Student Loan Borrowers in These Jobs Have Most Long-Term Financial Impact
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
A new national survey reveals that public-sector employees are significantly more likely to hold student loan debt than their private-sector counterparts. However, they often face fewer long-term financial repercussions, thanks in part to structured forgiveness programs and targeted employer resources.
Meanwhile, private sector workers continue to bear residual financial burdens despite repaying their loans. Researchers have labeled this phenomenon the "debt-overhang" effect.
The report, released by the MissionSquare Research Institute on Monday, surveyed over 2,000 U.S. workers across both sectors and found that 43 percent of public employees carry student loan debt, compared to 36 percent in the private sector. Yet the effects of that debt diverge sharply across employment types, with private sector workers reporting more enduring financial stress, even post-repayment.
Why It Matters
The study highlights a troubling contradiction in the financial health of America's workforce: private sector workers who pay off their student loans may not achieve the same long-term financial security as public workers still in debt.
This is due primarily to access disparities in employer-provided support and federal loan forgiveness programs.
"Balancing competing financial priorities while managing student debt can significantly hinder wealth accumulation," said Dr. Zhikun Liu, vice president and head of the MissionSquare Research Institute, in a statement.
Liu noted that even those who have paid off their loans may delay retirement savings or large purchases, extending financial insecurity into later life.
Graduates of Columbia University's lauded School of International and Public Affairs (SIPA) celebrate at SIPA's commencement exercises at St. John the Divine cathedral May 17, 2004 in New York City.
Graduates of Columbia University's lauded School of International and Public Affairs (SIPA) celebrate at SIPA's commencement exercises at St. John the Divine cathedral May 17, 2004 in New York City.What To Know
Among the key findings, nearly half of all employees (48 percent) reported receiving no employer-provided debt management resources, regardless of sector.
However, only 29 percent of public employees were informed by their employer about the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program, which can forgive federal loans after a decade of qualifying payments for government or nonprofit workers.
Despite the higher incidence of debt, public sector workers tend to fare better over time due to these support mechanisms.
As a result, private sector workers often express more concern about their long-term financial outlook, even when their student loans have been paid in full.
"The rising cost of education has outpaced inflation for decades, creating a financial barrier that hits private sector workers particularly hard," Kevin Thompson, the CEO of 9i Capital Group and the host of the 9inning podcast, told Newsweek. "As long as education remains this costly, the wealth gap will likely continue to grow, reinforcing economic disparities."
What People Are Saying
Drew Powers, the founder of Illinois-based Powers Financial Group, told Newsweek: "For many public sector workers, the potential of student loan forgiveness was a major deciding factor in choosing that position. As the cost of higher education continues to outpace inflation, a lower salary plus forgiveness over 10 years may be more viable than a higher salary with 30 years of payments in a private sector career."
Kevin Thompson, the CEO of 9i Capital Group and the host of the 9inning podcast, told Newsweek: "Public sector workers often carry more student debt, but they have unique advantages. Programs like Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) can wipe out balances after a set number of qualifying payments. On top of that, many government jobs come with pensions under the Federal Employee Retirement System (FERS) and generous retirement plans like the Thrift Savings Plan, often with matching. These benefits are often ignored by many but their power in regard to retirement savings is truly unmatched."
What Happens Next
Researchers recommend a dual-track approach: better communication and expanded access to relief programs in the public sector, as well as new debt-support initiatives in the private sector.
"For many private sector employees, student debt is a long-term financial drag. Without the automatic savings mechanisms like pensions and matching contributions that public sector workers enjoy, private employees often have to delay saving while chipping away at their loans," Thompson said.
Without broader intervention, disparities in financial security between sectors could widen.
