Letters to the Editor: hospital beds, Kaikorai stream, Census
The decision by the current government to significantly reduce dementia and psychogeriatric capacity in the new Dunedin hospital will add to the growing crisis for care of the elderly in Otago and Southland.
For decades, aged residential care facilities have provided a ''moat'' around the public health system, protecting hospitals from a major influx of long-term elderly patients, with public hospitals dealing only with the overflow.
This moat is now rapidly disappearing. Demand for aged care is rising as baby-boomers move through to later stages of life, but a broken government funding system means aged residential care is failing to keep up with demand.
The sector has become increasingly less viable, and no new conventional aged care capacity is being built.
Growing demand will not be met by the aged residential care sector, and the public hospital system will provide even less of a backstop.
Residents and families seeking appropriate dementia and psychogeriatric care will struggle to access the services they deserve.
It is disgraceful that our seniors, who have contributed so much to the communities we enjoy today, will pay the price for inept decision-making and lack of insight.
Malcolm Hendry
Chief executive, Birchleigh Residential Care Centre Actions and inaction
In your Saturday edition (ODT 3.5.25) the Prime Minister says ''six years of a Labour government of utter inaction didn't deliver a single thing for the people of Dunedin on the Dunedin Hospital''.
Has he not seen the all but completed out patients building that was initiated and nearly all built during the Labour government's term?
It is good that the National-led government is carrying on with the build, but why did the PM have to lie? Was it a diversion to cover their cutting back of the bed numbers?
Charlie Wilson
Green Island
Health Minister Simeon Brown has said the new hospital would open with 351 inpatient beds, 59 fewer than originally proposed, but with capacity to expand to 404 beds over time. - Editor. Vaping and health
I am an 81-year-old asthmatic. Moreover I also suffer from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Research reveals that young people of 16 and 17 are vaping (ODT 3.5.25) and that this will result in them at that young age progressing from vaping to fully blown chronic obstructive pulmonary disease for the rest of their lives. Furthermore, their lives will be cut short by vaping.
Brian Collins
Petone Owl lovely
What a lovely article about our native owl Maroon Pullover (ODT 2.5.25). Also known as morepork, the ruru was transported to Dunedin after being involved in a car accident in Fiordland. The good people at our Wildlife Hospital and Botanic Garden aviary nursed him back to health, allowing him to return home. What a feel good story - we need more of these.
Gaye Ellis
Waverley Restore natural streams like Kaikorai stream
Thanks Mary Williams for your informative article ''Stream of Toxicity'' (ODT 3.5.25).
Shame on all polluters of Kaikorai stream and best wishes to Aroha/Love Kaikorai Valley Trust (AKV).
That AKV are working to restore Kaikorai stream back to providing life for macroinvertebrates, insects, fish, eels and birds is great.
Why doesn't the Dunedin City Council remove the fence, opening the stream side path between Donald St and Townleys Rd, enabling walking there?
Wouldn't it be good to be able to walk beside this and other streams and rivers in Otago?
Many enjoy being part of nature, getting outside into our wonderful environment.
Thanks to all who help restore natural systems in public spaces.
Lynne Stewart
Clyde The silent type
Interesting to see Doug Hall's response to the planting of a few trees along the edge of the Kaikorai stream by the property he owns. He said more in this article than he did in the whole nine years he was a councillor at the Dunedin City Council.
Neville McLay
Opoho Double counts confusing and far too broad
I refer to an excellent expose by Hilary Calvert on the questions in the last census and a perplexing reply from Stats NZ (ODT 2.5.25) arguing why dual counting for mixed heritage is frankly OK, when it is arguably outside of the Census honesty requirement.
The issue is not assisted by the Census question of ethnicity and the further collation of those who ticked Maori (366,015). Those who had further confirmed their ethnicity was actually Maori mixed with European and other non determined races (409,401) were then, to assist Stats NZ, lumped in with Maori as a predominant ethnicity which gives a distorted total of 887,493 or 17.8% of the population.
Either Maori 7.4% - 366,015 or being part European/Maori 9.0% - 409,401 ethnicity or heritage should be what Census data and the government Budget appropriations apply funds to and not double dipping.
This is definitely misleading towards inaccuracy. Surely in 2025 we are either born here or happy to be a resident in New Zealand and the minutiae of our differences is irrelevant.
