RTE Act implementation delay in Telangana: It's just a small matter of money
HYDERABAD: The Telangana government's inability to implement a key provision of the Right to Education (RTE) Act, despite a high court directive, appears to boil down to one simple reason: lack of money.
Section 12(1)(c) of the RTE Act, 2009 mandates that 25 per cent of seats in private schools be reserved for students from disadvantaged groups in areas where there is no government school within a radius of 5 km to 10 km.
However, the state government has not put this into effect for the current academic year, even after the Telangana High Court ordered its immediate implementation. Officials say in private that the matter hinges not on intent but on funding.
Even basic liabilities remain unsettled. Dues amounting to roughly Rs 200 crore owed to private schools under the Best Available Schools scheme have not been cleared for three years. Additionally, the state government is yet to pay approximately Rs 6 crore to owners of private properties who lease buildings for government primary and secondary schools.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Broken vending machines expose Madhya Pradesh's failed promise of menstrual hygiene
A silent crisis is unfolding across government schools in Madhya Pradesh, after the state's commitment to menstrual hygiene lies in shambles as sanitary pad vending machines, once introduced with much fanfare, now lie defunct, unfilled, or missing tribal districts, the crisis has deepened further, with government schools and hostels operating on zero budget for menstrual hygiene like 'experience the freedom' have become hollow phrases in Madhya Pradesh. In place of support, girls are met with empty dispensers, malfunctioning machines, and administrative indifference. What should be safe spaces for learning have turned into sites of stress and indignity—especially in under-resourced tribal At Sarojini Naidu Government Girls Higher Secondary School in Bhopal, where nearly 1,300 girls are enroled, the only vending machine is locked inside the staff room. Teachers cited ongoing construction for the delay in the India Today team visited, the machine appeared functional but failed to dispense a pad after a five-rupee coin was inserted. A teacher admitted the machine hadn't been working for a long time, and that sanitary pads were often provided by staff from personal supplies. Only after testing the machine did the vice principal call a technician to repair Government Girls Higher Secondary School in Jehangirabad, with over 1,500 students, the condition was worse. The sole vending machine, donated by an NGO, was buried under dust and completely non-functional. It had not been maintained or refilled in months, with no accountability in sight. According to Vice Principal Vidushi Gupta of Sarojini Naidu School, 'There was construction going on, so we couldn't install the machine in the right place. It's been damaged—we've called someone to repair it.'advertisementWith no dedicated government budget, many schools rely on the Red Cross Society Fund, collected through annual student fees. Each student contributes Rs 20 to the fund, which is partly forwarded to the education department and partly retained by schools. Teachers use these limited funds to purchase sanitary pads, a stopgap measure at best. Nasreen, a senior teacher at the Jehangirabad school, said, 'The vending machine has been non-functional for a long time. We use Red Cross funds and sometimes depend on NGO donations. Teachers help on their own when nothing else is available.'TRIBAL GIRLS WORST HITThe crisis is far worse in the tribal belts, where the government claims to be focusing efforts. During the 2025 Budget Session, the Tribal Affairs Department admitted to allocating zero funds for sanitary pad vending machines in tribal regions from 2019 to 2025. Hostel girls receive just Rs 45 per month for menstrual needs—an amount grossly insufficient to maintain data highlights the severity of the problem:Sheopur: 0 machines in 21 schoolsMandla: 0 in 201 schoolsShahdol: 0 in 133 schoolsAlirajpur: 13 in 93 schoolsJhabua: 17 in 117 schoolsDhar: 5 in 233 schoolsKhargone: 4 in 155 schoolsBarwani: 14 in 147 schoolsSeoni: 7 in 119 schoolsDindori: 20 in 131 schoolsAnuppur: 3 in 135 schoolsadvertisementThese figures reflect systemic neglect in delivering basic healthcare to marginalised girls.'Whenever our periods start, we go into panic. There are no pads. We fear stains and judgment,' said Poonam Verma, a student. Another, Sarika Sable, added, 'The machine here hasn't worked in months. If friends don't help, we're left with nothing. It affects our health and our confidence.'STATE'S SCHEME TO PROMOTE MENSTRUAL HYGIENEIn August 2024, the Madhya Pradesh government claimed a breakthrough—transferring Rs 58 crore directly into the bank accounts of girls in Classes 6 to 12 at Rs 300 per student per year. This sum, meant to support 1.93 crore girls, translates to just Rs 25 per month—barely enough for one pack of sanitary pads, let alone a month's supply. Actual monthly needs typically range from Rs 70 to voices like Congress MLA Vikrant Bhuriya have slammed the initiative, calling it a 'scam worth crores.''The state says it's giving Rs 45 per girl for hygiene in the government hostels, but it has admitted there is no budget for vending machines in tribal areas. Schools are running without basic hygiene arrangements,' he told India Today. According to Bhuriya, over 3.3 lakh girls dropped out after Class 8 due to lack of hygiene infrastructure and Minister of State Krishna Gaur defended the government's approach. 'Our government is committed to providing free pads and installing machines. If there is negligence anywhere, it will not be tolerated. Authorities are responsible for this, and funding has been given,' she Watch
