he said contains 'additional measures which have been developed based on scientific research'.
The main additional measures include further restrictions on use of chemical phosphorus fertiliser and a farm phosphorus balance limit for more intensive farms.
Lord Tom Elliott said: 'We are aware that in many areas of life, including agriculture much action is required to improve the environment.
'I have always encouraged the minister to do that in cooperation with the farming sector, as opposed to direct confrontation.
'The farming community have already made significant progress towards reduction of nutrient and other positive environmental matters. However, they need the minister and DAERA to work with them as opposed to resistance of farmers.
'I agree with Dr. Sinclair Mayne, who is former CEO [chief executive] of the Agri Food and Biosciences Institute [AFBI] and former departmental scientific adviser for the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development that it is essential that proposed new measures are based on robust science, based on peer-reviewed scientific papers, rather than subjective assessment,' Lord Elliott added.
The UUP chairperson stressed that this was the basis for the first action programme agreed with the European Commission in 2007 and subsequent reviews.
Elliott claimed that Dr. Mayne has detailed a number of areas where DAERA has not presented the appropriate scientific evidence base for the proposals.
'DAERA [has] done little to even attempt to persuade farmers of the merits of these most recent proposals; they seem more intent on pushing the farming community beyond what it can achieve, with little cooperation or working together,' he continued.
'I repeat my earlier calls, before it's too late for the minister to work with the farming sector, as opposed to him being seen by many farmers as an enemy to their way of life and someone who seems to many as set on destruction of the agricultural industry in Northern Ireland.
'The farming sector has so much to offer the entire society, it is vital that the DAERA and the agricultural community work together.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
13 hours ago
- Agriland
Northern Ireland's NAP forum will not meet until September
Farmers for Action (FFA) is indicating that Northern Ireland's Nitrates Acton Plan (NAP) forum will not meet until September. The organisation's spokesperson, William Taylor told Agriland: 'Nothing will happen until the politicians at Stormont come back from their summer recess. 'FFA plans to actively participate in the discussions involving the members of the forum.' 'The appointment of an independent chair is extremely important. Agriculture Minister Andrew Muir has it within his gift to suggest an appointee. 'But the person stepping into the position must be fully ratified by the organisations that make up the stakeholder forum.' Regarding the issue of inheritance tax, and the decision taken by the chancellor last autumn to extend the scope of the levy to include production agriculture, Taylor believes that a legal precedent can be established that derogates Northern Ireland from this measure. He explained: 'The issue centres on Northern Ireland's unique, post-Brexit status and the continuing influence of certain European statutes. 'We are currently working with Fairness for Farmers in Europe on this issue.' Meanwhile, FFA is criticising what it regards as the unsustainable trends in farmgate prices currently impacting across the dairy, beef, and grain sectors. 'Dairy farmers should be getting at least 60p/L for their milk. And in the case of cattle sector, beef prices should be at least £8/kg," Taylor said. 'Dairy farmers across the UK are being driven out of business. And the same scenario is unfolding in the suckler sector.' The last 12 months have seen grain prices plateau at levels well below those recorded when Russia invaded Ukraine back in 2022. Taylor believes that corporate organisations operating within the grains and oilseeds sector have the influence to control markets in ways that suit their specific needs, and not those of farmers. 'The current Stormont Executive has the chance in what little time remains in this mandate to sort this problem out by introducing the Northern Ireland Farm Welfare Bill," the FFA spokesperson said. 'This measure would return farmers a true cost of production inflation linked plus a margin for their produce. 'Significantly, the Bill is now being looked at as a UK-wide initiative." 'Progress at either Stormont or Westminster couldn't come soon enough to help protect family farmers from inheritance tax and poor farm gate prices.'