Basil Walker
Queenstown
In her letter explaining how Stats NZ uses ethnicity information, Kathy Connolly confuses the issue by claiming Asian and European are ethnicities. These are not ethnicities but broad geographical areas.
It is ridiculous to suggest that people from Iraq and Korea are of the same ethnicity. Or that people from Greece are the same ethnicity as people from Iceland. It is estimated there are some 2000 ethnic groups in India, 600 in Indonesia.
Apparently Stats NZ decided that using accurate ethnicities was too ''messy'' and so they lump together huge geographical groups which they then falsely claim to be ethnic groups with something in common. This enables the production of meaningless statistics such as the average life span of Asians in New Zealand.
R Donaldson
Dunedin
Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Opinion: New Zealand needs more doctors, but is a new medical school the solution?
New Zealand desperately needs more doctors, especially general practitioners. However, the government's own analysis shows that its flagship solution — building a brand-new medical school in Waikato — is deeply flawed. The government said a Waikato Medical School would be a cheaper, faster route to training more doctors. However, the detailed business case — which is meant to ensure government projects deliver value for money and was released nearly a week later — shows this decision was based on misleading assumptions and omissions. Firstly, the government's pitch hinges on the Waikato school being a four-year graduate-entry programme, supposedly cheaper than the current six-year degrees at Otago and Auckland universities. What they conveniently omit is that students must first complete a minimum three-year bachelors degree before even starting. The government claimed running costs will be cheaper because of a shorter degree but had never considered trialling the four-year graduate model at Otago or Auckland, where infrastructure and proven teaching expertise already exist. Why build an entirely new institution rather than simply expanding existing, successful schools? Furthermore, the government modelled its plan on an Australian programme, assuming it would increase the number of GPs working rurally here. That's a risky assumption. The business case estimated that 38% of Waikato graduates would become general practitioners, compared to 23% if intake was increased at Auckland and Otago, and 33% through a joint rural training programme. This is speculation and contradicted by Prof Warwick Bagg, Dean of the University of Auckland's medical school, who said current programmes already had around 35% of graduates working as a GP eight years after graduation. There are also questions around what impact Waikato will have on Otago's existing rural programme and what effect it will have on placements already aligned with the university. The Waikato medical school was pitched to National as a political "gift" and the government has cherry-picked facts and overlooked other options. For example, Otago and Auckland universities could expand their intakes now, producing more doctors faster in proven, established environments that require only increased funding — not costly new infrastructure. Christopher Luxon's government is out of touch, prioritising pet projects, instead of focusing on the delivering what New Zealand needs. Rather than chasing a political headline, the government could look to support and expand the medical schools we already have. Our health system and patients deserve no less.
Otago Daily Times
3 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Letters to the Editor: sea lions, health and Trump
Today's Letters to the Editor from readers cover topics including what comes around for the killers of sea lions, funding our public health system, and a simple solution to Trump. You don't see them in the supermarket queue Several days ago three sea lions were shot at the Waitaki River mouth. To the person/persons responsible for this act, do you go fishing in the vicinity of the river mouth? Were you getting annoyed because the sea lions were catching more fish than you and you decided to do something about them? When you approached the sea lions and stood with your loaded weapon, feeling only anger towards them, why didn't you stop, admire, consider what the consequences of your actions would be and walk past? The sea lion's world is the ocean and this is where they get their food. They take only what they need to survive. You don't see them down the seafood aisle at a supermarket. Your actions have taken away something special from the coast for reasons known only to you. However, what goes around comes around. Carrying the cost In its first days, National gave landlords a $3 billion tax break. Soon after, Finance Minister Nicola Willis announced $14.7b in tax relief over four years—then borrowed $12b to cover the revenue shortfall. Despite this, Willis speaks of "balancing the books" while reframing the narrative to blame the previous government. The reality is that her early decisions created a $17.7b revenue black hole, forcing cuts across essential programmes. These cuts disproportionately harm those on low incomes, people at risk of discrimination, and the most vulnerable in our communities. Jobs have been lost, projects scrapped, and hopes for pay equity abandoned — all because of reckless tax and borrowing choices. Willis' approach prioritises short-term political gain over long-term stability, leaving ordinary New Zealanders to carry the cost. RUCs