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Calcutta HC orders Centre to rollout MGNREGA in West Bengal from August 1
The Calcutta High Court on Wednesday directed the Centre to implement the MGNREGA scheme prospectively in West Bengal from August 1. The HC said the Centre is empowered to impose special conditions, restrictions and regulations, which have not been imposed in other states of the country, so as to ensure that no illegality or irregularity occurs when the scheme is being implemented in the state. Allowing the Centre to continue its enquiry into the allegations of irregularities in some districts of the state, a division bench presided by Chief Justice TS Sivagnanam directed that the scheme be implemented prospectively with effect from August 1. The court directed that the authorities in charge of the implementation of the scheme are entitled to impose special conditions to ensure that whatever had occurred three years prior should not recur. The court said that it is not in dispute that certain irregularities have been pointed out by the Centre in the disbursement of wages under the MGNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act) scheme. The bench, also comprising Justice Chaitali Chatterjee (Das), noted that with regard to allegations of irregularities, action has been initiated, recoveries made and that such amount is being maintained in a bank account of the state nodal agency of MGNREGS, West Bengal. The division bench said that at this juncture, the endeavour of the court is to ensure implementation of the scheme, which has been kept in abeyance for the past close to three years in the state. The court said that no one can allow a person who illegally took advantage of the scheme to go scot free. "At this juncture, the court is concerned about the implementation of the scheme in West Bengal prospectively," the bench observed. "The scheme of the Act does not envisage a situation where the scheme would be put to cold storage for eternity," it said. The bench said that the Centre has sufficient powers to inquire into irregularities or illegalities in the manner of disbursement of the wages. The court said that there can, however, be a line drawn between past actions and future steps to be taken to implement the scheme. It said that this would be "in public interest" and subserve the object and purpose for which the central law was enacted.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Calcutta HC directs Centre to implement MGNREGA scheme in West Bengal from August 1
The Calcutta High Court on Wednesday (June 18) directed the Centre to implement the MGNREGA scheme prospectively in West Bengal from August 1. The HC said the Centre is empowered to impose special conditions, restrictions and regulations, which have not been imposed in other States of the country, so as to ensure that no illegality or irregularity occurs when the scheme is being implemented in the State. Allowing the Centre to continue its enquiry into the allegations of irregularities in some districts of the State, a Division Bench presided by Chief Justice T.S. Sivagnanam directed that the scheme be implemented prospectively with effect from August 1. The Court directed that the authorities in charge of the implementation of the scheme are entitled to impose special conditions to ensure that whatever had occurred three years prior should not recur. The Court said that it is not in dispute that certain irregularities have been pointed out by the Centre in the disbursement of wages under the MGNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act) scheme. The Bench, also comprising Justice Chaitali Chatterjee (Das), noted that with regard to allegations of irregularities, action has been initiated, recoveries made and that such amount is being maintained in a bank account of the state nodal agency of MGNREGS, West Bengal. The Division Bench said that at this juncture, the endeavour of the Court is to ensure implementation of the scheme, which has been kept in abeyance for the past close to three years in the state. The Court said that no one can allow a person who illegally took advantage of the scheme to go scot free. 'At this juncture, the court is concerned about the implementation of the scheme in West Bengal prospectively,' the Bench observed. 'The scheme of the Act does not envisage a situation where the scheme would be put to cold storage for eternity,' it said. The Bench said that the Centre has sufficient powers to inquire into irregularities or illegalities in the manner of disbursement of the wages. The Court said that there can, however, be a line drawn between past actions and future steps to be taken to implement the scheme. It said that this would be 'in public interest' and subserve the object and purpose for which the central law was enacted.