"Any student loan repayment is competing for dollars that might otherwise go towards retirement savings or purchasing a home," Powers said. "It's a time value of money and compound interest problem."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Redesigning the Bay's old stores come with challenges and opportunities
TORONTO — When Hudson's Bay began liquidating all of its stores and hunting for a potential new owner, Ruby Liu was determined not to let Canada's oldest company disappear. The B.C. mall owner made an offer for the company in hopes of restoring it to its former glory, but when Canadian Tire was chosen (court approval pending) to buy its name and trademark stripes, Liu's plan was foiled. Yet she didn't give up. Instead, she brokered a deal to take over up to 28 of the leases held by Hudson's Bay and its sister Saks businesses in Alberta, B.C. and Ontario and transform them into "a new modern department store." But making the jump from vision to reality won't be easy, even with her persistence and the billions of dollars reportedly at her fingertips. "There is a lot of research, a lot of planning, a lot of capital, a lot of logistical challenges, inventory, branding and people that need to be figured out," said Jenna Jacobson, the Eaton Chair in Retailing at Toronto Metropolitan University. Because Hudson's Bay sold off its real estate years ago, Liu's first task once the liquidation sales end Sunday will be convincing the landlords who own the massive spaces to get on board with her plan or it's unlikely a court will rubber stamp it. Several landlords have told The Canadian Press they are awaiting more details before they decide what to do about Liu, who declined to comment for this story. Don Gregor, an executive vice-president at Aurora Realty Consultants not involved with the deal, suspects their approval will be hard to win. He reasons that landlords like to be in control and usually don't want to have tenants selected for them, especially tenants who will pick up "trophy leases" with the kind of deep concessions only a business as storied as the Bay could extract. Many of those leases date back to the very inception of the malls or properties they cover and would have rent charges Gregor believes were "well-below market." He also figures they had clauses restricting what other tenants could move in and what else could be built on the site. "(Landlords) would have loved if HBC had gone bankrupt and hadn't just fallen apart totally and they just get the space back because all the restrictions that anchor tenant held in that old lease would have gone away," he said. "Now, there's going to be a negotiation, like a dance between the two parties, where they have a little bit of give and take." Liu will come to the table with plenty of business experience. She is said to have made billions through real estate developments in China before she headed to Canada. Once here, her Central Walk business bought British Columbia malls Tsawwassen Mills, Mayfair Shopping Centre and Woodgrove Centre, as well as Arbutus Ridge Golf Course. The shopping centres feature plenty of Canadian mall staples along with rarities like Bass Pro Shops, L.L. Bean and even café kiosks powered by robot baristas. Gregor thinks Liu operates "very good malls" but will need a "wonder team of lawyers" to advance a deal as significant and complex as the Bay one. One thing she'll have going for her is that landlords don't like to leave big pieces of their properties in limbo, said J.C. Williams Group retail strategist Lisa Hutcheson. "In some ways, she makes it easier for them to not have to be worrying about how they're going to fill that large square footage," she said. If they approve of Liu, they will also have someone to shoulder repairs the Bay neglected to do, Hutcheson said. A handful of its stores temporarily closed last summer because of air conditioning troubles and even more have been plagued with broken escalators for years. Gregor estimates it would cost half a million dollars to repair the HVAC system at just one of the Bay's biggest locations. Elevator fixes or replacements could take a year, he said. And that's on top of the $100 to $150 per square foot he thinks will have to be spent — at minimum — to shape the spaces. "These stores are several hundred thousand square feet, and that takes a lot to reposition," Hutcheson agreed. She pointed out La Maison Simons is spending about 18 months transforming some former Nordstrom locations in Toronto. "And that's with a fully baked concept that they're going off of," she said. Liu will have to generate a new concept that can go head-to-head with long-established department stores like Simons and Holt Renfrew and the plethora of options online. That will likely mean brokering relationships with suppliers Hutcheson believes will be "a little bit nervous" because they are still reeling from millions in losses that came from the fall of the Bay. It will also mean hiring a large workforce that will devote themselves to an untested brand and then sell it to customers. Liu has promised to give suppliers and vendors who worked with Hudson's Bay priority when selecting partners for her new venture. She has also said she will prioritize hiring from the Bay's workforce, which stood at 9,364 staff before its demise. A Sunday post on LinkedIn