Agriland
08-08-2025
- Agriland
In-person DAERA public consultations on draft NI climate plan set to start
The Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) will be holding public consultations over the coming months in relation to the draft Climate Action Plan 2023-2027. DAERA launched the consultation initiative back in June 2025, encouraging everyone to participate, saying "your views matter". Northern Ireland has stated its aim to achieve a target of net zero greenhouse gas emission by 2050 under the Climate Change Act, which was first passed in 2022. The draft Climate Action Plan sets out policies and proposals which aim to achieve these targets. The first consultation was held online last month (July 2), with the following consultations spread across Northern Ireland in the coming months: Belfast - Belfast City Hall, Banqueting Hall, August 20, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; - Belfast City Hall, Banqueting Hall, August 20, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; Cookstown - Burnavon Arts & Cultural Centre, August 27, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; - Burnavon Arts & Cultural Centre, August 27, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; Craigavon - Craigavon Civic and Conference Centre, September 2, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; - Craigavon Civic and Conference Centre, September 2, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; Enniskillen - Central Hall, South West College (Erne Campus), September 4, 2:00p.m-4:00p.m; - Central Hall, South West College (Erne Campus), September 4, 2:00p.m-4:00p.m; Ballymena - The Braid Arts Centre, September 9, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; - The Braid Arts Centre, September 9, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; Newry - Canal Court Hotel, September 16, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; - Canal Court Hotel, September 16, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; Ballynahinch - Millbrook Lodge Hotel, September 17, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; - Millbrook Lodge Hotel, September 17, 10:00a.m-12:00p.m; Omagh - Strule Arts Centre, September 23, 2:00p.m-4:00p.m; - Strule Arts Centre, September 23, 2:00p.m-4:00p.m; Derry/Londonderry - The Great Hall, Ulster University, Magee Campus, September 25, 2:00p.m-4:00p.m; - The Great Hall, Ulster University, Magee Campus, September 25, 2:00p.m-4:00p.m; Coleraine - Northern Regional College, Innovation Centre, October 1, 2:00p.m-4.00p.m; - Northern Regional College, Innovation Centre, October 1, 2:00p.m-4.00p.m; Online - October 2, 7:00p.m-8:00p.m DAERA has said it will be working with all other departments to carry out significant stakeholder engagement during the 16 weeks of this consultation to meet with, receive feedback, and hear the opinions of a wide range of stakeholders. DAERA also reminded the public that they can also respond to the consultation through the online survey on the DAERA website. This consultation provides the public with an opportunity to tell the department what they think of the policies and proposals that have been identified in the proposal, and share any comments or suggestions that they might have. DAERA said the draft plan will then be revised to reflect the views of the public gathered from this consultation, before a final plan is agreed. DAERA have said the main focus of this particular draft Climate Action Plan is on meeting the first carbon budget, which was agreed upon in December 2024 in a bid to meet targets by 2030, 2040, and 2050. There are 52 policies outlined in this draft that aim to reduce emissions, spanning across nine sectors, including: agriculture; land use and forestry; fisheries; waste management; public buildings; residential buildings; transport; energy production and supply; and business and industrial processes. Target/Budget Emission reduction required 2030 Target A 48% emissions reduction by 2030 against the baseline 2040 Target A 77% emissions reduction by 2040 against the baseline 2050 Target A 100% emissions reduction by 2050 against the baseline Carbon Budget 1 (2023-2027) 33% average annual reduction compared to the baseline Carbon Budget 2 (2028-2032) 48% average annual reduction compared to the baseline Carbon Budget 3 (2033-2037) 62% average annual reduction compared to the baseline The baseline above refers to 1990 emissions levels. DAERA said its analysis shows that if all the policies and proposals are implemented at the pace and scale detailed in the plan, the first carbon budget 2023-2027 can be met.
Agriland
07-08-2025
- Agriland
DUP: 'Farmers must be at the table' when resolving NI NAP issue
The Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) is calling for the development of a fair and equitable Nitrates Action Programme (NAP) in Northern Ireland. It is envisaged that the coming weeks will see a concerted attempt made to resolve this issue. The DUP's agricultural spokesperson, Carla Lockhart has confirmed that that many people had been very vocal regarding their opposition to the proposals currently on the table. She said: 'If implemented, they (the proposals) will decimate farming locally. 'Stormont's farm minister has now agreed to an independent group overseeing the NAP process. 'I would question the independence of that group. An appointment by the farm minister cannot be deemed to be independent.' Lockhart believes that the appointment of the chair of the new NAP group will be particularly important. She said: 'We need to see some meat on the bones of what actually is coming through as an amended package of proposal. 'Critical within all of this is a fully costed impact assessment, which must be carried out by staff within the Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs.' The DUP representative pointed to the £1.56 billion in losses indicated by the initial impact assessment work carried out by AgriSearch staff on the original NAP proposals. She said: 'Farmers must be at the table when it comes to resolving the NAP issue for the future. 'My understanding is that the final NAP package of measures must get the approval of the Stormont Executive. It is a cross-cutting matter. 'If we still end up with a scenario that does not meet the needs of agriculture in Northern Ireland, the DUP will veto the entire process at that stage.' Meanwhile, a cross party group of MPs is to meet at Westminster to seek changes to the recently published Finance Bill. This bill is the measure through which the UK government will introduce changes to inheritance tax, which will have a direct, and much anticipated, highly negative impact on UK agriculture. While attending the recent Clogher Valley Show, Lockhart confirmed to Agriland that the DUP "will be part of this process". She said: 'I also welcome the intervention made by President Trump in highlighting the very real downsides that result in extending the scope of inheritance tax to the farming industry. 'The president obviously puts real value on farmers and the people that feed us. And I think it is right that the prime minister should take note of these comments and learn from them accordingly. 'The inheritance tax issue hasn't gone away. The government has draft legislation in place at this stage. 'Working with other parties at Westminster, the DUP will seek to amend this." Lockhart has also confirmed that she is working with the chair of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (EFRA) Committee, Alistair Carmichael, on this matter. She said: 'The government must be forced into a U-turn on the inheritance tax issue.'