and reasons Why have a tax specifically for roads at all? We don't do it for other government services such as health, education. The only difference is private industry benefits directly from roads, and use and damage roads more. Scrap RUCs on all vehicles below X tonnes. That makes the majority of private motor vehicles RUC-free; eliminates the need for further public sector staffing, systems and policing. It still ensures the private sector mostly pays their way. The 80/20 rule. Roading is less than 3% of total government spend. Why further bloat and complicate the public service unnecessarily. Is it a jobs scheme for the usual suspects? Lights, revisited Back up the bus, my train of thought has proven to be off track. My previous tale (Letters ODT 22.7.25) may have been a tad too thoughtless. Some sod has turned a sod, well several sods. There is now one worksite in Tomahawk which has broken ground, digging to lay solid foundations. There is one new street light beside the work site, which surely completely justifies the turning on of all 22 new street lights. Although I have yet to hear evidence of workers working by the streetlight. I still wake up early each morning, look out the kitchen window, and ponder the extravagance of lighting fields of green. If we assume 200W of power for each light then 200 x 21 (leaving out one semi useful light) gives us 4.2kW of power running all night. The Aurora website has handy hints for saving power. I know the new lights are LED (an Aurora website recommendation for power saving) but how about switching off the ones not needed? If we want a health system, fund it properly In the last two months I have had to be taken twice to the Dunedin Hospital emergency department. In each case I could certainly see, after the event, that it was not strictly necessary, but that did not seem to be true at the time. On each occasion, the treatment that I experienced was the best I could possibly have expected or wished for. When I tried to thank all the staff that had helped me, on the feedback comments I found that many of the responses that had been received were very critical, almost always in similar ways. For example, 'I had to wait (some long time) to get any help", or "I had to leave before any special treatment had been given to me". We really ought to ask ourselves how a critically under-resourced (and yet extremely good) service can be expected to operate in the way we would like. If we are not prepared to fund our public health service adequately, what do we think will happen? I simply want to acknowledge just how special the doctors, nurses, and other staff are. With friends like these who needs enemies Donald Trump demonstrates a mind-boggling lack of ability to assess character and human values in people. He has befriended two of the world's most dangerous, cruel and evil leaders: Putin and Netanyahu. Irrespective of the rights and wrongs of historical events, they in no way exonerate these heads of state for the atrocities they are now committing. Both dictatorial despots are responsible for the mass killing of thousands of innocent men, women and children and the annihilation of large parts of their countries . Putin invaded Ukraine supposedly only interested in military targets. In his deranged mind he keeps blaming Ukraine. The only plus is that Trump may have realised Putin was playing him for a fool. Netanayhu continues to blast the life and livelihoods out of the Palestinians in the Gaza strip on the pretext of eliminating Hamas and getting them to release Israeli hostages The clumsy method of doing this (indiscriminate bombardment and shelling) is entirely consistent with the "asleep at the wheel" state of the supposedly sophisticated Israeli military allowing Hamas to invade in the first place. Blaming Hamas for the current trickle of aid and food getting to Gaza, the killing of citizens at aid stations , and the malnutrition crisis just demonstrates how mentally deranged and dishonest Netanyahu and his entourage are . Both Putin and Netanyahu are responsible for war crimes and crimes against humanity. Neither of them want peace — they are intent on bludgeoning their target country to submission. Simple solution If Donald Trump is really serious about getting criminality out of Washington DC, there is one simple, effective and incredibly popular action he could take. Five-letter word beginning in L. Address Letters to the Editor to: Otago Daily Times, PO Box 517, 52-56 Lower Stuart St, Dunedin. Email: editor@
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Wednesday Politics Panel for 20 August 2025
It's another hit of the most insightful and sharp 30 minutes in political analysis. Today Wallace is joined by journalist Annabelle Lee-Mather, former Greens MP Sue Kedgley and Maddison Burgess-Smith, commentator and Senior Consultant at Iron Duke Partners. Topics discussed on the show tonight include: Former Prime Minister Helen Clark has lamented the "boys club" environment of golbal politcs. The backlash over Labour ministers refusing to front up publicly for the Covid Royal Commission of Inquiry. Finance Minister Nicola Willis caused quite the stir this week by nabbing the Prime Minister's interview spot on the caucus run. Should we take note of the whispers of a roll? The Government's decision to remove te reo Maori from new early-reading books is, according to critics, just the latest in a run of policies seemingly targeting Maori. is it an assualt on Te Ao Maori? To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