from Central Walk CEO Linda Qin said Liu flew into Toronto on Saturday to interview 13 former Bay employees and hire 10, including some with 30 years of experience. "But between now and when I expect (Liu's) doors will open, will be a gap, and many of them will find jobs," Hutcheson said. Despite the battery of challenges Liu will have to overcome, Jacobson said the efforts could be worth it for both her and her customers. If Liu uses the opportunity to mirror the overseas department store model with new brands, supermarkets, restaurants, salons, entertainment and other digital experiences, Jacobson thinks Liu will "usher in a new form of retail" the Canadian market sorely needs. "If you look at the Chinese department stores, they often act like more of a destination in and of themselves than what we typically see in a Canadian or North American market," Jacobson said. "It's a destination where people could spend a significant amount of time ... which is going to be needed in order to have a successful model moving forward." This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 1, 2025. Tara Deschamps, The Canadian Press Sign in to access your portfolio
Hamilton Spectator
2 days ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Redesigning the Bay's old stores come with challenges and opportunities
TORONTO - When Hudson's Bay began liquidating all of its stores and hunting for a potential new owner, Ruby Liu was determined not to let Canada's oldest company disappear. The B.C. mall owner made an offer for the company in hopes of restoring it to its former glory, but when Canadian Tire was chosen (court approval pending) to buy its name and trademark stripes, Liu's plan was foiled. Yet she didn't give up. Instead, she brokered a deal to take over up to 28 of the leases held by Hudson's Bay and its sister Saks businesses in Alberta, B.C. and Ontario and transform them into 'a new modern department store.' But making the jump from vision to reality won't be easy, even with her persistence and the billions of dollars reportedly at her fingertips. 'There is a lot of research, a lot of planning, a lot of capital, a lot of logistical challenges, inventory, branding and people that need to be figured out,' said Jenna Jacobson, the Eaton Chair in Retailing at Toronto Metropolitan University. Because Hudson's Bay sold off its real estate years ago, Liu's first task once the liquidation sales end Sunday will be convincing the landlords who own the massive spaces to get on board with her plan or it's unlikely a court will rubber stamp it. Several landlords have told The Canadian Press they are awaiting more details before they decide what to do about Liu, who declined to comment for this story. Don Gregor, an executive vice-president at Aurora Realty Consultants not involved with the deal, suspects their approval will be hard to win. He reasons that landlords like to be in control and usually don't want to have tenants selected for them, especially tenants who will pick up 'trophy leases' with the kind of deep concessions only a business as storied as the Bay could extract. Many of those leases date back to the very inception of the malls or properties they cover and would have rent charges Gregor believes were 'well-below market.' He also figures they had clauses restricting what other tenants could move in and what else could be built on the site. '(Landlords) would have loved if HBC had gone bankrupt and hadn't just fallen apart totally and they just get the space back because all the restrictions that anchor tenant held in that old lease would have gone away,' he said. 'Now, there's going to be a negotiation, like a dance between the two parties, where they have a little bit of give and take.' Liu will come to the table with plenty of business experience. She is said to have made billions through real estate developments in China before she headed to Canada. Once here, her Central Walk business bought British Columbia malls Tsawwassen Mills, Mayfair Shopping Centre and Woodgrove Centre, as well as Arbutus Ridge Golf Course. The shopping centres feature plenty of Canadian mall staples along with rarities like Bass Pro Shops, L.L. Bean and even café kiosks powered by robot baristas. Gregor thinks Liu operates 'very good malls' but will need a 'wonder team of lawyers' to advance a deal as significant and complex as the Bay one. One thing she'll have going for her is that landlords don't like to leave big pieces of their properties in limbo, said J.C. Williams Group retail strategist Lisa Hutcheson. 'In some ways, she makes it easier for them to not have to be worrying about how they're going to fill that large square footage,' she said. If they approve of Liu, they will also have someone to shoulder repairs the Bay neglected to do, Hutcheson said. A handful of its stores temporarily closed last summer because of air conditioning troubles and even more have been plagued with broken escalators for years. Gregor estimates it would cost half a million dollars to repair the HVAC system at just one of the Bay's biggest locations. Elevator fixes or replacements could take a year, he said. And that's on top of the $100 to $150 per square foot he thinks will have to be spent — at minimum — to shape the spaces. 'These stores are several hundred thousand square feet, and that takes a lot to reposition,' Hutcheson agreed. She pointed out La Maison Simons is spending about 18 months transforming some former Nordstrom locations in Toronto. 'And that's with a fully baked concept that they're going off of,' she said. Liu will have to generate a new concept that can go head-to-head with long-established department stores like Simons and Holt Renfrew and the plethora of options online. That will likely mean brokering relationships with suppliers Hutcheson believes will be 'a little bit nervous' because they are still reeling from millions in losses that came from the fall of the Bay. It will also mean hiring a large workforce that will devote themselves to an untested brand and then sell it to customers. Liu has promised to give suppliers and vendors who worked with Hudson's Bay priority when selecting partners for her new venture. She has also said she will prioritize hiring from the Bay's workforce, which stood at 9,364 staff before its demise. 'But between now and when I expect (Liu's) doors will open, will be a gap, and many of them will find jobs,' Hutcheson said. Despite the battery of challenges Liu will have to overcome, Jacobson said the efforts could be worth it for both her and her customers. If Liu uses the opportunity to mirror the overseas department store model with new brands, supermarkets, restaurants, salons, entertainment and other digital experiences, Jacobson thinks Liu will 'usher in a new form of retail' the Canadian market sorely needs. 'If you look at the Chinese department stores, they often act like more of a destination in and of themselves than what we typically see in a Canadian or North American market,' Jacobson said. 'It's a destination where people could spend a significant amount of time ... which is going to be needed in order to have a successful model moving forward.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 1, 2025.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Exposé sheds light on shocking truth behind popular fashion brand's operations: 'We have no choice'
Workers making ultracheap Shein clothing in Guangzhou, China, face grueling 14-hour shifts with just one day off per month, despite earning fair wages compared to local standards, reported NZZ. In an area nicknamed "Shein Village" on the outskirts of Guangzhou, over a thousand factories operate almost exclusively for the popular online retailer. Workers earn about 8,000 yuan ($1,100) monthly — three times the local minimum wage — but must work more than twice the legally permitted hours to meet production quotas. "We have no choice," said Liu, a 42-year-old worker who irons clothing and stands for more than 10 hours daily. "What should my family eat and drink?" Chinese authorities are aware of these labor violations but ignore them to preserve jobs in an economy facing rising unemployment. Han Dongfang, who heads the Hong Kong-based China Labor Bulletin, fights for workers' rights but faces resistance from officials who prioritize economic activity over regulations. The working conditions in Shein factories reflect the fast-fashion business model's faults. Shein's "small batches, quick turnaround" strategy puts immense pressure on suppliers to deliver rapidly when designs sell well. This approach lets the company keep inventory costs low and pass savings to customers through rock-bottom prices. When you buy a $7 top or $12 jeans from Shein, that affordability comes at a human cost. While workers receive decent pay by local standards, they sacrifice their health and family time to keep up with production demands. This model also creates massive textile waste. Fast-fashion companies design clothing to deteriorate quickly, sending garments to landfills after just a few wears. The industry's focus on constantly changing styles and low-quality materials means millions of tons of textiles are wasted each year. The environmental impact is more than waste. Textile production requires significant water usage and often involves harmful chemicals that pollute local water sources when factories don't properly treat wastewater. You can make choices that support workers and the planet. Consider buying fewer but higher-quality garments that last longer. This approach might cost more upfront but saves money over time as pieces don't need frequent replacement. Which of these factors would most effectively motivate you to recycle old clothes and electronics? Giving me money back Letting me trade for new stuff Making it as easy as possible Keeping my stuff out of landfills Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. Thrifting offers another great solution with substantial financial benefits. You can find unique items at a small fraction of retail prices while giving clothing another life and keeping it out of pollution-spewing landfills. Some companies are now embracing more sustainable practices. Brands that openly share information about their supply chains and worker conditions give you the power to make informed choices about where your money goes. Supporting policies that require fashion companies to implement fair labor practices and environmental standards can drive industry-wide change. Your purchasing decisions send a powerful message about the kind of fashion industry you want to support. Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.
